Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-09-14 City Council Workshop Packet AGENDA MAPLEWOOD CITY COUNCIL MANAGER WORKSHOP 6:15 P.M. Monday, September 14, 2026 City Hall, Council Chambers Pursuant to Minn. Stat. 13D.02, one or more council members may be participating remotely A. CALL TO ORDER B. ROLL CALL C. APPROVAL OF AGENDA D. UNFINISHED BUSINESS None E. NEW BUSINESS 1. Maplewood Housing and Commercial Market Analysis Presentation F. ADJOURNMENT RULES OF CIVILITY FOR THE CITY COUNCIL, BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND OUR COMMUNITY Following are rules of civility the City of Maplewood expects of everyone appearing at council meetings - elected officials, staff and citizens. It is hoped that by following these simple rules, everyone’s opinions can be heard and understood in a reasonable manner. We appreciate the fact that when appearing at council meetings, it is understood that everyone will follow these principles: Speak only for yourself, not for other council members or citizens - unless specifically tasked by your colleagues to speak for the group or for citizens in the form of a petition. Show respect during comments and/or discussions, listen actively and do not interrupt or talk amongst each other. Be respectful of the process, keeping order and decorum. Do not be critical of council members, staff or others in public. Be respectful of each other’s time keeping remarks brief, to the point and non-repetitive. THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK E1 CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP STAFF REPORT Meeting Date September 14, 2026 REPORT TO: Michael Sable, City Manager REPORT FROM: Danette Parr, Community and Economic Development Director PRESENTER:Danette Parr, Community and Economic Development Director Joe Hollman, Director of Research with Maxfield Research & Consulting AGENDA ITEM: Maplewood Housing and Commercial Market Analysis Presentation Action Requested:MotionDiscussionPublic Hearing Form of Action:ResolutionOrdinanceContract/AgreementProclamation Summary: The City of Maplewood engaged Maxfield Research & Consulting to prepare a market analysis examining housing and commercial real estate conditions. The purpose of the study is to provide an evidence-based understanding of Maplewood’s economic health so that economic development activity can be directed toward opportunities the market will support. Joe Hollman, Director of Research with Maxfield Research & Consulting, will present the report findings and be available to answer questions. Recommended Action: This item is for discussion purposes only. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact?NoYes, the true or estimated cost is $0 Financing source(s):Adopted BudgetBudget ModificationNew Revenue Source Use of Reserves Other: NA Strategic Plan Relevance: Safety Sustainability Maintain strong financial health and stability Development Promote residential development and thoughtful redevelopment The market analysis provides data that can be shared with developers to attract investment in Maplewood and supports redevelopment efforts for targeted development types and locations. Background: As the council continues to determine where future investments are most beneficial to support continued economic growth and quality of life, it’s important to have current data to support those efforts. For that reason, Maxfield Research & Consulting was hired to evaluate the following: Workshop Packet Page Number 1 of 253 E1 HousingNeeds: Demographic Analysis Employment Trends Housing Characteristics and Conditions For-Sale Housing Market Analysis General Occupancy Rental Housing Analysis Senior Housing Market Analysis Housing Affordability Commercial Demand: Demographic and Employment Growth Trends and Characteristics Commerial Market Conditions and Absorption Trends Commercial/Industrial Building Supply Commercial Node Site Evaluations The overall conclusions of the analysis by Maxfield Research & Consulting were positive. Joe Hollman will share his findings, recommendations and answer questions at the workshop. Attachments: 1. Maplewood Housing Needs Analysis Report 2. Maplewood Commercial Real Estate Demand Analysis Report Workshop Packet Page Number 2 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 A Housing Needs Analysis forthe City of Maplewood, Minnesota Prepared for: City of Maplewood Maplewood, MN July2026 901 Twelve Oaks Center Drive Suite 922 Wayzata, MN 55391 612.338.0012 www.maxfieldresearch.com Workshop Packet Page Number 3 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 July 28, 2026 Ms. Danette Parr Community Development Director City of Maplewood 1830 County Rd B East Maplewood, MN55109 Ms. Parr: Needs Analysis for the City of Maplewood, Minne- sota.e Housing Needs Analysis examines current housing market conditions and deter- mines the market potential for developing different types of owned and rented housing in the communityto 2050. The scope of this study includesan analysis of the demographic and economic characteristics of the City of Maplewoodand surrounding area, a review of existing housing stock characteristics, and market analyses covering the for-sale, rental, and senior housing markets. Additionally, the study includes an assessment of housing affordability in the community. Detailed demand calculations and development concept recommendations are provided for Maplewood, and the study concludes with an evaluation of key opportunities and challenges associated with housing development in the community. Please contact us if you have questions or require additional information. Sincerely, MAXFIELD RESEARCH ANDCONSULTING Nathan RossMax PerraultJoe Hollman Research AssociateSenior AssociateDirector of Research Attachment (main) 612-338-0012 (fax) 612-904-7979 901 Twelve Oaks Center Drive, Suite 922, Wayzata, MN 55391 www.maxfieldresearch.com Workshop Packet Page Number 4 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................ 1 PURPOSE AND SCOPE OF STUDY ................................................................................. 7 DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW ............................................................................................. 8 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 8 Population and Household Growth Trends ................................................................... 10 Population Age Distribution ........................................................................................... 12 Household Income by Age of Householder ................................................................... 15 Household Tenure by Income ........................................................................................ 18 Household Tenure by Age .............................................................................................. 20 Tenure by Household Size .............................................................................................. 23 Household Type ............................................................................................................. 24 Race and Ethnicity .......................................................................................................... 26 Resident Mobility ........................................................................................................... 29 EMPLOYMENT TRENDS ............................................................................................... 31 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 31 Resident Employment .................................................................................................... 32 Commuting Patterns ...................................................................................................... 33 Employment Growth Trends .......................................................................................... 36 Industry Employment and Wage Data ........................................................................... 39 Major Employers ............................................................................................................ 43 HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS ....................................................................................... 44 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 44 Housing Stock by Structure Type and Tenure................................................................ 45 Age of Housing Stock ..................................................................................................... 50 Residential Construction Trends .................................................................................... 51 Residential Development Pipeline ................................................................................. 54 FOR-SALE MARKET ..................................................................................................... 55 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 55 Home Sale Trends .......................................................................................................... 56 Active Listings ................................................................................................................. 61 Actively Marketing Residential Lots ............................................................................... 63 Residential Lot Supply .................................................................................................... 65 New Construction Home Pricing .................................................................................... 67 Workshop Packet Page Number 5 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Title Page RENTAL HOUSING MARKET ......................................................................................... 69 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 69 Overview of Rental Market Conditions ......................................................................... 70 Rental Housing Properties ............................................................................................. 73 SENIOR HOUSING MARKET ......................................................................................... 79 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 79 Senior Housing Defined ................................................................................................. 80 Older Adult (Age 55+) Population and Household Trends ............................................ 82 Supply of Senior Housing ............................................................................................... 86 HOUSING AFFORDABILITY .......................................................................................... 91 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 91 Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing ........................................................................ 92 Rent and Income Limits ................................................................................................. 93 Housing Unit and Household Distribution ..................................................................... 94 Housing Choice Vouchers .............................................................................................. 95 Housing Cost Burden...................................................................................................... 96 Housing Costs as Percentage of Household Income ..................................................... 98 DEMAND ESTIMATES .................................................................................................. 100 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 100 Demographic Profile and Housing Demand .................................................................. 101 General Occupancy Housing Demand Summary ........................................................... 102 Senior Housing Demand Summary ................................................................................ 104 CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS ....................................................................... 108 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 108 Housing Demand Summary ........................................................................................... 109 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 110 Challenges and Opportunities ....................................................................................... 118 Housing Programs .......................................................................................................... 124 Workshop Packet Page Number 6 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 LIST OF TABLES Table Number and Title Page Table 1 Population and Household Growth Trends and Projections ...................................... 11 Table 2 Population Age Distribution ........................................................................................ 14 Table 3 Household Income by Age of Householder, City of Maplewood ............................... 16 Table 4 Household Income by Age of Householder, Ramsey County ..................................... 17 Table 5 Tenure by Household Income ..................................................................................... 19 Table 6 Tenure by Age of Householder ................................................................................... 21 Table 7 Household Size by Tenure ........................................................................................... 23 Table 8 Household Type .......................................................................................................... 25 Table 9 Population Distribution by Race & Ethnicity .............................................................. 28 Table 10 Resident Mobility in Past year by Age Group ............................................................. 30 Table 11 Labor Force and Resident Employment Trends .......................................................... 32 Table 12 Commuting Inflow/Outflow Characteristics ............................................................... 34 Table 13 Commuting Patterns ................................................................................................... 36 Table 14 Employment Growth Trends and Projections ............................................................ 37 Table 15 Industry Employment Trends ..................................................................................... 40 Table 16 Average Weekly Wages .............................................................................................. 41 Table 17 Major Employers ......................................................................................................... 43 Table 18 Housing Unit Structure Type by Tenure ..................................................................... 45 Table 19 Housing Units by Year Structure Built......................................................................... 51 Table 20 Residential Construction Trends ................................................................................. 52 Table 21 Residential Development Pipeline .............................................................................. 54 Table 22 Residential Sale Trends ............................................................................................... 57 Table 23 Residential Resale Price Distribution .......................................................................... 60 Table 24 Active Listings .............................................................................................................. 61 Table 25 Actively-Marketing Residential Lot Supply ................................................................. 64 Table 26 Century Ponds Development Summary...................................................................... 66 Table 27 New Construction Home Pricing Summary ................................................................ 68 Table 28 Rental Housing Vacancy & Rental Rates ..................................................................... 70 Table 29 Average Rents/Vacancies Trends ................................................................................ 72 Table 30 Select Affordable/Subsidized Rental Properties, Unit Type Summary ....................... 75 Table 31 Select Market Rate Rental Properties, Unit Type Summary ....................................... 77 Table 32 Senior Housing Supply Summary ................................................................................ 87 Table 33 Unit Type Summary, Affordable/Subsidized Senior Housing Properties ................... 88 Table 34 Unit Type Summary, Market Rate Active Adult Rental Properties ............................. 89 Table 35 HUD Income and Rent Limits, Ramsey County ........................................................... 93 Table 36 Housing Unit and Household Distribution by AMI ..................................................... 94 Table 37 Housing Cost Burden................................................................................................... 96 Table 38 Housing Affordability Based on Household Income ................................................... 99 Table 39 General Occupancy Housing Demand Summary ...................................................... 103 Table 40 Excess Senior Housing Demand by Service Level ..................................................... 104 Table 41 New Construction For-Sale Housing Pricing Recommendations .............................. 110 Table 42 General Occupancy Rental Housing Recommendations .......................................... 112 Table 43 Recommended Senior Housing Development .......................................................... 115 Workshop Packet Page Number 7 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISEXECUTIVE SUMMARY Purpose and Scope of Study Maxfield Research and Consulting was engaged by the City of Maplewoodto prepare a Housing Needs Analysis for the community. The analysis provides recommendations on the amount and types of housing that may be developed to meet the needs of current and future households in the City. The scope of this study includes an analysis of the demographic and economic characteristics of Maplewood, a review of existing housing stock characteristics, and market analyses covering the for-sale, rental, and seniorhousing markets. Additionally, the study includes an assessment of housing affordability in the area. Housing demand calculations to 2050, development con- cept recommendations, and housing program examplesare provided. The study concludes with an evaluation of challenges and opportunities associated with housing development in Maplewood. Summary of Key Findings Demand for affordable and subsidized rental housing (general occupancy and senior)comprises 32% of the total demand, while 9% will be for service-enhanced housing (independent living, assisted living, memory care). Another 37% will be for owned housing units (all ages) and 23% of the demand will be for market rate rental housing (general occupancy and active adult). senior housing as many seniors prefer to age in place instead of moving into alternative hous- ing. Additionally, funding availability for affordable and subsidizedhousing is limited, which will make it difficult to develop enough new housing to meet the projected demand. will limit growth potential. Redevelopment and infill projects will be needed to support the development of new housingin the commu- nity. There are housing needs across the spectrum,but moderately priced housing, both for-sale and rental,apriority need. Single-level housing alternatives for older adults and seniors are also needed. MAXFIELD RESEARCH ANDCONSULTING 1 Workshop Packet Page Number 8 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Demographic & Employment Analysis Maplewood contains an estimated 42,755 people and 16,418 households. Maplewood experi- enced 1.6% population growth (667 people) against 2.6% household growth (424 households) from 2020 to 2026. The rate of population growth in Maplewood is projected to remain con- sistent from 0.26% growth annually, on average, from 2020 to 2026 to 0.30% annual growth by 2050, adding 3,045 people (7.1% growth). The number of households is projected to increase 10.2% (1,682) by 2050. The largest adult cohort by age in Maplewood is 35 to 44 (13.9% of the total population), fol- lowed by the 25 to 34 (13.6%) and 55 to 64 (11.9%) age groups. Notable population shifts pro- jected for Maplewood between 2026 and 2050, include growth among the 25 to 34, 45 to 54, 55 to 64, and 75 and older age groups. As such, housing demand growth is expected to be strongest for units catering to the older senior population, move-up ownership housing, and entry-level housing for the younger age groups. In 2026, the median household income in Maplewood is estimated to be $90,028, -12% lower than the Metro Area ($102,599). Median household incomes are substantially higher among owner households than renter households. In Maplewood, owner households have an esti- mated median household income of $123,422 compared to $54,796 among renter households. An estimated 68% of all households own in Maplewood, giving it a homeownership rate that is higher than Ramsey County (58%) and the Metro Area (67%). The total number of owner households residing in the City grew by an estimated 294 households between 2010 and 2026, an increase of 3%, while the number of renter households expanded 31% (1,242 households). Households living alone are estimated to be the most common household type in Maplewood (30% of all households), followed by married couple without children households (28%). Be- tween 2010 and 2026, non-family households experienced strong growth, increasing by 996 households (19%) compared to a 6% increase in family households (540). job market has yet to fully recover since 2020, but the area is expected to have solid employment growth over the next several years. Maplewood is projected to add 3,175 jobs by 2030 (12.6% growth), and another 1,500 by 2040 (5.0% growth), although labor availa- bility will greatly impact the ability of the area to maintain employment levels and achieve pro- jected job growth. Maplewood and Ramsey County have historically maintained unemploy- ment rates that tracked below equilibrium (5.0% unemployment), suggesting a tight labor mar- ket. Nearly 13,600 people either commute into Maplewood for employment or live and work in the City. Inflow represents a potential target market for new housing in a community, particularly from workers that commute greater distances (i.e. 50+ miles). An estimated 6% of workers em- ployed in Maplewood travel more than 50 miles for their job (850 workers). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 2 Workshop Packet Page Number 9 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Housing Market Conditions From 2017 through May 2026, 1,083 housing units were permitted in the City of Maplewood. 93% of the permitted units were in multifamily structures (1,010 units), while 5% were de- tached single-family units (51) and 2% were townhome units (22). Annually, Maplewood aver- ages 116.8 new units per year, including 5.7 new detached single-family units, 2.4 townhome units, and 108.7 multifamily units per year. During the five-year period from 2017 through 2021, Maplewood averaged 90.4 new housing units per year. The pace of development activity increased sharply (66%) from 2022 through 2025, averaging 149.8 units per year. New detached single-family construction did not reach higher than 9 units constructed be- tween 2017 and 2025. As of May 2026, there have not been any detached single-family units constructed. The Century Ponds Development, however, is planned for 133 detached single- family units and 73 townhome units, which will bring a significant boost to the for-sale housing stock. Multifamily development activity increased from a rate of 82.2 units per year, on aver- age, from 2017 through 2021 to an average pace of 141.8 units per year from 2022 through 2025. A total of 206 new general occupancy residential units are in the development pipeline in Maplewood as of July 2026. In total, 87% of the approved housing supply will be for-sale units (206), while the remaining 13% (32) will be senior housing units. In Maplewood, home sale activity peaked at 54.6 resales per month in 2021, before declining to 32.8 resales per month in 2023. Transaction volume in Maplewood increased modestly to 33.7 resales per month in 2025. Volume decelerated due, in large part, to rising mortgage rates, which caused sales activity to slow across the region. Since 2023, Maplewood has averaged 33.2 resales per month, including 23.3 detached single- family home resales per month and 9.9 multifamily resales per month. Excluding new construc- tion listings, there is 2.4-month supply of previously owned units available for sale in the City, including a 2.3-month supply of detached single-family homes and a 2.8-month supply of multi- family units. Equilibrium in the for-sale housing market is generally considered to be a six- month supply, indicating that there is pent-up demand for homes in Maplewood. Increased competition for homes (as indicated by the decreasing supply of available housing and shortened marketing times) helped stimulate strong price appreciation, although the per- cent change has fluctuated in recent years. In Maplewood the median price for detached sin- gle-family homes increased 48%, climbing from $250,000 in 2018 to $369,900 in 2025, averag- ing 5.8% increases annually. Median multifamily prices increased 43% from $185,000 in 2018 to $265,000 in 2025, averaging 5.4% increases annually. The median price for new construction detached single-family units in Maplewood is $549,000 (48% higher than the median resale price). The median price for new construction multifamily units is $272,272 (only 3% higher than the median resale price). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 3 Workshop Packet Page Number 10 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The equilibrium vacancy rate for rental housing is considered to be 5.0% which allows for nor- mal turnover and an adequate supply of alternatives for prospective renters. Based on our sur- vey of general occupancy apartment properties in the community, we found that affordable and subsidized facilities are 2.4% vacant, while the market rate rental properties are 4.0% va- cant. This data suggests pent-up demand for new general occupancy rental housing in Maple- wood, both market rate and affordable/subsidized. The average monthly rental rate across all market rate general occupancy properties is $1,507, which equates to $1.69 per square foot (psf). There is a notable difference in rents between older and newer properties in Maplewood. The three newest properties (opened 2018, 2020, and 2025) have an average monthly rent of $1,869, roughly 31% higher than the average rent of $1,426 among the older properties. Maxfield Research identified a total of 19 age-restricted housing facilities in Maplewood, total- ing 1,794 units. There are 167 market rate active adult rental units, 487 affordable and subsi- dized rental units, 352 ownership active adult units, and 788 service-enhanced units in Maple- wood. Among the service-enhanced facilities, there are an estimated 99 independent living units and 438 assisted living units, along with 251 memory care units. At the time of the survey, there were two vacant units in the active adult market rate proper- ties in Maplewood, resulting in a 1.2% vacancy rate, well below equilibrium (5.0% vacancy). There were 25 vacancies across the affordable and subsidized active adult properties, resulting in a 5.1% vacancy rate, which is essentially at equilibrium. The affordable and subsidized age- restricted rental market is stable, while the low vacancy rate across the market rate active adult properties suggests pent-up demand in Maplewood. Market equilibrium for service-enhanced senior housing (i.e. assisted living and memory care) is generally considered to be 7.0% vacancy, which allows for an adequate supply of alternatives for prospective residents. At that time, there were 63 total service-enhanced vacancies across the 536 surveyed units resulting in an 11.8% vacancy rate, well-above equilibrium. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 4 Workshop Packet Page Number 11 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Housing Affordability An estimated 31% of all households in Maplewood are considered cost-burdened (paying more than 30% of their income for housing costs), including 20% of owner households and 52% of renter households. By comparison, 20% of owner households and 47% of renter households are cost burdened in the Twin Cities Metro Area. Based on current home prices, 59% of owner households in Maplewood could afford to pur- chase an entry-level detached single-family home priced at $325,000 in Maplewood. The pro- portion drops to 34% that could afford a move-up detached single-family home priced at $475,000. Roughly 51% of renter householders could afford to rent a one-bedroom unit at existing market rate rental properties in Maplewood at the average rent of $1,301 per month. However, the income-qualified percentage drops to 40% that could afford monthly rents for a new construc- tion one-bedroom unit priced at $1,600 per month. Households earning the average weekly wage in the City of Maplewood ($2,038) and Ramsey County ($1,564) would be able to afford monthly rents of approximately $2,649 and $2,033, re- spectively, to not exceed 30% of monthly income on housing costs, much higher than the aver- age rent for market rate one-bedroom rental housing units in Maplewood ($1,301). A house- hold would need a minimum annual income of $112,688 to be able to afford a single-family home at the 2025 median resale price of $369,900 in Maplewood. Average weekly wages equate to annual incomes of $105,976 and $81,328 in the City of Maplewood and Ramsey County, respectively. Much of Maplewoods workforce commutes from outside the city. Based on this data, rental housing is more attainable than for-sale housing for workers earning the average weekly wage that may want to relocate to Maplewood, particularly those relying on a single income. Housing Demand Analysis As summarized in the following figure, we find demand for 3,026 for-sale housing units be- tween 2026 and 2050, although a supply of development-ready lots will be required to satisfy demand. The Century Ponds Development has 206 lots that are being developed into for-sale housing units. Additional lots will be needed to meet long-term demand for new ownership housing in the City. We also estimate that there is excess demand for 3,637 general occupancy rental housing units in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050. Additionally, we find excess demand for 529 age-re- stricted housing units targeting older adults and seniors in 2026, increasing to 665 units in 2050. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 12 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Summary of Housing Demand in Maplewood 2026 to 2050 These demand estimates reflect potential market demand for housing in Maplewood and are not based solely on population and household growth projections. Our findings indicate that housing demand exceeds what would be implied by projected household growth alone, sug- gesting that Maplewood could accommodate growth beyond current population and household forecasts if sufficient housing is developed. Housing demand estimates often exceed growth forecasts because household growth is only one factor driving the need for new residential con- struction. Other factors include turnover among existing households, replacement of physically obsolete units, and the need to maintain a healthy level of vacancy, among others. Based on findings from this analysis, we recommend various for-sale, rental, and senior housing development concepts in Maplewood which are intended to act as a development guide to meet the housing needs of existing and future households in the community. Detailed findings are described in the Conclusions & Recommendations section of this report. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 6 Workshop Packet Page Number 13 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS PURPOSE AND SCOPE Purpose and Scope of Study Maxfield Research and Consulting was engaged by the City of Maplewood to prepare a Housing Needs Analysis for the community. The analysis provides recommendations on the amount and types of housing that may be developed to meet the needs of current and future households in the community. The scope of this study includes an analysis of the demographic and economic characteristics of Maplewood and the surrounding area, a review of existing housing stock characteristics, and market analyses covering the for-sale, rental, and senior housing markets. Additionally, the study includes an assessment of housing affordability in the area. Detailed housing demand calculations to 2050 and development concept recommendations are provided for the commu- nity. The study concludes with an evaluation of challenges and opportunities associated with housing development in Maplewood. Methodology This report includes both primary and secondary research. Primary research includes personal interviews, data on existing rental properties, and information on pending developments. Sec- ondary research, which is credited to the source when used, is always used as a basis for analy- sis and is carefully considered along with other factors that may impact projections. Typical secondary data resources include: ESRI (a nationally recognized demographic services firm, Minnesota Department of Administration (DOA) State Demographic Center, Metropolitan Council, United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), and the United States Census Bureau (Decennial Census, American Community Survey, Local Employment Dy- namics). The ACS is an ongoing statistical survey that gathers data previously contained only in the De- cennial Census to provide an ongoing portrait of demographic, economic, social, and household characteristics every year, not just every ten years. Maxfield Research and Consulting utilizes five-year data estimates, which provide a larger sample size and have a longer data collection period than the one-year data estimates. At the time this analysis was prepared, the 2020- 2024 ACS was the most recent five-year data available. The ACS demographic and housing characteristics data is adjusted by Maxfield Research to reflect current year information. For reference, a household is an occupied housing unit, while a householder refers to the per- son in whose name the housing unit is owned or rented. Housing unit is defined as a house, an apartment, a group of rooms, or a single room occupied or intended for occupancy as separate living quarters. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 7 Workshop Packet Page Number 14 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Demographic Review Introduction Demographic characteristics and trends are important factors when evaluating housing needs in any given market. This section of the report reviews the demographic and economic charac- teristics of Maplewood and the surrounding area to provide insight into demand for various housing product types. Housing demand in Maplewood will be driven primarily by household growth and turnover of existing households in the community. A portion of the demand, however, will be generated from outside the city. For this reason, comparisons are made to Ramsey County and the seven- county Metro Area, which together represent a broader housing draw area for the city. The following topics are evaluated. Population and household growth trends and projections Age distribution of the population Household income distribution by age group Household tenure by income and age group Average household sizes Household types Race and ethnicity Household mobility Data sources utilized for this analysis include ESRI, a nationally recognized demographic services firm, Minnesota Department of Administration (DOA), the Metropolitan Council, the U.S Census . The following map illustrates the location of Maplewood within Ramsey County along with its regional location in the Seven County Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 8 Workshop Packet Page Number 15 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW The City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 9 Workshop Packet Page Number 16 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Population and Household Growth Trends The tableon the following page presents population and household growth trends in the City of Maplewoodfrom 2010to 2050. The 2010and 2020 figures are from the United StatesCensus. Estimatesfor 2026are based on a review ofpopulation and household estimatesprovided by the MinnesotaState Demographer, Metropolitan Council, ESRI,and the ACS,with adjustments made by Maxfield Researchbased on recentresidential development activityto reflect current year data. Maxfield Research arrived at the2030, 2040, and 2050projections for the City of Maplewoodbased on a review of forecasts published by the Metropolitan Council. The following graph depicts historical population growth trends in Maplewoodover the past 60+years (1960to 2026). As shown, population has experienced steady growthsince the 1960s. Historically, Maplewoodaveraged 1.3% population growth on an annual basis. We estimate that the pace population growth in Maplewoodslowedpost-COVID, averaging 0.3% average annual growth between 2020 and 2026. Between , while the household base increased by 7% (1,112 households). By comparison, the population in- creased by 9% in Ramsey County and 11% in the Metro Area, while the household base in- creased by 8% in Ramsey County and 11% in the Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 10 Workshop Packet Page Number 17 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 1 POPULATION AND HOUSEHOLD GROWTH TRENDS AND PROJECTIONS CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2010 to 2050 Population MaplewoodRamsey CountyMetro Area* 2010 Census 38,018508,6402,849,567 2020 Census 42,088552,3523,163,104 2026 Estimate 42,755557,1473,289,702 2030 Forecast 43,200560,3433,374,100 2040 Forecast 43,700580,3123,559,300 2050 Forecast 45,800602,9343,814,000 Change No.Pct.No.Pct.No.Pct. 2010 - 2020 4,07010.7%43,7128.6%313,53711.0% 2020 - 2026 6671.6%4,7950.9%126,5984.0% 2026 - 2030 4451.0%3,1960.6%84,3982.6% 2030 - 2040 5001.2%19,9693.6%185,2005.5% 2040 - 2050 2,1004.8%22,6223.9%254,7007.2% Households MaplewoodRamsey CountyMetro Area* 2010 Census 14,882202,6911,117,749 2020 Census 15,994218,0771,239,526 2026 Estimate 16,418223,9531,310,190 2030 Forecast 16,700227,8711,357,300 2040 Forecast 17,200240,1731,454,300 2050 Forecast 18,100250,6231,563,300 Change No.Pct.No.Pct.No.Pct. 2010 - 2020 1,1127.5%15,3867.6%121,77710.9% 2020 - 2026 4242.6%5,8762.7%70,6645.7% 2026 - 2030 2821.7%3,9181.7%47,1103.6% 2030 - 2040 5003.0%12,3025.4%97,0007.1% 2040 - 2050 9005.2%10,4504.4%109,0007.5% * The Twin Cities 7-County Metropolitan Area encompasses Anoka, Carver, Dakota, Hennepin, Ramsey, Scott, and Washington counties Sources: US Census; ESRI; Metropolitan Council; MN State Demographer; Maxfield Research & Consulting We estimate that growth has slowed slightly since 2020, with Maplewood adding 667 peo- ple (1.6% growth) and 424 households (2.6% growth) between 2020 and 2026. Ramsey County gained 4,795 people (0.9%) and 5,876 households (2.7%), and the Metro Area expe- rienced 4.0% population growth and 5.7% household growth from 2020 to 2026. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 11 Workshop Packet Page Number 18 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Between 2026and 2050, population is forecasttoadd 3,045 people(7% growth)and 1,682 households (10%growth).Ramsey Countyexpected to increase by 8%against12%household growthbetween 2026 and 2050. Population Age Distribution Young adults (age 20 to 24 and 25 to 34)will likelytarget rental housing or entry-level owner- ship housing, whilefamily households age 35 to 54 often seek move-up ownership housing. Maintenance-free, single-level housing (ownership or rental) generally targetsthe empty nester population (age 55 to 74), while householdsage 65to 74 and 75 and older may seek age-re- stricted active adult or service-enhanced (i.e. assisted living) senior housing. The following tablepresents the age distribution of the City of Maplewoodpopulation from 2010 to 2050. Information from 2010 and 2020 is sourced from the U.S. Census. The 2026esti- mates and projections for 2030were provided by ESRI, with adjustments made by Maxfield Re- search to reflect current information. The 2050projections are based on data provided by the MinnesotaDOA and the Minnesota State Demographer, adjusted by Maxfield Research to re- flect the local 2050population forecasts. Those under the age of 20represent the largest share of the population in Maplewood (25%),followed bythe 25 to 34 and the 35 to 44 age groups, eachat 14%of the total popu- lation.Older adults and younger s ulation, whileseniors age65 years or older account for 20%. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 12 Workshop Packet Page Number 19 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Among the adult population,those ages25 to 34 arethe largest cohort in Ramsey County (14.8% of the population), followed by the 35 to 44 age group(14.2%). In the Metro Area, age 35 to 44 is the largest cohort (14.5%). The fastest population growth is occurredamong the 65 to 74age group, as aging of baby boomers led to a substantial increase between 2010 and 2026, increasing 82% in Maple- wood, 83% in Ramsey County, and 99% in the Metro Area. As this group ages, the 75 and older age group is expected to increase 11.3% in Maplewoodbetween 2026 and 2040, be- fore remaining flat at 0.1% growth between 2040 and 2050. Maplewood is also expected to experience solid growth among people age 45 to 54, adding 1,266people between 2026 and 2050(29% growth). Based on projections for Maplewood andRamsey County, housing demand growth is ex- pected to be strongest for units catering to the older senior population, move-up ownership housing, as well as entry-level housing and rental housing for the younger age groups. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 13 Workshop Packet Page Number 20 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 2 POPULATION AGE DISTRIBUTION CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2010 - 2050 Change CensusEstimateProjection2010-20262026-2050 Age20102020202620302050No.Pct.No.Pct. Maplewood Under-209,69110,52110,43610,35610,2657457.7-171-1.6 20 to 242,4482,5232,4182,3442,936-30-1.251821.4 25 to 345,0495,9915,8165,2926,37676715.25619.6 35 to 444,5034,9705,9286,1206,1751,42531.72474.2 45 to 545,9154,5594,3275,0815,593-1,588-26.81,26629.2 55 to 644,6175,8245,1064,4475,77548910.666913.1 65 to 742,6274,2664,7894,9164,2972,16282.3-493-10.3 75+3,1683,4343,9344,6464,38276624.244811.4 Total38,01842,08842,75543,20045,8004,73712.53,0457.1 Ramsey County Under-20135,728141,217137,826132,721135,1382,0981.5-2,688-2.0 20 to 2444,19441,73241,59843,51438,657-2,596-5.9-2,940-7.1 25 to 3477,11988,07882,53776,87183,9425,4187.01,4051.7 35 to 4460,93370,96679,15879,30581,29118,22529.92,1342.7 45 to 5470,57059,29259,41567,42573,629-11,155-15.814,21523.9 55 to 6458,91566,03558,30153,59776,029-614-1.017,72830.4 65 to 7430,35150,20355,70954,88456,56325,35883.58551.5 75+30,83034,82942,60452,02757,68411,77438.215,07935.4 Total508,640552,352557,147560,343602,93448,5079.545,7878.2 Metro Area Under-20774,287807,770807,338795,755856,57333,0514.349,2346.1 20 to 24190,135204,447220,720225,091213,23630,58516.1-7,484-3.4 25 to 34420,311461,046453,810457,238495,73433,4998.041,9249.2 35 to 44391,324433,214476,280471,984543,79684,95621.767,51614.2 45 to 54440,753383,578387,016432,974509,088-53,737-12.2122,07231.5 55 to 64326,007407,524380,637353,143451,23254,63016.870,59518.5 65 to 74163,425280,318325,461340,760350,931162,03699.225,4707.8 75+143,325185,207238,440297,155393,41195,11566.4154,97165.0 Total2,849,5673,163,1043,289,7023,374,1003,814,000440,13515.4524,29815.9 Sources: US Census; ESRI; MN State Demographic Center; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 14 Workshop Packet Page Number 21 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Household Incomeby Age of Householder Household income data helps ascertain the demand for different types of housing based on the size of the market at specific cost levels. The following tablespresent data on household in- come by age of householder for Maplewoodand Ramsey Countyin 2026and 2030. The data is estimated by ESRIwith adjustments made by Maxfield Research to reflect current household estimates and projections. The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) defines affordable housing cost as less than 30% As illustrated in the following chart, household incomes tend to peak in their late 40s to early 50s. The 45 to 54 age group has the highest estimated incomes at $132,047in Maple- wood, $116,111in Ramsey County, and $139,710in the Metro Area. In 2026, the median household income in Maplewoodis estimated to be $90,028,10% higherthanRamsey County($81,619) but-12% lower than the Metro Area($102,599). By 2030, median household incomesareprojected to increase 11% in Maplewood ($99,509), 10% in Ramsey County($89,710),and 9% in the Metro Area($111,545). Household growth is projected to be strongest among the highest income brackets, as the total number of households with incomes of $100,000 or higher increases 14% (1,051 households) in Maplewoodand 15% in Ramsey County(13,620households). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 15 Workshop Packet Page Number 22 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 3 HOUSEHOLD INCOME BY AGE OF HOUSEHOLDER CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2026 - 2030 Age of Householder TotalUnder 2525 - 3435 - 4445 - 5455 - 6465 - 7475+ 2026 Less than $15,0001,0928519313107116109469 $15,000 to $24,9998534176551167225288 $25,000 to $34,9999433658114021246262 $35,000 to $49,9991,40937162173111286402236 $50,000 to $74,9992,615134258291418416401697 $75,000 to $99,9991,96143397422139294240424 $100,000 to $149,9993,889307391,069525827536163 $150,000 to $199,9991,8016295388567150260135 $200,000+1,85659344546744130599 Total16,4184182,2712,9702,3362,9072,9422,573 Median Income$90,028$51,929$99,264$113,025$132,047$96,181$65,864$57,134 2030 Less than $15,0001,02474166151019198480 $15,000 to $24,9997354160500111188284 $25,000 to $34,999808384386215041970 $35,000 to $49,9991,24034120161104222343256 $50,000 to $74,9992,476143210258401310372782 $75,000 to $99,9991,82141338356141224223498 $100,000 to $149,9994,037326931,114628742591236 $150,000 to $199,9992,05910292419673153309202 $200,000+2,5006124563663513432200 Total16,7004192,0473,0222,7132,5152,9763,008 Median Income$99,509$54,091$103,030$118,043$144,188$104,654$78,266$60,852 Change - 2026 to 2030 Less than $15,000-68-11-271-6-25-1211 $15,000 to $24,999-119-1-16-5-1-56-37-4 $25,000 to $34,999-1352-15-272-62-438 $35,000 to $49,999-168-3-42-12-7-64-5920 $50,000 to $74,999-1398-48-33-17-106-2986 $75,000 to $99,999-140-3-59-662-70-1874 $100,000 to $149,9991482-4645103-855573 $150,000 to $199,9992584-33110734967 $200,000+64513111819572126101 Total2821-22552377-39233435 Median Income$9,481$2,162$3,766$5,018$12,141$8,473$12,402$3,718 Sources: ESRI; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 16 Workshop Packet Page Number 23 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 4 HOUSEHOLD INCOME BY AGE OF HOUSEHOLDER RAMSEY COUNTY 2026 - 2030 Age of Householder TotalUnder 2525 - 3435 - 4445 - 5455 - 6465 - 7475+ 2026 Less than $15,00019,9942,0473,3772,5981,0774,2263,2743,395 $15,000 to $24,99911,7831,0421,1061,9118601,7252,2322,906 $25,000 to $34,99913,9611,0673,1501,1341,4432,0223,8191,327 $35,000 to $49,99920,0331,3843,9423,0072,4422,4034,0002,856 $50,000 to $74,99937,1592,4066,7017,1334,4744,6065,7516,088 $75,000 to $99,99928,1081,1395,8175,5113,7273,7793,1015,034 $100,000 to $149,99941,5319198,6978,7037,0886,7146,4432,968 $150,000 to $199,99922,3311733,5545,3475,4283,6863,0811,062 $200,000+29,0551142,5437,9127,6485,5563,3041,978 Total223,95310,29038,88643,25634,18634,71735,00527,614 Median Income$81,619$44,920$78,892$101,163$116,111$89,224$65,925$61,195 2030 Less than $15,00018,7191,9472,8672,3181,0433,6852,9853,876 $15,000 to $24,99910,2171,0238161,5457151,2911,9422,886 $25,000 to $34,99911,9491,0082,3929481,2981,5383,2701,495 $35,000 to $49,99917,9791,2913,1982,6232,3051,8963,4553,212 $50,000 to $74,99935,7402,5875,9536,5804,3213,8545,3837,063 $75,000 to $99,99926,7311,2445,0985,0253,7362,9922,7555,881 $100,000 to $149,99943,1401,0738,3798,8668,0156,2726,5144,021 $150,000 to $199,99925,4042903,9275,6826,6153,7943,5311,564 $200,000+37,9931873,3549,54110,4536,4564,4723,530 Total227,87110,64935,98443,12638,50131,77734,30633,528 Median Income$89,710$49,338$85,213$107,715$128,209$100,485$73,872$65,639 Change - 2026 to 2030 Less than $15,000-1,274-100-510-281-35-541-288481 $15,000 to $24,999-1,565-19-290-366-145-435-290-20 $25,000 to $34,999-2,012-59-758-186-145-484-549167 $35,000 to $49,999-2,054-93-744-385-137-506-545356 $50,000 to $74,999-1,419182-748-553-153-752-368975 $75,000 to $99,999-1,377105-719-4869-788-346847 $100,000 to $149,9991,609154-317163928-442701,053 $150,000 to $199,9993,0731173733351,187109450502 $200,000+8,938738111,6282,8058991,1681,553 Total3,918360-2,902-1304,315-2,940-6985,914 Median Income$8,091$4,418$6,321$6,552$12,098$11,261$7,947$4,444 Sources: ESRI; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 17 Workshop Packet Page Number 24 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Household Tenure by Income The following summarizes household tenure by income in the Market Area in 2026based on estimatesfrom the ACS. Generally, the higher the income, the lower the percentage a house- hold typically allocates to housing. Many lower income households, as well as many young and senior households, spend more than 30% of their income on housing, while middle-aged house- holds in their prime earning years generallyallocate 20% to 25% of their income to housing. In Maplewood, 27%of households with incomes below $15,000 are owner households while 24% of households with incomes in the $15,000 to $24,999 range own. The homeownership rate increases to 83% of all households with incomes in the $100,000 to $149,999 range and 95% of households with incomes of $150,000 or higher. Among owner households in Maplewood, the highest proportion haveincomes at or above $150,000(33% of all owner households), followed by households with incomes in the $100,000 to $149,999 range(27%). The highest proportion of renter households in Maplewoodhaveincomesin the $50,000 to $74,999 range (22% of renter households), followed by households with less than $15,000 and those who earn $75,000 to $99,999, each accountingfor 15% of renter households. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 18 Workshop Packet Page Number 25 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW In Ramsey County, 21% of renter households have incomes in the $50,000 to $74,999 range while 15% have incomes in the $35,000 to $49,999 range. The $50,000 to $74,999 range is also most common renter household incomes range in the Metro Area (20% of renter households). Median household incomes are substantially higher among owner households than renter households in the Market Area. In Maplewood, owner households have an estimated me- dian household income of $123,422 compared to $54,796 among renter households. Esti- mated median household incomes in Ramsey County are $116,345 for owner households and $53,788 for renter households. TABLE 5 TENURE BY HOUSEHOLD INCOME CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2026 MaplewoodRamsey CountyMetro Area No.Pct.No.Pct.No.Pct. Owner Households Less than $15,000 30327.4 4,12923.9 25,22832.4 $15,000 to $24,999 21324.4 3,33525.8 20,56234.0 $25,000 to $34,999 36455.4 5,01535.9 27,64342.9 $35,000 to $49,999 1,09159.5 9,24739.0 53,50247.7 $50,000 to $74,999 1,29152.8 18,51848.7 106,741 55.3 $75,000 to $99,999 1,18160.0 17,48361.6 109,605 65.9 $100,000 to $149,999 3,02882.6 28,30471.5 197,452 76.0 $150,000+ 3,69595.4 43,65287.1 337,362 89.7 Subtotal: 11,16568.0 129,68257.9 878,09567.0 Median HH Income$123,422$116,345$132,026 Renter Households Less than $15,000 80372.6 13,16176.1 52,66367.6 $15,000 to $24,999 66075.6 9,59374.2 39,92366.0 $25,000 to $34,999 29344.6 8,94464.1 36,77757.1 $35,000 to $49,999 74240.5 14,45061.0 58,60852.3 $50,000 to $74,999 1,15447.2 19,49551.3 86,29144.7 $75,000 to $99,999 78840.0 10,88238.4 56,74934.1 $100,000 to $149,999 63817.4 11,28428.5 62,20824.0 $150,000+ 1764.6 6,46212.9 38,87810.3 Subtotal: 5,25332.0 94,27242.1 432,09633.0 Median HH Income$54,796$53,788$61,271 Total Households 16,418 100 223,954 100 1,310,191 100 Sources: 2020-2024 American Community Survey; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 19 Workshop Packet Page Number 26 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Household Tenure by Age The followingtablesummarizeshousehold tenure by age of householder for the City of Maple- woodin 2010 and 2026. Data for 2010 is obtained from the Decennial Census, while the 2026 informationis based on the 2020 Decennial Censusand adjusted by Maxfield Research to re- flect 2026household estimates. The table shows the number and percent of renter-and owner-occupied housing units in the Market Area. All data excludes unoccupied units and group quarters such as dormitories and nursing homes. or own their housing. In addition to preferences, factors that contribute to these proportions include mortgage interest rates, household age, and lifestyle considerations, among others. In Maplewood, an estimated 68% of all households own in 2026, giving it a homeownership rate that is higherthan in Ramsey County(58%) andthe Metro Area(67%). Within the prime ownership years (35 to 64), 74% of households in Maplewoodown in 2026, compared to 63% in Ramsey Countyand 73% in the Metro Area. Homeownership Rate by Age of Householder (2026) 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% <2525-3435-4445-5455-6465-7475+Total Maplewood 19.8%52.0%67.3%75.0%79.5%76.5%61.7%68.0% Ramsey Co. 10.5%35.4%56.4%63.8%70.0%74.3%66.1%57.9% Metro Area 12.1%43.8%67.3%75.1%78.9%80.0%69.4%67.0% Typically, the youngest and oldest households rent their housing in greater proportions than middle-age households. This pattern is apparent among younger householdsin Maplewood as80% of households under the age of 25 rent. The percentage of renter households de- creases to 48% of age 25 to 34 households. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 20 Workshop Packet Page Number 27 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 6 TENURE BY AGE OF HOUSEHOLDER CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2010 & 2026 20102026 No.Pct.No.Pct.No.No.Pct.No.Pct.No. MaplewoodOwnerRenterTotalOwnerRenterTotal Under 25 122 23.1% 40776.9% 529 8319.8% 33580.2% 418 25 to 34 1,27057.5% 93942.5% 2,209 1,181 52.0% 1,090 48.0% 2,271 35 to 44 1,70272.0% 66328.0% 2,365 2,000 67.3% 97132.7% 2,970 45 to 54 2,71282.2% 58817.8% 3,300 1,752 75.0% 58425.0% 2,336 55 to 64 2,32384.3% 43315.7% 2,756 2,312 79.5% 59520.5% 2,907 65 to 74 1,36784.4% 25315.6% 1,620 2,250 76.5% 69223.5% 2,942 75+ 1,37565.4% 72834.6% 2,103 1,588 61.7% 98538.3% 2,573 Total: 10,87173.0% 4,011 27.0% 14,882 11,16568.0% 5,253 32.0% 16,418 Ramsey Co.OwnerRenterTotalOwnerRenterTotal Under 25 1,35111.2% 10,75288.8% 12,103 1,080 10.5% 9,210 89.5% 10,290 25 to 34 15,14339.9% 22,79860.1% 37,941 13,78235.4% 25,10464.6% 38,886 35 to 44 20,64960.3% 13,61139.7% 34,260 24,41156.4% 18,84543.6% 43,256 45 to 54 29,24070.7% 12,14729.3% 41,387 21,81963.8% 12,36736.2% 34,186 55 to 64 27,73576.1% 8,689 23.9% 36,424 24,31870.0% 10,39930.0% 34,717 65 to 74 15,19478.0% 4,291 22.0% 19,485 26,02674.3% 8,979 25.7% 35,005 75+ 14,13667.0% 6,955 33.0% 21,091 18,24766.1% 9,367 33.9% 27,614 Total: 123,448 60.9% 79,24339.1% 202,691 129,68257.9% 94,27242.1% 223,954 Metro AreaOwnerRenterTotalOwnerRenterTotal Under 25 7,94716.0% 41,78984.0% 49,736 5,792 12.1% 41,95587.9% 47,747 25 to 34 102,23650.6% 99,71649.4% 201,952 91,79543.8% 117,57356.2% 209,368 35 to 44 154,67872.3% 59,30327.7% 213,981 173,60467.3% 84,27332.7% 257,877 45 to 54 202,40479.8% 51,37920.2% 253,783 165,06875.1% 54,61724.9% 219,685 55 to 64 162,59582.6% 34,35517.4% 196,950 174,96278.9% 46,75621.1% 221,718 65 to 74 85,34782.6% 17,99817.4% 103,345 160,39280.0% 40,03120.0% 200,423 75+ 67,26868.6% 30,73431.4% 98,002 106,48269.4% 46,89130.6% 153,373 Total: 782,475 70.0% 335,27430.0% 1,117,749 878,09567.0% 432,09633.0% 1,310,191 Note: Some totals may not add due to rounding Sources: U.S. Census; Maxfield Research & Consulting The total number of owner households residing in Maplewood grew by an estimated 294 households between 2010 and 2026, an increase of 3%, while the number of renter house- holds expanded 31% (1,242 households). By comparison, the Metro Area experienced 12% growth in owner households between 2010 and 2026 compared to 29% growth among renter households. As depicted in the following chart, the largest overall increase occurred in the 65 to 74 age group in Maplewood between 2010 and 2026, with the addition of 883 owner households (65% growth) and 439 renter households (174% growth). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 21 Workshop Packet Page Number 28 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW In Maplewood, owner household growth occurred in the 35 to 44, 65 to 74, and 75 and older age groups but contracted in the under 25, 25 to 34, 45 to 54, and 55 to 64age co- horts between 2010 and 2026. Aside from the 65 to 74 age group, owner household growth was largest among the 35 to 44 (298households, 18% growth), and 75 and older(213households, 16% growth) age groups. Renter household growth occurred in the 25 to 34, 35 to 44, 55 to 64, 65to 74, and 75 and olderage groups between 2010 and 2026, while renter household contraction occurred among the under age 25, 45 to 54, and 75 and older age cohorts. Aside from age 65 to 74, renterhousehold growth was largest among the 35 to 44 (308 households, 46% growth), age75 and older(257households, 35% growth), and 55 to 64 (162 households, 37% growth)age groups. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 22 Workshop Packet Page Number 29 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Tenure by Household Size The following table summarizes household tenure by size of household in the City of Maple- wood during 2010 and 2026 from the U.S. Census and ACS. Note that some totals may not add due to rounding. The tables show the number and percent of renter- and owner-occupied housing units by household size. All data excludes unoccupied units and group quarters. TABLE 7 HOUSEHOLD SIZE BY TENURE CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2010 & 2026 20102026 No.Pct.No.Pct.No.No.Pct.No.Pct.No. MaplewoodOwnerRenterTotalOwnerRenterTotal 1-Person 2,554 58.9% 1,784 41.1% 4,338 2,483 50.2% 2,461 49.8% 4,944 2-Person 4,084 81.0% 95819.0% 5,042 4,720 84.3% 87915.7% 5,599 3-Person 1,725 75.9% 54724.1% 2,272 1,593 80.6% 38419.4% 1,978 4-Person 1,432 79.2% 37620.8% 1,808 1,047 69.6% 45730.4% 1,504 5-Person 56874.3% 19625.7% 764 73277.0% 21823.0% 950 6-Person 26976.4% 8323.6% 352 58582.2% 12617.8% 711 7+Person 23978.1% 6721.9% 306 62585% 10815% 733 Total: 10,87173.0% 4,01127.0% 14,882 11,16568.0% 5,25332.0% 16,418 Avg. HH Size 2.55 2.19 2.46 2.91 1.87 2.57 Ramsey CountyOwnerRenterTotalOwnerRenterTotal 1-Person 31,46946.8% 35,71253.2% 67,181 35,35845.2% 42,92754.8% 78,284 2-Person 45,05069.3% 19,91930.7% 64,969 48,94066.7% 24,40233.3% 73,342 3-Person 18,92666.7% 9,452 33.3% 28,378 19,74269.9% 8,518 30.1% 28,259 4-Person 15,90370.1% 6,769 29.9% 22,672 16,19173.0% 5,993 27.0% 22,184 5-Person 6,678 65.2% 3,572 34.8% 10,250 7,849 71.8% 3,090 28.2% 10,939 6-Person 2,754 60.6% 1,788 39.4% 4,542 3,936 71.1% 1,597 28.9% 5,533 7+Person 2,668 56.8% 2,031 43.2% 4,699 3,719 68.7% 1,693 31.3% 5,411 Total: 123,44860.9% 79,24339.1% 202,691 129,68257.9% 94,27242.1% 223,954 Avg. HH Size 2.52 2.19 2.39 2.67 1.89 2.34 Metro AreaOwnerRenterTotalOwnerRenterTotal 1-Person 171,24153.7% 147,78946.3% 319,030 199,73950.6% 194,70949.4% 394,448 2-Person 280,55276.3% 87,13923.7% 367,691 332,44674.3% 115,06625.7% 447,511 3-Person 128,19775.1% 42,56324.9% 170,760 141,33277.3% 41,55722.7% 182,889 4-Person 123,21980.6% 29,58719.4% 152,806 138,57782.9% 28,63717.1% 167,214 5-Person 50,85477.4% 14,88322.6% 65,737 57,54879.2% 15,12920.8% 72,677 6-Person 16,88771.0% 6,908 29.0% 23,795 20,59576.8% 6,222 23.2% 26,817 7+Person 11,52564.3% 6,405 35.7% 17,930 13,24171.1% 5,394 28.9% 18,635 Total: 782,47570.0% 335,274 30.0% 1,117,749 878,095 67.0% 432,096 33.0% 1,310,191 Avg. HH Size 2.61 2.17 2.48 2.67 1.89 2.41 Sources: U.S. Census; 2020-2024 American Community Survey; Maxfield Research & Consulting In 2010, the average renter household in Maplewood contained 2.19 persons per house- hold, while the average owner household included 2.55 persons. By 2026, average renter household sizes decreased to 1.87, while average owner household sizes increased to 2.91. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 23 Workshop Packet Page Number 30 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW In 2026, two-person households are the most common household size in Maplewood, rep- resenting 34% of all households, followed closely by one-person households (30%). By com- parison, one-person households are most common in Ramsey County (35% of all house- holds). The strongest growth in Maplewood between 2010 and 2026 occurred in the number of one-person households, adding 606households (14%). Solid growth also occurred among most other household size categories, with the exception of three-and four-person house- holds, which contracted by 13% and 17%, respectively. Household Type The following table summarizeshousehold type trends in Maplewoodand Ramsey Countycom- pared to the Metro Areain 2010 and 2026. Data is obtained from the Decennial Censusand the ACS. Shifting household types can stimulate demand for a variety of housing products. Married couple family householdswith childrentypically generate demand for single-family de- tached ownership housing. Married couples without children, which are generally younger cou- ples that have not had children (and may not have children) and older couples with adult chil- dren that have moved out of the home, often desire multifamily housing for convenience rea- sons. Other family households, defined as a male or female householder with no spouse pre- sent (typicallysingle-parent households), often require affordable housing. Changes in non- family households (households living alone and households composed of unrelated roommates) drive demand for rental housing. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 24 Workshop Packet Page Number 31 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 8 HOUSEHOLD TYPE CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2010 & 2026 MaplewoodRamsey CountyMetro Area 201020262010202620102026 Total Households14,88216,418202,691223,9531,117,7491,310,190 Non-Family Households5,2626,25884,89299,188410,253506,934 Living Alone4,3384,94467,18178,284319,030394,448 Other (Roommates)9241,31517,71120,90491,223112,486 Family Households9,62010,160117,799124,765707,496803,256 Married w/ Children2,8992,93936,04636,513252,934267,323 Married w/o Children4,2104,54547,34451,743290,476353,738 Other Family2,5112,67534,40936,509164,086182,195 Change (2010 - 2026)No.Pct.No.Pct.No.Pct. Total Households1,53610.3%21,26210.5%192,44117.2% Non-Family Households99618.9%14,29616.8%96,68123.6% Living Alone60614.0%11,10316.5%75,41823.6% Other (Roommates)39142.3%3,19318.0%21,26323.3% Family Households5405.6%6,9665.9%95,76013.5% Married w/ Children401.4%4671.3%14,3895.7% Married w/o Children3358.0%4,3999.3%63,26221.8% Other Family1646.5%2,1006.1%18,10911.0% Sources: U.S. Census; 2020-2024 American Community Survey; Maxfield Research & Consulting In Maplewood, households living alone are estimated to be the most common household type (30% of all households), followed by married couples without children households (28%). Households living alone are also the most common household type in Ramsey County (35% of all households) and the Metro Area (30%). In 2026, family households comprise an estimated 62% of all households in Maplewood compared to 56% in Ramsey County and 61% in the Metro Area. Family households experienced modest growth between 2010 and 2026 in Maplewood, in- creasing by an estimated 540 households (5.6%). The number of family households ex- panded 5.9% in the County while increasing 13.5% in the Metro between 2010 and 2026. - Maplewood experienced 1.4% growth in married couple with children households (40 households) between 2010 and 2026, while the number of married couples without chil- dren expanded 8.0% (335 households). The number of other family households in- creased 6.5% (164 households). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 25 Workshop Packet Page Number 32 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Non-family households experienced much strongergrowth between 2010 and 2026 in Maplewood, increasing by an estimated 996households (18.9%), including 14.0% growth in households living alone (606) and 42.3% growth in roommate households (391). By comparison,non-family households expanded 16.8% inRamsey County and 23.6% in the Metro Areabetween 2010 and 2026. Race and Ethnicity The following tabledisplays the breakdown of the City of Maplewoodpopulation by race and ethnicity. This data is useful in that it illustrates shifts in the demographic characteristics of Maplewoodpopulation from 2020to 2026. Data for 2020is obtained from the Decennial Cen- sus, while currentestimatesarebased oninformationprovided by ESRIand household tenure data is sourced from the ACS. Federal standards mandate that race and ethnicity are separate and distinct identities and Cen- sus results are based on self-identification. A person may be categorized as one of two ethnic self- the 2010 Census to the 2020 Census that enabled respondents to report multiple races gener- ated a significant increase in the number of people identifying as multiracialbetween the two Census periods. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 26 Workshop Packet Page Number 33 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW In 2026the populationin Maplewood, at an estimated 55% compared to 58% in Ramsey Countyand 68%in the Metro Area. Peo- ple identified as Asian Alonewasthe second most populous group in Maplewood(20%) and in Ramsey County(16%), was thesecond most populousgroupin the Metro Area(11%). Based on 2020-2024American Community Survey estimates, approximately 78% of White Alone households in Maplewoodown their housing while the remaining 22% rent. The home ownership rate declinesto 58% amongall other races in the City. An estimated 56% of Hispanic households own compared to 79% of non-Hispanic households in Maplewood. Mostraces experienced population growth between 2020 and 2026in Maplewood, with the exception of (2.6% decrease)and (11% de- crease). The largest growth occurred among people identifying as being (747 people, 9.3% growth)and Some Other Race Alone(155people, 8.2% growth). The number of people self-identifying as being of Hispanic or Latino origin expanded in Maplewoodbetween 2020and 2026, adding 274people (7.3% growth), compared to 11% growth intheMetro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 27 Workshop Packet Page Number 34 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 9 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 28 Workshop Packet Page Number 35 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW Resident Mobility The following tablesummarizesmobility patterns of the City of Maplewoodresidents within a one-year timeframefrom the ACS survey period. People move for various reasons, but housing is aprimary motivator, followed by family-related reasons, and job-related reasons. Local moves are generally housing-related, while longer-distance moves are oftenjob-related. Renter households and younger households tend to be more highly mobile than owner house- holds and older households. The majority of residents in Maplewooddid not change residences within a one-year time period of the ACS Survey, including 91% of residents in Maplewood, 85% in Ramsey County, and 87% of residents in the Metro Area. Among the residents that movedtoMaplewood, most moved from withinRamsey County (4% of all residents). Another 3% relocated to Maplewoodfrom within a different County in Minnesota, and 1.2% moved from outside a different state. The following graph illustrates the number of residentsthat moved to Maplewoodin the past year by age group compared to resident mobility by age group in the Metro Area. Among the residents that moved in Maplewood within the one-year time period 24% were in the 25 to 34 age group, while 19% were under the age of 18and 15% were ages 35 to 44. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 29 Workshop Packet Page Number 36 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW TABLE 10 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 30 Workshop Packet Page Number 37 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Employment Trends Introduction Employment characteristics are relevant when evaluating housing needs in any given market area as employment growth often fuels household growth. Typically, households prefer to live near work for convenience, which is a primary factor in choosing a housing location. Many households, however, choose to commute greater distances to work provided their housing is affordable enough to offset the additional transportation costs. This section of the report evaluates employment trends and characteristics in Maplewood, Ramsey County and the Seven County Metro as they relate to housing demand in the commu- nity, with comparisons made to the surrounding region. The following topics are reviewed. Labor force, resident employment, and unemployment trends Commuting patterns Job growth trends and projections Employment and average wages by industry sector Major employers Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development (MN DEED) is the primary data resource for this section of the market study. Other information sources include the United States Census Bureau Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics (LEHD) program. Ad- ditionally, Maxfield Research and Consulting researched General Obligation Bond Official State- ments via the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) Electronic Municipal Market Ac- cess (EMMA) to obtain information on major employers in the area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 31 Workshop Packet Page Number 38 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Resident Employment The following table shows information on labor force, resident employment, and unemploy- ment trends over the past ten years in Maplewood and Ramsey County compared to the Seven County Metro Area. Data is sourced from MN DEED. Resident employment data reveals the workforce and number of employed people living in the area. It is important to note that not all of these individuals necessarily work in the area. TABLE 11 LABOR FORCE AND RESIDENT EMPLOYMENT TRENDS MAPLEWOOD, RAMSEY COUNTY & SEVEN COUNTY METRO AREA 2015 - 2026 MaplewoodRamsey CountySeven County Metro Area LaborEmployedUELaborEmployedUELaborEmployedUE ForceResidentsRateForceResidentsRateForceResidentsRate Year 2026*21,20420,3004.3%287,770276,6123.9%1,762,5471,697,8283.7% 202521,50920,6074.2%291,837280,8043.8%1,788,3681,723,5363.6% 202421,22620,5073.4%288,265279,4323.1%1,767,0581,715,5072.9% 202321,28620,6682.9%287,288279,7562.6%1,756,7581,712,3502.5% 202221,16120,5972.7%286,107279,2422.4%1,738,0151,699,6182.2% 202121,45620,5364.3%286,584275,0424.0%1,723,5241,661,7983.6% 202022,48920,8537.3%296,702276,2796.9%1,762,0381,649,1976.4% 201922,47921,7493.2%296,640287,7933.0%1,755,3811,704,6952.9% 201822,38821,7522.8%294,854286,8592.7%1,733,7691,688,2882.6% 201722,37421,6243.4%293,908284,6423.2%1,724,5411,671,9493.0% 201622,01821,2003.7%290,545280,3183.5%1,697,8031,640,1943.4% 201520,48319,7063.8%280,242270,1413.6%1,653,8381,597,3103.4% *Monthly data for April 2026 Sources: MN DEED; Maxfield Research & Consulting In 2025, Maplewood had a labor force of 21,509 and resident employment of 20,607, for an unemployment rate of 4.2%. It was slightly higher than the unemployment rate of 3.8% in Ramsey County and 3.6% in the Metro Area. - As of April of 2026, unemployment was at 4.3% in Maplewood compared to 3.9% in Ramsey County and 3.7% in the Metro Area. labor force contracted 2.3% (509) during the ten-year time period from 2016 to 2025, while resident employment increased 2.8% (593). During that same time, Ramsey County experienced 0.4% labor force growth (1,292) against 0.2% resident employment growth (486). By comparison, the labor force in the Metro Area expanded 5.3% against a 5.1% increase in resident employment. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 32 Workshop Packet Page Number 39 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS Because labor force growth outpaced employment growth in the Market Area, unemploy- ment rates declined. Resident employment dropped sharply in Maplewood in 2020 due to job losses related to the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent economic recession, declining 4.1% (896) com- pared to decreases of4.0% in Ramsey County and 3.3% in the Metro Area. As resident employment dropped in 2020, the annual unemployment rate spiked to 7.3% in Maplewood, 6.9% in Ramsey County, and 6.4% in the Metro Area. ployment increased 0.3% (73). By comparison, Ramsey County experienced 1.8% labor force growth (5,253) and 2.1% resident employment growth (5,762) during that period. Commuting Patterns Proximity to employment is often a primary consideration when choosing where to live, partic- ularly for younger and lower income households since transportation costs often account for a greater proportion of their budgets. For this analysis, we reviewed commuting pattern data for the City of Maplewood from the U.S. Census Bureau Local Employment Dynamics data for 2023, the most recent data available. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 33 Workshop Packet Page Number 40 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS The following table provides a summary of the inflow and outflow characteristics of the work- ers in Maplewood. Outflow reflects the number of workers living in the area but employed out- side the City, while inflow measures the number of workers that are employed in the City but live outside the area. Interior flow reflects the number of workers that live and work in Maple- wood. Approximately 12,628 workers commute into Maplewood for employment daily (inflow), while 17,540 resident workers leave the community (outflow). An estimated 954 people both live and work in the City (interior flow). Roughly 93% of the jobs in Maplewood are filled by workers commuting into the City. The highest proportion of workers coming into the area are aged 30 to 54 and earn more than the largest percentage of employees (56%). TABLE 12 Overall, Maplewood is an exporter of workers as a higher number of residents commute out of the City for employment than nonresidents commute into the City. With 12,628 workers commuting into Maplewood for employment daily, there appears to be an opportunity to provide housing options for a portion of these workers. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 34 Workshop Packet Page Number 41 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS 2023Commuting PatternCity of Maplewood The following informationhighlights the commuting patterns, including distance and destina- tion, of workers with primary jobs in Maplewood based on Local Employment Dynamics data for 2023. Home Destination summarizes where workers live who are employed in the City, while Work Destination represents where workers are employed who live in Maplewood. Roughly 93% of the workers employed in Maplewood reside outside the City, while 7% (954) reside in the City. The largest proportion of workers commuting into Maplewood come from St. Paul(15.5%), Minneapolis (5.6%),Woodbury(4.0%), and Oakdale(3.2%). Approximately 48% of the workers in Maplewood reside within ten miles of their place of employment while 36% travel from 10 to 24 miles. Roughly 10% of the workers commute from a distance of 25 to 50 miles and another 6% come from more than 50 miles away Roughly 95% of the workers living in Maplewood commute outside of the City, most notably to St. Paul (21.1%), Minneapolis (12.4%), Edina (3.6%), and Roseville (3.6%). Among workers living in Maplewood, 51% travel less than ten miles for their jobs, while 42% have a commute distance from 10 to 24 miles. Approximately 3% commute between 25 and 50 miles while 4% commute more than 50 miles for employment. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 35 Workshop Packet Page Number 42 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS TABLE 13 Employment Growth Trends The table on the following page shows employment growth trends and projections from 2030 to 2050 for Maplewood, Ramsey County and the Seven County Metro Area. Annual employ- ment data is sourced from the MN DEED Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, while projections are sourced from the Metropolitan Council. All establishments covered under the Unemployment Insurance Program are required to report wage and employment data quarterly. Federal government establishments are also covered by the QCEW program. Workers and jobs excluded from these statistics include the self-em- ployed, family farm workers, and those who work only on a commission basis. As of 2025, there were 25,125 jobs in Maplewood, representing roughly 8% of jobs in Ram- sey County. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 36 Workshop Packet Page Number 43 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Data indicates that employment in Maplewood contracted between 2010 and 2025, losing 2,046 jobs (7.5%) during that period. Due, in part, to the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent recession, employment con- tracted 7.8% (2,173 jobs) in Maplewood, compared to a 7.7% decrease in Ramsey County and 7.4% decrease in the Seven County Metro between 2019 and 2020. Employment in Maplewood contracted 2.5% (617 jobs) between 2020 and 2025, while Ramsey County and the Metro Area both experienced modest growth, increasing 6.4% and 7.2%, respectively during that time period. Solid job growth is anticipated in Maplewood and Ramsey County over the next 25 years. The Metropolitan Council forecasts Maplewood will experience 27% growth, adding 6,775 jobs between 2025 and 2050, while Ramsey County experiences 11% job growth and em- ployment in the Metro Area expands 16%. TABLE 14 Labor availability will be a key factor impacting the ability of Maplewood to maintain em- ployment levels and achieve projected job growth. New housing will be needed to support potential labor force growth in the area. Additionally, job growth in the Twin Cities Metro Area will also stimulate some housing de- mand in Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 37 Workshop Packet Page Number 44 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS RamseyCountyJob Concentrations MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 38 Workshop Packet Page Number 45 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS Industry Employment and Wage Data The tables on the following pages display information on the employment and wage situation in Maplewood, Ramsey County and the Metro Area. The Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW) data is sourced from MNDEED and data for 2025, 2024, and 2023 is the annual figure, the most recent data available. Certain industries may not display any information which means that there is either no re- ported economic activity for that industry or the data has been suppressed to protect the confi- dentiality of cooperating employers. This generally occurs when there are too few employers or one employer comprises too much of the employment in that geography. Professional and Business Services is the largest employment sector in Maplewood (8,109 reported jobs, 32.3% of the total). Education and Health Services is the second largest sec- tor, representing 26.1% of jobs in Maplewood (6,552 jobs), followed by Trade, Transporta- tion and Utilities (17.8% of employment, or 4,469 jobs). Education and Health Services is the largest employment sector in Ramsey County (32.1% of total jobs), followed by Professional and Business Services (13.3%). Maplewood employment contracted 3.7% (953 jobs) between 2023 and 2025, while Ram- sey County added 5,729 jobs (1.8% growth). Public Administration experienced the largest increase in Maplewood, adding 33 jobs (9.6% growth) during that time period, followed by Leisure and Hospitality (35 jobs, 1.7% growth). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 39 Workshop Packet Page Number 46 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS TABLE 15 INDUSTRY EMPLOYMENT TRENDS MAPLEWOOD, RAMSEY COUNTY AND SEVEN COUNTY METRO AREA 2023 - 2025 Change 2023-20242024-2025 Industry202320242025No.Pct.No.Pct. Maplewood Total, All Industries26,07825,77525,125-303-1.2%-650-2.5% Natural Resources & Mining-------------- Construction786798761121.5%-37-4.6% Manufacturing1,0991,0481,002-51-4.6%-46-4.4% Trade, Transportation & Utilities4,7414,7544,469130.3%-285-6.0% Information615456-7-11.5%23.7% Financial Activities536504534-32-6.0%306.0% Prof. & Business Svcs.8,7008,4388,109-262-3.0%-329-3.9% Education & Health Svcs.6,5936,5666,552-27-0.4%-14-0.2% Leisure & Hospitality2,4932,5262,528331.3%20.1% Other Services72373173581.1%40.5% Public Administration34435337792.6%246.8% Ramsey County Total, All Industries324,921325,867330,6509460.3%4,7831.5% Natural Resources & Mining837260-11-13.3%-12-16.7% Construction12,55512,67613,0711211.0%3953.1% Manufacturing28,59927,56926,897-1,030-3.6%-672-2.4% Trade, Transportation & Utilities43,54943,92043,5963710.9%-324-0.7% Information4,9785,1044,9691262.5%-135-2.6% Financial Activities19,09918,99319,675-106-0.6%6823.6% Prof. & Business Svcs.45,65743,56343,988-2,094-4.6%4251.0% Education & Health Svcs.101,701102,236106,2555350.5%4,0193.9% Leisure & Hospitality28,16528,91328,2627482.7%-651-2.3% Other Services11,79512,00011,9072051.7%-93-0.8% Public Administration28,73730,81831,9682,0817.2%1,1503.7% Seven County Metro Total, All Industries1,757,4331,765,1731,771,7747,7400.4%6,6010.4% Natural Resources & Mining4,1864,1114,371-75-1.8%2606.3% Construction80,18480,05682,958-128-0.2%2,9023.6% Manufacturing175,899172,858169,752-3,041-1.7%-3,106-1.8% Trade, Transportation & Utilities318,759319,462314,8377030.2%-4,625-1.4% Information30,11928,72626,889-1,393-4.6%-1,837-6.4% Financial Activities131,228126,683125,948-4,545-3.5%-735-0.6% Prof. & Business Svcs.292,747282,862276,208-9,885-3.4%-6,654-2.4% Education & Health Svcs.426,525442,704461,39916,1793.8%18,6954.2% Leisure & Hospitality167,502171,161171,2773,6592.2%1160.1% Other Services55,75756,65556,0228981.6%-633-1.1% Public Administration74,52779,89382,1135,3667.2%2,2202.8% Sources: MN DEED; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 40 Workshop Packet Page Number 47 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS TABLE 16 AVERAGE WEEKLY WAGES MAPLEWOOD, RAMSEY COUNTY AND SEVEN COUNTY METRO AREA 2023 - 2025 Change 2023-20242024-2025 Industry202320242025No.Pct.No.Pct. Maplewood Total, All Industries$1,782$1,807$2,038$251.4%$23112.8% Natural Resources & Mining-------------- Construction$1,680$1,740$1,869$603.6%$1297.4% Manufacturing$1,648$1,686$1,842$382.3%$1569.3% Trade, Transportation & Utilities$921$898$930-$23-2.5%$323.6% Information$1,898$1,947$1,810$492.6%-$137-7.0% Financial Activities$1,684$1,711$1,790$271.6%$794.6% Prof. & Business Svcs.$2,998$3,144$3,749$1464.9%$60519.2% Education & Health Svcs.$1,419$1,379$1,464-$40-2.8%$856.2% Leisure & Hospitality$505$531$548$265.1%$173.2% Other Services$795$828$838$334.2%$101.2% Public Administration$1,673$1,701$1,770$281.7%$694.1% Ramsey County Total, All Industries$1,431$1,497$1,564$664.6%$674.5% Natural Resources & Mining$1,732$1,544$1,686-$188-10.9%$1429.2% Construction$1,781$1,866$2,007$854.8%$1417.6% Manufacturing$1,858$1,953$1,990$955.1%$371.9% Trade, Transportation & Utilities$1,244$1,258$1,324$141.1%$665.2% Information$2,134$2,333$2,472$1999.3%$1396.0% Financial Activities$1,949$2,095$2,200$1467.5%$1055.0% Prof. & Business Svcs.$1,961$2,124$2,255$1638.3%$1316.2% Education & Health Svcs.$1,191$1,235$1,269$443.7%$342.8% Leisure & Hospitality$611$640$674$294.7%$345.3% Other Services$1,063$1,105$1,146$424.0%$413.7% Public Administration$1,629$1,714$1,793$855.2%$794.6% Seven County Metro Total, All Industries$1,506$1,559$1,609$533.5%$503.2% Natural Resources & Mining$1,088$1,142$1,137$545.0%-$5-0.4% Construction$1,765$1,873$1,949$1086.1%$764.1% Manufacturing$1,704$1,799$1,869$955.6%$703.9% Trade, Transportation & Utilities$1,284$1,314$1,381$302.3%$675.1% Information$2,171$2,314$2,417$1436.6%$1034.5% Financial Activities$2,438$2,581$2,635$1435.9%$542.1% Prof. & Business Svcs.$2,046$2,141$2,217$954.6%$763.5% Education & Health Svcs.$1,237$1,278$1,309$413.3%$312.4% Leisure & Hospitality$663$682$717$192.9%$355.1% Other Services$952$982$1,015$303.2%$333.4% Public Administration$1,530$1,599$1,689$694.5%$905.6% Sources: MNDEED; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 41 Workshop Packet Page Number 48 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS In 2025, average weekly wages were $2,038 in Maplewood, compared to $1,564 in Ramsey County and $1,609 in the Seven County Metro. Since 2023, average weekly wages increased 14.4% in Maplewood and 9.3% in Ramsey County compared to a 6.8% increase in the Seven County Metro. Highest average wages in Maplewood are found in the Professional and Business Services ($3,749) and Construction ($1,869) industry sectors. The Professional and Business Services ($2,255) and Financial Activities ($2,200) sectors have the highest wages in Ramsey County. Households earning the average weekly wage in the City of Maplewood($2,038) and Ram- sey County($1,564) would be able to afford monthly rents of approximately $2,649and $2,033, respectively, to not exceed 30% of monthly income on housing costs, much higher thanthe average rent for market rate one-bedroom rental housing units in Maplewood ($1,301). Assuming that a potential home buyer has good credit and makes a 10% down payment, a household would need a minimum annual income of $112,688to be able to afford a single- family home sold at the 2025 median sale price of $369,900in Maplewood. The average weekly wages equate to an annual income of $105,976in Maplewoodand $81,328inRam- seyCounty. Much of Maplewoods workforce commutes from outside the city. Based on this data, rental housing is more attainable than for-sale housing forworkers earning the average weekly wage that may want to relocateto Maplewood, particularly those relying on a single income. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 42 Workshop Packet Page Number 49 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Major Employers The following list provides a summary of the major employers in Maplewood. Data was sourced from the City of Maplewood via the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) Electronic Municipal Market Access (EMMA) General Obligation Corporate Purpose Bonds Offi- cial Statement for the City, which was posted in 2025, the most recent data available. The largest employer in the community is 3M (Maplewood location only) with 4,452 em- ployees, followed by ISD No. 622, with 2,107 employees, and M Health Fairview with 1,473 employees. TABLE 17 Based on the industry sector composition of these employers, it appears that the economy in Maplewood is fairly diverse as five different industry sectors are represented by these major employers. - Retail Trade has the highest concentration with four major employers, followed by Health Care and Social Assistance with three. Manufacturing, Educational Services, and Public Administration sectors each contain one of the major employers. Combined, these ten major employers employ an estimated 9,926 workers, representing approximately 40% of jobs in Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 43 Workshop Packet Page Number 50 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS Housing Characteristics Introduction This section of the report examines characteristics of the housing stock in Maplewood com- pared to Ramsey County and the Metro Area. Housing demand is influenced, in large part, by factors related to the supply of housing in a market area such as the age and condition of the housing stock, as well as financial considerations. The following topics are covered. Housing units by structure type and tenure Age of the existing housing stock Residential development activity trends Housing projects in the development pipeline, and Geographic Information System (GIS) maps illustrating key characteristics of Maple- woodinventory is the primary data resource for the Housing Characteristics section of this report. Maxfield Research and Consulting utilizes the ACS five-year data estimates which provide a larger sample size and has a longer period of data collection than the one-year data estimates. At the time this analysis was prepared, the 2020- 2024 ACS was the most recent five-year data available, although data is adjusted by Maxfield Research to reflect the 2020 Census along with recent residential building development activity. Residential construction data was provided by the City of Maplewood and the Metropolitan Council. Housing unit is defined as a house, an apartment, a group of rooms, or a single room occupied or intended for occupancy as separate living quarters, while a household is an occupied housing unit. A householder refers to the person in whose name the housing unit is owned or rented. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 44 Workshop Packet Page Number 51 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS Housing Stock by Structure Type and Tenure Information presented in the following table summarizes the number of housing units by struc- ture type and tenure in Maplewood compared to Ramsey County and the Metro Area. Data is sourced from the 2020-2024 ACS, adjusted by Maxfield Research to reflect 2026 housing unit estimates based on 2020 Census data and recent residential building activity. There are an estimated 17,373 housing units in Maplewood, 94% of which are occupied (16,418), and there are an estimated 249,954 housing units in Ramsey County (93% occu- pied). In the Metro Area, 94% of the housing units are occupied. TABLE 18 Among all occupied units, detached single-unit structures are the most common housing product type in Maplewood, comprising an estimated 57% of units in the city. By compari- son, 51% of occupied housing units in Ramsey County and 57% in the Metro Area are single unit detached structures. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 45 Workshop Packet Page Number 52 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING CHARACTERISTICS The owner-occupied housing inventory in Maplewoodis weighted toward single-unit struc- tures. Of the owner-occupied units in Maplewood, an estimated 80% are single-unit, de- tached structures (8,883owner-occupied units)and another 11%are attached single-unit structures (1,259). Renter-occupied housing units in Maplewoodare distributed fairly evenlyacross multiple structure types, with the highest proportions in multifamily structures with50+units (36% of all renter-occupied units), followed bystructures with 20 to 49units (14%)and 10 to 19 units (14%). By comparison, the highest proportion of renter-occupied units in Ramsey County(32%)and the Metro Area(37%)are in multifamily structures with 50 or moreunits. Compared to Ramsey County, Maplewoodhasnotablyhigherproportions of units in at- tached, single-unit structures. Maplewoodhas slightlylower proportions of small to mid- sized multifamily structures compared to Ramsey County. The series of maps on the following pages illustrate key characteristics of theexisting housing stockin Maplewood, including residential dwelling style, rental housing property locations, and the total market value for residentialparcels. Data is sourced from Ramsey County. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 46 Workshop Packet Page Number 53 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING CHARACTERISTICS The following map illustrates residential parcelsin Maplewoodby dwellingtype. The major- ity of homes in the City have adwellingclassification that would be considered detached single-family (72% of all residential parcels). Another 15% are classified as townhomes, 6% are , which primarily includes mobile homes.Approximately3% are condominiums, 1.5% are duplexes,and less than 1% are multifamily (4+ unit) parcels. Residential DwellingType City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 47 Workshop Packet Page Number 54 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING CHARACTERISTICS The following map illustrates the location of residential parcels in Maplewoodthat are con- sidered multifamily (4+ unit)properties. MultifamilyProperties City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 48 Workshop Packet Page Number 55 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING CHARACTERISTICS The following mapillustrates the estimated total marketvalue of residential propertiesin Maplewood. As shown, highest property valuesare situated in the northwest portion of the city, near GervaisLake, as well as the southern portion that bordersthe west side of Wood- bury. Propertieswith the lowest propertyvalues are concentrated in the central portion of the community. Residential TotalMarket Value City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 49 Workshop Packet Page Number 56 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING CHARACTERISTICS Age of Housing Stock Information in the following tableis sourced from the ACSwith adjustments made by Maxfield Research to reflect 2026housing unitestimatesbased on 2020 Census data and recent residen- tial development activity. The table includes the number of housing units built prior to 1940 and during each subsequent decade in Maplewoodand Ramsey Countycompared to the Metro Area. The Census Bureau began collecting year-built data in 1940. As depicted in the following chart, an estimated 6% of the housing units in Maplewood (1,058) were built prior to 1940. By comparison, 24% of all housing units in Ramsey County and 14% of all housing units in the Metro Areawere built prior to 1940. The 1950s and 1980s werethe mostactive decadesin Maplewoodfor housing unit produc- tion, More recently, an estimated 12.9% of housing stock was built from 2000 to 2009(2,238units), 5.2% of the housing units were constructed from 2010to 2019(905 units), and 4.6% of the housing units were constructed since 2020 (804 units). Housing Units by Decade Built 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% <'40'40-'49'50-'59'60-'69'70-'79'80-'89'90-'99'00-'09'10-'19'20+ Ramsey County 25.0%5.0%12.1%10.8%13.4%11.2%6.4%6.0%4.9%5.2% Metro Area 13.5%3.5%9.2%9.3%13.0%13.1%11.6%11.0%8.5%7.5% Maplewood 6.1%2.9%15.6%9.8%14.3%15.6%13.0%12.9%5.2%4.6% MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 50 Workshop Packet Page Number 57 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS TABLE 19 Residential Construction Trends The following information summarizes the number of new housing units permitted for de- tached single-family, townhome (single-family attached), duplex/triplex/quad, and multifamily structures in Maplewood over the past ten years (2017 through 2026). Data was provided by the City of Maplewood and the Metropolitan Council. From 2017 to May 2026, 1,083 housing units were permitted in the City of Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 51 Workshop Packet Page Number 58 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS Annually, Maplewood averages 108.3 new units per year, including 5.1 new detached sin- gle-family units, 2.2 townhome units, and 101 multifamily units per year. The vast majority (93.3%) of the residential units permitted in Maplewood since 2017 were in multifamily structures (1,010 units), while 4.7% were detached single-family units (51) and 2.2% were townhome units (22). During the five-year period from 2017 through 2021, 452 new housing units were permitted in Maplewood, for an average of 90 new units per year. The pace of development activity increased by 40% from 2022 through May 2026, averaging 126 units per year (631 total units over the past five years). Multifamily development activity decreased from a rate of 411 units per year, on average, from 2017 through 2021 to an average pace of 119.8 units per year from 2022 through May 2026. TABLE 20 RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION TRENDS CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2017 - MAY 2026 Townhome Detached Single-(Single-Family Duplex / Triplex MultifamilyTotal FamilyAttached)/ QuadUnitsUnits Year 2017500107112 201890009 2019240152158 2020580013 2021800152160 2022700148155 20233007275 20247100327344 20255002025 'May 20260003232 Units Permitted512201,0101,083 Sources: City of Maplewood; Metropolitan Council; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 52 Workshop Packet Page Number 59 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING CHARACTERISTICS The following map illustrates residential properties in Maplewoodby year built. As shown, the newest residential properties in Maplewoodare concentratedin the northern and southern most portions of the city. Older residential propertiesare generally situatednear the central portion of the community. Residential Properties by Year Built City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 53 Workshop Packet Page Number 60 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS Residential Development Pipeline Maxfield Research compiled information provided by the City of Maplewood to identify any new housing projects that are proposed, approved, or currently under construction in the City of Maplewood. Note that shovel-ready subdivisions that have lots for sale or available for new home construction are considered active subdivisions, not pending developments. Our findings are summarized below. As of May 2026, we identified a total of 278 residential units/lots pending across three pro- jects in the City of Maplewood. - Among these projects, two are approved (238 lots/units) and one is proposed (40 units). - The two approved projects include a senior living facility, which is slated to include 32 units, while Century Ponds will include 133 single-family lots and 73 townhome lots. Fi- nally, the one proposed project will have 40 affordable multifamily rental units. TABLE 21 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 54 Workshop Packet Page Number 61 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET For-Sale Market Introduction Maxfield Research analyzed the for-sale housing market in Maplewood and the surrounding area by collecting data on home sales, home listings, and the supply of residential lots in the area. This section of the report reviews recent home sale trends against the supply of available for-sale housing, including detached single-family and multifamily housing. For the purposes of this analysis, housing sales data for townhomes and twin homes (i.e. attached single-family) are This section evaluates for-sale housing market conditions by examining the following data. Home resale trends The supply of homes currently listed as available for sale A map of the residential lot supply Information on new construction sales activity Data was collected in June 2026. Information on home sales, active listings, and actively mar- keting residential lots was obtained from Minneapolis Area Realtors (MAR) and includes all transactions sold through a Realtor via the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) which generally ac- counts for 90% to 95% of all home sales. Private sales (not sold on the MLS by a Realtor) are not included. Residential land supply data was sourced from Ramsey County, while information on actively- marketing residential lots was provided by Minneapolis Area Realtors via the MLS. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 55 Workshop Packet Page Number 62 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISFOR-SALE MARKET Home SaleTrends The following graph summarizes median home resale (excludes new construction) price trends from 2018through 2025for Maplewoodcompared to Ramsey County and the Twin Cities Seven-County Metro Area. Data is sourcedfrom Minneapolis Area Realtors and represents pricing for all housing product types (i.e. detached single-family, townhomes, condominiums, etc.) In Maplewood, the median sale price jumped45%, climbing from $235,000in 2018to $340,000in 2025, averaging 5.5% increases annually. By comparison, median sale prices in Ramsey County and the Twin Cities Metro Area in- creased 46% between 2018 and 2025 to $335,000 and $380,000, respectively, representing 5.6% annual growth. Median sale price trends in Maplewoodhave tracked consistentlywith Ramsey Countyand the Twin Cities Metro Area, although prices in Maplewood are slightly higher than Ramsey Countybut lower than the Metro Area. In 2025, the median sale price for all product types in Maplewood($340,000) was -1.5% higherthan the County($335,000) and -10.5% lower than the Metro Area($380,000). The table on the following page presents home sale data from 2018through 2025for Maple- woodcompared to the County and the Twin Cities Metro Area. The table displays the median resale price, number of closed transactions, and marketing times (averagedays on market) for all detached single-family and multifamily (i.e townhomes, twin homes, condominiums) resales. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 56 Workshop Packet Page Number 63 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET From 2018 through 2025, there were 4,025 residential resales in Maplewood, accounting for 7% of all resales in Ramsey County (54,760). TABLE 22 Transaction activity in Maplewood increased from 46.0 resales per month in 2018 to 54.6 resales per month in 2021 before declining to 32.8 resales per month in 2023. There were 33.7 resales per month, on average, in 2025. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 57 Workshop Packet Page Number 64 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISFOR-SALE MARKET Sales volumedecelerated due, in large part, torising mortgage rates, whichcaused sales ac- tivity to slow across the region. As shown below, resale activity in the County and Metro Areafollowed a similar trend to Maplewood. Of all sales in Maplewoodfrom2018through 2025, 71% have been detachedsingle-family homes (2,876) while 29% (1,149) were resales of multifamily units. By comparison, detached single-family units accounted for 78% of all residential resales in Ramsey Countyand 73% of all residential resales in the Twin Cities Metro Area. In 2025, Maplewoodaveraged 24.1detached single-family resales per month along with 9.6 multifamily resales per month. The Countyaveraged 338.2detached single-family and 98.2 multifamily resales per month during the year. After declining from 2018 to 2021, average marketing times increasedin Maplewoodin re- cent years, as the averagenumber of days on market for detached single-family homes in- creased from 18days in 2021to 29days in 2025. Average multifamily marketing times in- creased from 24days on market in 2021to 55days in 2025. Increased competition for homes (as indicated by the decreasing supply of available housing and shortened marketing times) helped stimulate strong price appreciation, although the rate of increase decelerated in recent years. In Maplewoodthe median price for detached single-family homes increased 48%, climbing from $250,000in 2018 to $369,900in 2025, averaging 5.8% increases annually. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 58 Workshop Packet Page Number 65 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISFOR-SALE MARKET Median multifamily sale pricesincreased43%from $185,000in 2018 to $265,000 in 2025, averaging 5.4% increases annually. The 2025median price for detached single-family homes of $369,900in Maplewoodwas 2.8% higherthan the County($359,900)but-11.9% lowerthan $420,000in the Twin Cities Metro Area. In Maplewood, the2025median resale price for multifamily units was $265,000, 6% higher than $250,050in theCountybut-5.3% lowerthan $279,900in the Metro Area. The following tablesummarizesresidential resales in Maplewoodfrom 2023through 2025by price range, including the price distribution for detached single-family and multifamily sales. Detached single-family homes priced between $300,000 and $399,999 were the most com- monly purchased product in Maplewoodsince 2023, representing 34.2% of all resales (48.8%of detached single-family sales), followed by multifamilyhomes priced in the $200,000 to $299,999 range (16.4% of all resales, 54.9% of multifamily sales). From 2023 through 2025, Maplewood experienced an average of 23.3 detached single-fam- ily resales per month and 9.9 multifamily resale per month. Among detached single-family resales, homes priced in the $300,000 to $399,999 range av- erage 11.4 resales per month and homes priced in the $400,000 to $499,999 range average 5.1 resales per month. Among multifamily resales, there were 5.4 and 2.2 resales per month, on average, among units priced in the $200,000 to $299,999 and $300,000 to $399,999 ranges, respectively. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 59 Workshop Packet Page Number 66 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET TABLE 23 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 60 Workshop Packet Page Number 67 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET Active Listings The following table presents a summary of housing units listed for sale by a Realtor on the MLS in Maplewood as of June 16, 2026. Data is presented by price range, including information on the number of active listings, median year built, median size (based on total finished square feet), median price, and median price per square foot. Data is sourced from Minneapolis Area Realtors and includes listings for all construction types (i.e. previously owned, under construc- tion, etc.) TABLE 24 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 68 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET There were 85 homes listed for sale in Maplewood as of June 16, 2026, 65% of which (55) were detached single-family homes while 35% were multifamily units (30). The median asking price for detached single-family homes was $425,00, 15% higher than the 2025 median resale price of $369,900. The median list price for multifamily units ($276,950) is 5% higher than the 2025 median resale price of $265,000. The median size of the detached single-family homes listed for sale was 2,036 square feet which equates to a median price per square foot (psf) of $209, while the median list price for multifamily units is $179 psf based on the median size of 1,549 square feet. Detached single-family homes and multifamily homes priced in the $300,000 to $399,999 range are the most common listings in Maplewood, both with 13 homes listed for sale (15% of all listings). The median year built of the detached single-family homes listed for sale is 1967, while the multifamily units have a median year built of 2005. Among the 55 detached single-family homes listed for sale two are new construction and 53 are previously owned. The median list price for new construction detached single-family units is $549,000, 31% higher than the median price for previously owned units ($419,900). Two of the multifamily units listed for sale are new construction homes while 28 are previ- ously owned resales. The median list price for the new construction units is $369,000, 34% higher than the median price for previously owned multifamily units ($274,950). From 2023 through 2025, Maplewood averaged 33.2 resales per month, including 23.3 de- tached single-family home resales per month and 9.9 multifamily resales per month. - Based on the supply of available for-sale housing in the City as of June 2026, there is a 2.6-month supply of homes available for sale on the market, including a 2.4-month sup- ply of detached single-family homes and a 3.0-month supply of multifamily units. - Excluding the new construction listings, there is 2.4-month supply of previously owned units available for sale in the City, including a 2.3-month supply of detached single-fam- ily homes and a 2.8-month supply of multifamily units. Equilibrium in the for-sale housing market is generally considered to be a six-month supply, indicating that there is pent-up demand for homes in Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 62 Workshop Packet Page Number 69 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISFOR-SALE MARKET Actively Marketing Residential Lots The table on the following page summarizes residential lots listed for sale by a Realtor on the MLS in the City of Maplewoodand the surrounding citiesas of June2026. Data is sourced from Minneapolis Area Realtors. As of June2026, there were eightresidential lots available for sale in Maplewoodon the MLS. There were another 32 lots available for sale in the surrounding cities. This infor- mation excludes larger acreagesand commercial land that may also be listed for sale in the area. With 24listings, 60% of thesurrounding available residential lots are in St. Paulwhile there are seven lots available for sale in Rosevilleand one in Oakdale. The median size of lots currently available for sale in Maplewoodand the surrounding cities is 0.16acres (6,970square feet), ranging from0.09-acre for alot in St. Paulto 3.13 acresfor an unplattedparcelin Maplewood. Lot prices vary depending on location and features, ranging from $20,000for a 0.09-acrelot in the Edmund Rices First Additionsubdivision in St. Paulto $365,000for a 0.13-acre lotin the Woodland Park Addition subdivision in St. Paul. The median list price for lots in the areais $114,950, which equates to $16.49psf($718,438 per acre) based on the median size of 6,970square feet (0.16acre). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 63 Workshop Packet Page Number 70 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET The median list price for lots in Maplewood is $152,500, which equates to $5.39 psf ($234,615 per acre based on the median size of 28,314 square feet (0.65 acre). Maple- flecting its larger median lot size (28,314 square feet versus 5,881), as per-square-foot pric- ing typically declines as lot size increases. TABLE 25 ACTIVELY-MARKETING RESIDENTIAL LOT SUPPLY MAPLEWOOD & SURROUNDING CITIES June 2026 ---------- Lots Listed For Sale ---------- Lot Size RangeLot Price Range SubdivisionLots for Min AcMedian AcMinMedianPrice/Ac City/TownshipSaleMax AcMedian SFMaxPricePrice/SF City of Maplewood Cardon Estates10.400.40$155,000$155,000$387,500 Maplewood0.4017,424$155,000$8.90 De Mars 10th Add10.250.25$150,000$150,000$600,000 Maplewood0.25150,000$150,000$1.00 Gladstone Homesites10.460.46$150,000$150,000$326,087 Maplewood0.4620,037$150,000$7.49 Hillcrest Gardens10.840.84$165,000$165,000$196,429 Maplewood0.8436,590$165,000$4.51 Kings Add11.151.15$199,000$199,000$173,043 Maplewood1.1550,094$199,000$3.97 Pfluegers Add10.220.22$79,900$79,900$363,182 Maplewood0.229,583$79,900$8.34 Unplatted Parcels21.272.20$105,000$140,000$63,636 Maplewood3.1395,832$175,000$1.46 Summary80.220.65$79,900$152,500$234,615 3.1328,314$199,000$5.39 Surrounding Cities Midland Legacy Estate20.260.52$265,000$282,000$542,308 Roseville0.7722,433$299,000$12.57 The Enclave at McCarrons Lake10.100.10$124,900$124,900$1,249,000 Roseville0.104,305$124,900$29.01 Lake Park Addition10.280.28$125,000$125,000$446,429 Oakdale0.2812,197$125,000$10.25 Scattered Parcels40.210.49$69,900$252,000$514,286 Roseville0.8021,127$325,000$11.93 Scattered Parcels240.090.12$20,000$82,450$687,083 St. Paul1.175,227$365,000$15.77 Summary320.090.14$20,000$89,950$642,500 1.175,881$365,000$15.30 Total Lot Listings400.090.16$20,000$114,950$718,438 3.136,970$365,000$16.49 Sources: Minneapolis Area Realtors; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 64 Workshop Packet Page Number 71 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISFOR-SALE MARKET Residential Lot Supply The following mapillustratesthe supply of vacant residential lots in Maplewoodas of June 2026. Data is from Ramsey County. Vacant Residential Lots by Active Subdivision City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 65 Workshop Packet Page Number 72 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET Although currently undergoing construction, we found it important to mention the lots within the Century Ponds Development. The following summarizes the info on these lots and the new construction homes that will be available for sale in the Fall of 2026. There will be 133 detached single-family homes and 73 townhomes developed at Century Ponds for a total of 206 housing units. Among these homes, there will be one- and two-story detached single-family homes devel- oped on 55-foot wide lots, one- and two-story detached single-family homes developed on 65-foot lots, and townhome units that will be 26 feet wide. The following table summarizes the square footage and price ranges for the different home types. TABLE 26 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 66 Workshop Packet Page Number 73 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET New Construction Home Pricing The following table and related points summarize new construction home sales from January 2024 through mid-June 2026 in Maplewood and the surrounding cities along with new con- struction homes listed for sale by a Realtor on the MLS as of June 2026. Information is pre- sented for the City of Maplewood and the surrounding cities by subdivision. Data includes the number of sales or listings, property type, total finished square feet, price ranges, and median price per square foot. Data for the surrounding cities was provided if the subdivision had more than one sale/listing. Data is sourced from Minneapolis Area Realtors. Information is provided on 272 new construction sales and active listings in the area. Among these new construction units, 61% are multifamily units (166) and 39% are detached single-family units (106). Among the new construction multifamily units, 93.4% are classi- fied as townhomes, 5.4% are condominiums, and 1.2% are classified as twin homes. There were three new construction detached single-family units listed/sold on the MLS in Maplewood since 2024. Multifamily listings/sales totaled 11 units since 2024, including nine sales in the Shores of Maplewood subdivision and two listings of unplatted parcels. There are 258 new construction listings/sales in the surrounding cities (103 detached single- family, 155 multifamily), most notably in St. Paul (100) and Little Canada (46). Overall, new construction units in Maplewood and the surrounding cities have a median price of $591,718 which equates to $282 psf based on the median size of 2,096 square feet. New construction detached single-family homes in Maplewood have a median size of 2,481 square feet, ranging from 2,481 square feet to 2,815 square feet. The median price for new construction detached single-family units in Maplewood is $549,000 ($221 psf), ranging from $549,000 to $613,220. By comparison, new construction detached single-family homes in the surrounding cities have a median price of $615,990 ($248 psf based on the median size of 2,480 square feet). Median prices range from $268,000 in St. Paul to $1,695,000 in White Bear Lake. New construction multifamily units in Maplewood have a median size of 1,419 square feet, ranging from 1,226 square feet to 1,988 square feet. Both units are condominiums in the Shores of Maplewood. The median price for new construction multifamily units in Maple- wood is $272,272 ($192 psf), ranging from $240,240 in the Shores of Maplewood to $374,000 for a townhome unit on an unplatted parcel. New construction multifamily units in the surrounding cities have a median price of $592,500 ($299 psf based on the median size of 1,981 square feet). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 67 Workshop Packet Page Number 74 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS FOR-SALE MARKET TABLE 27 NEW CONSTRUCTION HOME PRICING SUMMARY MAPLEWOOD & SURROUNDING CITIES June 2026 Subdivision/Sales/Finished Square FeetPrice RangePrice/ CommunityCity/TownshipListingsLowHighMedianLowHighMedianSF City of Maplewood Detached Single-Family Unplatted Parcels Maplewood32,4812,8152,481$549,000$613,220$549,000$221 Summary:32,4812,8152,481$549,000$613,220$549,000$221 . Multifamily Shores of Maplewood Maplewood91,2261,9881,398$240,240$347,167$268,840$192 Unplatted Parcels Maplewood21,7091,7091,709$364,000$374,000$369,000$216 Summary:111,2261,9881,419$240,240$374,000$272,272$192 Surrounding Cities Detached Single-Family Gervais Woods Little Canada102,6054,5223,626$700,000$1,535,000$977,875$270 Villas of Gervais Lake Little Canada32,9603,4512,960$1,191,699$1,285,172$1,249,999$422 Sunrise over Gervais Little Canada31,7262,2202,126$699,900$892,600$734,800$346 5th Add of N. St. Paul N. St. Paul32,1632,4882,163$449,000$479,000$479,000$221 Willowbrooke Oakdale291,5873,8702,348$434,990$761,305$489,500$208 Midland Legacy Estate Roseville32,7384,7683,250$817,500$1,567,300$949,000$292 Victoria Shores Roseville32,5103,2652,720$858,000$1,129,650$859,950$316 Villas of Reservoir Woods Roseville21,7402,8302,285$812,765$876,500$844,633$370 Unplatted Parcels Roseville21,6222,2171,920$737,830$804,700$771,265$402 A Gotzians St. Paul21,7501,9761,863$349,900$352,500$351,200$189 Borup & Paynes Add St. Paul22,1852,1852,185$324,900$325,000$324,950$149 Edmund Rices Third Add St. Paul21,9762,7162,346$349,900$400,000$374,950$160 Highview Add St. Paul22,9713,0903,031$770,000$949,900$859,950$284 Hillcrest Heights St. Paul31,6381,6381,638$365,000$365,000$365,000$223 Kensington Park Add St. Paul22,5203,5653,043$995,000$1,060,000$1,027,500$338 Rivoli Bluff St. Paul21,3801,3801,380$268,000$268,000$268,000$194 Stinsons Add St. Paul21,7951,9501,873$290,000$360,000$325,000$174 Stinsons Sub of Lyman Day St. Paul22,0002,0062,003$365,000$370,000$367,500$183 Stone & Mortons St. Paul22,1092,7802,445$385,000$444,000$414,500$170 Bluebird Grove Vadnais Heights62,5434,7963,940$855,000$1,075,000$922,475$234 Mondello Shores Vadnais Heights151,8274,4182,183$550,046$1,041,872$637,164$292 White Bear Beach White Bear Lake32,7004,5973,000$859,900$1,695,000$1,195,000$398 Summary:1031,3804,7962,480$268,000$1,695,000$615,990$248 . Multifamily Pioneer Commons Little Canada301,7191,8001,777$310,000$421,690$375,995$212 7th St. Townhomes N. St. Paul51,3752,6301,375$469,900$537,268$485,850$353 Delaware Place N. St. Paul51,4131,5571,413$389,900$468,408$414,900$294 Willowbrooke Oakdale141,6752,2501,944$333,000$400,085$364,343$187 Enclave at McCarons Lake Roseville62,3032,7722,653$567,500$856,659$745,000$281 The Woods of Roseville Roseville52,0962,0962,096$450,000$523,500$465,000$222 Highland Bridge St. Paul751,9733,0472,373$575,000$1,082,905$689,990$291 THs of Hillcrest Heights St. Paul41,6061,9191,919$284,900$329,900$307,400$160 Moores Vincent Estates Vadnais Heights61,9432,2722,090$490,000$590,000$540,677$259 Wildwood Rowhomes White Bear Lake51,7421,7971,742$425,000$475,000$430,000$247 Summary:1551,3753,0471,981$284,900$1,082,905$592,500$299 Total New Construction2721,2264,7962,096$240,240$1,695,000$591,718$282 Sources: Minneapolis Area Realtors; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 68 Workshop Packet Page Number 75 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET Rental Housing Market Introduction Maxfield Research analyzed the rental housing market in Maplewood by collecting data on key rental housing industry metrics such as inventory, vacancy rates, and rental rates. Data was col- lected in June and July 2026. Topics covered in this section of the analysis include. An overview of rental housing market conditions Summary information from a survey of select general occupancy (i.e. not age-restricted) market rate and income-restricted rental properties in Maplewood Maxfield Research and Consulting identified and surveyed a select group of rental properties in the community. For the purposes of this analysis, rental housing is categorized into one of two sectors: - General occupancy market rate properties (those without age or income restrictions) - Affordable and subsidized properties (those with income restrictions and rents afforda- ble to households with incomes at 80% of Area Median Income or lower) Secondary data resources utilized for this section of the analysis include GVA Marquette Advi- sors, Yardi Matrix, and online apartment listing services such as apartment websites, Zillow, and . MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 69 Workshop Packet Page Number 76 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISRENTAL HOUSING MARKET Overview of Rental Market Conditions The following table summarizesvacancy rates and rental rates from 1stQuarter 2022 through 1stQuarter 2026. Data is from Marquette Advisors, which compiles apartment trends quar- terly, with 1stQuarter 2026 being the most recent available data. The detailed table is located at the end of this section. TABLE 28 Duringthe 1st Quarter of 2026, the vacancy rate was 2.3% in Maplewoodcompared to 4.4% in the Twin Cities Metro Area. Over the past fiveyears (2022to 2026), Maplewoodhas av- eraged 2.9% vacancycompared to 4.4% vacancy in the Twin Cities Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 70 Workshop Packet Page Number 77 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET The equilibrium vacancy rate for rental housing is considered to be 5.0% which allows for normal turnover and an adequate supply of alternatives for prospective renters. Rental housing vacancy rates in Maplewood have tracked well below equilibrium and lower than the Metro Area in recent years. Average rents in Maplewood increased 9% to $1,276 from the 1st Quarter of 2022 to the 1st Quarter of 2026 compared to a 14% increase in average rents ($1,576) in the Twin Cities Metro Area. The following charts show average monthly rents and vacancy rates by unit type from 1st Quar- ter 2026 in Maplewood and the Twin Cities Metro Area. The average rent in Maplewood as of 1st Quarter 2026 was $1,276, which was -23.5% lower than the Twin Cities Metro Area average of $1,576. The lower average rent reflects the older supply of rental properties in Maplewood compared to the rest of the Metro Area. Across bedroom types, the average rents in Maplewood range from -13% lower for studio units to -40% lower for two-bedroom plus den units than the Twin Cities Metro Area rents. One-bedroom and studio units currently exhibit the highest vacancy rates in Maplewood, at 3.0% and 2.6%, respectively, still much lower than the market equilibrium vacancy rate of 5.0%. By comparison, vacancy rates for comparable unit types in the Twin Cities Metro Area are higher at 4.7% for one-bedroom units and 4.9% for studio units. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 71 Workshop Packet Page Number 78 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET TABLE 29 AVERAGE RENTS/VACANCIES TRENDS 1st Quarter 2023 through 1st Quarter 2026 1 BR2 BR3 BR/DAverage Increase TotalStudio1 BRw/ Den2 BRw/ Den3 BRor 4BR MAPLEWOOD Units 2,004 77730--1,07711109---- No. Vacant 66 219--34011---- Avg. Rent$1,221$1,050$1,123--$1,290$1,377$1,297--4.1% Vacancy 3.3%2.6%2.6%--3.2%0.0%10.1%--1.7% Units 2,007 77730--1,07711112---- No. Vacant 79 141--26011---- Avg. Rent$1,232$1,066$1,147--$1,285$1,377$1,384--0.9% Vacancy 3.9%1.3%5.6%--2.4%0.0%9.8%--0.6% Units 2,007 77730--1,07711112---- No. Vacant 70 439--2007---- Avg. Rent$1,274$1,105$1,191--$1,329$1,389$1,395--3.4% Vacancy 3.5%5.2%5.3%--1.9%0.0%6.3%---0.4% Units 2,086 78770--1,10311124---- No. Vacant 48 223--2003---- Avg. Rent$1,276$1,107$1,196--$1,332$1,378$1,377--0.2% Vacancy 2.3%2.6%3.0%--1.8%0.0%2.4%---1.2% TWIN CITIES METRO AREA Units 176,389 13,36278,8083,72869,3181,8078,940426-- No. Vacant 8,389 9533,897853,0435330058-- Avg. Rent$1,438$1,189$1,274$1,607$1,569$2,179$1,946$2,9024.0% Vacancy 4.8%7.1%4.9%2.3%4.4%2.9%3.4%13.6%1.2% Units 185,873 14,57483,5373,69971,9381,8069,872447-- No. Vacant 8,432 8774,109572,9735534219-- Avg. Rent$1,490$1,237$1,324$1,621$1,624$2,193$2,062$2,7283.6% Vacancy 4.5%6.0%4.9%1.5%4.1%3.0%3.5%4.3%-0.2% Units 194,651 16,11488,0263,69975,5491,8058,3261,132-- No. Vacant 9,178 9594,483513,22836311110-- Avg. Rent$1,553$1,256$1,378$1,647$1,711$2,200$2,136$2,6364.2% Vacancy 4.7%6.0%5.1%1.4%4.3%2.0%3.7%9.7%0.2% Units 197,065 16,49289,7713,75174,6021,8539,3811,215-- No. Vacant 8,742 8094,194663,1943434798-- Avg. Rent$1,576$1,269$1,401$1,667$1,742$2,282$2,146$2,7011.5% Vacancy 4.4%4.9%4.7%1.8%4.3%1.8%3.7%8.1%-0.3% Sources: Marquette Advisors; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 72 Workshop Packet Page Number 79 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET Rental Housing Properties Maxfield Research and Consulting compiled detailed information for rental housing properties (excluding age-restricted) with 24 or more units in the City of Maplewood. Data was collected through a telephone and email survey of rental property managers and owners in June and July of 2026. Information sourced from online resources was also utilized. This information is categorized into two groups; general occupancy market rate housing (prop- erties that do not have any age or income restrictions) and affordable or subsidized properties which are restricted to residents with incomes at, or below, certain limits depending on funding source. The following tables and related points summarize the unit mix, average unit sizes, and average rental rate ranges among the participating properties. Rents shown represent quoted rents and have not been adjusted to reflect the inclusion or exclusion of utilities. Rents represent a weighted average based on the number of units at each property, so buildings with a larger number of units contribute more toward the average than those with fewer units. We surveyed 13 general occupancy affordable and subsidized properties totaling 986 units and 24 market rate properties totaling 2,467 units in the City of Maplewood. The map on the following page reflects general locations of these surveyed rental proper- ties. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 73 Workshop Packet Page Number 80 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISRENTAL HOUSING MARKET Rental HousingLocation Map MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 74 Workshop Packet Page Number 81 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET Affordable/Subsidized Property Summary The following table presents a detailed summary of the general occupancy affordable and sub- sidized rental properties in the City, including unit mix, vacancies, unit sizes, and pricing. The inventory includes Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC), Project-Based Section 8, and HOME Investment Partnerships Program units. There is one Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing (NOAH) property included because AEON preserves the affordability within the property by maintaining rents at or below 60% of the Area Median Income (AMI). Residents in LIHTC housing and HOME Investment Partnerships Program properties pay basic monthly rents. Residents in project-based Section 8 and public housing pay 30% of their ad- justed income on rent, with the remaining costs covered by the government. TABLE 30 We surveyed 13 affordable and subsidized general occupancy apartment properties in Maplewood, totaling 986 units. At the time of the survey, there were 24 vacant units re- sulting in a 2.4% vacancy rate. The equilibrium vacancy rate for rental housing is considered to be 5.0% which allows for normal turnover and an adequate supply of alternatives for prospective renters. Additionally, many of these properties are maintaining lengthy wait lists, one up to three years out. - This data suggests that there is pent-up demand for affordable and subsidized general occupancy rental housing in Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 75 Workshop Packet Page Number 82 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISRENTAL HOUSING MARKET On average, units have 935square feet, ranging from an average size of 662square feet for one-bedroom units to 1,527square feet for four-bedroom townhome units. Average monthly rents range from $691for one-bedroom units to $2,621for four-bedroom townhomeunits. The weighted average rent across all unit types is $1,486per month ($1.59per square foot, on average). Residentsin Project-based Section 8 housingunitstypically pay 30% of theiradjusted gross income on rent. One-bedroom units target one-to two-person households, while two-bedroom units target two-to four-person households. Three-and four-bedroom units have six-person and eight- person maximum household sizes, respectively. The following chartillustratesmaximum household incomes by household size in Ramsey County at 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, and 80% Area Median Income (AMI), which represents the target market for the affordable and subsidized propertiesin Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 76 Workshop Packet Page Number 83 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET Market Rate Summary The following table summarizes the unit mix, vacancies, average unit sizes, and average rental rate ranges among the surveyed market rate rental properties in Maplewood. We surveyed 24 existing general occupancy market rate rental properties in Maplewood, totaling 2,467 units. At the time of the survey, there were 98 vacant units, resulting in a 4.0% vacancy rate among the general occupancy market rate rental properties in Maplewood. As mentioned previously, the equilibrium vacancy rate for market rate rental housing is con- sidered to be 5.0%. At 4.0% vacant, the supply of market rate rental housing in Maplewood is below equilibrium, suggesting pent-up demand. TABLE 31 On average, units have 891 square feet, ranging from an average size of 512 square feet for studio units to 1,542 square feet for three-bedroom townhome units. The average monthly rental rate across all market rate general occupancy properties is $1,507, which equates to $1.65 per square foot (psf). Studio units have the lowest average monthly rent at $1,199, followed by one-bedroom units at $1,301. Three-bedroom units have the highest average monthly rent at $2,256. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 77 Workshop Packet Page Number 84 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS RENTAL HOUSING MARKET There is a notable difference in rents between the older and the newest properties in Maplewood. The three newest properties (opened 2018, 2020, and 2025) have an average monthly rent of $1,869, roughly 31% higher than the average rent of $1,426 among the older properties. - On a per square foot basis, average rents in the newest properties ($2.03 psf) are 26% higher than the older properties ($1.61). While each property manages utilities differently, heat, trash removal, water, and sewer are typically included in the rent in older properties, while the tenant is responsible for most utilities in the newer properties. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 78 Workshop Packet Page Number 85 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET Senior Housing Market Introduction This section provides an assessment of the market support for senior housing, including a re- view of demographic and economic characteristics of senior population along with detailed information on existing and pending senior housing facilities in the City. Data on the senior housing facilities was collected in June and July 2026. Topics covered in this section of the analysis include. A definition of senior housing product types An overview of older adult and senior demographic characteristics in the area Market information on existing senior housing facilities in Maplewood Secondary data resources utilized for this analysis include the U.S Census Bureau Decennial Census and American Community Survey, along with ESRI, the Minnesota State Demographic Center, and Minneapolis Area Realtors. Care Options Network and Senior Housing Guide were also referenced. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 79 Workshop Packet Page Number 86 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET Senior Housing Defined Senior housing is a concept that generally refers to the integrated delivery of housing and services to seniors. However, as Figure 1 illustrates, senior housing embodies a wide variety of product types across the service-delivery spectrum. FIGURE 1 CONTINUUM OF HOUSING AND SERVICES FOR SENIORS Single-familyTownhome or Independent LivingAssisted LivingSkilled Nursing HomeApartment Apartments w/ Optional Services Active Adult Independent Living FULLYFULLY OR Age-Restricted Townhomes, Apartments w/ INDEPENDENTApartments, Condos,HIGHLY Intensive ServicesMemory Care LIFESTYLEDEPENDENT Cooperatives Products range from independent apartments and/or townhomes with virtually no services on one end, to highly specialized, service-intensive assisted living units or housing geared for people with dementia-related illnesses (termed "memory care") on the other end of the spectrum. In general, independent senior housing attracts people age 65 and over while assisted living typically attracts people age 80 and older who need assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs). live independently and purchase assisted living services as needed without relocating to a unit specifically designated for independent living or assisted living. For analytical purposes, Maxfield Research and Consulting classifies senior housing into five primary categories based on the level and type of services offered as described in the following figure. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 80 Workshop Packet Page Number 87 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET Active Adult Active Adult properties (or independent living without services available) are similar to a general- occupancy building, in that they offer virtually no services but have age-restrictions (typically 55 or 62 or older). Residents are generally age 70 or older if in an apartment-style building. Organized entertainment, activities and occasionally a transportation program represent the extent of ser- vices typically available at these properties. Because of the lack of services, active adult properties generally do not command the rent premiums of more service-enriched senior housing. Active adult properties can have a rental or owner-occupied (condominium or cooperative) format. Independent Living Independent Living properties offer support services such as meals and/or housekeeping, either on an optional basis or a limited amount included in the rents. These properties often dedicate a larger share of the building to common areas, because units are smaller than in active adult hous- ing and to encourage socialization. Independent living properties attract a slightly older target market than adult housing (i.e. seniors age 75 or older). Rents are also above those of active adult buildings. Sponsorship by a nursing home, hospital or health care organization is common. Assisted Living Assisted Living properties come in a variety of forms, but the target market for most is generally the same: very frail seniors, typically age 80 or older (but can be much younger, depending on their health situation), who need extensive support services and personal care assistance. Absent an as- sisted living option, these seniors would otherwise need to move to a nursing facility. At a mini- mum, assisted living properties include two meals per day and weekly housekeeping in the monthly fee, with the availability of a third meal and personal care (either included in the monthly fee or for an additional cost). Assisted living properties also have staff on duty 24 hours per day or at least 24-hour emergency response. Memory Care other dementias, is one of the newest trends in senior housing. Properties consist mostly of suite- style or studio units or occasionally one-bedroom apartment-style units, and large amounts of communal areas for activities and programming. In addition, staff typically undergoes specialized training in the care of this population. Because of the greater amount of individualized personal care required by residents, staffing ratios are much higher than traditional assisted living and thus, the costs of care are also higher. Unlike conventional assisted living, however, which addresses housing needs almost exclusively for widows or widowers, a higher proportion of persons afflicted -person households. That means the decision to move a spouse a special facility while continuing to maintain their home. Skilled Nursing Care Skilled Nursing Care, or long-term care, provides a living arrangement that integrates shelter and food with medical, nursing, psychosocial and rehabilitation services for persons who require 24- hour nursing supervision. Residents in skilled nursing homes can be funded under Medicare, Medi- caid, Veterans, HMOs, insurance as well as use of private funds. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 81 Workshop Packet Page Number 88 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISSENIOR HOUSING MARKET Older Adult (Age 55+) Population and Household Trends The Demographic Review section of this study presented general demographic characteristics of the population and household base in Maplewood. The following points summarize key find- ings from that section as they pertain to the older adult and senior population. The senior population grew nearly 33%, adding 3,418people, from2010 to 2026. The 65 to 74 age groupgrew by 82%between 2010 and 2026, adding 2,162people. As this group ages, the 75 and older age group isexpected toincrease11% between 2026 and 2050, add- ing 448people. The 55 to 64age group is projected to expand13%, adding 669people, between 2026 and 2050, whilethe 65to 74 age group contracts-10%(-493people). The key market for active adult housing is comprised of senior households age 65 and older, although active adult properties areoftenrestricted to residents age 55 and older. The pri- mary market for service-enhanced housing (i.e. assisted living) is senior households age 75 and older. While individuals in their 50s and 60s typically do not comprise the market base for service- enhanced senior housing, they often have elderly parents to whom they provide support when they decide to relocate to senior housing. Elderly parents often preferto be near their adult caregivers, so the older adult age cohort (age 55 to 64) also generates some ad- ditional demand for service-enhanced senior housing products. The frailer the senior, the greater the proportion of their income they typically spend on housing and services, with income allocations ranging from40% to 50% for market rate ac- tive adult housing, 65% for independent living, and 80% to 90% or more for assisted living. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 82 Workshop Packet Page Number 89 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISSENIOR HOUSING MARKET The proceeds fromahome sale, as well as financial assistance from their adult children, are often used as supplemental income to afford senior housing alternatives. The keytarget for market rate active adult housing is comprised of senior households (age 65 and older) with incomes of $40,000 or more. In 2026, we estimate there are an esti- mated 3,689age-(65 and older) and income-qualified households inMaplewood that com- prise the primarymarket for active adult housing. The target market for affordableand subsidizedseniorhousing is households age 65 and older with incomes at or below 60% AMI, although some affordable properties may be re- stricted to households at 80% AMI or lower. At 60% AMI, household income limits are $55,260for a one-person household and $63,120for a two-person householdin Ramsey County. There are an estimated 2,830households age 65 and older in the Citywith incomes of $63,120or lower (51% of all age 65 and older households). Independent living and assisted living housing demand is primarily driven by senior house- holds age 75 and older with incomes of $40,000 or more(plus senior homeowners with lower incomes). We estimate the number of age-and income-qualified households in the Cityto be 1,676in 2026. The target market for memory care housing consists ofsenior households age 65 and older with a memory impairment and incomes of at least $60,000. In 2026, we estimate that there are 2,822age 65 and older households in the Citywith incomes of at least $60,000 (51% of all senior households). Based on anestimated 15% incidence rate of Alz- 423households in the Cityare candidates for memory care housing in 2026. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 83 Workshop Packet Page Number 90 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET After adjusting for inflation, growth among households age- and income-qualified for senior housing in Maplewood between 2026 and 2030 is projected to be largest for market rate active adult housing, increasing by 356 households (10% growth). The number of households age- and income-qualified at 60% AMI is expected to increase 5% (151 households) between 2026 and 2030, while the number of households qualified for independent and assisted living is projected to increase 20% (327 households). We antici- pate that there will be a 12% increase in households qualified for memory care housing be- tween 2026 and 2030 (50 households). The estimated homeownership rate is 80% for age 55 to 64 households in Maplewood, higher than 79% in the Metro Area. Maplewood decreases slightly to 76% for age 65 to 74 households compared to 80% in the Metro Area. Seniors typically begin to consider moving into senior housing alternatives in their early to mid-70s. This movement pattern is demonstrated in Maplewood as the homeownership rate declines from 76% (age 65 to 74) to 62% for age 75 and older households in the City compared to a drop from 80% (age 65 to 74) to 69% (age 75 and older) in the Metro Area. With a homeownership rate of 70% for all households age 65 and older in Maplewood, many residents would be able to use proceeds from the sales of their homes toward senior housing alternatives. Home sale data is useful in that it represents the amount of equity seniors may be able to de- rive from the sales of their homes that could be used to cover the cost of senior housing alter- natives. The following information summarizes resale data for homes that were built in 2009 or earlier in the City from 2020 through 2025. Sales of newer homes are excluded because older adults and seniors often reside in older homes and are typically not a market for new single- family home construction, so we evaluate sales data for homes that are at least 15 years old. The data was obtained from Minneapolis Area Realtors. Resale activity has trended slower, as the number of closed transactions declined -33% from 595 transactions in 2020 to 397 resales in 2025. Resales of older single-family homes peaked in 2021, with 645 transactions. - The decline in sales volume is due, in part, to increased mortgage rates which reduced the affordability of homes, causing many potential buyers to defer a decision to pur- chase until rates decline. Resale values of older homes experienced strong growth in Maplewood in recent years, climbing 28.5% from $264,500 in 2020 to $339,900 in 2025. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 84 Workshop Packet Page Number 91 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISSENIOR HOUSING MARKET Based on the 2025median resale price for older (built in 2009 or earlier) homes in Maple- wood($339,900), a senior household could generate an estimated $6,390of additional in- come annually ($533per month) if they invested in an income-producing account (2.0% in- terest rate) after accounting for marketing costs and/or real estate commissions (6.0% of home sale price). Duetothe rising home resale prices, many older adults and seniors particularly those in the market for independent housing products may be inclined to sell their home and con- sider housing alternatives. Should a senior utilize the home sale proceeds dollar for dollar to support living in senior housing with services, the proceeds would last roughlynineyears in independent living housing (monthly rent approximated at $3,200), about five and a half yearsin assisted living (monthly rent approximated at $5,000), or roughly four and a halfyears in memory care housing (monthly rent approximated at $6,250). Seniors in service-intensive housing typically have lengths of stays between two and three years indicating that a large portion of seniors in the areawill be financially prepared to pri- vately pay for their housing and services. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 85 Workshop Packet Page Number 92 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET Supply of Senior Housing The information on the following pages summarizes existing senior housing facilities in Maple- wood, including supply (number of units) and service level. Maxfield Research identified a total of 19 age-restricted housing facilities in Maplewood, totaling 1,794 units. In total, there are 167 market rate active adult rental units, 487 affordable and subsidized rental units, and 788 service-enhanced units in Maplewood. - Among the service-enhanced facilities, there are an estimated 99 independent living units and 438 assisted living units, along with 251 memory care units. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 86 Workshop Packet Page Number 93 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET TABLE 32 SENIOR HOUSING SUPPLY SUMMARY CITY OF MAPLEWOOD July 2026 Project NameAddressCityUnitsType/Notes Ecumen Lakeview Commons1200 Lakewood Dr NMaplewood82Assisted Living Ecumen Lakeview Commons1200 Lakewood Dr NMaplewood16Memory Care Ecumen Seasons167-Legacy Pkwy EMaplewood49Independent Living Ecumen Seasons167-Legacy Pkwy EMaplewood72Assisted Living Ecumen Seasons167-Legacy Pkwy EMaplewood30Memory Care Carefree Cottages1801 Gervais AveMaplewood26362+ Active Adult LIHTC Norgard Court1807 Gervais CourtMaplewood6055+ Active Adult Woodlyn Village2122 Woodlyn AveMaplewood5955+ Active Adult LIHTC Encore Assisted Living2300 Hazelwood StMaplewood16Assisted Living Encore Memory Care2300 Hazelwood StMaplewood32Memory Care Maplewood Assisted Living1890 Sherren Ave EMaplewood37Assisted Living Maplewood Assisted Living1890 Sherren Ave EMaplewood24Memory Care Maple Hill3030 Southlawn DrMaplewood79Assisted Living Maple Hill3030 Southlawn DrMaplewood27Memory Care Shores of Lake Phalen1870 E Shore DrMaplewood73Assisted Living Shores of Lake Phalen1870 E Shore DrMaplewood32Memory Care Century Trails1730 Monastery WayMaplewood40Section 202 HUD Concordia Arms2030 Lydia Ave EMaplewood12555+ Active Adult LIHTC Boden Maplewood1700 Beam AveMaplewood50Memory Care Frost English Silver1957 English StMaplewood10755+ Active Adult Caretta Senior Living1910 Cty. R. C E.Maplewood47Assisted Living Caretta Senior Living1910 Cty. R. C E.Maplewood26Memory Care Harmony Gardens1438 Cty. R. C E.Maplewood50Independent Living Harmony Gardens1438 Cty. R. C E.Maplewood32Assisted Living Harmony Gardens1438 Cty. R. C E.Maplewood14Memory Care Cardinal Pointe3003 Hazelwood StMaplewood10855+ Co-Op Summerhill Co-Op935 Ferndale St NMaplewood4455+ Co-Op Connemara Condominiums2465 Londin Ln EMaplewood14455+ Active Adult Owner The American Co-Op on Lake Phalen1875 E Shore DrMaplewood5662+ Co-Op Market Rate Active Adult:167 Affordable Active Adult:487 Ownership Active Adult:352 Independent Living:99 Assisted Living:438 Memory Care:251 Senior Housing Total:1,794 Sources: Care Options Network; Senior Housing Guide; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 87 Workshop Packet Page Number 94 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET Affordable/Subsidized Senior Rental Summary The following points summarize key findings from our survey of affordable and subsidized sen- ior housing properties in Maplewood, including unit mix, vacancies, and quoted basic and con- tract rents. Rental rates presented in the table are a weighted average based on the number of units at each property, so buildings with a larger number of units of any one type contribute more toward the average than those with only a few units of a specific type. We surveyed four affordable and subsidized facilities, totaling 487 units. - Woodlyn Village, Carefree Cottages, and Concordia Arms are LIHTC properties, totaling 447 units. - Century Trails is a Section 202 HUD property with 40 units. At the time of the survey, there were 25 vacant units, resulting in a 5.1% vacancy rate among the affordable and subsidized senior rental properties in Maplewood, which is in line with a balanced market (5.0% vacancy). TABLE 33 Average monthly rents range from $1,176 for one-bedroom units to $1,653 for three-bed- room cottages. The weighted average rent across all unit types is $1,319 per month ($1.63 psf, on average). Tenants in project-based Section 202 housing pay 30% of their adjusted income on rent, with the remaining costs covered by the federal government. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 88 Workshop Packet Page Number 95 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS SENIOR HOUSING MARKET Market Rate Active Adult Summary Maxfield Research identified two market rate active adult rental facilities in Maplewood, to- taling 167 existing units. Properties include Norgard Court Apartments (60 units), which is marketed as independent living but does not offer any supportive services, and Frost Eng- lish Silver (107 units). - There were two vacant units at the time of our research, resulting in a 1.2% vacancy rate, well below equilibrium (5.0%) vacancy. TABLE 34 Ownership Active Adult Summary We identified four senior ownership communities in Maplewood, totaling 352 units. Three of the properties are senior cooperatives, totaling 208 units. As of July 2026, there were four units available for sale across the senior ownership communities. Service-Enhanced Facility Summary We identified nine service-enhanced facilities in Maplewood, totaling 788 units. Market equilibrium for service-enhanced senior housing (i.e. assisted living and memory care) is generally considered to be 7.0% vacancy, which allows for an adequate supply of al- ternatives for prospective residents. Market equilibrium for independent living is generally considered to be 5.0% vacancy. Six of the nine service-enhanced facilities in Maplewood provided vacancy information for this survey. At that time, there were eight vacancies in independent living (8.1% vacancy rate), 38 vacancies in assisted living (14.6% vacancy rate), and 17 vacancies in memory care (9.7% vacancy rate), all above equilibrium. The map below illustrates the general location of these senior housing facilities in Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 89 Workshop Packet Page Number 96 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISSENIOR HOUSING MARKET Senior Housing Location Map City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 90 Workshop Packet Page Number 97 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Housing Affordability Introduction Affordable housing is a term that has various definitions according to different people and is of- ten a product of supply and demand. According to the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), the definition of affordability is for a household to pay no more than 30% of its annual income on housing (including utilities). Families who pay more than 30% of their income for housing (either rent or mortgage) are considered cost burdened and may have difficulty affording necessities such as food, clothing, transportation, and medical care. The following topics are covered in this analysis. Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing (NOAH) units Household income and rent limits for affordable housing Housing Choice Voucher program Cost burdened households in the area, and Housing costs in Maplewood relative to household income The United States Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS), Minnesota Housing and Finance Agency, and HUD are the primary data resources for the Housing Affordability section of this report. Additionally, Maxfield Research and Consulting utilizes findings from the For-Sale Market and Rental Housing Market sections of this study to evaluate housing cost affordability in the community. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 91 Workshop Packet Page Number 98 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Generally, housing that is income-restricted to households earning at or below 80% of Area Me- dian Income (AMI) is considered affordable. However, individual properties may have income restrictions set anywhere from 30% to 80% of AMI. Rent is not based on income but instead is a contract amount that is affordable to households within the specific income restriction seg- ment. Moderate-can refer to both rental and ownership housing. The definition is broadly defined as housing that targets house- holds earning between 50% and 120% AMI. The following figure summarizes generally recog- nized AMI Definitions: Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing (NOAH) Although affordable housing is typically associated with an income-restricted property, there are other housing units in communities that indirectly provide affordable housing. Housing units that were not developed or designated with income restrictions yet are more affordable The NOAH housing supply is available through the private market, as opposed to assisted hous- ing programs through various governmental agencies. Property values on these units are lower based on a combination of factors, such as: age of structure, location, condition, size, school district, etc. Because of these factors, housing costs tend to be lower. According to the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, the privately unsubsidized housing stock sup- plies three times as many low-cost affordable units than assisted projects nationwide. Unlike assisted rental developments, most unsubsidized affordable units are scattered across older, sometimes smaller, rental buildings. These older properties are often vulnerable to rede- velopment due to their age, modest rents, and deferred maintenance. Because many of these housing units have affordable rents, project-based and private housing markets cannot be eas- ily separated. Some households (typically those with household incomes of 50% to 60% AMI) income-qualify for both market rate and project-based affordable housing. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 92 Workshop Packet Page Number 99 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Rent and Income Limits The following table displays the maximum allowable incomes by household size to qualify for affordable housing and maximum gross rents that can be charged by bedroom size in Ramsey County. TABLE 35 These incomes are published and revised annually by HUD and also published separately by Minnesota Housing and Finance Agency based on the date a project is placed into service. The Novogradac income limit calculator was used to determine income and rent limits at 100% AMI. Fair Market Rent reflects the amount needed to pay gross monthly rent at modest rental hous- ing in a given area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 93 Workshop Packet Page Number 100 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Housing Unit and Household Distribution The following table summarizes the distribution of occupied housing units and households in Maplewood. This information was compiled by the Metropolitan Council using American Com- munity Survey 2024 five-year estimates, with adjustments made by Maxfield Research to reflect 2026 housing unit and household estimates. TABLE 36 Half (50.1%) of the ownership units in Maplewood are valued in the 81% to 115% AMI range, while the largest proportion of rental units (31.8%) are priced in the 51% to 60% AMI range. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 94 Workshop Packet Page Number 101 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Housing Choice Vouchers -Housing Choice Vouch- ers (HCV), assist low income households secure housing through the private market. The ten- ant-based subsidy is funded by HUD. Under the HCV program, also referred to as Section 8, qualified households are issued a voucher that can be taken to an apartment that has rent lev- els at or less than the payment standards by bedroom type for their area. The household then pays approximately 30% of their Adjusted Gross Income for rent and utilities, and the Federal Government pays the remainder of the rent to the landlord. The maximum income limit to be eligible for a Voucher is 50% of AMI based on household size. The voucher program uses a payment standard which matches the cost of housing and utili- ties and households may use the housing voucher for units with rent that is below or above the payment standard. Metro HRA has payment standards that are set up by Metro Area Zip Code depending on the geographic location. Monthly Payment Standards 55109 Zip Code 0-Bedroom 1-Bedroom 2-Bedroom 3-Bedroom 4-Bedroom Payment Standard $1,150 $1,300 $1,590 $2,120 $2,370 As of year-end 2025, Metro HRA had 7,303 Housing Choice Vouchers. These vouchers cover all of Carver and Anoka Counties and suburban Hennepin and Ramsey Counties. There are 358 voucher holders living in the census tracts comprising the City of Maplewood. Metro HRA maintained 100% utilization of the Housing Choice Voucher program in 2025. The waiting list was opened in April 2025 for the first time since summer 2022, and 1,000 households were randomly selected to be placed on the list. Applicants on the wait list should expect to wait one to five years for a voucher. This list is currently closed and Metro HRA is no longer accepting applications. The Housing Choice Voucher program faces several issues, notably rising rents and low va- cancy. Rising rents reduce the overall budget allocation for the vouchers so fewer house- holds can be served at the same allocation level, and low vacancy rates reduce incentives from landlords to accept vouchers. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 95 Workshop Packet Page Number 102 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Housing Cost Burden The following summarizes the number and percentage of owner and renter households in Maplewood compared to Ramsey County and the Metro Area that pay 30% or more of their gross income for housing. This information was compiled from the American Community Sur- vey 2024 five-year estimates and adjusted by Maxfield Research to reflect 2026 household esti- mates. The Federal standard for affordability is 30% of income for housing costs. Moderately cost-bur- dened is defined as households paying between 30% and 50% of their income to housing; while severely cost-burdened is defined as households paying more than 50% of their income for housing. Higher-income households that are cost-burdened may have the option of moving to lower priced housing, but lower-income households often do not. TABLE 37 HOUSING COST BURDEN CITY OF MAPLEWOOD MaplewoodRamsey Co.Metro Area No.Pct.No.Pct.No.Pct. Owner Households All Owner HHs11,165129,682878,095 Cost Burden 30.0% or greater2,26420.3%27,51021.2%171,62419.5% Cost Burden 30.0% to 34.9%5925.3%7,1965.5%43,9105.0% Cost Burden 35.0% to 49.9%7326.6%9,4127.3%61,3657.0% Cost Burden 50.0% or more9408.4%10,9028.4%66,3497.6% Owner HHs w/ incomes <$50,00017421,213119,839 Cost Burden 30.0% or greater7945.3%14,44868.1%84,03670.1% Renter Households All Renter HHs5,25394,272432,096 Cost Burden 30.0% or greater2,73952.1%46,07648.9%203,27547.0% Cost Burden 30.0% to 34.9%68813.1%9,67110.3%41,1849.5% Cost Burden 35.0% to 49.9%88016.8%13,97214.8%63,26614.6% Cost Burden 50.0% or more1,17122.3%22,43223.8%98,82522.9% Renter HHs w/ incomes <$35,0001,62428,781117,092 Cost Burden 30.0% or greater1,36884.3%25,09287.2%103,16988.1% Sources: American Community Survey, 2020-2024 estimates; Maxfield Research & Consulting In total, an estimated 5,003 households in Maplewood are considered cost-burdened, rep- resenting 31% of all households. By comparison, 33% of households in Ramsey County and 29% of households in the Metro Area are cost burdened. An estimated 20.3% of owner households (2,264 households) are estimated to be paying more than 30% of their income toward housing costs in Maplewood, lower than 21.2% in Ramsey County but higher than 19.5% in the Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 96 Workshop Packet Page Number 103 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISHOUSING AFFORDABILITY In Maplewood, an estimated 52.1%of all renter households (2,739) pay more than 30% of their income towardhousing,higherthan 48.9% in Ramsey Countyand 47.0% in the Metro Area. The number of cost burdened households increases proportionally based on lower incomes. An estimated84% of renters with incomes below $35,000 are cost burdened and 45% of owners with incomes below $50,000 are cost burdened in Maplewood. An estimated 12.9% of all households in Maplewood (2,112 households) are severely cost- burdened (paying 50% or more of their income toward housing costs), lower than Ramsey County (14.9%) but higher than the Metro Area (12.6%). An estimated 8.4% of owner households in both Maplewood and Ramsey County are se- verely cost-burdened, compared to 7.6% in the Metro Area. In Maplewood, 22.3% of renter households are estimated to be severely cost-burdened, lowerthan 23.8% inRamsey Countyand 22.9% in the Metro Area. The following figure summarizes the percentage of cost-burdened households in Maple- wood by race/ethnicity. Percent Cost-burdened by Race(Maplewood) BlackAmerican IndianAsianWhiteHispanic/Latino % Cost-Burdened48.9%59.6%27.4%22.9%30.7% MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 97 Workshop Packet Page Number 104 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Housing Costs as Percentage of Household Income Housing costs are generally considered affordable at 30% of a households adjusted gross in- come. The table on the following page illustrates key housing metrics based on housing costs and household incomes in Maplewood. The table estimates the percentage of householders that can afford rental and for-sale housing based on a 30% allocation of income to housing. The housing affordability calculations assume the following: For-Sale Housing - 10% down payment with good credit score - Closing costs rolled into mortgage - 30-year mortgage at 6.49% interest rate (rate as of July 9, 2026) - Private mortgage insurance (equity of less than 20%) - Homeowners insurance for single-family homes and association dues for townhomes - Owner household income estimates per 2024 ACS Rental Housing - Background check on tenant to ensure credit history - 30% allocation of income - Renter household income estimates per 2024 ACS Because of the down payment requirement and strict underwriting criteria for a mortgage, not all households will meet the income qualifications as outlined above. An estimated 59% of existing owner households in Maplewood could afford to buy an en- try-level detached single-family home priced at $325,000. The proportion of income-qualified households declines as the sale price increases, and roughly 34% of existing owner households could afford to purchase a move-up detached single-family home priced at $475,000. Roughly 64% of owner households could afford an entry-level multifamily unit (i.e. town- home, twin home, condominium) priced at $275,000, while 41% could afford a move-up unit priced at $425,000. An estimated 51% of renter households in Maplewood can afford to rent a one-bedroom unit at existing market rate properties (average rent of $1,301 per month), while 40% can afford a two-bedroom unit at the average market rate rent of $1,612 at the existing proper- ties. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 98 Workshop Packet Page Number 105 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY New construction market rate rents will be higher than existing, older product. The esti- mated new construction rents shown in the table are based on our knowledge of rental rates at recently built market rate apartments properties in Maplewood. An estimated 40% of existing renters in Maplewood could afford to rent a one-bedroom apartment within a new development renting for $1,600 per month, while only 26% could afford a new two-bedroom unit priced at $2,000. TABLE 38 Based on these price points, this data indicates that new construction housing in Maple- wood is unattainable for the majority of households, both owner and renter. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 99 Workshop Packet Page Number 106 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Demand Estimates Introduction Maxfield Research & Consulting was engaged to quantify the demand potential for new housing in Maplewood from 2026 to 2050. Earlier sections of this report examined growth trends and demographic characteristics of the household base in the community, as well as employment trends, housing characteristics, and housing market conditions in the area. This section of the report summarizes our demand calculations for new housing in Maplewood to 2050, including the following product types. General occupancy for-sale housing demand General occupancy rental housing demand calculations, including demand for subsi- dized, affordable, and market rate rental housing Owned and rented market rate active adult senior housing demand Demand for affordable and subsidized senior rental housing Demand for service-enhanced (independent living, assisted living, and memory care) senior housing MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 100 Workshop Packet Page Number 107 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOODHOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISDEMAND ESTIMATES Demographic Profile and Housing Demand Housing demand can be generated by several sources including household growth, changes in housing preferences, and replacement need. Household growth necessitates the construction of new housing units unless there is enough vacant housing available to absorb the increase. Demand is also affected by shifting demographics, such as an aging population, which dictates the type of housing preferred. The following figure illustrates typical life cycle housing needs by age group. Apartments Singles, roommates, couples without children in the 18 34age range Entry-Level Purchase Often married/cohabitating in the 25 39age range beginning to start families Move-Up Housing Typically, family households in the 30 49age range, many with children Single-Level, Maintenance-Free Empty-nesters or never-nesters in the 55 74age range that prefer to downsize Housing w/ Services Often households age 65and older in need of some assistance with daily activities MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 101 Workshop Packet Page Number 108 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES General Occupancy Housing Demand Summary General occupancy housing demand is comprised of several components, including household growth and turnover, pent-up demand, and replacement needs. Solid household growth is pro- jected for Maplewood, but much of the housing demand will be generated by the turnover of existing households. Satisfying the projected demand and achieving population and household growth in Maplewood will be highly dependent on the availability of suitable housing options catering to a variety of household types, income levels, and age groups. First, we calculate potential demand from new household growth based on the propensity of households to own or rent their housing (i.e. household tenure data). To estimate for-sale housing demand, we focus on households under the age of 75 that will account for the majority of demand, but we include all age groups for the rental housing demand calculations. The second part of the analysis calculates demand from existing households, or turnover de- mand. Younger households tend to be highly mobile, relative to older households. Mobility rates were estimated based on American Community Survey data and applied to the existing household base. We then estimate the percentage of existing households turning over that would prefer to purchase or rent new housing. An additional proportion is added for households that would purchase or rent in the City who currently reside outside the community. We estimate that 30% of the demand potential for general occupancy housing would be derived from outside the City. - Overall, we find demand potential for 3,026 new general occupancy for-sale housing units and 3,637 general occupancy rental units in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050. - Demand potential includes 478 for-sale units and 825 rental units between 2026 and 2030, 1,097 for-sale units and 1,298 rental units between 2030 and 2040, and 1,451 for- sale units and 1,514 rental units between 2040 and 2050. Based on the age distribution of households in Maplewood and residential development trends, we estimate that 55% of the householders seeking new for-sale housing in Maplewood will de- sire detached single-family homes, while the remaining 45% will seek other housing product types such as townhomes, twin homes, or condominiums. - We anticipate that there will be demand for 1,664 detached single-family homes and 1,362 units of other product types in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050. - There is demand for 263 detached single-family units and 215 other product types be- tween 2026 and 2030, 604 detached single-family units and 494 other product types be- tween 2030 and 2040, and 798 detached single-family units and 653 other product types between 2040 and 2050. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 102 Workshop Packet Page Number 109 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Based on a review of renter household incomes and income limits, we estimate the proportion of the total demand potential by rental housing product type, as follows: - Market rate housing (households with incomes at 60% AMI and higher) - Affordable housing (affordable to households with incomes between 30% and 60% AMI) - Subsidized housing (affordable to households at 30% AMI or less) Due to the income limits relative to rents, we understand that there is some crossover between affordable and subsidized demand, as well as between affordable and market rate demand. Some households with incomes between 30% and 60% AMI may qualify for subsidized housing, depending on income restrictions at the property, as well as new market rate housing depend- ing on rents. We then subtract pending general occupancy rental housing developments that are under con- struction from the demand potential der construction, rental demand remains the same. TABLE 39 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 103 Workshop Packet Page Number 110 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES On an annual basis, new for-sale housing demand in Maplewood equates to 126.1 new housing units per year, including 69.3 new detached single-family homes per year and 56.7 new units of other product types per year. These projections reveal much higher demand than what has been constructed in the City annually over the past ten years. These demand estimates assume that residential lots will be available for development in the community, as it would be difficult for Maplewood to capture the projected demand potential without an adequate supply of development-ready lots. When complete, the Century Ponds development will consist of 133 detached single-family homes and 73 townhomes. This development will capture a large portion of the projected de- mand between 2026 and 2030. Additional developments will be necessary to capture for-sale housing demand in the long-term. Senior Housing Demand Summary The following table summarizes our senior housing demand estimates for Maplewood by ser- vice level in 2026, 2030, 2040, and 2050, including demand for market rate owned and rented active adult units, affordable and subsidized age-restricted rental units, independent living, as- sisted living, and memory care. Due to the projected population and household increases among the older adult and senior age groups between 2026 and 2050, strong senior housing demand growth is projected in Maplewood. TABLE 40 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 104 Workshop Packet Page Number 111 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES As of 2026, excess senior housing demand is largest for affordable and subsidized rental housing, totaling 1,001 units. There is excess demand for 599 service-enhanced units, most notably independent living at 412 units, while excess demand also exists for 529 market rate active adult units (325 owner and 204 renter units). Due to the age distribution of the population, excess demand growth is projected to be strongest for service-enhanced units, increasing by 188 units (31%) between 2026 and 2050. Maplewood is also projected to experience a 26% increase in excess demand for market rate active adult units (136 units) between 2026 and 2050. Excess demand for affordable and subsidized units is projected to increase 10% (95 units) between 2026 and 2050. Senior Housing Demand Methodology The market for active adult housing is comprised of older adult (age 55 to 64), younger senior (age 65 to 74) and older senior (age 75+) households, with market demand weighted toward older seniors. To arrive at the potential age-, income- and asset-qualified base for market rate active adult housing, we include all age-qualified households with incomes of $40,000 or more plus homeowner households with lower incomes who would qualify with the proceeds from a home sale. We then adjust the potential market based on capture rates for each age cohort. These cap- ture rates reduce the total number of age/income/asset-qualified households to consider only the portion of older adult and senior households who would be willing, able, and inclined to move to senior housing alternatives, including both owner- and renter-occupied housing. We estimate that seniors residing outside the City will generate 30% of the demand for market rate active adult housing. Demand is then apportioned between ownership and rental product types. The methodology used to calculate demand for affordable housing closely mirrors that used to calculate demand for market rate active adult housing, although we adjust to more precisely quantify demand among this market segment. To arrive at the potential age- and income-quali- fied base for low-income and affordable housing, we include all senior households age 55 and older that qualify within the income guidelines for two-person households in 2026. Households earning between 30% and 60% of AMI are generally candidates for affordable housing, while households earning less than 30% AMI are typically a market for subsidized housing. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 105 Workshop Packet Page Number 112 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Households in a need-based situation (either requiring services or financial assistance) more readily move to housing alternatives than those not in need-based situations. Based on our ex- perience in market feasibility for affordable and subsidized senior housing, along with our anal- ysis of demographic and competitive market factors in the area, we apply a conservative 25% capture rate to the age/income-qualified market to arrive at a total potential demand. An additional proportion (30%) is added for senior households that would move into affordable senior housing in the City who currently reside outside the area. Based on the existing and pro- jected distribution of households with incomes below 60% AMI, we estimate the proportion of demand for affordable and subsidized units. Independent living demand calculations focus on the potential private pay/market rate demand for independent living units. To arrive at the potential age-income qualified base for independ- ent senior housing, we include all senior households with incomes of $40,000 or more and homeowners with incomes between $30,000 and $40,000 who would qualify with the proceeds from a home sale. Demand for independent living housing is need-driven, which reduces the qualified market to only the portion of seniors who need some assistance. To account for this, the age/income- qualified base is multiplied by the percentage of seniors who need some assistance with at least three Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADLs), but not six or more Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) and IADLs, as these frailer seniors would need the level of care found in service-intensive assisted living. An additional proportion (30%) is added for senior households that would move into an independent living facility in the City who currently reside outside the area. Assisted living demand estimates also focus on the potential private pay/market rate demand. The age-qualified market for assisted living is defined as seniors ages 75 and over. Demand for assisted living housing is need-driven, which reduces the qualified market to only the portion of seniors who need assistance. According to a study completed by the Centers for Disease Con- trol and the National Center for Health Statistics, about 35% of seniors need assistance with everyday activities. We consider seniors in households with incomes of $40,000 or greater to be income-qualified for assisted living senior housing in the City. Households with incomes of $40,000 could afford monthly assisted living fees of $3,000 by allocating 90% of their income toward the fees. In ad- dition to households with incomes of $40,000 or greater, there is a large base of senior house- holds with lower incomes who income-qualify based on assets their homes, in particular. We estimate that 65% of the qualified market needing significant assistance with ADLs could either remain in their homes or less service-intensive senior housing with the assistance of a family member or home health care or would need greater care provided in a skilled care facil- ity. The remaining 35% could be served by assisted living. An additional proportion (30%) is added for seniors that would move into assisted living who currently reside outside the City. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 106 Workshop Packet Page Number 113 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Demand for memory care housing is calculated by starting with the estimated senior (ages 65+) population in 2026 age cohorts in this population. Based on our review of senior household incomes, homeownership rates, and home sale data, we estimate the portion of Maplewood seniors that have incomes and/or assets to sufficiently cover the costs for memory care housing. An additional proportion (30%) is added for seniors that would move into memory care housing who currently reside outside the area. From the demand potential for each service level, we subtract existing and pending competitive senior housing units in the City at equilibrium to arrive at excess demand potential in the City. Competitive units are adjusted based on location in the City to account for draw area overlap with other communities. - We find excess demand potential for 325 market rate active adult ownership units and 204 market rate active adult rental units in Maplewood in 2026, increasing to 407 active adult ownership units and 258 active adult rental units in 2050. - We also find excess demand potential for 474 age-restricted subsidized units and 527 age-restricted affordable units in Maplewood in 2026, increasing to 512 subsidized units and 584 affordable units in 2050. - Additionally, we find excess demand for 599 service-enhanced units in Maplewood in 2026 (412 independent living, 76 assisted living, and 111 memory care). Excess service- enhanced demand in Maplewood is projected to increase to 787 units in 2050 (543 in- dependent living, 101 assisted living, and 143 memory care). Assumptions used to estimate demand in 2040 and 2050 include: 1) the percentages used to determine income- and asset-qualifications for senior housing are the same proportions used for the 2030 calculations; 2) all capture rates hold steady for each age group; and 3) no new product is added between 2030 and 2050. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 107 Workshop Packet Page Number 114 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Conclusions & Recommendations Introduction This section of the report summarizes calculated demand for specific housing products in Maplewood and recommends development concepts to meet the housing needs forecast for the community. All recommendations are based on findings of the Housing Needs Analysis. The following topics are covered. Review of housing demand findings Development concept recommendations to meet projected demand An overview of challenges and opportunities as they pertain to housing development in Maplewood A summary of potential housing programs that could be utilized to help achieve housing goals MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 108 Workshop Packet Page Number 115 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISCONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Housing Demand Summary In total, we find demand for 6,663general occupancy housing units in Maplewoodbetween 2026and 2050, with 25%of the demand being for detached single-family units (1,664) and 20% other for-sale product typeunits(1,362). Overhalf(55%)of the anticipateddemand will be for rental units (3,637units), including 1,819market rate, 728affordable, and 1,090subsidized units. We also found excess demand for a total of 2,129senior housing units in 2026, expanding 20% to 2,548units by2050. This level of senior housing demand may not be realizedas many sen- iorsprefer to age in place and delay moving to senior housing until they need services. Addi- tionally, a large portion of the active adult demand (market rate and affordable) could be satis- fied with the development of maintenance-free housing products such as apartmentsand townhomesthat are not age-restricted (i.e. general occupancy housing). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 109 Workshop Packet Page Number 116 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Recommendations Based on findings from this analysis, the tables and comments on the following pages summa- rize recommended development concepts for general occupancy and senior housing in Maple- wood through 2050. These proposed concepts are intended to act as a development guide to meet the housing needs of existing and future households in the community. For-Sale Housing Based on information gathered on for-sale properties in the area, we provide the following con- clusions and recommendations regarding the for-sale housing market in Maplewood. We estimate that there will be demand for 1,664 general occupancy detached single-family units and 1,362 general occupancy multifamily units between 2026 and 2050. Additionally, we find excess demand for 407 active adult ownership housing units, which would likely be satisfied with the development of townhome, twin home, villa, or condominium products. The following table summarizes a potential pricing breakdown for new construction units, -- TABLE 41 A move-up buyer is typically someone who is selling one house and purchasing another one, usually a larger and more expensive home. The move often occurs due to a lifestyle change, such as a new job or a growing family. The 35 to 44 and 45 to 54 age groups are generally target markets for move-up housing, while move-up townhome/twin home/condominium units would also target an older buyer (age 55 to 74) looking to downsize or right-size. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 110 Workshop Packet Page Number 117 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS We consider homes priced below $350,000 to be entry-level, while move-up new construc- tion detached single-family homes would likely be priced in the $500,000 to $650,000 range. Pricing for an entry-level multifamily unit (i.e. townhome, twin home, condominium) would likely be at $325,000 or lower, while pricing for move-up new construction multifamily units would likely begin at $400,000. There is modest demand for executive/luxury housing within City limits in Maplewood, and we anticipate that a portion (10%) of new construction detached single-family units would be priced for this market ($700,000 and higher). We anticipate that 75% of the new detached single-family units (1,249 units) will target move-up buyers and recommend that 15% (250) be priced at $350,000 or lower to target moderate income buyers (entry-level). - A household would need to have a minimum income of $111,352 to afford a home pur- chased at $350-. Income limits for a two-person household are $105,200 at 100% AMI and $126,240 at 120% AMI, while four-person households have limits of $131,500 and $157,800 at 100% AMI and 120% AMI, respectively. We anticipate that 65% of the new construction multifamily units (885) will target move-up buyers and/or empty nesters and recommend that 35% (477 units) should be priced at $325,000 or lower to target moderate income buyers. The development of any new for-sale housing products in the community priced to target moderate income buyers will likely require a public-private partnership or alternative de- velopment concept (i.e. community land trust, affordable housing cooperative). Entry-level home demand will primarily be satisfied through turnover of the existing supply of older single-family homes by increasing the supply of move-up housing or with the in- creased development of townhome, twin home, or condominium products. Because the primary target market for new multifamily units will be empty-nesters and young seniors (age 65 to 74), the majority of these units should be zero-entry and single- level or have a master suite on the main level if a unit has two stories. Units could also be constructed using Universal Design principles. In addition to older buyers, mid-age professionals, particularly singles and couples without children, will seek multifamily units if they prefer not to have the maintenance responsibili- ties of a detached single-family home. Younger households may also find purchasing a mul- tifamily unit to be more affordable than a new detached single-family home. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 111 Workshop Packet Page Number 118 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS General Occupancy Rental Housing The following table summarizes the recommended mix of rental housing units by product type, including monthly rent ranges, development timing, and target markets. The recommendations are intended to reflect potential development concepts for new rental housing in Maplewood but do not equate to total estimated demand. The equilibrium vacancy rate for rental housing is considered to be 5.0% which allows for nor- mal turnover and an adequate supply of alternatives for prospective renters. Based on our sur- vey of general occupancy apartment properties in the community, we found that affordable and subsidized facilities are 2.4% vacant, while the market rate rental properties are 4.0% va- cant. This data suggests pent-up demand for new general occupancy rental housing in Maple- wood, both market rate and affordable/subsidized. TABLE 42 We find excess demand potential for 3,637 general occupancy rental housing units in Maple- wood between 2026 and 2050, including 1,819 market rate units. Based on the income distri- bution of renter households, we estimate that there will also be demand for income-restricted units, including 728 affordable and 1,090 subsidized units by 2050. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 112 Workshop Packet Page Number 119 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS The strongest sources of demand for new rental housing in the City will likely be young singles and roommate households along with couples without children in their early/mid-20s to mid- 30s who work for area employers. Other family households (i.e. single-parent households) as well as mid-age and older households (never-nesters or empty-nesters) will also account for a portion of demand for new general occupancy rental housing in the area. We recommend projects varying in size (i.e. 120- to 150-unit market rate apartment building, 60- to 70-unit affordable building, 30- to 40-unit rental townhome projects). We recommend a phased approach to rental housing development in the City, beginning with a new market rate Many young workers in Ramsey County employed in sectors such as Manufacturing, Educa- tional Services, and Health Services earn roughly $24 to $30 per hour, which equates to approx- imately $49,920 to $62,400 per year. This annual pay range falls generally between 50% AMI ($46,050) and 70% AMI ($64,470) for a one-person household, so we recommend a market rate workforce rental housing project with rent limits set to target households earning between 60% and 80% AMI ($55,260 to $73,680 for a one-person household). Market Rate & Workforce Rental Housing We recommend that average new construction market rate workforce rents range from approximately $1,500 for a studio unit to $2,200 per month for a two-bedroom unit. A $1,500 monthly rent would be affordable to a single- person household earning $60,000 per year ($28.75 per hour). Market rate rents at existing rental properties in the City average approximately $1.69 per square foot, however average monthly rents in a new construction project would be sub- stantially higher. Based on the recommended pricing, unit rents in a new apartment devel- opment would likely range from about $1.20 to $2.60 per square foot, depending on unit size, to be financially feasible. New market rate rental units should be designed with contemporary amenities that include open floor plans, higher ceilings, full kitchen appliance package, air-conditioning, garage parking, outdoor recreation (fire pit, grilling area, etc.). Since the pandemic, an increasing number of people are working remotely, a trend that is likely to continue to some degree, so buildings that are well-equipped for telecommuting are becoming more important to renters. Including features like units with dens and built in USB ports should be well-re- ceived by prospective renters looking for a designated workspace. We anticipate that demand also exists for market rate rental townhome units targeting empty-nesters and young families, including those who are new to the community and want to rent until they find a home for purchase. New construction market rate townhome rents would likely begin at $2,500 for two-bedroom units and $3,000 for three-bedroom units. Units should be larger than in an apartment development and feature contemporary ameni- ties (i.e. in-unit washer/dryer, full kitchen appliance package, kitchen island, high ceilings, etc.), an attached two car garage, and some open/green space. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 113 Workshop Packet Page Number 120 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Affordable General Occupancy Rental Housing Demand exists for general occupancy af- fordable units in Maplewood, although we anticipate that some qualified seniors would also be drawn to a new affordable general occupancy rental housing development. Affordable rental housing attracts households that cannot afford new market rate rental units but do not income-qualify for subsidized housing. Affordable projects often attract a broad group of tenants based on the unit type. One-bedroom units target singles and couples, while two and three-bedroom units target family households. We recommend an affordable project that would target residents at approximately 40% to 60% AMI. Units should feature air conditioning, full kitchen appliance package, and garage parking. A townhome development should include an attached one/two car garage along with open/green space. Subsidized Rental Housing Subsidized housing receives financial assistance (operating sub- sidies, rent payments, etc.) from governmental agencies to make rents affordable to low-to- moderate income households. Subsidized housing is challenging to develop financially. We find demand for 481 subsidized general occupancy rental housing units in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050. However, new subsidized general occupancy developments are rare as available funding is very limited, so we exclude subsidized units from the recom- mended development concepts table. There are, however, properties under special fund- ing programs that target long-term homeless, households with disabilities, or households that require permanent supportive housing that have been constructed recently. Through the Section 811 Supportive Housing for Persons with Disabilities program, HUD provides funding to develop and subsidize rental housing with support services available for very low- and extremely low-income adults with disabilities. This population could also be served through the Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) program as well as through a combination of other funding resources. Renter households in need of subsidized housing may also apply for the Housing Choice Voucher program through Metro HRA, although there is currently a wait list and applicants should expect up to five years for a voucher. Under the Housing Choice Voucher program, qualified households pay 30% of their Adjusted Gross Income for rent and utilities, and the Federal Government pays the remainder of the rent to the landlord. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 114 Workshop Packet Page Number 121 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Senior Housing The growing older adult and senior population will support long-term demand for senior hous- ing units in Maplewood through 2050. Demand exists for a variety of senior housing products, and we recommend the development of additional senior housing units to provide housing op- tions for these residents as they age. The development of new senior housing will satisfy housing needs in Maplewood by increasing the number of options for older adult and senior residents that want to relocate into new age- restricted housing. Additionally, the development of housing alternatives for seniors will stimu- late the turnover of existing homes and rental units occupied by seniors, creating more oppor- tunities for general occupancy buyers and renters. The following table summarizes a recom- mended mix of senior housing units by service level including product type, monthly rents, pro- ject size, and development timing. TABLE 43 Market Rate Active Adult Housing Because age-restricted active adult housing is not need- driven, demand competes, to some degree, with general occupancy housing. We estimate that there is excess demand for 204 market rate active adult rental units in Maplewood in 2026, increasing to 258 units in 2050. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 115 Workshop Packet Page Number 122 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS It is likely there are seniors who currently reside in general occupancy housing that would consider a new active adult rental product. In addition, there may be seniors who no longer want the burden of home maintenance and would like the choice of an active adult rental product. The rent structure for new active adult rental units would be similar to new gen- eral occupancy market rate rental housing, although the unit mix should consist of larger units resulting in slightly higher monthly rents. We also estimate that there is excess demand for 325 market rate active adult ownership units in 2026, increasing to 407 units in 2050. Active adult ownership demand can be satis- fied through a variety of products, including age-restricted detached single-family or villa communities, townhome/twin home developments, age-restricted condominium projects, or senior cooperative developments. We anticipate that much of the excess demand for market rate active adult for-sale units in Maplewood can be met by the general occupancy (not age-restricted) market, notably through the development of townhome, twin home, and/or condominium products. General pricing recommendations for new construction ownership units are reflected in the table, although active adult pricing can vary greatly, depending on product type (i.e. cooper- ative, condominium, twin home), unit sizes, amenities, and availability of services. Affordable and Subsidized Senior Rental Excess demand was calculated for 527 affordable senior housing units in 2026 and 584 units in 2050. Many candidates for affordable senior rental may be residents at older market rate rental properties. These older properties would have similar (or lower) rents that would be considered affordable for these seniors. An affordable senior housing development would most likely be a LIHTC project. We rec- ommend affordable senior housing developments as either stand-alone buildings or incor- porated into a mixed-income development. We also find excess demand for 474 subsidized units in 2026 and 512 units in 2050. The de- velopment of subsidized senior housing can be challenging due to limited financing availa- bility as federal funds have been shrinking. Funding a new subsidized development would likely rely on a mix of sources, including LIHTC, tax-exempt bonds, or Section 202 program, among others. As noted previously, there is a 5.1% vacancy rate among the affordable and subsidized sen- ior rental properties in Maplewood, essentially at equilibrium (5.0% vacancy). This data in- dicates that the market is stable in Maplewood. Service-Enhanced Senior Housing Overall, we find excess demand for 599 market rate ser- vice-enhanced senior housing units in 2026 (includes 412 independent living, 76 assisted liv- ing, and 111 memory care units), increasing to 787 units in 2050 (543 independent living, 101 assisted living, and 143 memory care). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 116 Workshop Packet Page Number 123 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS While we find excess demand for service-enhanced housing in Maplewood, many seniors prefer to age in place and delay moving to senior housing until absolutely necessary. For these reasons, we do not recommend the development of additional assisted living or memory care units in the short-term, although the growing older adult and senior popula- tion should support long-term demand for assisted living senior housing in Maplewood. We do, however, anticipate that there is immediate demand potential for independent living units in Maplewood. Independent Living Service Level The monthly fees should include the base monthly rent, utilities, and some services, such as programs (social, health, wellness and educational), 24-hour emergency call system, and regularly scheduled van transportation. In addition, meals and other support and personal care services should be made available to independent living residents on a fee-for-service basis. When their care needs increase, residents should be provided the option of receiving assisted living services in their existing units, either in bundled packages or a-la-carte. Assisted Living Service Level The fees should include the base monthly rent, utilities, three meals per day plus snacks, weekly housekeeping, linen service, professional activity programs, scheduled outings, nurs- ing care management, and 24-hour on site staffing. Additional services and care fees should also be available either in service packages or a la carte for an extra monthly charge. Memory Care Component We suggest that any memory care units be located in a separate, secured, self-contained wing located on the first floor of the building with its own dining and common area ameni- ties including a secure outdoor patio and wandering area. Fees should include the same services as assisted living along with medication reminders, medication administration, and personal care assistance, with other service packages available a-la-carte. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 117 Workshop Packet Page Number 124 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Challenges and Opportunities The previous information provided a summary of demand for various housing product types through 2050 in Maplewood. The following highlights some of the issues that will likely present a challenge, or an opportunity, for new housing development in the community (in no particu- lar order). Housing Affordability Housing costs are a key factor impacting the ability of households to afford new housing. Ap- proximately 20% of all owner households in Maplewood are considered cost burdened, includ- ing 8% that are considered severely cost burdened. An estimated 52% of existing renter house- holds are cost burdened (22% severely cost burdened) in Maplewood. Based on current home prices, 59% of existing owner households in Maplewood could afford to purchase an entry-level detached single-family home priced at $325,000, and the proportion drops to 34% that could afford a move-up home priced at $475,000. Roughly 51% of renter householders could afford an existing market rate one-bedroom unit in Maplewood. The in- come-qualified percentage drops to 40% that could afford monthly rents for a new construction one-bedroom unit priced at $1,600 per month. Housing options, both for-sale and rental, for people with moderate incomes are needed. These Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed (ALICE) households need housing opportu- nities. Home sale price appreciation and rental rate growth are both outpacing income and wage growth, further widening the gap between households that are able to afford housing in the area. These trends, coupled with elevated mortgage interest rates, are further exacerbat- ing the housing affordability issue, particularly for first-time home buyers and younger renters. Mortgage rates have a significant impact on housing affordability. Lower mortgage rates result in a lower monthly mortgage payment and buyers receiving more home for their dollar. Rising interest rates often require homebuyers to raise their down payment in order to maintain the same housing costs. The 30-year fixed rate mortgage according to Freddie Mac reached 7.79% for qualified buyers in October 2023, the highest rate since November 2000 (7.79%). As of July 9, 2026, it was at 6.49%. Elevated mortgage rates can price certain buyers out of the market, slow demand, and reduce home sales activity, while also causing a "lock- lower rates choose to stay in their current home. This can constrict inventory and keep prices high despite lower activity, creating affordability challenges. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 118 Workshop Packet Page Number 125 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSISCONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Increased mortgage rates negatively impact first-time buyers,in particular, as monthly pay- ments are higher which reduces purchasing power and forces potential buyers to delay pur- chase, seek smaller homes, or accept higher debt loads. Additionally, there is reduced activity -- priced homes, decreasing the number of options for entry level buyers. The following chart illustrates historical mortgage rate averages as compiled by Freddie Mac. The Freddie Mac Market Survey (PMMS) has been tracking mortgage rates since 1971 and is the most relied upon benchmark for evaluating mortgage interest market conditions. The Fred- die Mac survey is based on 30-year mortgages with a loan-to-value of 80%. Residential Construction and Development Costs The cost to build and develop new single-family housing has increased significantly over the past decade due to a number of factors, including rising costs (i.e. land, material, labor), a lack of construction labor, and increasing regulation and entitlement fees. As a result, affordable new construction. Based on information from the Craftsman National Building Cost Manual, construction costs in Maplewood(utilizing averages adjusted for St. Paul) likely average about $214per square foot --family home. Based on an average size of 2,000square feet, a new home would cost approximately $428,560to build. Most new con- struction homes in Maplewoodare selling for over $500,000 which is not affordable for house- holds with moderate incomes. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 119 Workshop Packet Page Number 126 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Additionally, it may be difficult to construct new multifamily product with modern amenities given market rents at older properties in the community relative to development costs. Ac- cording to the Craftsman National Building Cost Manual, construction costs in Maplewood likely average about $160 psf ing with ten or more units. Based on an average unit size of 850 square feet, a project would cost approximately $158,200 per unit to develop. Based on these costs, it may be difficult for a private developer to construct market rate rental housing and single-family homes that would be affordable to households with moderate in- comes. As a result, a private-public partnership or other financing programs may be needed to spur development and potentially reduce housing costs to bridge some of the gap between ex- isting older product and new product and keep prices affordable to local residents/workforce (i.e. tax abatement, Tax Increment Financing, funds through Workforce Housing Program from Minnesota Housing). Demographic & Employment Factors Senior population growth is projected in Maplewood, and the homeownership rate among sen- iors age 65 and older is relatively high. High homeownership rates among seniors suggests that there could be a lack of senior housing options available, or simply that many seniors prefer to live in their home and age in place. Because of the growing senior population, demand for maintenance-free housing products is rising. In addition, demand for home health care services and home remodeling programs to assist seniors with retrofitting their existing homes should also increase. There is an opportunity to attract younger households to Maplewood, housing projects tar- geted to these younger age groups should be pursued, notably moderately priced new con- struction single-family or townhomes. Additionally, the development of housing for older adults and seniors can help satisfy some of the demand from younger households through the turnover of existing, older housing units. Without the addition of these types of projects, young people who are ready to purchase may need to relocate out of the community if suitable hous- As highlighted previously, solid growth is projected between 2026 and 2050 across several age groups in the area. The 45 to 54 and 20 to 24 age cohorts are expected to experience the most rapid growth, while more moderate growth is projected across the other age groups, which are typically the target market for general occupancy rental and for-sale housing. Much of the demand for new housing units will be generated by turnover of existing house- holds in the community, although turnover often leads to opportunities for new households to move into the area. Population and household growth in the area will be highly dependent on the availability of suitable housing options catering to a variety of age groups, income levels, and household types. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 120 Workshop Packet Page Number 127 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Low unemployment often generates demand for both existing home purchases and new home purchases. Historically, unemployment rates in Maplewood and Ramsey County have tracked slightly higher than those of the Twin Cities Metro Area but have remained below the equilib- rium rate (generally considered to be 5.0%). Job counts in Maplewood have yet to fully get back to pre-COVID numbers, but the area is ex- pected to have strong employment growth over the coming years. Maplewood is projected to add 3,175 jobs between 2025 and 2030 (12.6% growth). Between 2030 and 2040 and 2040 and 2050, Maplewood is projected to add 1,500 (5.0% growth) and 2,100 jobs (6.6% growth), re- spectively. Labor availability will impact the ability of Maplewood to maintain employment lev- els and achieve projected job growth. New housing will be needed to support economic devel- opment in the area. Maplewood is an exporter of workers as a higher number of residents commute out of the City for employment than non-residents commute into the City. However, 13,582 people either commute into Maplewood for employment or live and work in the City. St. Paul, Minneapolis, and Woodbury are the most common commute destinations for workers employed in Maple- wood, while the most common destinations for workers living in Maplewood are St. Paul, Min- neapolis, Edina, Roseville. Inflow represents a potential target market for new housing in a community, particularly from workers that commute greater distances (i.e. 50+ miles). Roughly 6% of workers employed in Maplewood travel more than 50 miles for their job (850 workers). Additionally, potential job growth throughout the Twin Cities Metro Area could stimulate de- mand for housing in Maplewood. Workers could choose to commute to other communities within the Metro Area for employment and reside in Maplewood due to any number of factors, including lower housing costs and/or lifestyle preferences. Residential Lot Supply and Land Availability As of June 2026, there were eight actively-marketing lots scattered throughout the City. We did not identify any actively-marketing subdivisions in Maplewood as of June 2026, however the Century Ponds development will create 206 homes that will be made available for sale when fully complete. Based on the for-sale housing demand calculations through 2030, Century Ponds represents a 3.1-year supply of pending lots in Maplewood. Additional lots will need to be made available to meet long-term demand for new ownership housing in the City. Maplewood can benefit from and will likely need to create infill and redevelopment sites to meet housing demand. Existing sites served by municipal utilities are often overlooked because they can present challenges to develop (i.e. small lot sizes). However, infill housing develop- ment and redevelopment can be an effective way to create new housing that is consistent with the surrounding neighborhood and potentially removes functionally or physically obsolete housing units, replacing them with new housing. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 121 Workshop Packet Page Number 128 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Due, in part, to land constraints and the tight supply of several housing product types, Maple- wood is missing out on potential growth, losing some households to nearby communities that have more options available. With high demand for affordably priced housing, infill can create an opportunity to develop smaller homes on smaller lots that enhance and maintain the character of existing neighbor- hoods. However, infill housing can often be priced higher than surrounding homes due to costs related to the removal of an existing home and then its replacement with a new construction home. Assistance with demolition through redevelopment funding can reduce expenses and support more affordably priced housing. We recommend that the City target potential infill, adaptive reuse, and redevelopment sites for future housing developments. Additionally, opportunities to convert underutilized commercial and retail land into residential property should be explored. Development of these types of properties could potentially enhance the diversity of housing opportunities available in Maple- wood and improve housing affordability through reduced infrastructure costs and increased density. Housing Development Innovation Alternative construction methods such as modular construction, Structural Insulated Panel (SIP) construction, 3- tionally, unconventional housing concepts, such as accessory dwelling units, Community Land Trusts, and affordable housing cooperatives can also help produce affordable or workforce housing. An affordable housing cooperative provides a homeownership model where residents can pur- chase a share in the development and commit to resell their share at a price that maintains long-term affordability. In a housing cooperative, residents collectively own the building or land where they live, not the individual unit. Community Land Trusts (CLT) create affordable housing by taking the cost of land out of the purchase price of a home and keep housing affordable for future buyers by controlling the re- sale price of houses through a ground lease and resale formula. Multigenerational Housing When two or more adult generations (e.g. grandparents, parents, and children) live together under the same roof or on the same property, it is considered multigenerational housing. Sev- eral factors are contributing to the growing demand for multigenerational housing, including high housing costs, debt burdens, older adults living longer and caregiving/support needs, sin- gle-parent households, and lifestyle preferences. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 122 Workshop Packet Page Number 129 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Zoning & Other Regulatory Issues In many communities, restrictive zoning ordinances and other land use regulations can prevent innovation as well as the development of affordably priced housing units by limiting allowable density, regulating minimum lot sizes, and requiring that new homes meet minimum size and parking standards. We recommend that the City review land use regulations and look for opportunities to make amendments that would increase innovation and flexibility in the types and sizes of housing units allowable within certain districts in a manner that would decrease development costs, in- creasing affordability. The following summarizes some potential regulatory amendments that could be considered. - Revise single-family zoning to encourage the development of hous- ing, such as duplexes, triplexes, townhomes, and small multifamily buildings. - Reform development standards such as height restrictions, minimum parking re- quirements, minimum setbacks, minimum floor areas, and minimum lot sizes to al- low the construction of smaller, more affordable units. - Create opportunities for the creation of lower cost housing units on existing lots by allowing Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) and Single Room Occupancies (SROs). - Allow higher density housing in more areas of the community. - ment if a project complies with applicable ordinances and codes. There are legislative changes being considered to eliminate or change federal capital gains tax on primary homes sales. Under the current tax law, homeowners can exclude up to $250,000 in capital gains from the sale of a primary residence if they file as a single (up to $500,000 for married couples filing jointly). These caps have remained unchanged since 1997, and many homeowners, particularly older homeowners, have enough equity in their homes to exceed these caps. Due to the potential tax burden, many people choose to remain in their homes and delay a move, which limits housing turnover. The tax law changes being considered could re- sult in more homes being available on the market. Workforce/Moderate Income Housing As previously noted, workforce housing is generally considered to be housing that targets households earning between 50% and 120% AMI. Units are not income restricted but are priced at rates affordable to the local workforce. Workforce housing represents a critical housing-related opportunity, and challenge, for Maple- wood. The development of workforce housing, both owned and rented, is needed to attract and maintain employees. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 123 Workshop Packet Page Number 130 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Private businesses can partner with each other and with local units of government to help get new housing built. Generally, Employer-Assisted Housing (EAH) programs include any housing initiative that an employer either finances or assists in some way, and they are used to either produce new housing in a community or help employees purchase or rent housing. Examples include land donation, cash contributions, and construction financing. In some cases, employ- ers develop and own housing for their employees. Other methods include down payment assis- tance, closing cost assistance, gap financing, and rent subsidies. Local units of government can partner with EAH programs by offering TIF, tax abatement, or other housing resources. The development of workforce housing can be complex, and many communities ultimately lev- erage multiple tools and programs to achieve their housing goals. Public-private partnerships will likely be needed to help finance the development of workforce housing. Housing Programs Many local governments offer housing programs designed to enhance, improve, or develop new housing stock. The following information is intended to provide insight into available pro- grams, but this is not an all-inclusive list as many governmental agencies offer a variety of dif- ferent programs based on their individual needs. Federal funds for housing development have been declining for years and the remaining hous- ing programs include the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), the HOME Investment Partnerships Program, Housing Choice Vouchers, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC), and USDA rural housing programs. However, local units of government are increasingly dependent on other resources to support development such as housing trust funds and housing bonds. Local Resources: The City of Maplewood offers multiple resource programs that are available to both renters and homeowners in Maplewood. The Maplewood Home Improvement Program offers below-market fixed-rate loans between $5,000 and $40,000 to eligible owner-occupants for essential home improvements. Examples of eligible repairs include exterior repairs, energy-efficiency upgrades, and accessibility modifi- cations. Below is a list of other resources offered to homeowners: The Greater Metropolitan Housing Corporation (GMHC) helps homeowners find funding to fix their homes. The Home Repair Program provides volunteer-delivered safe and healthy housing re- pairs as well as subcontractor-delivered repair or replacement of essential systems. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 124 Workshop Packet Page Number 131 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Hearts and Hammers is a private non-profit organization that provides exterior painting and home improvement assistance for seniors and the physically disabled. Ramsey County FirstHome Down Payment Assistance Program assists first-time and first-generation homebuyers with low-to moderate incomes who are purchasing homes in suburban Ramsey County. Eligible buyers may purchase a home up to $372,600 and qualify for downpayment and closing costs assistance loans. Ramsey County has resources to help homeowners avoid foreclosure, access counseling, and find financial support. Ramsey County offers the Critical Repair Grant Program and the Residential Rehab De- ferred Loan Program to assist low- to moderate-income homeowners with home im- provements. Resources for renters and more detailed information on the programs and resources available to the City of Maplewood residents can be found using the link below. Resource Programs | Maplewood, MN The Metropolitan Council also offers funding and finance opportunities for housing projects. The Livable Communities Act program provides funding to clean up polluted sites for re- development, create affordable housing, and link different land uses with transporta- tion. This is a voluntary program that provides incentives that leverage partnerships and resources. The Pathways to Removing Obstacles (PRO) to Housing program is a HUD initiative de- signed to support communities taking steps to remove barriers to building and preserv- ing affordable housing. The Metropolitan Council, in partnership with Hennepin and Ramsey Counties, was awarded two grants to improve policy, award grants to imple- ment local policies, and build new deeply affordable housing. State/National Resources: Minnesota Housing Minnesota Housing is a housing finance agency whose mission is to finance affordable housing for low- and moderate-income households across Minnesota. Minnesota Housing partners with for-profit, non-profit, and gov- ernmental sectors to help develop and preserve affordable housing. The organization provides numerous products and services for both the single-family and multifamily housing sectors. The Statewide Affordable Housing Aid (SAHA) is a 2023 program that helps counties, Tribal nations, and greater Minnesota local governments develop and preserve afforda- ble housing. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 125 Workshop Packet Page Number 132 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Statewide Affordable Housing Aid will be paid directly to all counties, cities of the first, second, and third class (those with populations above 10,000). Cities in Greater Minne- sota that are under 10,000 in population, will be eligible to participate in a discretionary grant program administered by Minnesota Housing for grants of at least $25,000. Hous- ing developed or rehabilitated with funds under this program must be affordable to the local workforce. Qualifying projects include: - Emergency rental assistance for households earning less than 80% AMI - Financial support to nonprofit affordable housing providers - Construction, acquisition, rehabilitation, etc. for homeownership projects for households at 115% AMI and rental housing for households at 80% AMI, and - New construction or rehabilitation of a building containing more than four units. The Minnesota Affordable Housing Tax Credit (AHTC) and the Housing Tax Credit Contri- bution Account (HTCCA) offer a flexible fund that provides loans and grants to develop- ers for eligible housing projects. The fund is capitalized by contributions from taxpayers. Participating taxpayers receive a $0.85 credit for every dollar contributed to the Housing Tax Credit Contribution Account (minimum contribution of $1,000). - Eligible uses of funds include gap financing, new construction, acquisition, reha- bilitation, demolition, construction financing and permanent financing. Eligible awardees include a City, federally recognized American Indian tribe, tribal hous- ing corporation, private developer, non-profit organization, housing and redevel- opment authority, public housing authority, owner of the housing. The Economic Development and Housing Challenge funds the construction, purchase, financing, and redevelopment of single-family homes and multifamily rental properties with deferred loans. The program has a specific goal of enhancing economic develop- ment and is a primary resource for workforce housing. The Low- and Moderate-Income Rental Program (LMIR) provides long-term amortizing mortgage debt for multifamily rental housing affordable to low- and moderate-income households in Minnesota. Eligible activities include new construction, rehabilitation of existing affordable housing, adaptive reuse, preservation of affordable and/or federally assisted housing, and refinance of existing mortgages. The Workforce and Affordable Homeownership Development Program provides a one- time grant of up to $375,000 for the development of workforce and affordable home- ownership projects across Minnesota. Funds serve households up to 115% AMI, and may be used for residential housing development, rehabilitation, land development, in- frastructure development, and repair for manufactured home parks. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 126 Workshop Packet Page Number 133 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS The Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) program, which is administered by Minne- sota Housing, incentivizes developers to create and maintain affordable housing by of- fering tax credits which provide investors with a reduction in their federal tax liability. Eligible projects include new construction, rehabilitation, or acquisition with rehabilita- tion of rental housing. Greater Minnesota Housing Fund preserves, and creates affordable housing in Minnesota, addressing housing needs in under- served areas, including cities, towns, rural areas, and Tribal nations. The GMHF provides nu- merous programs, financing mechanisms, technical support, and research to support produc- tion of affordable housing. The Revolving Development Loan Fund awards development loans to create or preserve affordable homes throughout Minnesota. Minnesota Equity Fund raises equity capital from corporations and banks to invest in sustainable affordable housing developments, including workforce housing, low-income senior housing, mixed-use and mixed-income housing, and supportive housing. The NOAH Impact Fund finances the acquisition and preservation of naturally occurring affordable rental housing to preserve the long-term affordability of rental units at risk of conversion to higher rents. Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development MN DEED is the Admin- istrator for federal Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds via the Community De- velopment Small Cities Development Program which helps cities, townships, and counties with funding for housing, public infrastructure and commercial rehabilitation projects. Cities with fewer than 50,000 residents, townships and counties with fewer than 200,000 residents are eli- gible for the Small Cities Development Program. Projects must meet one of three federal objectives, including benefit people of low and moder- ate incomes, eliminate slum and blight conditions, or eliminate an urgent threat to public health or safety. Housing grant funds are awarded to local units of government, which then lend funds to rehabilitate the local housing stock. Loans may be used for owner-occupied, rental, single-family or multifamily housing rehabilitation. In all cases, housing funds must ben- efit low- and moderate-income households. Additionally, public facility grants are directed to- ward wastewater treatment projects. For CDBG funding, low income is defined as households at 50% AMI or lower while moderate income is defined as households at 80% AMI or lower. Income limits vary by household size, but an estimated 47% of all households in Maplewood have incomes below $84,160 (income limit for a two-person household at 80% AMI), including 75% of all renter households and 33% of all owner households. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 127 Workshop Packet Page Number 134 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS This data indicates that a large portion of Maplewood households would income-qualify for projects utilizing CDBG funds, and we recommend that the City pursue Small Cities Develop- ment Program housing grants from MN DEED to help serve low- and moderate-income house- holds in the community. Minnesota Housing Partnership opment capacity and promotes systems change to expand opportunity, especially for those with the greatest need. They support a diversity of partners to stimulate innovation and drive positive impact in affordable housing and community development in Minnesota and beyond. MHP has expertise in single and multifamily housing, as well as special needs projects, including supportive, transitional and culturally relevant housing. Other Potential Resources There are many other housing programs that Maplewood could consider utilizing to aid and im- prove the housing stock. The following is a list of potential programs that could be explored. - Accessory Dwelling Units - An Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) is a self-contained residen- tial unit that meets the requirements of the State Building Code. These units, often re- building on the lot or may be located in a detached accessory building on the same lot. Cities within the County could consider allowing ADUs in residential zoning districts to increase the variety of housing types available in the City. - Construction Management Services - Assist homeowners regarding local building codes, reviewing contractor bids, etc. Typically provided as a service by the building depart- ment. This type of service could also be rolled into various remodeling related pro- grams. - Density Bonuses - Since the cost of land is a significant barrier to housing affordability, increasing densities can result in lower housing costs by reducing the land costs per unit. Municipalities can offer density bonuses as a way to encourage higher-density residen- tial development while also promoting an affordable housing component. - Fast Track Permitting - Program designed to reduce delays during the development pro- cess that ultimately add to the total costs of housing development. By expediting the permitting process costs can be reduced to developers while providing certainty into the development process. Typically, no-cost to the local government jurisdiction. - First-Time Home Buyers - Below market-rate mortgage loans for first-time homebuyers, or those who have not owned a home in the past three years. Financial assistance may also be available for down payment, closing costs, and principal reduction. Usually sub- ject to income guidelines, purchase price limits, and eligible property. Some cities part- ner with a 3rd party. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 128 Workshop Packet Page Number 135 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS - Historic Preservation - Encourage residents to preserve historic housing stock in neigh- borhoods with homes with character through restoring and preserving architectural and building characteristics. Typically funded with low interest rates on loans for preserva- tion construction costs. - Home Improvement Area (HIA) - HIAs allow a townhome or condo association low inter- est loans to finance improvements to communal areas. Unit owners repay the loan through fees imposed on the property, usually through property taxes. Typically, a "last resort" tool when associations are unable to obtain traditional financing due to the loss of equity from the real estate market or deferred maintenance on older properties. - Home-Building Trades Partnerships - Partnership between local Technical Colleges or High Schools that offer building trades programs. Affordability is gained through re- duced labor costs provided by the school. - Home Point of Sale - City ordinance requiring an inspection prior to the sale or transfer of residential real estate. The inspection is intended to prevent adverse conditions and meet minimum building codes. Sellers are responsible for any costs for the inspection. - Housing Fair - Free seminars and advice for homeowners related to remodeling and home improvements. Most housing fairs offer educational seminars and "ask the ex- pert" consulting services. Exhibitors include architects, landscapers, building contrac- tors, home products, city inspectors, financial services, among others. - Home Energy Loans Offer low interest home energy loans to make energy improve- ments in their homes. - Household and Outside Maintenance for the Elderly (H.O.M.E.) - Persons 60 and over receive homemaker and maintenance services. Typical services include house cleaning, grocery shopping, yard work/lawn care, and other miscellaneous maintenance requests. - Land Trust - Utilizing a long-term 99-year ground lease, housing is affordable as the land is owned by a non-profit organization. Subject to income limits and targeted to work- force families with low-to-moderate incomes. If the family chooses to sell their home, the selling price is lower as land is excluded. - Live Where You Work - Program designed to promote homeownership in the same com- munity where employees work. City provides a grant to eligible employees to purchase a home near their workplace. Employers can also contribute or match the City's grant. Participants must obtain a first mortgage through participating lenders. The grant can be allocated towards down payment assistance, closing costs, and gap financing. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 129 Workshop Packet Page Number 136 of 253 E1, Attachment 1 MAPLEWOOD HOUSING NEEDS ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS - Low or No Cost City/County-Supplied Land - Sell city/county-owned land at low/no cost for the construction of mixed-income and affordable housing. - Realtor Forum - Typically administered by City with partnership by local school board. Inform local Realtors about school district news, current development projects, and other marketing factors related to real estate in the community. In addition, Realtors usually receive CE credits. - Remodeling Tours - City-driven home remodeling tour intended to promote the en- hancement of the housing stock through home renovations/additions. Homeowners open their homes to the public to highlight home improvements. - Rent to Own - Income-eligible families rent for a specified length of time with the end- goal of buying a home. The administering agency saves a portion of the monthly rent that will be allocated for a down payment on a future house. - Scattered Site Housing Program - Target distressed or blighted single-family properties for demolition and rehabilitation. Once demolished, vacant lots can be sold for the con- struction of a new single-family home. - Tax Abatement - A temporary reduction in property taxes over a specific time period on new construction homes or home remodeling projects. Encourages new construction or rehabilitation through property tax incentives. - Tax Increment Financing (TIF) - Program that offers communities a flexible financing tool to assist housing development projects and related infrastructure. TIF enables commu- nities to dedicate the incremental tax revenues from new housing development to help make the housing more affordable or pay for related costs. TIF funds can be used to provide a direct subsidy to a particular housing project or they can also be used to promote affordable housing by setting aside a portion of TIF pro- ceeds into a dedicated fund from other developments receiving TIF. - Visitability - Defined as designs that allow persons with mobility impairments to enter and stay, but not live, in a residence. There are three specific design elements that must be incorporated in the dwelling to satisfy the State visitability requirements: the dwell- ing must include at least one no-step entrance, 32-inch clear opening doorways, and at least a one-half bathroom on the main level that meets minimum clear floor space for half baths. - Waiver or Reduction of Development Fees - There are several fees developers must pay including impact fees, utility and connection fees, park land dedication fees, etc. To help facilitate affordable housing, some fees could be waived or reduced to pass the cost savings onto the housing consumer. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 130 Workshop Packet Page Number 137 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 CommercialReal EstateDemand Analysis forthe City of Maplewood, Minnesota Prepared for: City of Maplewood Maplewood, Minnesota July2026 901 Twelve Oaks Center Drive Suite 922 Wayzata, MN 55391 612.338.0012 www.maxfieldresearch.com Workshop Packet Page Number 138 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 July 31, 2026 Ms. Danette Parr Community Development Director City of Maplewood 1830 County Rd B East Maplewood, MN55109 Ms. Parr: The scope of this study includes an analysis of the demographic and economic characteristics of the area, employment and business growth trends, information on commercial real estate (hotel, retail, office) market conditions, and available land for future development. Detailed demand calculations to 2050 are provided for hotel rooms, retail space, and office space. Additionally, the report provides an evaluation of multiple sites in Maplewood that could be targeted for infillor redevelopment, and recommendations are provided on the types of real estate product typesthat would be most suitable on those sites. We appreciate the opportunity to complete this market analysis and are available should you have any questions or need additional information. Sincerely, MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING Nathan RossJoe Hollman ResearchAssociateDirector of Research Attachment (main) 612-338-0012 (fax) 612-904-7979 901 Twelve Oaks Center Drive, Suite 922, Wayzata, MN 55391 www.maxfieldresearch.com Workshop Packet Page Number 139 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .......................................................................................................... 1 PURPOSE AND SCOPE ............................................................................................................ 7 DEMOGRAPHIC REVIEW ........................................................................................................ 8 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 8 Population and Household Growth Trends ...................................................................... 10 Population Age Distribution .............................................................................................. 12 Incomes ............................................................................................................................. 15 Occupation ........................................................................................................................ 18 Educational Attainment .................................................................................................... 20 Consumer Expenditure Patterns ....................................................................................... 21 EMPLOYMENT ....................................................................................................................... 24 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 24 Resident Employment ....................................................................................................... 25 Commuting Patterns ......................................................................................................... 26 Employment Growth Trends ............................................................................................. 29 Industry Employment and Wage Data .............................................................................. 34 Business Expansions .......................................................................................................... 37 Major Employers ............................................................................................................... 38 MARKET TRENDS ........................................................................................................ 39 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 39 Nonresidential Building Permit Trends ............................................................................. 40 Hospitality Market Overview ............................................................................................ 42 Selected Competitive Hotel Properties ............................................................................. 47 Metro Area Commercial Real Estate Market Overview .................................................... 56 Maplewood Commercial Real Estate Market Overview ................................................... 60 Maplewood Retail Market Conditions .............................................................................. 61 Retail Sales Trends ............................................................................................................ 65 Maplewood Office Market Conditions.............................................................................. 69 Office-Using Business Growth by Type of Business .......................................................... 73 Pending Commercial Developments ................................................................................. 76 Actively-Marketing Commercial Land Sites ...................................................................... 78 DEMAND ESTIMATES .................................................................................................. 80 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 80 Calculation of Hotel Room Demand ................................................................................. 81 Retail Development Potential ........................................................................................... 82 Office Development Potential .......................................................................................... 83 Workshop Packet Page Number 140 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Title Page SITE EVALUATION ....................................................................................................... 86 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 86 Site Overview .................................................................................................................... 87 Site Evaluation Summary & Recommendations ............................................................... 97 CONCLUSIONS ....................................................................................................................... 102 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 102 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 102 Redevelopment Node Opportunities ................................................................................ 104 Job Creation ....................................................................................................................... 105 Target Industries ................................................................................................................ 106 Economic Development Initiatives .................................................................................... 109 Workshop Packet Page Number 141 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 LIST OF TABLES Table Number and Title Page Table 1 Population and Household Growth Trends and Projections ...................................... 11 Table 2 Population Age Distribution ........................................................................................ 14 Table 3 Household Income by Age of Householder, City of Maplewood ............................... 16 Table 4 Household Income by Age of Householder, Ramsey County ..................................... 17 Table 5 Occupation .................................................................................................................. 19 Table 6 Educational Attainment .............................................................................................. 20 Table 7 Estimated Household Expenditures by Selected Product Type .................................. 22 Table 8 Labor Force and Resident Employment Trends .......................................................... 25 Table 9 Commuting Inflow/Outflow Characteristics ............................................................... 27 Table 10 Commuting Patterns ................................................................................................... 29 Table 11 Employment Growth Trends and Projections ............................................................ 30 Table 12 Employment Growth Trends and Projections Office Sectors .................................. 32 Table 13 Industry Employment Trends ..................................................................................... 35 Table 14 Average Weekly Wages .............................................................................................. 36 Table 15 Recent Business Expansions ....................................................................................... 37 Table 16 Major Employers ......................................................................................................... 38 Table 17 Nonresidential Building Permit Trends ....................................................................... 40 Table 18 Minneapolis Area Hospitalilty Market Performance Trends ...................................... 44 Table 19 Hospitality Market Performance, St. Paul Submarket by Segment ............................ 46 Table 20 Select Hotel Properties ............................................................................................... 47 Table 21 Summary of Key Metrics ............................................................................................. 50 Table 22 Day of the Week Analysis ........................................................................................... 54 Table 23 Commercial Real Estate Market Trends ..................................................................... 56 Table 24 Maplewood Trade Area Retail Inventory by Community ........................................... 62 Table 25 Retail Sales Growth ..................................................................................................... 65 Table 26 Retail Sales Trends by Industry Sector ........................................................................ 67 Table 27 Maplewood Trade Area Office Inventory by Community .......................................... 70 Table 28 Office-Using Business Growth by Type of Business .................................................... 73 Table 29 Pending Commercial Developments, Maplewood Trade Area .................................. 77 Table 30 Hotel Demand Estimates ............................................................................................ 81 Table 31 Demand for Retail Space............................................................................................. 83 Table 32 Demand for Office Space ............................................................................................ 84 Table 33 Development/Redevelopment Sites ........................................................................... 88 Table 34 Potential Job Creation ............................................................................................... 105 Table 35 Employment Projections by Industry........................................................................ 107 Table 36 High Growth/High Pay Job Growth Projections ....................................................... 108 Workshop Packet Page Number 142 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Introduction This summary presents the principal findings from the commercial real estate demand analysis for Maplewood, Minnesota. The analysis evaluates demographic and household growth, income and consumer spending patterns, employment and commuting trends, local and regional market conditions. The study concludes with demand calculations for hotel rooms, retail space, and office space through 2050 along with an evaluation of sites and nodes targeted for potential development, redevelopment, or infill. Overall, the findings indicate that Maplewood is positioned for continued commercial demand, supported by household growth, strengthening consumer expenditures, a large employment base, very low reported vacancy among available retail and office listings, and measurable long- term demand for new commercial development. Key Findings Population and household growth will continue to support commercial demand. Maplewood is forecast to add 3,045 people and 1,682 households between 2026 and 2050, representing population growth of 7% and household growth of 10%. This growth will increase demand for neighborhood-oriented retail, services, medical care, hospitality, and other commercial uses. Income growth and consumer spending provide a positive demand foundation. 2026 median household income is estimated at $90,028, above Ramsey County but below the Metro Area. Median income is projected to increase 11% by 2030, while households earning $100,000 or more are projected to increase 14%. Maplewood residents are expected to spend $478 million on retail goods and services in 2026, with average annual consumer expenditures projected to rise 11.5% by 2030. The workforce base is expected to expand over the long term. workforce population, ages 20 to 64, contracted slightly between 2020 and 2026 but is projected to grow 13.8% by 2050. This trend supports future labor availability and reinforces esses, and office users. Employment projections point to renewed job growth. Maplewood had 25,125 jobs in 2025, representing 8% of Ramsey County employment. Although total employment declined between 2010 and 2025, the Metropolitan Council forecasts Maplewood will add 6,775 jobs by 2050, a 27% increase that exceeds projected growth in both Ramsey County and the Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 1 Workshop Packet Page Number 143 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Office-using employment is a major long-term demand driver. Office-using jobs accounted for nearly 48% of Maplewood employment in 2025. While these sectors declined over the past 15 years, Maplewood is projected to add 3,761 office-using jobs by 2050, a 31.4% increase. This growth materially supports future demand for office and medical office space. Demand Summary Demographic and Economic Demand Drivers has slowed since 2020, long-term projections indicate continued expansion. Household growth is particularly important because it directly influences local spending patterns, service needs, and the supportable amount of retail and commercial space. By 2050, Maplewood is expected to support 1,682 additional households, creating sustained demand for neighborhood-serving retail, restaurants, personal services, health care, and other commercial uses. Age distribution trends also influence commercial opportunity. Seniors age 65 and older account for roughly one- continue to support demand for medical services, wellness, pharmacy, personal care, and convenience-oriented retail. At the same time, growth among working-age residents and households with higher incomes will support demand for professional services, restaurants, fitness, specialty retail, and other discretionary spending categories. Income trends are favorable relative to the County and supportive of future commercial higher than Ramsey County, and is projected to approach $100,000 by 2030. While per capita income remains below the Metro Area, growth in higher-income households is expected to be MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 2 Workshop Packet Page Number 144 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY strongest, with households earning $100,000 or more increasing by approximately 1,051 households between 2026 and 2030. These income gains are expected to translate into stronger purchasing power and expanded demand for local goods and services. Employment, Commuting, and Business Conditions 21,509 in 2025, while resident employment was 20,607, resulting in a 4.2% unemployment e Metro labor force and resident employment increased slightly, indicating stabilization following pandemic-related job losses. residential community within the regional economy. Approximately 12,628 workers commute into Maplewood daily, while 17,540 residents commute out of the City for employment. Roughly 93% of jobs in Maplewood are filled by workers who live outside the City, creating a meaningful daytime population that supports local restaurants, retail stores, convenience services, and other commercial establishments. Services is the largest employment sector in Maplewood, followed by Education and Health Services and Trade, Transportation and Utilities. Combined, the ten largest employers account for approximately 9,926 workers, or about 40% of Maplewood jobs. This concentration and remains an important competitive advantage for business attraction, office demand, and lodging activity. Market Conditions and Development Activity From 2016 through May 2026, the City issued 98 nonresidential building permits totaling approximately $445 million in value. Nearly half of the permits were for remodels, while 28% were for new buildings and 26% were for additions. Commercial permits represented the majority of permit activity, while public and institutional projects accounted for the largest and institutional building stock, with modernization and reinvestment activity complementing new construction. Regional retail market conditions are comparatively stable, while the office market remains more uneven. In the Metro Area, retail vacancies were 7.7% in the first quarter of 2026, while office vacancies were 21.0%. The Northeast Submarket, which includes much of Maplewood, outperformed the broader Metro Area, with lower combined vacancy and stronger office fundamentals. Retail vacancy in the Northeast Submarket was 7.8% in early 2026, while office vacancy declined to 6.0%, reflecting a tighter office environment than the broader Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 3 Workshop Packet Page Number 145 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Within Maplewood, available commercial space appears limited based on current listings. The City contains approximately 11.7 million square feet of commercial real estate across 290 properties, including 4.2 million square feet of retail space and 7.5 million square feet of office space. As of June 2026, listed retail vacancy totaled 49,772 square feet (1.2% vacancy) while listed office vacancy totaled 22,457 square feet (0.3% vacancy). These figures indicate a tight leasing environment for tenants seeking space in Maplewood. Hospitality Demand Outlook The lodging market in Maplewood and the surrounding trade area has strengthened materially since 2021. Room supply was stable during the survey period, while demand increased 30%, from 321,770 room nights sold in 2021 to 419,653 in 2025. Occupancy increased from 49.3% in 2021 to 63.3% in 2025, and average daily rate increased 16% over the same period. RevPAR rose 49%, while total hotel revenue increased from $30.6 million to $46.2 million. These performance improvements indicate a recovering and increasingly stable hospitality market. Occupancy, ADR, and RevPAR are highest on Fridays and Saturdays, reflecting strong leisure-oriented demand, while midweek performance indicates that business travel also contributes to room-night demand. Seasonal trends show occupancy peaking during the summer and softening during winter, which is typical of the local lodging market. Demand estimates indicate support for additional lodging supply. Assuming annual room-night demand grows 2.0% between 2026 and 2050 and supply holds steady, the trade area would need 138 additional rooms by 2030, 566 rooms by 2040, and 1,087 rooms by 2050 to maintain equilibrium (65% occupancy rate). These findings indicate sufficient market support for a new hotel development in Maplewood, particularly if positioned to capture both leisure travelers and commercial demand generated by major employers, medical uses, regional retail, and nearby activity centers. Retail Demand Outlook 4.2 million square feet across 184 properties, with only 49,772 square feet listed for lease as of June 2026. This equates to a listed vacancy rate of 1.2%, lower than the broader trade area. $24.89 per square foot, which is above the trade area average of $19.37 per square foot. The combination of low vacancy and stronger rents indicates a tight retail market with limited available space for expansion or new tenants. Retail sales trends further support additional retail demand. Gross retail sales in Maplewood retail establishment reached $6.4 million in Maplewood, well above the Metro Area average of $3.9 million. Although the number of retail establishments declined modestly, average sales per establishment increased. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 4 Workshop Packet Page Number 146 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY We estimate demand for 281,086 square feet of new retail space in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050, equal to approximately 11,712 square feet annually. Based on a typical retail floor area ratio of 0.20, this demand would require approximately 32 acres of land by 2050, or about 1.3 acres of annual land absorption. The strongest opportunities are likely to be neighborhood- and community-serving uses, including food and beverage, services, restaurants, convenience retail, fitness, and specialty retail. Additional demand could be supported if Maplewood attracts destination-oriented retailers capable of drawing customers from a broader trade area. Office Demand Outlook unique because much of the inventory is concentrated in corporate facilities, which account for approximately 83% of total square footage. Medical and dental properties also represent an important component of the office market. Listed office vacancy in Maplewood was only 0.3% as of June 2026, with 22,457 square feet available across 11 listings. Office lease rates in Maplewood ranged from $9.00 to $23.02 per square foot, averaging $15.55 per square foot, generally consistent with the broader trade area. Business growth data suggests that future office demand will be strongest among smaller users, particularly in health care and social assistance. The number of office-using businesses in Maplewood increased 5% from 2019 to 2023, with the strongest growth in Health Care and Social Assistance and Finance and Insurance. More than half of office-using businesses have fewer than five employees, and 22% have between five and nine employees, indicating demand for smaller suites, flexible office layouts, medical office space, and service-oriented professional office space. The office demand analysis estimates excess demand for 780,408 square feet of new office space in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050, equal to approximately 32,517 square feet annually. Based on a typical office floor area ratio of 0.30, this level of demand would require approximately 60 acres of land by 2050, or about 2.5 acres of annual land absorption. While the broader office market continues to face structural challenges from remote work and changing jected office-using employment growth, and health care-oriented business expansion suggest that well-located, modern, smaller-scale, and medical office formats will be best positioned to meet demand. Land Supply and Development Implications The analysis identified 21 commercial land listings in the trade area totaling 139.6 acres, including five sites in Maplewood totaling 46.8 acres. Average listed pricing was approximately $852,132 per site, $288,126 per acre, or $6.61 per square foot. Mapl supply provides capacity for some commercial development, but long-term demand estimates for retail and office uses alone imply substantial land absorption needs by 2050. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 147 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Overall Conclusions Maplewood is positioned to support additional commercial real estate development over the long term. The strongest demand indicators include continued household growth, rising incomes, expanding consumer expenditures, a growing workforce population, projected job growth, low listed retail and office vacancy, strengthening lodging fundamentals, and an established base of major employers. These conditions collectively support demand for additional hotel rooms, retail space, and office space through 2050. The most immediate opportunities appear to be in service-oriented retail, food and beverage, convenience uses, medical office, small professional office suites, and hospitality. Longer-term opportunities will depend on continued population and employment growth, successful absorption of pending projects, and the availability of well-located sites that can accommodate constraints if suitable space is not delivered or repositioned. Strategic redevelopment, adaptive reuse, and targeted infill development will be important tools for capturing demand while making efficient use of available land. Overall, the analysis supports a positive but disciplined development outlook. Maplewood has sufficient demand to justify new commercial investment, but the most successful projects will be those that align with demonstrated market needs: smaller and flexible office space, medical and health-related uses, neighborhood-oriented and service retail, selective restaurant and food concepts, and lodging that can capture both leisure and business demand. Development should be prioritized in locations with strong access, visibility, proximity to employment, and the ability to serve both residents and daytime workers. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 6 Workshop Packet Page Number 148 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS PURPOSE AND SCOPE Purpose and Scope Maxfield Research and Consulting was engaged by the City of Maplewood to prepare a Commercial Real Estate Demand Analysis for the community. The scope of this study includes an analysis of the demographic and economic characteristics of the area, employment and business growth trends, information on commercial real estate (hotel, retail, office) market conditions, and available land for future development. Detailed demand calculations to 2050 are provided for hotel rooms, retail space, and office space. The study concludes with an evaluation of sites identified by the Client as potential locations for future development, redevelopment, and infill. Methodology This report includes both primary and secondary research. Secondary research, which is credited to the source when used, is always used as a basis for analysis and is carefully considered along with other factors that may impact projections. Secondary data resources include: ESRI (a nationally recognized demographic services firm) Kalibri Labs LLC Minnesota Commercial Association of Real Estate/Realtors (MNCAR) Minnesota Department of Administration (DOA) State Demographic Center Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development Minnesota Department of Revenue Minnesota Department of Transportation Metropolitan Council Ramsey County Real Estate Data, Inc. Commercial Real Estate (REDI CRE) United States Census Bureau (Decennial Census, American Community Survey, County Business Patterns, Local Employment Dynamics). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 7 Workshop Packet Page Number 149 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Demographic Review Introduction Demand for commercial real estate is impacted by shifting demographic and economic trends. This section of the report examines demographic characteristics of Maplewood and its surrounding trade area, including: Population and household growth trends and projections Age distribution of the population Household income distribution Occupation of area residents Educational attainment of the population, and Consumer expenditures. Data sources utilized for this analysis include ESRI, a nationally recognized demographic services firm, Minnesota Department of Administration (DOA) State Demographic Center, the Metropolitan Council, the U.S Census Bureau Decennial Census, and the U.S. Census Bureau . The following map illustrates the location of Maplewood within Ramsey County along with its regional location in the Seven County Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 8 Workshop Packet Page Number 150 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIALREAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHICTRENDS The City of Maplewood MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING9 Workshop Packet Page Number 151 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIALREAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHICTRENDS Population and Household Growth Trends The table on the following page presents population and household growth trends in the City of Maplewood from 2010 to 2050. The 2010 and 2020 figures are from the United States Census. Estimates for 2026 are based on a review of population and household estimates provided by the MinnesotaState Demographer, Metropolitan Council, ESRI, and the ACS, with adjustments made by Maxfield Research based on recent residential development activity to reflect current year data. Maxfield Research arrived at the 2030, 2040, and 2050 projections based on a review of forecasts published by the Metropolitan Council. The following graph depicts historical population growth trends in Maplewood over the past growth since the 1960s. Historically, Maplewood averaged 1.3% population growth on an annual basis. We estimate that the pace population growth in Maplewood slowed post-COVID, averaging 0.3% average annual growth between 2020 and 2026. the household base increased by 7% (1,112 households). By comparison, the population increased by 9% in Ramsey County and 11% in the Metro Area, while the household base expanded8% in Ramsey County and 11% in the Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING10 Workshop Packet Page Number 152 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Table 1 We estimate that growth has slowed slightly since 2020, with Maplewood adding 667 people (1.6% growth) and 424 households (2.6% growth) between 2020 and 2026. Ramsey County gained 4,795 people (0.9%) and 5,876 households (2.7%), and the Metro Area experienced 4.0% population growth and 5.7% household growth from 2020 to 2026. growth increase by 8% against 12% household growth during that same time period. Additional commercial goods and services will be needed to support the expanding population and household base in the trade area over the next several years. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 11 Workshop Packet Page Number 153 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIALREAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHICTRENDS Population Age Distribution goods and services needed. For example, the need for medical services increases for older people, while middle-aged people often demand services such as real estate and financial advice. Younger people typically seek retail services such as entertainment, electronics, and workforce trends which will influence demand for commercial real estate. As the size of the workforce population changes over time, the availability of labor also changes. The following table presents the age distribution of the City of Maplewood population from 2010 to 2050. Information from 2010 and 2020 is sourced from the U.S. Census. The 2026 estimates and projections for 2030were provided by ESRI, with adjustments made by Maxfield Research to reflect current information. The 2050 projections are based on data provided by the Minnesota DOA and the Minnesota State Demographer, adjusted by Maxfield Research to reflect the local2050 population forecasts. Those under the age of 20 represent the largest share of the population in Maplewood (25%), followed by the 25 to 34 and the 35 to 44 age groups, eachat 14%of the total population population, while seniors age65 years or older account for 20%. Among the adult population, those ages 25 to 34 are the largest cohort in Ramsey County (14.8% of the population), followed by the 35 to 44 age group (14.2%). In the Metro Area, age 35 to 44 is the largest cohort (14.5%). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING12 Workshop Packet Page Number 154 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIALREAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHICTRENDS The fastest population growth occurredamong the 65 to 74 age group, as aging of baby boomers led to a substantial increase between 2010 and 2026, increasing 82% in Maplewood, 83% in Ramsey County, and 99% in the Metro Area. As this group ages, the 75 and older age group is expected to increase 11.3% in Maplewoodbetween 2026 and 2040, before flattening to0.1% growth between 2040 and 2050. Maplewood is also expected to experience solid growth among people age 45 to 54, adding 1,266people between 2026 and 2050 (29% growth). Proximity to labor is increasing in importance for companies seeking new locations. primary workforce population (age 20 to 64), which contracted -1.1% between 2020 and 2026 (-272), is projected to expand 13.8% (3,261 people) by 2050. increase 10.1% between 2026 and 2050, while the Metro Area experiences 15.4% workforce population growth during that time period. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING13 Workshop Packet Page Number 155 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Table 2 POPULATION AGE DISTRIBUTION 2010 - 2050 Change CensusEstimateProjection2010-20262026-2050 Age20102020202620302050No.Pct.No.Pct. MAPLEWOOD Under-209,69110,52110,43610,35610,2657457.7-171-1.6 20 to 242,4482,5232,4182,3442,936-30-1.251821.4 25 to 345,0495,9915,8165,2926,37676715.25619.6 35 to 444,5034,9705,9286,1206,1751,42531.72474.2 45 to 545,9154,5594,3275,0815,593-1,588-26.81,26629.2 55 to 644,6175,8245,1064,4475,77548910.666913.1 65 to 742,6274,2664,7894,9164,2972,16282.3-493-10.3 75+3,1683,4343,9344,6464,38276624.244811.4 Total38,01842,08842,75543,20045,8004,73712.53,0457.1 RAMSEY COUNTY Under-20135,728141,217137,826132,721135,1382,0981.5-2,688-2.0 20 to 2444,19441,73241,59843,51438,657-2,596-5.9-2,940-7.1 25 to 3477,11988,07882,53776,87183,9425,4187.01,4051.7 35 to 4460,93370,96679,15879,30581,29118,22529.92,1342.7 45 to 5470,57059,29259,41567,42573,629-11,155-15.814,21523.9 55 to 6458,91566,03558,30153,59776,029-614-1.017,72830.4 65 to 7430,35150,20355,70954,88456,56325,35883.58551.5 75+30,83034,82942,60452,02757,68411,77438.215,07935.4 Total508,640552,352557,147560,343602,93448,5079.545,7878.2 METRO AREA Under-20774,287807,770807,338795,755856,57333,0514.349,2346.1 20 to 24190,135204,447220,720225,091213,23630,58516.1-7,484-3.4 25 to 34420,311461,046453,810457,238495,73433,4998.041,9249.2 35 to 44391,324433,214476,280471,984543,79684,95621.767,51614.2 45 to 54440,753383,578387,016432,974509,088-53,737-12.2122,07231.5 55 to 64326,007407,524380,637353,143451,23254,63016.870,59518.5 65 to 74163,425280,318325,461340,760350,931162,03699.225,4707.8 75+143,325185,207238,440297,155393,41195,11566.4154,97165.0 Total2,849,5673,163,1043,289,7023,374,1003,814,000440,13515.4524,29815.9 Sources: US Census; ESRI; MN State Demographic Center; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 14 Workshop Packet Page Number 156 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIALREAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHICTRENDS Incomes The following information summarizesdata on household income by age of householderand per capita incomefor Maplewood and Ramsey County in 2026 and 2030. The data was estimated and projected by Maxfield Research and Consulting based on income trends provided by ESRI Inc. Income data is useful in that it can reflect wage trends, helps assess living conditions, and reveals demand for various commercial goodsand services. As illustrated in the following chart, household incomes tend to peak in their late 40s to early 50s. The 45 to 54 age group has the highest estimated incomes at $132,047 in Maplewood, $116,111 in Ramsey County, and $139,710 in the Metro Area. In 2026, the median household income in Maplewood is estimated to be $90,028, 10% higher than Ramsey County ($81,619) but-13% lower than the Metro Area ($102,599). By 2030, median household incomes are projected to increase 11% in Maplewood ($99,509), 10% in Ramsey County($89,710), and 9% in the Metro Area($111,545). Household growth is projected to be strongest among the highest income brackets, as the total number of households with incomes of $100,000 or higher increases 14% (1,051 households) in Maplewood and 15% in Ramsey County (13,620households). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING15 Workshop Packet Page Number 157 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Table 3 HOUSEHOLD INCOME BY AGE OF HOUSEHOLDER CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2026 - 2030 Age of Householder TotalUnder 2525 - 3435 - 4445 - 5455 - 6465 - 7475+ 2026 Less than $15,0001,0928519313107116109469 $15,000 to $24,9998534176551167225288 $25,000 to $34,9999433658114021246262 $35,000 to $49,9991,40937162173111286402236 $50,000 to $74,9992,615134258291418416401697 $75,000 to $99,9991,96143397422139294240424 $100,000 to $149,9993,889307391,069525827536163 $150,000 to $199,9991,8016295388567150260135 $200,000+1,85659344546744130599 Total16,4184182,2712,9702,3362,9072,9422,573 Median Income$90,028$51,929$99,264$113,025$132,047$96,181$65,864$57,134 2030 Less than $15,0001,02474166151019198480 $15,000 to $24,9997354160500111188284 $25,000 to $34,999808384386215041970 $35,000 to $49,9991,24034120161104222343256 $50,000 to $74,9992,476143210258401310372782 $75,000 to $99,9991,82141338356141224223498 $100,000 to $149,9994,037326931,114628742591236 $150,000 to $199,9992,05910292419673153309202 $200,000+2,5006124563663513432200 Total16,7004192,0473,0222,7132,5152,9763,008 Median Income$99,509$54,091$103,030$118,043$144,188$104,654$78,266$60,852 Change - 2026 to 2030 Less than $15,000-68-11-271-6-25-1211 $15,000 to $24,999-119-1-16-5-1-56-37-4 $25,000 to $34,999-1352-15-272-62-438 $35,000 to $49,999-168-3-42-12-7-64-5920 $50,000 to $74,999-1398-48-33-17-106-2986 $75,000 to $99,999-140-3-59-662-70-1874 $100,000 to $149,9991482-4645103-855573 $150,000 to $199,9992584-33110734967 $200,000+64513111819572126101 Total2821-22552377-39233435 Median Income$9,481$2,162$3,766$5,018$12,141$8,473$12,402$3,718 Sources: ESRI; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 16 Workshop Packet Page Number 158 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Table 4 HOUSEHOLD INCOME BY AGE OF HOUSEHOLDER RAMSEY COUNTY 2026 - 2030 Age of Householder TotalUnder 2525 - 3435 - 4445 - 5455 - 6465 - 7475+ 2026 Less than $15,00019,9942,0473,3772,5981,0774,2263,2743,395 $15,000 to $24,99911,7831,0421,1061,9118601,7252,2322,906 $25,000 to $34,99913,9611,0673,1501,1341,4432,0223,8191,327 $35,000 to $49,99920,0331,3843,9423,0072,4422,4034,0002,856 $50,000 to $74,99937,1592,4066,7017,1334,4744,6065,7516,088 $75,000 to $99,99928,1081,1395,8175,5113,7273,7793,1015,034 $100,000 to $149,99941,5319198,6978,7037,0886,7146,4432,968 $150,000 to $199,99922,3311733,5545,3475,4283,6863,0811,062 $200,000+29,0551142,5437,9127,6485,5563,3041,978 Total223,95310,29038,88643,25634,18634,71735,00527,614 Median Income$81,619$44,920$78,892$101,163$116,111$89,224$65,925$61,195 2030 Less than $15,00018,7191,9472,8672,3181,0433,6852,9853,876 $15,000 to $24,99910,2171,0238161,5457151,2911,9422,886 $25,000 to $34,99911,9491,0082,3929481,2981,5383,2701,495 $35,000 to $49,99917,9791,2913,1982,6232,3051,8963,4553,212 $50,000 to $74,99935,7402,5875,9536,5804,3213,8545,3837,063 $75,000 to $99,99926,7311,2445,0985,0253,7362,9922,7555,881 $100,000 to $149,99943,1401,0738,3798,8668,0156,2726,5144,021 $150,000 to $199,99925,4042903,9275,6826,6153,7943,5311,564 $200,000+37,9931873,3549,54110,4536,4564,4723,530 Total227,87110,64935,98443,12638,50131,77734,30633,528 Median Income$89,710$49,338$85,213$107,715$128,209$100,485$73,872$65,639 Change - 2026 to 2030 Less than $15,000-1,274-100-510-281-35-541-288481 $15,000 to $24,999-1,565-19-290-366-145-435-290-20 $25,000 to $34,999-2,012-59-758-186-145-484-549167 $35,000 to $49,999-2,054-93-744-385-137-506-545356 $50,000 to $74,999-1,419182-748-553-153-752-368975 $75,000 to $99,999-1,377105-719-4869-788-346847 $100,000 to $149,9991,609154-317163928-442701,053 $150,000 to $199,9993,0731173733351,187109450502 $200,000+8,938738111,6282,8058991,1681,553 Total3,918360-2,902-1304,315-2,940-6985,914 Median Income$8,091$4,418$6,321$6,552$12,098$11,261$7,947$4,444 Sources: ESRI; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 17 Workshop Packet Page Number 159 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS The per capita income in Maplewood, estimated at $40,544 in 2026, is -8% lower than Ramsey County ($44,190) and -27% lower than the Metro Area ($55,603). By 2030, the per capita income in Maplewood is projected to increase 8% to $43,986 compared to 10% increases in Ramsey County and the Metro Area. Occupation The following information summarizes occupations of employed residents age 16 years or older in Maplewood, Ramsey County, and the Metro Area in 2020 compared to 2024, the most recent data available. Information is sourced from the 2016-2020 and the 2020-2024 American Community Surveys. Occupation data provides information on the types of positions that are held, offering an indication of potential labor force skills in various industry sectors. A Management, Business, Science and Arts job is the most common occupation in the market area, representing 42% of the occupations for employed residents in Maplewood, 48% in Ramsey County, and 51% in the Metro Area. In Maplewood, an estimated 18% of employed residents work in a Sales and Office occupation, while 17% are employed in a Production, Transportation, and Material Moving occupational group and 16% have a Service occupation. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 18 Workshop Packet Page Number 160 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Table 5 An estimated 7.4% of residents in Maplewood were self-employed in 2024 (self-employed in incorporated and non-incorporated businesses), slightly higher than 7.2% in Ramsey County but lower than 8.5% in the Metro Area. Between 2020 and 2024, the proportion of employed residents working in the Management, Business, Science, and Arts occupation increased 3.1% in Maplewood, the largest shift among these sectors. The proportion of self-employed residents in Maplewood increased 1.1%, while the share of employed residents in a Service occupation increased 0.5%. The share of employed residents in a Natural Resources, Construction, and Maintenance or a Production, Transportation, and Material Moving occupation increased 0.9% and 0.7%, respectively. The percentage of employed residents in a Sales and Office occupation declined -5.2% in Maplewood, compared to decreases of -2.5% in Ramsey County and -2.3% in the Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 19 Workshop Packet Page Number 161 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Educational Attainment Educational Attainment measures the highest level of education that individuals have completed within the Market Area. This data is useful as an indicator evaluating quality of life, workforce preparedness, and economic potential. The following summarizes the number and percent of the age 25 and older population in the Market Area by the highest level of education achieved in 2020 compared to 2024. Information is sourced from the 2016-2020 and the 2020-2024 American Community Surveys. Table 6 In 2024, 35% of population age 25 and older achieved a or higher (241% with a Graduate/Professional Degree) compared to 46% in Ramsey County and 48% in the Metro Area. degree as their highest level of education, notably higher than 20% in Ramsey County and 19% in the Metro Area. Degree, higher than both Ramsey County (26%) and the Metro Area (28%). The proportion of population with some college, increased 1.3% from 2020 to 2024. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 20 Workshop Packet Page Number 162 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIALREAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISDEMOGRAPHICTRENDS Consumer Expenditure Patterns The following summarizesconsumer expenditures on retail goods and services in Maplewood for 2026 with projections for 2030, according to data obtained from ESRI based on Consumer Expenditure Surveys from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Consumer spending is influenced by market conditions and trends. In times of economic troubles, market conditions drive spending patterns toward convenience and necessities, whereas in times of a robust economy consumer trends feature opportunity and luxury items. Sales of luxury items and other large purchases are generally the first to falter in economic downturns. Average annual retail expenditures(excluding housing, finance/insurance, and travel expenditures and vehicle purchases)areestimated to be $29,142per household in Maplewood in2026, lower than $37,443 per household in the Metro Area. As illustrated below, average annual expenditures per household are lower in Maplewood than in the Metro Area in every major retail category. Maplewood residents are expected to spend $478 million on retail goods and services in 2026. Average annual consumer expenditures per household are projected to increase 11.5% from 2026 to 2030 in Maplewoodcompared to 9.3% in the Metro Area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING21 Workshop Packet Page Number 163 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS Table 7 ESTIMATED HOUSEHOLD EXPENDITURES BY SELECTED PRODUCT TYPE CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2026 & 2030 CITY OF MAPLEWOODMETRO AREA 20262030 Forecast2026 CategoryTotal (000's)Per HHTotal (000's)Per HHPer HH Goods & Services Apparel & Services$36,576$2,228$41,463$2,483$2,924 Entertainment & Recreation$63,034$3,839$71,451$4,279$4,876 Nonprescription Drugs$2,937$179$3,332$200$222 Prescription Drugs$6,590$401$7,478$448$491 Eyeglasses & Contact Lenses$2,072$126$2,349$141$158 Personal Care Products$9,350$570$10,600$635$749 Smoking Products$6,056$369$6,884$412$471 Educational Books/Supplies/Etc.$676$41$766$46$56 Other School Supplies$1,290$79$1,463$88$103 Computers & Hardware for Home Use$3,282$200$3,720$223$260 Computer Software & Accessories$650$40$737$44$51 Pets$16,634$1,013$18,863$1,130$1,269 Food Food at Home$113,101$6,889$128,266$7,681$8,839 Food Away from Home$63,531$3,870$72,005$4,312$5,084 Alcoholic Beverages$10,563$643$11,970$717$825 Home Home Mortgage Payment/Rent$204,980$12,485$232,040$13,895$15,289 Maintenance & Remodeling Services$71,395$4,349$80,823$4,840$5,223 Maintenance & Remodeling Materials$10,343$630$11,724$702$758 Utilities$87,667$5,340$99,412$5,953$6,767 Household Furnishings, Equipment, & Operations Household Textiles$1,574$96$1,784$107$123 Furniture$12,282$748$13,917$833$963 Rugs$581$35$658$39$45 Major Appliances$7,147$435$8,099$485$541 Housewares$1,492$91$1,692$101$117 Small Appliances$19,934$1,214$22,592$1,353$1,548 Luggage$368$22$417$25$29 Telephones and Accessories$992$60$1,125$67$76 Child Care$8,872$540$10,040$601$712 Lawn/Garden$10,515$640$11,918$714$769 Moving/Storage/Freight Express$1,419$86$1,609$96$114 Housekeeping Supplies$13,504$823$15,316$917$1,044 ---------- continued ---------- MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 22 Workshop Packet Page Number 164 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 23 Workshop Packet Page Number 165 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Employment Trends Introduction Local employment trends are a driving factor influencing demand for commercial real estate. This section of the report evaluates employment trends and characteristics in Maplewood, Ramsey County and the Metro Area. The following topics are reviewed. Labor force, resident employment, and unemployment trends Commuting patterns Job growth trends and projections Employment and average wages by industry sector Business expansions Major employers Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development (MN DEED) is the primary data resource for this section of the market study. Other information sources include the United States Census Bureau Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics (LEHD) program. Additionally, Maxfield Research and Consulting researched General Obligation Bond Official Statements via the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) Electronic Municipal Market Access (EMMA) to obtain information on major employers in the area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 24 Workshop Packet Page Number 166 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Resident Employment The following table shows information on labor force, resident employment, and unemployment trends over the past ten years in Maplewood and Ramsey County compared to the Metro Area. Data is sourced from MN DEED. Resident employment data reveals the workforce and number of employed people living in the area. It is important to note that not all of these individuals necessarily work in the area. Table 8 In 2025, Maplewood had a labor force of 21,509 and resident employment of 20,607, for an unemployment rate of 4.2%, slightly higher than the unemployment rate of 3.8% in Ramsey County and 3.6% in the Metro Area. - As of April of 2026, unemployment was at 4.3% in Maplewood compared to 3.9% in Ramsey County and 3.7% in the Metro Area. labor force contracted 2.3% (509) during the ten-year time period from 2016 to 2025, while resident employment increased 2.8% (593). During that same time, Ramsey County experienced 0.4% labor force growth (1,292) against 0.2% resident employment growth (486). By comparison, the Metro Area labor force expanded 5.3% against a 5.1% increase in resident employment. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 25 Workshop Packet Page Number 167 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS Because labor force growth outpaced employment growth in the Market Area, unemployment rates declined. Resident employment dropped sharply in Maplewood in 2020 due to job losses related to the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent economic recession, declining -4.1% (896) compared to decreases of-4.0% in Ramsey County and -3.3% in the Metro Area. As resident employment dropped in 2020, the annual unemployment rate spiked to 7.3% in Maplewood, 6.9% in Ramsey County, and 6.4% in the Metro Area. employment increased 0.3% (73). By comparison, Ramsey County experienced 1.8% labor force growth (5,253) and 2.1% resident employment growth (5,762) during that period. Commuting Patterns The following summarizesthe inflow and outflow characteristics of the workers in Maplewood. Outflow reflects the number of workers living in the area but employed outside the City, while inflow measures the number of workers that are employed in the City but live outside the area. Interior flow reflects the number of workers that live and work in Maplewood. For this analysis, we reviewed commuting pattern data for the City of Maplewood from the U.S. Census Bureau Local Employment Dynamics data for 2023, the most recent data available. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING26 Workshop Packet Page Number 168 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Approximately 12,628 workers commute into Maplewood for employment daily (inflow), while 17,540 resident workers leave the community (outflow). An estimated 954 people both live and work in the City (interior flow). Roughly 93% of the jobs in Maplewood are filled by workers commuting into the City. The highest proportion of workers coming into the area are aged 30 to 54 and earn more than the largest percentage of employees (56%). Table 9 Overall, Maplewood is an exporter of workers as a higher number of residents commute out of the City for employment than nonresidents commute into the City. Many retailers and other commercial establishments can benefit from the daytime population commuting into Maplewood (12,628 workers per day in 2023), as employees at establishments located in Maplewood will purchase commercial goods and services from area retailers. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 27 Workshop Packet Page Number 169 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS 2023 Commuting Pattern City of Maplewood The following information highlights the commuting patterns, including distance and destination, of workers with primary jobs in Maplewood based on Local Employment Dynamics data for 2023. Home Destination summarizes where workers live who are employed inthe City, while Work Destination represents where workers are employed who live in Maplewood. Roughly 93% of the workers employed in Maplewood reside outside the City, while 7% (954) reside in the City. The largest proportion of workers commuting into Maplewood come from St. Paul (15.5%), Minneapolis (5.6%), Woodbury (4.0%), and Oakdale (3.2%). Approximately 48% of the workers in Maplewood reside within ten miles of their place of employment while 36% travel from 10 to 24 miles. Roughly 10% of the workers commute from a distance of 25 to 50 miles and another 6% come from more than 50 miles away. Roughly 95% of the workers living in Maplewood commute outside of the City, most notably to St. Paul (21.1%), Minneapolis (12.4%), Edina (3.6%), and Roseville (3.6%). Among workers living in Maplewood, 51% travel less than ten miles for their jobs, while 42% have a commute distance from 10 to 24 miles. Approximately 3% commute between 25 and 50 miles while 4% commute more than 50 miles for employment. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING28 Workshop Packet Page Number 170 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Table 10 Employment Growth Trends Job growth is a primary driver of demand for commercial real estate, particularly office space. Increased hiring can also lead to higher levels of consumer spending, stimulating demand for retail goods which can generate demand for retail space. The following summarizes employment growth trends and projections from 2010 to 2050 for Maplewood, Ramsey County and the Metro Area. Annual employment data is sourced from the MN DEED Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, while projections are sourced from the Metropolitan Council. All establishments covered under the Unemployment Insurance Program are required to report wage and employment data quarterly. Federal government establishments are also covered by the QCEW program. Workers and jobs excluded from these statistics include the self- employed, family farm workers, and those who work only on a commission basis. As of 2025, there were 25,125 jobs in Maplewood, representing roughly 8% of jobs in Ramsey County. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 29 Workshop Packet Page Number 171 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Employment in Maplewood contracted between 2010 and 2025, losing -2,046 jobs (-7.5%) during that period. Due, in part, to the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent recession, employment contracted -7.8% (-2,173 jobs) in Maplewood, compared to a -7.7% decrease in Ramsey County and -7.4% decrease in the Seven County Metro between 2019 and 2020. Employment in Maplewood contracted -2.5% (-617 jobs) between 2020 and 2025, while Ramsey County and the Metro Area both experienced modest growth, increasing 6.4% and 7.2%, respectively during that time period. Solid job growth is anticipated in Maplewood and Ramsey County over the next 25 years. The Metropolitan Council forecasts Maplewood will experience 27% growth, adding 6,775 jobs between 2025 and 2050, while Ramsey County experiences 11% job growth and employment in the Metro Area expands 16%. Table 11 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 30 Workshop Packet Page Number 172 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS Ramsey County Job Concentrations MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING31 Workshop Packet Page Number 173 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS As noted previously, job growth is a key demand driver for office space and, to a lesser extent, retail space. The primary industry sectors that generate demand for office space include Information, Financial Activities, Professional and Business Services, and Education and Health Services. The following information summarizes employment growth trends in the office-using sectors. Data is sourced from MN DEED and the Metropolitan Council. To account for jobs in hospitals and schools that typically do not require office space, these calculations exclude 50% of employment in the Education and Health Services sector. In Maplewood, the number of office-using jobs decreased -12.3% (-1,676 jobs) between 2010 and 2025, compared to a -7.5% decline in total employment. Table 12 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 32 Workshop Packet Page Number 174 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS By comparison, job growth in the office-using sectors outperformed total employment in both Ramsey County and the Metro Area between 2010 and 2025. Office-using jobs increased 5.8% in Ramsey County and 19.5% in the Metro Area during that time period, compared to total job growth of 4.8% and 15.3%, respectively. As of year-end 2025, 47.9% of all jobs in Maplewood were in the office-using sectors, down from 50.2% in 2010 and 54.0% in 2020. Over the past 15 years, Ramsey County experienced a minimal shift in the share of office-using jobs, climbing from 36.4% in 2010 to 36.8% in 2025. That shift was slightly more pronounced in the Metro Area, as the percentage of office-using jobs increased from 35.9% in 2010 to 37.2% in 2025. These percentages are projected to increase modestly as the greatest job growth in the Metro Area over the next several years according to MN DEED will be among industries that often require office space, such as Education and Health Services, Professional and Business Services, and Financial Activities. Between 2025 and 2050, Maplewood is projected to experience a 31.4% increase in office-using jobs (3,761 jobs) compared to a 14.7% increase in Ramsey County and a 20.4% increase in the Metro Area. These trends are accounted for in our demand calculations presented later in this Report. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 33 Workshop Packet Page Number 175 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISEMPLOYMENT TRENDS Industry Employment and Wage Data The following summarizes information on the employment and wage situation in Maplewood, Ramsey County and the Metro Areaover the past three years. Annual data from theQuarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW) is sourced from MNDEED. Certain industries may not display any information which means that there is either no reported economic activity for that industry or the data has been suppressed to protect the confidentiality of cooperating employers. This generally occurs when there are too few employers or one employer comprises too much of the employment in that geography. Professional and Business Services is the largest employment sector in Maplewood (8,109 reported jobs, 32.3% of the total), followed by Education and Health Services (26.1%)and Trade, Transportation and Utilities (17.8%). Education and Health Services is the largest employment sector in Ramsey County (32.1% of total jobs). Maplewood employment contracted -3.7% (-953 jobs) between 2023 and 2025, while Ramsey County added 5,729 jobs (1.8% growth). In 2025, average weekly wages were $2,038 in Maplewood, $1,564 in Ramsey County,and $1,609 in the MetroArea.Highest average wages in Maplewood are found in the Professional and Business Services ($3,749) and Construction ($1,869) industry sectors. Average weekly wages increased 14.4% in Maplewoodsince 2023, compared to increase of 9.3% in Ramsey County and6.8% in the MetroArea. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 34 Workshop Packet Page Number 176 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Table 13 INDUSTRY EMPLOYMENT TRENDS 2023 - 2025 Change 2023-20242024-2025 Industry202320242025No.Pct.No.Pct. Maplewood Total, All Industries26,07825,77525,125-303-1.2%-650-2.5% Natural Resources & Mining-------------- Construction786798761121.5%-37-4.6% Manufacturing1,0991,0481,002-51-4.6%-46-4.4% Trade, Transportation & Utilities4,7414,7544,469130.3%-285-6.0% Information615456-7-11.5%23.7% Financial Activities536504534-32-6.0%306.0% Prof. & Business Svcs.8,7008,4388,109-262-3.0%-329-3.9% Education & Health Svcs.6,5936,5666,552-27-0.4%-14-0.2% Leisure & Hospitality2,4932,5262,528331.3%20.1% Other Services72373173581.1%40.5% Public Administration34435337792.6%246.8% Ramsey County Total, All Industries324,921325,867330,6509460.3%4,7831.5% Natural Resources & Mining837260-11-13.3%-12-16.7% Construction12,55512,67613,0711211.0%3953.1% Manufacturing28,59927,56926,897-1,030-3.6%-672-2.4% Trade, Transportation & Utilities43,54943,92043,5963710.9%-324-0.7% Information4,9785,1044,9691262.5%-135-2.6% Financial Activities19,09918,99319,675-106-0.6%6823.6% Prof. & Business Svcs.45,65743,56343,988-2,094-4.6%4251.0% Education & Health Svcs.101,701102,236106,2555350.5%4,0193.9% Leisure & Hospitality28,16528,91328,2627482.7%-651-2.3% Other Services11,79512,00011,9072051.7%-93-0.8% Public Administration28,73730,81831,9682,0817.2%1,1503.7% Seven County Metro Total, All Industries1,757,4331,765,1731,771,7747,7400.4%6,6010.4% Natural Resources & Mining4,1864,1114,371-75-1.8%2606.3% Construction80,18480,05682,958-128-0.2%2,9023.6% Manufacturing175,899172,858169,752-3,041-1.7%-3,106-1.8% Trade, Transportation & Utilities318,759319,462314,8377030.2%-4,625-1.4% Information30,11928,72626,889-1,393-4.6%-1,837-6.4% Financial Activities131,228126,683125,948-4,545-3.5%-735-0.6% Prof. & Business Svcs.292,747282,862276,208-9,885-3.4%-6,654-2.4% Education & Health Svcs.426,525442,704461,39916,1793.8%18,6954.2% Leisure & Hospitality167,502171,161171,2773,6592.2%1160.1% Other Services55,75756,65556,0228981.6%-633-1.1% Public Administration74,52779,89382,1135,3667.2%2,2202.8% Sources: MN DEED; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 35 Workshop Packet Page Number 177 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Table 14 AVERAGE WEEKLY WAGES 2023 - 2025 Change 2023-20242024-2025 Industry202320242025No.Pct.No.Pct. MAPLEWOOD Total, All Industries$1,782$1,807$2,038$251.4%$23112.8% Natural Resources & Mining-------------- Construction$1,680$1,740$1,869$603.6%$1297.4% Manufacturing$1,648$1,686$1,842$382.3%$1569.3% Trade, Transportation & Utilities$921$898$930-$23-2.5%$323.6% Information$1,898$1,947$1,810$492.6%-$137-7.0% Financial Activities$1,684$1,711$1,790$271.6%$794.6% Prof. & Business Svcs.$2,998$3,144$3,749$1464.9%$60519.2% Education & Health Svcs.$1,419$1,379$1,464-$40-2.8%$856.2% Leisure & Hospitality$505$531$548$265.1%$173.2% Other Services$795$828$838$334.2%$101.2% Public Administration$1,673$1,701$1,770$281.7%$694.1% RAMSEY COUNTY Total, All Industries$1,431$1,497$1,564$664.6%$674.5% Natural Resources & Mining$1,732$1,544$1,686-$188-10.9%$1429.2% Construction$1,781$1,866$2,007$854.8%$1417.6% Manufacturing$1,858$1,953$1,990$955.1%$371.9% Trade, Transportation & Utilities$1,244$1,258$1,324$141.1%$665.2% Information$2,134$2,333$2,472$1999.3%$1396.0% Financial Activities$1,949$2,095$2,200$1467.5%$1055.0% Prof. & Business Svcs.$1,961$2,124$2,255$1638.3%$1316.2% Education & Health Svcs.$1,191$1,235$1,269$443.7%$342.8% Leisure & Hospitality$611$640$674$294.7%$345.3% Other Services$1,063$1,105$1,146$424.0%$413.7% Public Administration$1,629$1,714$1,793$855.2%$794.6% METRO AREA Total, All Industries$1,506$1,559$1,609$533.5%$503.2% Natural Resources & Mining$1,088$1,142$1,137$545.0%-$5-0.4% Construction$1,765$1,873$1,949$1086.1%$764.1% Manufacturing$1,704$1,799$1,869$955.6%$703.9% Trade, Transportation & Utilities$1,284$1,314$1,381$302.3%$675.1% Information$2,171$2,314$2,417$1436.6%$1034.5% Financial Activities$2,438$2,581$2,635$1435.9%$542.1% Prof. & Business Svcs.$2,046$2,141$2,217$954.6%$763.5% Education & Health Svcs.$1,237$1,278$1,309$413.3%$312.4% Leisure & Hospitality$663$682$717$192.9%$355.1% Other Services$952$982$1,015$303.2%$333.4% Public Administration$1,530$1,599$1,689$694.5%$905.6% Sources: MN DEED; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 36 Workshop Packet Page Number 178 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Business Expansions The following summarizes major business expansions in Ramsey County since 2023. Information is sourced from MN DEED, which gathers this data from public announcements, media reports, and other resources. There have been 23 major publicly announced employer expansions in Ramsey County since 2023. Saint Paul was the leader, with eight expansions, followed by Arden Hills with five and Maplewood with three. Shoreview and Roseville each had two publicly announced expansions and there was one each in White Bear Lake, Oakdale, and New Brighton. Of those expansions, medical/medical device manufacturing was most common with six companies expanding. There were 14 other industry sectors represented. Table 15 RECENT BUSINESS EXPANSIONS RAMSEY COUNTY 2023 - 2026 Q1 COMPANY NAMEINDUSTRY DESCRIPTIONCITYQUARTER Maplewood St. John's HospitalHealth Care, Social AssistMaplewood2026-Q1 3MMedicalMaplewood2024-Q4 Hampton CompaniesReal EstateMaplewood2024-Q3 Ramsey County Hope&PlumApparelSaint Paul2026-Q1 Fairview Health ServicesHealth Care, Social AssistShoreview2026-Q1 DelkorMachineryArden Hills2026-Q1 CarecubesMedical DevicesArden Hills2026-Q1 CossettaFoodSaint Paul2025-Q4 IntriconMedicalArden Hills2025-Q2 Nextera PackagingWholesaleWhite Bear Lake2025-Q2 IntriconMedicalArden Hills2025-Q1 Simpli-Fi Automation Inc.ElectronicsSaint Paul2024-Q2 PaR SystemsMachineryShoreview2024-Q2 CogwearMedicalSaint Paul2024-Q2 Pace Analytical Life Sciences LLCEngineeringOakdale2024-Q1 J&L Wire Cloth LLCFabricated MetalSaint Paul2024-Q1 IWG (Spaces)Real Estate, LeasingSaint Paul2023-Q4 ComputypePrintingRoseville2023-Q3 Pioneer IndustriesWaste Management (Recycling)New Brighton2023-Q3 ForwardEdge ASIC (Lockheed Martin)Electrical EquipmentSaint Paul2023-Q2 Optiscan ImagingMedicalRoseville2023-Q2 Xcel EnergyUtilitiesSaint Paul2023-Q2 Saltbox CoReal Estate, LeasingArden Hills2023-Q1 Sources: MN DEED; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 37 Workshop Packet Page Number 179 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS EMPLOYMENT TRENDS Major Employers The following list provides a summary of the major employers in Maplewood. Data was sourced from the City of Maplewood via the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) Electronic Municipal Market Access (EMMA) General Obligation Corporate Purpose Bonds Official Statement for the City, which was posted in 2025, the most recent data available. The largest employer in the community is 3M (Maplewood location only) with 4,452 employees, followed by ISD No. 622, with 2,107 employees, and M Health Fairview with 1,473 employees. Table 16 There are five different industry sectors represented by these major employers, although employment is concentrated among the three largest employers (3M, ISD 622, and M Health Fairview). Among the industry sectors represented, Retail Trade has the highest concentration with four major employers, followed by Health Care and Social Assistance with three. Manufacturing, Educational Services, and Public Administration sectors each contain one of the major employers. Combined, these ten major employers employ an estimated 9,926 workers, representing approximately 40% of jobs in Maplewood. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 38 Workshop Packet Page Number 180 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS Market Trends Introduction This section of the report presents and analyzes information relating to the condition of the commercial real estate markets in Maplewood as they pertain to demand for future development/redevelopment. The following topics are covered. Nonresidential Building Permit Trends Hospitality Market Trends Performance Metrics for Hotel Properties in Maplewood and the Surrounding Area Retail and Office Real Estate Trends in the Metro Area and the Northeast Submarket Maplewood Retail Market Conditions Retail Sale Trends Maplewood Office Market Conditions Business Growth Trends in the Office-Using Industry Sectors Pending Commercial Developments Available Commercial Land Detailed information is provided for the commercial real estate market in Maplewood along with the competitive Trade Area. For the purposes of this analysis, the competitive trade area is comprised of portions of several nearby communities, including Gem Lake, Little Canada, Mahtomedi, Newport, North St. Paul, Oakdale, Roseville, Saint Paul, Vadnais Heights, White Bear Lake, Willernie, and Woodbury. The competitive hotel location map on a subsequent page provides an illustration of the general boundaries of the competitive trade area. Maxfield Research compiled secondary data on commercial real estate inventory in Maplewood and the surrounding trade area, including retail and office space, vacancies, and pricing. Sources include the Minnesota Commercial Association of Real Estate/Realtors commercial property exchange, accessed through Real Estate Data, Inc. Commercial Real Estate (REDI CRE), This data is provided to show the types and amount of space listed as available on the exchange at the time of our survey. Unless otherwise noted in the report, space that may be vacant but is not marketed on the exchange as available is not included. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 39 Workshop Packet Page Number 181 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS NonresidentialBuilding Permit Trends The following summarizes information on nonresidential (commercial, industrial, public, institutional) building permits issued in Maplewood over the past ten years (2016 through May 2026). Information was obtained from the City of Maplewood and the Metropolitan Council which collects data from communities in the seven-county Metro Area via an annual survey. Permit data includes new buildings, additions, and remodels if the permit valuation is $100,000 or more. The value represents the estimated cost of construction as reported on the permit. Table 17 A total of 98 nonresidential building permits were issued in Maplewood from 2016 through May 2026, totaling roughly $445 million in value. Maplewood issues 9.5 nonresidential building permits annually, on average. During that ten-year time period, permitting activity was strongest in 2024, with 17 permits issued, followed by 2017 with 16 permits. Based on total value identified on the building permits, 2020 was the strongest year, with $117.7 million in total value, followed by 2023 ($80.5 million) and 2017 ($77.3 million). Nearly half of the nonresidential permits issued (46%) were for remodels, totaling $200.7 million in value. Another 28% of the permits were for new buildings ($117.1 million in value) and 26% of the permits were for additions ($127.2 million). Among the nonresidential permits issued, the majority (71%) were for commercial buildings, while 23% were public and institutional, and 5% were for industrial buildings. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 40 Workshop Packet Page Number 182 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS Permits for public and institutional buildings had a value of $231.5 million (52% of the total permit value), while commercial permits had a value of $175.5 million (39%) and industrial permits had a value of $38.0 million (9%). On average, nonresidential permits have a construction value of $4.5 million per project, including $2.5 million per commercial permit, $10.1 million per public and institutional permit, and $7.6 million per industrial permit. The following graph depicts the average construction value per permit for the various nonresidential property subtypes, as defined by the Metropolitan Council. As shown, schools had the highest value at an average of $15.1 million per permit, followed by government projects at $14.6 million per project. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 41 Workshop Packet Page Number 183 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Hospitality Market Overview Maxfield Research and Consulting acquired data from Kalibri Labs LLC to gain an understanding of the hotel market in Maplewood and the surrounding area. Kalibri is a data and technology company equipping lodging industry stakeholders with the intelligence and tools to grow cash flow, improve performance, and increase asset value. Occupancy, demand, revenue, room rate, supply, and revenue per available room (RevPAR) are the key metrics used to measure performance in the hotel industry. Kalibri defines these key industry metrics as shown below. Occupancy Proportion (in percent) of available rooms occupied with room night demand, calculated as room night demand divided by supply for a given date range. Revenue Hotel collected revenue reflects the amount of room revenue a hotel collects and records in their financial statement but does not account for wholesale commissions. Supply Count of hotel rooms available for sale during a given date range. Room Rate (Average Daily Rate, ADR) Room revenue divided by room night demand for a given date range, displayed as the average rate for a single room. Demand The number of rooms sold for a given date range. RevPAR Revenue per available room, calculated as room revenue divided by available rooms for a given date range. Length of Stay Duration in days of a given guest stay, from check-in until check-out. Kalibri Labs categorizes hotel demand into specific segments (Leisure, Commercial, Group, and Contract) to analyze revenue performance, customer acquisition costs, and profit contribution. This information helps differentiate between high-margin revenue and business that costs more to acquire. The following provides a breakdown of key differences between these segments. Leisure Segment (Transient Leisure): Individual travelers booking for pleasure, nonbusiness related trips. Travelers typically book shorter lengths of stay (i.e. one to four days) and are heavy users of Online Travel Agencies (OTAs), brand websites, or direct bookings. Demand is strongest on weekends, holidays, and summer months. Leisure is a major demand driver, recently exceeding 60% to 70% of occupancy. Commercial Segment (Transient Business): Individual business travelers who are not part of a group block; often corporate travelers, consultants, or government personnel. Business travelers are generally less price-sensitive than leisure guests and value convenience, location, and on-site work amenities. Demand is strongest from Monday through Thursday, with minimal activity on weekends. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 42 Workshop Packet Page Number 184 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Group Segment (Meetings & Events): Blocks of rooms booked together (usually 10+ rooms) for a specific event. This segment includes conferences, conventions, weddings, and "SMERFE" (Social, Military, Ethnic, Religious, Fraternal, and Educational) events, and often books months or years in advance. The segment provides high base-load demand, particularly in the spring and fall and often generates significant ancillary revenue, such as catering and audio/visual which are often sold through the group contract. Contract Segment (Negotiated & Specialized): Business secured through a formal agreement with a set rate for a fixed period, and frequently involves airline crew layovers, extended-stay projects, or long-term training contracts. Contract demand is often constant throughout the year, regardless of weekday/weekend patterns. The lodging industry is commonly segmented into six major hotel chain scales based on pricing, service levels, and amenity offerings. These classifications provide a framework for evaluating market positioning, competitive supply, and development opportunities. Economy hotels offer basic accommodations at the lowest price point, emphasizing value and efficiency. They typically provide limited amenities, smaller room sizes, and minimal staffing, catering primarily to pricesensitive travelers and shortstay demand. Midscale facilities provide comfortable accommodations with moderate amenities and competitive pricing. Most properties include complimentary breakfast, standardized room layouts, and basic business services, appealing to both leisure and budgetconscious business travelers. Upper Midscale facilities feature newer construction, higherquality finishes, and enhanced guest amenities compared to midscale properties. Common features include expanded breakfast offerings, fitness centers, and modern business amenities, targeting travelers seeking greater comfort and consistency. Upscale properties typically offer fullservice or highend selectservice experiences, including onsite dining, meeting space, and elevated service standards. These facilities are oriented toward business travelers, small groups, and higherincome leisure guests. Upper Upscale properties deliver a more refined hospitality experience with premium accommodations, extensive meeting and event facilities, and fullservice food and beverage options. Service levels are more personalized, and properties often occupy prominent or destinationoriented locations. Luxury hotels represent the highest tier of the lodging market, emphasizing exceptional service, distinctive design, and comprehensive amenities. These properties focus on highly personalized guest experiences, upscale dining, spa services, and prime locations, catering to affluent travelers and specialoccasion stays. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 43 Workshop Packet Page Number 185 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Market Area Hospitality Trends The following information summarizes supply, occupancy, average daily rate (ADR), and RevPAR for the Minneapolis market area (i.e. Metro Area) over the past ten years. Year-over-year (YoY) percentage change for each of these metrics is also displayed. Data is sourced from Kalibri Labs Table 18 Occupancy rates in the market area, which were consistently between 67% and 70% from 2016 through 2019, dropped sharply in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent shutdown of the economy. Market area occupancy rates have gradually improved, climbing from 21.5% in 2020 to 61.9% in 2025, although occupancy rates remain below pre-pandemic levels. Room supply in the Minneapolis market area increased 14% over the past ten years, climbing from 37,850 rooms on a daily basis in 2016 to 43,161 rooms in 2025, averaging 1.5% average growth annually, although the pace of growth has flattened over the past three years. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 44 Workshop Packet Page Number 186 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The average daily room rate (ADR) increased 12.8% since 2016, climbing from an average of $114.31 per room in 2016 to $128.98 in 2025, despite a -38% drop in 2020 during the pandemic. RevPAR, however, has just returned to pre-pandemic levels, increasing 1.2% from $78.93 in 2016 to $79.87 in 2025. The slow recovery in RevPAR is due, in part, to a large increase in supply between 2016 and 2021, as the market added roughly 5,000 rooms (13% increase) in preparation for several major events (i.e. Super Bowl LII in 2018, NCAA Final Four in 2019, NCAA Wom Four in 2022). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 45 Workshop Packet Page Number 187 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS the Minneapolis market area. Occupancy and revenue metrics are improving due to higher average daily rates and a strengthening of travel. These trends reflect renewed confidence in lodging demand, driven by leisure travel and increased business activity. The following table summarizes average occupancy, ADR, RevPAR, and ALOS over the past 12 months in the St. Paul Submarket, which includes Maplewood, by market segment including Leisure, Commercial, Group, and Contract. Data is sourced from Kalibri Labs LLC. Occupancy rates and RevPAR presented in the table reflect the share of total Submarket occupancy and RevPAR over the past 12 months. Table 19 The St. Paul Submarket had an average occupancy rate of 60.2% from June 2025 through May 2026, slightly lower than the Metro Area during the same 12-month period (61.6%). Average ADR in the submarket over the past 12 months is $122.17, -7% lower than the Metro Area, while average RevPAR ($73.9) in the submarket is -9% lower than the Metro. The average length of stay in the submarket (1.99 days over the past 12 months) is consistent with the Metro Area. In the submarket, ALOS is highest in the Group (2.46 days) and Commercial (2.27 days) segments, compared to 1.74 days in the Leisure segment and 1.38 days in the Contract segment. Longer ALOS benefit hotels by increasing profitability through lower operating expenses (i.e. reduced housekeeping, lower guest turnover costs, fewer check-ins). Longer ALOS also increases RevPAR, stabilizes occupancy, and reduces customer acquisition costs. The Leisure segment comprised the highest portion of submarket occupancy over the past 12 months, at 27.8%, followed by the Commercial segment (23.8%). The ADR is highest among the Group ($132.80) and Commercial ($123.82) segments, while the RevPAR share is highest in the Leisure ($33.13) and Commercial ($29.57) segments. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 46 Workshop Packet Page Number 188 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Selected Competitive Hotel Properties The following table provides a summary of the hotel properties in Maplewood and surrounding areas that would likely be competitive with a potential new hotel in Maplewood. Detailed performance metrics for the competitive set of hotels are provided in the subsequent tables and related points. Data is sourced from Kalibri Labs LLC. In total, we selected 17 properties with 1,851 rooms in Maplewood and the surrounding area. Among these 17 facilities, 12 (1,230 rooms) are weekly participants in the Kalibri Labs LLC survey. Five of the properties (621 rooms) are not weekly participants in the survey. Table 20 The 157-room Extended Stay America Suites in Woodbury is the newest property (opened in 2019), followed by the 120-room Courtyard in Woodbury (2018). Among the selected properties, 37% of the rooms opened from 2010 to 2020 (689 rooms, six properties), while 19% opened in the 1980s (351 rooms, three properties) and 19% opened between 2000 and 2010 (350 rooms, three properties). Three properties (195 rooms) opened during the 1990s and two opened prior to 1980 (266 rooms). The following map illustrates the location of these competitive facilities. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 47 Workshop Packet Page Number 189 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS Competitive Hotel Property Location Map MAP KEY 1.AmericInn 2.Hampton by Hilton 3.Emerald Inn 4.Sheraton Hotel 5.Country Inn & Suites 6.Best Western Plus 7.LivINNHotel 8.Comfort Inn 6 9.Comfort Inn 1 10.Holiday Inn Express 11.Hampton by Hilton 12.Courtyard 13.Extended Stay America 14 10 14.Fairfield Inn 8 15.La Quinta Inn & Suites 3 16.Residence Inn 17.DoubleTree by Hilton Trade Area 9 11 7 17 12 5 16 4 15 13 2 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 48 Workshop Packet Page Number 190 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS supply is located in Maplewood. Woodbury contains 47% of the room supply (867 rooms, seven properties), while 16% of the supply is located in Vadnais Heights (288 rooms, three properties) and 11% of the rooms are in Saint Paul (195 rooms in one property). Kalibri Labs LLC tracks hotel properties under six different chain scale classes, including Luxury, Upper Upscale, Upscale, Upper Midscale, Midscale, and Economy. Nine of the properties, totaling 884 rooms, are classified as Upper Midscale. There are also three Upscale hotels (431 rooms) and three Midscale properties (319 rooms), along with one 150-room Upper Upscale property and one 67-room Economy hotel. As depicted in the following graph, nearly half (48%) of the room supply is considered Upper Midscale while 23% of the rooms are classified as Upscale, and 17% are Midscale. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 49 Workshop Packet Page Number 191 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The following information summarizes key performance metrics for the competitive set of hotel properties from 2021 through 2026 year-to-date (through May), including supply and demand trends, occupancy, ADR, RevPAR, total revenue, and average length of stay. Kalibri Labs provides aggregate data for all properties in the competitive set but not for the individual properties. Room supply is determined by multiplying the number of rooms in the competitive set by the number of days in that time period (i.e. 365 days in a year). Room supply experienced little change, with no new hotel facilities opening during the survey period (2021 through May 2026). Table 21 While the supply of available rooms held steady, demand, as measured by the number of rooms sold, increased 30%, climbing from 321,770 rooms sold in 2021 to 419,653 rooms sold in 2025. There have been 274,065 rooms sold through the first five months of 2026. Demand has increased 7.3% annually, on average, including 24.1% growth from 2021 to 2022 and 3.7% growth from 2024 to 2025. Demand growth was relatively flat between 2022 and 2024. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 50 Workshop Packet Page Number 192 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The following graph illustrates annual supply and demand trends among the competitive set of hotel properties. With increasing demand, the annual occupancy rate has also increased, climbing from 49.3% in 2021 to 63.3% in 2025 and 62.4% through the first five months of 2026. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 51 Workshop Packet Page Number 193 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS With occupancy among competitive hotel properties increasing over the past five years, the 2025 annual occupancy of 63.3% is higher than the average occupancy recorded over the past 12 months in both the Minneapolis Market Area (61.6%) and the St. Paul Submarket (60.2%). Over the past five years, ADR in the competitive set increased 16%, averaging 3.8% increases on an annual basis, climbing from $95.15 in 2021 to $110.12 in 2025. Higher room rates, together with improving occupancy, contributed to a 49% increase in RevPAR, climbed from $30.6 million in 2021 to $46.2 million in 2025. The 2025 ADR in the competitive set ($110.12) is -10% lower than the St. Paul Submarket ($122.17 over the past 12 months), while 2025 RevPAR ($69.76) is -6% lower than the Submarket ($73.90 over the past 12 months). Length of stay (ALOS) in the competitive set averaged 2.14 days in 2025, consistent with the average of 2.16 days over the past five years. The ALOS in the competitive set is higher than both the submarket (1.99 days) and the Minneapolis Metro Area (1.98 days). A review of these key performance metrics indicates that lodging market conditions in the area surrounding Maplewood are strengthening, with measurable improvement across all major indicators. - Demand has averaged 7.3% annual growth while ADR and RevPAR have experienced average annual increases of 3.8% and 11.1%, respectively, as total revenue has averaged 11.6% annual growth. The charts on the following page show the seasonal nature of the local lodging market, as occupancy rates peak in the summer months and are lowest in December, January, and February of each year. Over the past five years, occupancy peaked in summer (June, July, August), averaging 73.3%, compared to 43.6% in the winter (December, January, February). Occupancy is second highest in the fall (September, October, November), averaging 61.0%, while springtime (March, April, May) occupancy averages 57.3%. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 52 Workshop Packet Page Number 194 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Daily rates and RevPAR are highest during summer, averaging $112.78 and $82.89, respectively, and lowest in the winter ($95.01 and $41.89, respectively). In fall, daily rates average $106.88 with average RevPAR of $65.78. Springtime ADR and RevPAR average $99.09 and $57.31, respectively. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 53 Workshop Packet Page Number 195 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The following summarizes occupancy rates, average room rates, and RevPAR by day of the week in twelve-month periods over the past three years. Day-of-the-week performance data highlights demand patterns between leisure and business travelers. Business-oriented hotels typically experience peak demand midweek (Tuesday, Wednesday), while leisure-oriented properties peak on weekends. This information allows hotels to optimize revenue and operations by understanding shifting demand patterns. Key benefits include pricing adjustments for high-demand weekends versus softer midweeks, forecasting occupancy to align staffing needs, and targeting marketing efforts toward business travelers during the week and leisure guests on weekends. Table 22 DAY OF THE WEEK ANALYSIS 2020 - 2026 ---------- OCCUPANCY ---------- Time PeriodSatSunMonTueWedThuFri 2021 62.9%39.3%43.9%46.2%47.0%47.9%57.9% 2022 69.9%48.1%56.0%60.5%60.8%59.5%67.1% 2023 70.4%48.3%57.5%61.9%61.7%59.1%65.1% 2024 70.0%48.2%58.3%62.6%62.1%58.6%66.7% 2025 71.9%51.0%61.7%66.2%64.0%60.2%68.3% 2026 ytd 70.8%50.3%60.0%65.1%65.2%58.7%66.8% Average69.3%47.6%56.2%60.4%60.1%57.3%65.3% ---------- ADR ---------- Time PeriodSatSunMonTueWedThuFri 2021$102.50$89.71$91.18$92.67$92.90$92.46$99.80 2022$109.96$96.68$100.19$102.93$102.35$100.47$107.81 2023$114.85$98.79$103.73$106.63$105.85$103.59$111.89 2024$115.02$100.03$106.86$111.12$110.80$106.43$112.52 2025$114.85$100.43$108.66$112.28$111.62$107.20$112.77 2026 ytd$109.62$99.81$109.11$113.98$112.42$105.50$108.19 Average$111.13$97.57$103.29$106.60$105.99$102.61$108.83 ---------- RevPAR ---------- Time PeriodSatSunMonTueWedThuFri 2021$64.45$35.29$39.99$42.82$43.65$44.27$57.75 2022$76.88$46.49$56.12$62.30$62.23$59.80$72.31 2023$80.87$47.76$59.61$65.99$65.32$61.23$72.86 2024$80.46$48.26$62.33$69.56$68.78$62.32$75.04 2025$82.63$51.23$67.03$74.38$71.39$64.56$77.07 2026 ytd$77.63$50.19$65.50$74.17$73.28$61.90$72.27 Average$77.15$46.54$58.43$64.87$64.11$59.01$71.22 Sources: Kalibri Labs LLC; Maxfield Research & Consulting Within the competitive set, occupancy, ADR, and RevPAR peak on Fridays and Saturdays, indicating that leisure travelers account for the majority of room-night demand in Maplewood and the surrounding area. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 54 Workshop Packet Page Number 196 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Performance metrics are weakest on Sundays, with modest gains mid-week, indicating that business travel also contributes to room-night demand in competitive set of properties. Hotel Occupancy, ADR & RevPAR by Day of the Week $120.00100.0% 90.0% $100.00 80.0% 70.0% $80.00 60.0% $60.0050.0% 40.0% $40.00 30.0% 20.0% $20.00 10.0% $0.000.0% SatSunMonTueWedThuFri ADR $111.13$97.57$103.29$106.60$105.99$102.61$108.83 RevPAR $77.15$46.54$58.43$64.87$64.11$59.01$71.22 Occupancy 69.3%47.6%56.2%60.4%60.1%57.3%65.3% In 2025, occupancy rates range from highs of 71.9% on Saturdays and 68.3% on Fridays to a low of 50.3% on Sundays. Average daily rates in 2025 followed a similar pattern, peaking at $114.85 on Saturdays and declining to $100.43 on Sundays, with RevPAR ranging from $82.63 to $51.23 over the same period. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 55 Workshop Packet Page Number 197 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Metro Area Commercial Real Estate Market Overview Maxfield Research analyzed published quarterly market reports covering retail and office real estate trends in the Metro Area and the Northeast Submarket (includes much of Maplewood). Key indicators include vacancy, development activity, and absorption (the Data is sourced from MNCAR via REDI CRE. Tracked retail properties include multi- and single- tenant buildings 15,000 square feet or larger, while the tracked set of office properties include multi- and single-tenant buildings 20,000 square feet or larger. Table 23 COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE MARKET TRENDS 2021 - 2026 RETAIL MARKET2026 Q120252024202320222021 Twin Cities Metro Area Inventory93,819,09993,785,18193,639,03294,087,45395,102,92694,514,744 Total Vacant7,185,9417,200,7306,794,8057,550,3937,600,7167,731,801 Vacancy Rate7.7%7.7%7.3%8.0%8.0%8.2% Absorption65,328(584,021)587,599(337,505)501,0961,266,530 NNN Lease Rate$19.13$19.19$19.11$18.40$17.44$17.93 Delivered100,294298,550526,723284,628629,988334,512 Northeast Submarket Inventory28,991,48528,965,39829,000,54529,200,28329,162,94029,203,002 Vacant SF2,255,0262,214,0132,106,8742,464,7662,510,4092,438,036 Vacancy Rate7.8%7.6%7.3%8.4%8.6%8.3% Absorption(18,829)(321,500)231,193(132,062)52,230555,540 NNN Lease Rate$17.85$17.82$15.41$16.58$14.26$15.62 Delivered062,55295,77897,890222,379173,481 OFFICE MARKET2026 Q120252024202320222021 Twin Cities Metro Area Inventory124,258,063124,478,825125,630,591126,901,052129,670,689129,388,269 Total Vacant26,151,38925,902,69525,163,04121,731,35220,903,79419,466,344 Vacancy Rate21.0%20.8%20.0%17.1%16.1%15.0% Absorption(324,973)(764,362)(2,292,240)(1,803,727)(1,405,520)(2,814,890) FSG Lease Rate$28.13$28.17$27.60$26.76$26.08$25.34 Delivered01,500,270459,400554,121869,305755,886 Northeast Submarket Inventory22,719,63622,722,85823,089,04523,106,53322,830,51022,554,709 Vacant SF1,364,5681,391,8051,660,9261,733,0741,866,8592,002,194 Vacancy Rate6.0%6.1%7.2%7.5%8.2%8.9% Absorption18,48570,47717,931(10,356)(101,578)(419,053) FSG Lease Rate$24.82$24.45$23.40$23.05$21.99$21.55 Delivered09,3600104,05050,20290,147 Sources: REDI CRE; MNCAR; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 56 Workshop Packet Page Number 198 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS As of the first quarter of 2026, the tracked inventory contained 218.1 million square feet of commercial real estate in the Metro Area, 57% of which is office space and 43% is retail. There were 33.3 million square feet vacant in the Metro Area, representing a combined vacancy rate of 15.3%. Retail properties were 7.7% vacant while office buildings were 21.0% vacant. Commercial real estate vacancies have trended higher over the past five years, climbing steadily from 12.1% in 2021 to 15.2% in 2025. With a combined total of 51.7 million square feet of space, the Northeast Submarket contains 24(retail and office) inventory. The 56% retail and 44% office. The combined vacancy rate in the Northeast Submarket is lower than the Metro Area, and Submarket vacancies have declined steadily over the past five years, decreasing from 8.6% in 2021 to 7.0% in the first quarter of 2025. Retail Market Trends | Metro Area vs. Northeast Submarket Metro Area retail absorption outpaced deliveries from 2021 through 2024 causing vacancy rates to decrease from 8.2% in 2021 to 7.3% in 2024 as 2.0 million square feet were absorbed against the delivery of 1.8 million square feet. Absorption turned negative in 2025 (-584,021 square feet) as 298,550 square feet of space were delivered which drove the vacancy rate up to 7.7%. During the first quarter of 2026, 65,328 square feet were absorbed against the delivery of 100,294 square feet. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 57 Workshop Packet Page Number 199 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Lease rates increased steadily during that time period, climbing 6.7% to $19.13 per square foot (psf) NNN during the first quarter of 2026. Retail vacancy rates in the Northeast Submarket have tracked consistently with the Metro Area, declining from 8.3% in 2021 to 7.8% in the first quarter of 2026. Retail absorption has fluctuated over the past five years in the Northeast Submarket, averaging 77,080 square feet of absorption annually. A total of 652,080 square feet were delivered in the submarket since 2021, averaging 130,416 square feet of new space per year. Suburban retail demand is being driven, in large part, by food and service-based operators along with fitness, experiential, and specialty retailers. Office Market Trends | Metro Area vs. Northeast Submarket The Metro Area office market has faced persistent challenges in recent years, with vacancy climbing from 15.0% in 2021 to 20.8% in 2025 and 21.0% in the first quarter of 2026 after negative absorption occurred every year. Office market absorption experienced -9.4 million square feet of net losses during that time period, ranging from -2.8 million square feet in 2021 to -764,362 square feet in 2025. Despite weak leasing fundamentals, average quoted lease rates steadily increased, climbing 11% from $25.34 psf FSG (Full-Service Gross) in 2021 to $28.17 psf FSG in 2025. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 58 Workshop Packet Page Number 200 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS New deliveries have been moderate, averaging about 659,678 square feet annually before 1.5 million square feet were delivered in 2025. Office market conditions in the Northeast Submarket contradict Metro Area trends, as vacancy in the Submarket declined steadily from 8.9% in 2021 to 6.0% in the first quarter of 2026. While absorption has been modest, the Submarket experienced positive absorption of office space in 2024, 2025, and the first quarter of 2026, while just 9,360 square feet were delivered during that time period. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 59 Workshop Packet Page Number 201 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Rent growth in the Submarket is outperforming the Metro Area, as quoted lease rates increased 15%, climbing from $21.55 FSG in 2021 to $24.82 FSG in the first quarter of 2026. At an average lease rate of $24.82 FSG in the first quarter of 2026, office space in the Northeast Submarket is -12% more affordable than the Metro Area ($28.13 FSG). While the office market is facing structural demand declines (likely reflecting remote work impacts), office demand is generally being driven by smaller tenants seeking modern spaces in well-located buildings that offer a high level of amenities. Maplewood Commercial Real Estate Market Overview Maxfield Research compiled secondary data on the existing inventory of commercial real estate (retail, office) in the City of Maplewood and the surrounding trade area. Key market indicators include total supply, vacancies, pricing and development trends. The following tables and related points summarize key data sourced from the MNCAR commercial property exchange via of retail and office space, including smaller owner-occupied buildings. As a result, direct comparisons to the previously summarized submarket vacancy trends are not applicable. There are 290 commercial real estate properties in the City of Maplewood, totaling 11.7 million square feet of space. As illustrated above, 63% of the commercial real estate properties in Maplewood are classified as retail, while 37% are considered office. However, based on total square feet, 36% of the commercial real estate space in Maplewood is retail and 64% is office space. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 60 Workshop Packet Page Number 202 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Maplewood Retail Market Conditions The following summarizes retail space listed as available for lease or for sale in Maplewood and the surrounding trade area as of June 2026. This data is provided to show the types and amount of available space at the time of our survey in addition to pricing. Information was Retail Inventory Marketed for Lease Listed Vacancy 184 49,772 SF 1.2% properties in Maplewood vacant Tight retail leasing environment overall 4.2M SF total 16 lease listings The following graph illustrates retail distribution by category (i.e. neighborhood center, strip center) as classified in the MNCAR Exchange. The largest number of properties are classified as restaurants with 24 (19% of all properties), followed by freestanding buildings with 32 (17%) and strip centers (15%). On a square footage basis, big box stores represent the largest portion of the inventory at 1.3 million square feet (30% of the total), followed by community/specialty centers at 735,185 square feet (18%). The average retail building in Maplewood is 22,869 square feet, with average sizes ranging from 5,278 square feet for restaurants to 454,117 square feet for regional center. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 203 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS As of June 2026, there are 16 suites listed as available for lease on the Exchange in Maplewood, totaling 49,772 square feet of space representing a 1.2% retail vacancy rate, lower than the trade area (3.0% vacant). Table 24 As illustrated in the following graph, the portion of Woodbury located in the trade area contains the largest concentration of vacant space with 152,710 square feet for lease (35% of the available space in the trade area). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 62 Workshop Packet Page Number 204 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The following figure illustrates retail vacancies by category, including vacancy rate and vacant square feet. With 105,619 square feet of space available, strip centers provide the largest opportunity for retailers seeking space in the trade area, followed by big box properties with 86,350 square feet available and community/specialty centers with 80,671 square feet available. Vacancy rates are highest among grocery anchored neighborhood centers at 20.0%, followed by strip centers at 6.3% and freestanding buildings at 5.4%. Commercial leases are generally net leases. In addition to the base rent for occupancy, net leases (also commonly referred to as triple-net or NNN leases) require that the lessee pays maintenance and operating expenses such as taxes, insurance, utilities, and repairs. A gross lease requires that the tenant pay a fixed rent with the landlord covering all other expenses. Based on information available, quoted lease rates for retail space in Maplewood ranges from $14.00 psf to $32.08, averaging $24.89 psf compared to an average of $19.37 across the trade area. There are also two suites available within Maplewood Mall that are not listed on the Exchange. Maxfield was unable to obtain square footage information from management team. Additionally, we understand that the former Sears space (170,348 square feet) is currently unoccupied, but the property is no longer listed as available after being acquired in 2023. Including the Sears space in our vacancy analysis increases retail vacancy rate to 5.2%. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 63 Workshop Packet Page Number 205 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS In addition to space available for lease, we identified tworetail properties in Maplewood marketed for sale. These twoproperties total 21,218square feet of space and are being marketed at an average asking price of $290psf. Asking prices range from $1.4 millionto $4.7million ($229psf to $314psf). Maplewood RetailInventoryMap MAP KEY Retail Property Available Suite MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 64 Workshop Packet Page Number 206 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Retail Sales Trends The following summarizes gross sales along with the number of business establishments in the Retail sector in the City of Maplewood compared to the larger seven-county Twin Cities Metro Area from 2020 through 2024 (the most recent data available). Information is sourced from the Minnesota Department of Revenue, Tax Research Division. Table 25 Gross Retail sales in Maplewood increased 41% during the five-year span from 2020 to 2024, averaging 7.7% growth annually during that period, outpacing Metro Area sales growth (26% increase, 5.1% average annual growth during that same five-year period). - Other sectors of the economy are outperforming Retail in Maplewood, as total gross sales jumped 56% from 2020 to 2024. Total sales in the Metro Area expanded 24% during that period. As of 2024, there were 303 retail establishments in Maplewood. From 2020 to 2024, the number of retail businesses reporting sales in the City declined -5% (-15 establishments) compared to a -4% decline in the Metro Area. At $6.4 million in average sales per establishment, sales in Maplewood are much higher than the Metro Area ($3.9 million per establishment). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 65 Workshop Packet Page Number 207 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Average sales per establishment increased 9.0% annually, on average, in Maplewood compared to 6.0% average annual growth in the Metro Area from 2020 to 2024. The following summarizes sales data for the various Retail Trade subsectors in Maplewood in 2024 compared to 2020. Information for Food Services and Drinking Places is also provided. Note some retail categories were reclassified between 2020 and 2024 (i.e. Furniture and Electronics stores were separate in 2020 but grouped together as Furniture, Electronics, and Appliances in 2024). Between 2020 and 2024, several categories added business establishments, with the largest growth occurring among Food and Beverage stores (+14 businesses, 47% growth). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 66 Workshop Packet Page Number 208 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Table 26 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 67 Workshop Packet Page Number 209 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS During 2024, gross sales were highest at Motor Vehicle and Parts dealers ($920.5 million), followed by General Merchandise stores ($388.1 million) and Food and Beverage stores ($155.5 million) in Maplewood. Motor Vehicle and Parts dealers generate the highest average sales per establishment at nearly $30.7 million, followed by General Merchandise stores at $21.6 million. Most categories experienced increases in average sales per establishment between 2020 and 2024, with the strongest growth occurring in General Merchandise stores and Food Services and Drinking Places. These gains were partially offset by declines among Food and Beverage stores. We expect that population, household, and employment growth in Maplewood, and the surrounding trade area, will stimulate ongoing consumer demand for retail goods and services. Continued growth in consumer demand will generate demand for retail space. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 68 Workshop Packet Page Number 210 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Maplewood Office Market Conditions The following summarizes office space listed as available for lease or for sale in Maplewood and the surrounding trade area as of June 2026. This data is provided to show the types and amount of available space at the time of our survey in addition to pricing. Information was Office Inventory Marketed for Lease Listed Vacancy 106 22,457 SF 0.3% properties vacant Limited opportunities for office tenants 7.5M SF total 11 lease listings The following graph illustrates the distribution of office space in Maplewood by property type as classified in the MNCAR Exchange. The largest number of properties are classified as general office with 54 (51% of all properties), followed by medical/dental with 33 (31%). On a square footage basis, corporate facilities represent a majority of the entire inventory at 6.2 million square feet (83% of the total), followed by medical/dental properties at 646,569 square feet (9%). Office buildings in Maplewood average 70,519 square feet, with average sizes ranging from 6,497 square feet for mixed use buildings to 413,126 square feet for corporate facilities. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 69 Workshop Packet Page Number 211 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS As of June 2026, there are 11 suites listed as available for lease on the Exchange in Maplewood, totaling 22,457 square feet of space representing a 0.3% office vacancy rate, lower than the Trade area (3.6% vacant). Table 27 As illustrated in the following graph, the portion of Oakdale located in the trade area contains the largest concentration of vacant space with 219,174 square feet for lease (47% of the available space in the trade area). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 70 Workshop Packet Page Number 212 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The following figure illustrates office vacancies in Maplewood by property type, including vacancy rate and vacant square feet. With 245,220 square feet of space available, general office properties provide the largest opportunity for tenants seeking space in the trade area, followed by corporate facilities and medical/dental buildings with 141,152 square feet and 67,409 square feet available, respectively. Vacancy rates are highest among general office buildings at 6.4%, followed by mixed use buildings at 5.0% and medical/dental properties at 3.4%. Based on information available, quoted lease rates for office space in Maplewood ranges from $9.00 psf to $23.02, averaging $15.55 psf compared to an average of $15.57 across the trade area. Excluding Corporate Facilities (i.e. 3M), which are fully occupied in the community and 1.8% vacant. In addition to space available for lease, we identified four office buildings in Maplewood marketed for sale. These four properties total 25,961 square feet of space and are being marketed at an average asking price of $156 psf. Asking prices range from $650,000 to $1.5 million ($147 psf to $165 psf). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 71 Workshop Packet Page Number 213 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS Maplewood Office Inventory Map MAP KEY Office Property Available Suite MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 72 Workshop Packet Page Number 214 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Office-Using Business Growth by Type of Business The following summarizes the distribution of businesses that are typical users of office space by number of employees in Maplewood in 2019 and 2023, the most recent data available. Sectors that typically occupy office space include Information; Finance and Insurance; Real Estate and Rental and Leasing; Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services; Management of Companies; Educational Services; and Health Care and Social Assistance. Growth in these sectors is an important indicator of total demand for office space, and business size data indicates the type and size of space required. The data is extracted from the Business Register, a database of all known employer companies which is maintained and updated by the Census Bureau. Information is available at the County level, as well as for ZIP Code tabulation areas, so information for Maplewood is based on the 55109 and 55119 ZIP Code boundaries, which encompass much of the city as well as portions of North St. Paul, Saint Paul, and Oakdale. Due to data suppression, the total number of businesses by size range may vary from the industry totals presented in the tables. Table 28 OFFICE-USING BUSINESS ESTABLISHMENTS BY INDUSTRY AND SIZE MAPLEWOOD (55109, 55119 ZIP CODES) 2019 & 2023 2019---------- EMPLOYEE SIZE RANGE ---------- Year10- 20- 50- 100-250-500-1,000 Industry Sector1-45-9194999249499999or + Total 2023 Information1000000000 17 Finance & Insurance4884040000 67 Real Estate & Rental & Leasing5837000000 70 Professional, Scientific, Technical Svcs.671312400000 96 Management of Companies000000000 5 Educational Services403000000 16 Health Care & Social Assistance1041015639137000 323 Total:2911258243177000594 2019 Information645000000 17 Finance & Insurance3994040000 61 Real Estate & Rental & Leasing5685000000 74 Professional, Scientific, Technical Svcs.761213300000 104 Management of Companies000000000 5 Educational Services033000000 18 Health Care & Social Assistance9178653658000 288 Total:268114953998000567 Numbers may not add due to data suppression Sources: Census Bureau, County Business Patterns; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 73 Workshop Packet Page Number 215 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS The number of Maplewood businesses (based on ZIP Code tabulation areas) in these categories expanded 5% from 567 in 2019 to 594 in 2023. The Health Care and Social Assistance sector experienced the largest growth between 2019 and 2023, adding 35 businesses (12% growth), followed by Finance and Insurance which added six businesses (10% growth). These gains were partially offset by decreases in the Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services, Real Estate, and Educational Services sectors. As of 2023, the Health Care and Social Assistance sector covered 323 businesses (54% of all the businesses in the office-using sectors) followed by Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services with 96 businesses (16%). Of the office-using businesses in the area, 52% had fewer than five employees (291 businesses), 22% had between five and nine workers (125), and 15% had between 10 and 19 workers (82). Between 2019 and 2023, the largest growth occurred among businesses with fewer than five employees, adding 23 businesses (9% growth). Health Care and Social Assistance added 13 establishments with fewer than five employees while Finance and Insurance added nine. On a percentage basis, growth was strongest among businesses with between 50 and 99 employees, increasing 89% with the addition of eight establishments. All of this growth occurred in the Health Care and Social Assistance sector. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 74 Workshop Packet Page Number 216 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS According to commercial real estate services firm Cushman & Wakefield, the average amount of office space per employee in the United States ranges from 150 to 250 square feet depending on geography and industry. Office space utilization declined steadily from 197 square feet in 2010 to 182 square feet leading up to the COVID-19 pandemic, although that trend has stabilized post-pandemic. Business size range data indicates that the largest portion of office users in Maplewood are likely to require smaller spaces, although a portion of the establishments with fewer than five employees may be in home offices. Based on an average of 175 square feet per employee, 52% of businesses in Maplewood would require less than 700 square feet of space, while 22% would need between 875 and 1,575 square feet. These two size ranges increased by 9% and 10%, respectively, between 2019 and 2023. Another 15% of these business establishments would require roughly 1,750 to 3,325 square feet, while 8% need from 3,500 to 8,575 square feet and 3% would require between 8,750 and 17,325 square feet of office space. Based on these business growth trends, it appears that office demand in Maplewood is strongest among firms requiring smaller spaces, particularly in the Health Care and Social Assistance sector. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 75 Workshop Packet Page Number 217 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Pending Commercial Developments The following summarizes the amount of commercial space currently under construction or planned in Maplewood. Additionally, Maxfield Research and Consulting compiled information on actively-marketing projects identified as under construction or proposed in the trade area. Information was sourced from the City of Maplewood and the MNCAR commercial property exchange. As summarized below, there are three commercial developments pending in Maplewood, totaling nearly 193,000 square feet of new space. These projects are factored into our demand calculations presented later in this report. - Seven Brews Coffee is drive-thru retail operation currently under construction at 2982 White Bear Avenue. The project includes a 510-square-foot building, a 388-square-foot remote cooler, and a trash enclosure. - Café Zupas has approval to construct a new 2,886-square-foot retail building at 3069 White Bear Avenue. - MHealth Fairview has been approved to construct a 189,600-square-foot expansion to the existing 370,000-square-foot facility at 1575 Beam Avenue. In total, there are 14 pending commercial developments in the trade area, totaling 486,673 square feet of space. Aside from these three projects in Maplewood, there are 11 actively-marketing projects, totaling 293,677 square feet, pending elsewhere in the trade area. Within the trade area, there are nine pending retail projects totaling 97,233 square feet (20% of the pending commercial supply) and five office developments totaling 389,440 square feet (80% of the pending supply). Two of these pending developments are under construction, totaling 2,835 square feet, including the 510-square-foot Seven Brews Coffee in Maplewood and a 2,325-square-foot Chipotle in Oakdale. The 12 remaining projects (483,838 square feet) are either approved or proposed. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 76 Workshop Packet Page Number 218 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Table 29 PENDING COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENTS MAPLEWOOD TRADE AREA June 2026 PROJECT/ADDRESSCITYSIZE (SQ. FT.)STATUSDESCRIPTION Retail Seven Brews CoffeeMaplewood510Under Const.Drive-thru 2982 White Bear Ave Café ZupasMaplewood2,886ApprovedRestaurant 3069 White Bear Ave ChipotleOakdale2,325Under Const.Restaurant 3480 HighPoint Dr N 4FRONT RetailOakdale13,465ProposedFreestanding High Point Dr N Oakdale MarketplaceOakdale12,000ProposedGrocery-Anchored Hwy 5 7 Ideal AveNeighborhood 810 Maryland Ave ESaint Paul50,094ProposedFreestanding 810 Maryland Ave E Hoffman Corners IIWhite Bear Lake2,760ProposedStrip Center 1656 County Rd E E Woodbury Village OutparcelWoodbury8,800ProposedStrip Center 7040 Valley Creek Plz Valley Creek CommonsWoodbury4,393ProposedStrip Center 6949 Valley Creek Rd Office/Other Saint John's HospitalMaplewood189,600ApprovedMedical 1575 Beam AveHospital Expansion 4FRONT Technology & Office Campus 4Oakdale140,000ProposedCorporate Facility 3510 Hopkins Pl N Willow Marsh Office Park Outlot CWhite Bear Lake15,600ProposedMixed Use Linden Ave Woodbury Central OfficeWoodbury34,240ProposedGeneral 1806 Wooddale Dr Cornerstone Medical Specialty Centre IIWoodbury10,000ProposedMedical/Dental 6025 Lake Rd Trade Area Total:486,673 Sources: City of Maplewood; REDI CRE; MNCAR; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 77 Workshop Packet Page Number 219 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS MARKET TRENDS Actively-Marketing Commercial Land Sites The following summarizes commercial land sites listed for sale in the trade area as of June 2026. This data is provided to show the amount of land and pricing of land listed for sale for future commercial development. Information was sourced from the MNCAR commercial Listings Land Supply Pricing 21 139.6 $852,132 trade area total acres average list price 5 in Maplewood 6.65 average acres $6.61 psf average We identified 21 land listings in the trade area marketed for potential commercial development, totaling 139.6 acres (6.08 million square feet). These land sites range in size from 0.63-acre (27,443 square feet) to 30.41 acres (1.32 million square feet), averaging 6.65 acres (289,633 square feet). Five of the sites are located in Maplewood, totaling 46.8 acres (2.0 million square feet). The average size of available land sites in Maplewood is 9.4 acres. Based on properties with pricing information available, the average list price for these land sites is $852,132, equating to an average land price of $288,126 per acre and $6.61 per square foot. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 78 Workshop Packet Page Number 220 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMANDANALYSISMARKET TRENDS Maplewood Available Land Sites MAP KEY LandListing MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 79 Workshop Packet Page Number 221 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Demand Estimates Introduction Previous sections of this study analyzed demographic and economic trends that drive demand for commercial real estate along with commercial real estate market conditions. Additionally, the overall supply of hotel rooms and commercial real estate (land and buildings) in Maplewood and the surrounding trade area was evaluated. Based on these findings, we estimate demand for future commercial real estate development in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050. This section of the analysis provides detailed demand calculations for the following commercial real estate product types. Hotel rooms Retail space Office space MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 80 Workshop Packet Page Number 222 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Calculation of Hotel Room Demand The following summarizes our demand estimates for additional hotel rooms in Maplewood from 2026 to 2050. In general, demand for hotel rooms comes primarily from three sources, including leisure travelers, people visiting the area for special gatherings (i.e. weddings, reunions), and commercial travelers (i.e. regular business travelers). According to HotStats, a global provider of hotel industry market intelligence, the average break-even occupancy rate for hotels in the United States is 37%, ranging from 34% for luxury hotels to 39% for extended-stay and select-service properties. A 65% to 70% occupancy rate is commonly cited as equilibrium for hotels. However, the older age and lower cost basis of many existing properties in the trade area suggest that profitability can be achieved at lower occupancy levels. Equilibrium represents the and demand are balanced, allowing for a stable ADR. As of year-end 2025, there were a total of 662,475 annual room nights available in the trade area and 419,653 rooms were sold (demand) equating to an annual occupancy rate of 63.3%. Table 30 HOTEL DEMAND ESTIMATES CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2026 - 2031 EXISTING---------- PROJECTIONS ---------- 20252026203020402050 Annual Room Night Supply¹662,475662,475662,475662,475662,475 2 Annual Room Night Demand419,653428,046463,331564,798688,485 Leisure188,844192,621208,499254,159309,818 Group62,94864,20769,50084,720103,273 Commercial167,861171,218185,332225,919275,394 3 Additional Room Nights Needed--050,342206,445396,733 Estimated Market Occupancy63.3%64.6%65.0%65.0%65.0% 4 Demand Potential (Rooms)--01385661,087 1 Based on competitive set of properties in trade area. 2 Projected room night demand assumes 2.0% average annual growth and room night demand will be split at 45% leisure market, 15% group market, and 40% business travelers. 3 Additional room nights needed to maintain target occupancy rate of 65.0% 4 Rooms needed to maintain target occupancy rate of 65.0% Sources: Kalibri Labs LLC; Maxfield Research & Consulting Assuming the room night supply holds steady and annual room night demand increases 2.0% annually between 2026 and 2050, total demand potential will exceed supply by 2050 unless additional rooms are delivered. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 81 Workshop Packet Page Number 223 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES To maintain equilibrium (65.0% occupancy) in the trade area, 138 rooms will need to be added to the inventory by 2030. Based on an assumption that no additional rooms get delivered, 566 additional rooms will be needed by 2040 and 1,087 additional rooms will be needed by 2050 to maintain equilibrium in the market. These demand estimates indicate that there is sufficient market support for a new hotel in Maplewood. Retail Development Potential Demand for additional retail space, measured in gross leasable space in square feet, is calculated in the table on the following page which combines demand information with supply to calculate the amount of retail space supportable in the communtiy. The retail demand calculation begins with Maplewood household growth projections combined with an estimate of the total expenditures for retail goods and services, excluding expenditures for automobiles, homes, finance and insurance, education, and travel. Due to growth in the household base, projected increases in household income, and accounting for inflation, overall retail expenditures by local residents are expected to increase between 2026 and 2050. Accounting for inflation and for anticipated growth in online spending, we anticipate that the average retail sales per square foot will increase from an estimated $325 in 2026 to $523 by 2050. The retail sales per square foot metric reflects an average across all shopping types. The primary source of demand for new retail space in Maplewood will be generated by household and consumer expenditure growth in the community. However, we understand that retail demand will also be generated by households outside of Maplewood. We estimate that 30% of the demand potential will be generated by sources other than Maplewood households. We estimate that there will be demand for 99,651 square feet of new retail space in Maplewood between 2026 and 2030. We then subtract retail space under construction or approved from the 2026 to 2030 demand potential in Maplewood. Overall, we find excess demand for 281,086 square feet of new retail space in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050, equating to 11,712 square feet of new space annually. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 82 Workshop Packet Page Number 224 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES Table 31 Based on a typical Floor Area Ratio (FAR) for retail development of 0.20, we estimate that approximately 32 acres of land will be needed to support the projected demand for retail space by 2050 in Maplewood, equating to 1.3 acres of land absorption on an annual basis. These estimates reflect demand growth generated from local households for neighborhood- and community-oriented goods and services. Additional retail space could potentially be supported if the retail tenant mix consisted of destination-oriented retailers that are unique to the area and would draw customers from a larger trade area. Office Development Potential This section focuses on factors that influence demand for office space, primarily business and employment growth. The amount (in square feet) of additional office space supportable in Maplewood is based on projected employment growth, particularly among the sectors that typically utilize office space. Our demand calculations are shown in the following table and are summarized in the following points. The demand calculations begin by evaluating the total number of jobs in Maplewood and estimating the proportion of those jobs which were in typical office-using industries. To account for jobs in hospitals and schools that typically do not require office space, these calculations exclude 50% of employment in the Education and Health Services sector. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 83 Workshop Packet Page Number 225 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES These percentages are projected to increase modestly as the greatest job growth over the next several years in the Metro Area according to MN DEED will be among industries that often require office space, such as Education and Health Services, Professional and Business Services, and Financial Activities. Not all of the office-using jobs created will seek or want space in office buildings, so we adjust the number of employees likely working in office space to account for the proportion of office-using businesses with fewer than five employees. The majority of these businesses are likely one- or two-person businesses, with many operating from home-based offices. According to commercial real estate services firm Cushman & Wakefield, the amount of office space per employee ranges from 150 to 250 square feet depending on geography and industry. The average amount of office space per employee in the United States declined steadily from 197 square feet in 2010 to 182 square feet leading up to the COVID-19 pandemic, although that trend has stabilized post-pandemic. We multiply the estimated number of employees in office space by an industry standard of 175 square feet of office space per job, resulting in the estimated demand for office space in 2026. Multiplying this office space per employee metric by the number of employees estimated to require office space for each time period reveals the projected growth in demand for office space between 2026 and 2050. Table 32 DEMAND FOR OFFICE SPACE CITY OF MAPLEWOOD 2026 to 2050 2026203020402050 Total Jobs25,12528,30029,80031,900 (times) % jobs in industries requiring office spacex47.6%47.9%48.6%49.3% (equals) Projected number of office-occupying jobs=11,96913,56014,48515,730 (times) % of jobs seeking/needing office space^x83%83%83%83% (equals) Projected # of employees in office space=9,93411,25512,02313,056 (times) Square feet of office space per employeex175175175175 (equals) Demand for office space (sq. ft.)=1,738,4971,969,5902,103,9462,284,783 (plus) Demand from Outside City+30%30%30%30% (equals) Total Office Space Demand (Sq. Ft.)=2,483,5682,813,7003,005,6383,263,975 OFFICE DEMAND GROWTH BY TIME PERIOD2026 - 20302030 - 20402040 - 2050 Office Space Demand Growth by Time Period (sq. ft.)330,133191,938258,338 (minus) Pending office space (sq. ft.)-000 Excess demand for office space (sq. ft.)330,133191,938258,338 Total Excess Office Demand (Sq. Ft.) 2026 to 2050780,408 ^Percent seeking office space versus home offices or retail spaces. Sources: MN DEED; Census Bureau, County Business Patterns; Maxfield Research & Consulting MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 84 Workshop Packet Page Number 226 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS DEMAND ESTIMATES The primary source of demand for new office space in Maplewood will be generated by business and employment growth in the community. However, we understand that office demand (an estimated 30%) will also be generated by businesses outside of Maplewood seeking opportunities to relocate or consolidate employees and operations. - We would then subtract any pending office space from the demand potential, but we did not identify any office buildings under construction in Maplewood. Overall, we find excess demand for 780,408 square feet of new office space in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050, equating to 32,517 square feet of new space annually. Based on a typical Floor Area Ratio (FAR) for office development of 0.30, we estimate that approximately 60 acres of land will be needed to support the projected demand for office space by 2050 in Maplewood, equating to 2.5 acres of land absorption on an annual basis. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 85 Workshop Packet Page Number 227 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Site Evaluation Introduction This section of the report provides an evaluation of multiple sites in Maplewood that could be targeted for infill or redevelopment. The list of properties to be evaluated was provided by the City of Maplewood. This analysis presents a summary of the location and general characteristics of each site. Adjacent land uses, accessibility and visibility are addressed, and recommendations regarding the appropriateness of each site for future development are provided. When sites are clustered together in close proximity to one another, the development potential for those locations are analyzed together as a commercial development/redevelopment node. The following components are included. Map of potential development/redevelopment sites in Maplewood Table summarizing salient facts for each property Aerial photographs each site/node Photographs of a select group of properties Summary of land uses, access, and visibility for each site/node General recommendations MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 86 Workshop Packet Page Number 228 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISSITE EVALUATION Site Overview Maplewood Potential Development/Redevelopment Sites MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING87 Workshop Packet Page Number 229 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Table 33 DEVELOPMENT/REDEVELOPMENT SITES CITY OF MAPLEWOOD MAPADDRESS/LOCATIONACRESLAND VALUE*OWNERSHIPTRAFFIC KEYEXISTING LAND USE DESCRIPTIONTOTAL VALUE*ZONINGVOLUME ANW of Bailey Ct at Bailey Rd 76.99$4,967,600PrivateBailey Rd: 17,519 Bailey redevelopment site/undeveloped land$4,967,600Mixed UseSterling St S: 711 B601 Century Ave S 178.1$44,126,700PrivateCentury Ave S: 10,420 Century Ponds residential subdivision$63,196,700Farm ResidentialLower Afton Rd: 9,174 C1300 McKnight Rd N 29.92$5,301,700PrivateLakewood Dr N: 9,985 Industrial site$8,094,900Light Manufacturing D1875 East Shore Drive N 1.91$1,120,000PrivateE Shore Dr: 1,900 American Cooperative$19,507,200Multiple Dwelling E1160 Frost Ave E 3.09$3,000,000PrivateFrost Ave: 3,733 Oberon multifamily residential$36,129,300Multiple Dwelling F1221 Frost Ave E 1.3$495,000PrivateFrost Ave: 3,733 Auto body sites$673,700Mixed Use G1247 Frost Ave0.21$72,000PrivateFrost Ave: 3,733 Little Maintenance/Running Bear Healing Ctr.$168,800Mixed Use H1905 English St N 0.99$343,400PrivateFrost Ave: 3,733 Vacant parcel$343,400Mixed UseEnglish St: 4,755 I1321 Frost Ave E 0.59$153,000PrivateFrost Ave: 3,733 Moose Lodge, adjacent sites$857,100Mixed UseEnglish St: 4,755 J1310 Frost Ave 1.12$1,300,000PrivateFrost Ave: 3,733 Juniper multifamily residential$18,932,300Mixed UseEnglish St: 4,755 K1880 English St N 1.22$1,120,000PrivateEnglish St: 4,755 The Waldo multifamily residential$7,678,000Mixed Use L1351 Frost Ave E1.18$309,500PrivateFrost Ave: 4,319 Maplewood Bakery/Heritage Liquor$682,500Mixed Use M1344 Frost Ave E0.44$114,700PrivateFrost Ave: 4,319 Borchert's Meat Market$710,200Mixed Use N1375 Frost Ave E 0.61$158,400PrivateFrost Ave: 4,319 Gladstone House/Beacon Interfaith$158,400Mixed Use O2055 White Bear Ave 8.88$3,095,000PrivateWhite Bear Ave: 23,675 Multitenant office building$5,081,700Mixed UseProsperity Rd: 2,098 P1830 Co Rd B East 33.08$4,460,300PublicWhite Bear Ave: 23,675 Maplewood City Hall/excess land$8,420,400Farm ResidentialCo. Rd B E: 5,001 Q1745/1751 Cope Ave 2.18$569,800PrivateCope Ave: 3,681 Taste of India/Strauss Skates & Bikes$1,189,800Light Manufacturing R2425 White Bear Ave 9.19$4,804,900PrivateWhite Bear Ave: 25,782 Redeeming Love$7,628,100Limited Business Comm.Gervais Ave: 5,751 S1910 Co Rd C East 2.95$1,440,000PrivateCounty Rd C E: 2,685 Caretta Senior Living$13,963,300Business CommercialWhite Bear Ave: 20,812 T3001 White Bear Ave 68.71$29,083,000PrivateWhite Bear Ave: 19,995 Maplewood Mall/Myth/Former Sears$29,544,600North EndCo. Rd D E: 13,327 Beam Ave: 11,740 Southlawn Dr: 4,953 ---------- continued ---------- MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 88 Workshop Packet Page Number 230 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 89 Workshop Packet Page Number 231 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISSITE EVALUATION Site A(Bailey Redevelopment Site) Aerial Photograph Site Photographs Southeast corner of Site, looking northSoutheast corner of Site, looking west MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING90 Workshop Packet Page Number 232 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISSITE EVALUATION Site B (Century Ponds) Aerial Photograph Site Photographs View of Site from Century AveLooking south at Site from Lower Afton Rd MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING91 Workshop Packet Page Number 233 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISSITE EVALUATION Site C(Industrial Site) Aerial Photograph Site Photographs View of Site from Lakewood DrLooking north across Site MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING92 Workshop Packet Page Number 234 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Sites D N (Frost-English Node) Aerial Photograph Photographs of Selected Sites Site F 1221 Frost Ave E Site H Vacant parcel MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 93 Workshop Packet Page Number 235 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Sites O S (White Bear Avenue-Highway 36 Node) Aerial Photograph Photographs of Selected Sites Site Q 1745/1751 Cope Ave Site R 2425 White Bear Ave MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 94 Workshop Packet Page Number 236 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISSITE EVALUATION Sites TV(Beam AvenueNode) Aerial Photograph Photographs of Selected Sites Site TMaplewood MallSite U Birch Run Station MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING95 Workshop Packet Page Number 237 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Sites W Y (Highway 61 Node) Aerial Photograph Photographs of Selected Sites Site X Manufactured Home Park Site Y Vacant land adjacent to Northernaire Motel MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 96 Workshop Packet Page Number 238 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Site Evaluation Summary & Recommendations The following recommendations are based on our analysis of each site along with our understanding of commercial real estate and housing needs in Maplewood. Site A (Bailey Redevelopment Site) With 77 acres of land positioned for future development, Site A offers the largest development opportunity in Maplewood. Aside from undeveloped land, much of the surrounding area is developed with residential uses. There are also recreational uses in the immediate area (e.g. Carver Lake Park and Beach, Fish Creek Natural Area, Bailey School Forest Park). From a commercial land use perspective, the Site is large enough to support a business park, but the property has inconvenient access and lacks visibility from major highways. Understanding that there is a strong need for housing in Maplewood, we recommend that the Site be designated for residential development, with for-sale detached and attached single- family homes being a priority need. Site B (Century Ponds) The Century Ponds residential subdivision is currently being developed on Site B. When complete, the project will include 133 detached single-family homes and 73 townhome units. While the addition of households occupying these housing units will stimulate additional demand for commercial goods and services, we do not anticipate that the Site will support future commercial development. Site C (Industrial Site) The subject property is an approximately 30-acre parcel currently developed with a 96,500 square-foot industrial building. The property is currently listed for sale as either an industrial use or a redevelopment site. Land uses surrounding the property are predominantly residential, but development. The Heights is a redevelopment of the former Hillcrest Golf Club in Saint Paul. A mix of medium- to high-density residential and light industrial uses are planned for the project. The Site is situated along a railroad track, and the configuration of the property will limit its potential for redevelopment. With good site planning, a multifamily residential development could be a suitable use, although environmental remediation may be required. There is limited opportunity for retail to be developed on the property but it could potentially support commercial operations that do not require high visibility such as industrial services (auto repair, contractors, warehousing, light manufacturing) and appointment-only services. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 97 Workshop Packet Page Number 239 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Sites D-N (Frost-English Node) The Frost-English Node consists of 11 properties, totaling 12.7 acres with individual parcel sizes ranging from 0.44-acre to 3.09 acres. Several of these properties have recently been developed/redeveloped, including Site D (American Cooperative multifamily), Site E (Oberon multifamily), Site J (Juniper multifamily), and Site K (The Waldo multifamily). Also, Beacon Interfaith is proposing to redevelop Site N (1375 Frost Ave E) for a 40-unit multitenant apartment building. These parcels are not targets for redevelopment. Properties that could potentially be redevelopment/infill sites include: Site F | 1221 Frost Ave E | 1.3 acres | used for auto body services Site G | 1247 Frost Ave | 0.21-acre | occupied by a small commercial building Site H | 1905 English St N | 1.0 acre | vacant parcel Site I | 1321 Frost Ave E | 0.59-acre | multitenant commercial building Site L | 1351 Frost Ave E | 1.2 acres | multitenant commercial building Site M | 1344 Frost Ave E | 0.44-acre | commercial building (meat market) Existing land uses in the area consist of a mix of commercial and multifamily residential uses along Forst Avenue and English Street, surrounded by residential neighborhoods. There are also recreational uses in the area such as Gladstone Savanna, Gateway Trail, Bruce Vento Trail, Keller Golf Course, and Keller Regional Park. Much of the redevelopment that has occurred in the Frost-English Node has been for multifamily housing, a trend that is likely to continue. Commercial redevelopment should target neighborhood-oriented businesses along with commercial establishments that could target people utilizing the Bruce Vento Trail and the Gateway Trail. Sites I, L, and M are adjacent to the Bruce Vento Trail and Sites F, G, and H are adjacent to or in close proximity to the Gateway Trail. Examples of potential businesses include coffee shops and cafés, bakeries, specialty food, wine and spirit shops, barbershops and hair salons, pharmacies, fitness studios, pet grooming and supplies, bike rental and repair shops, pizzerias, ice cream shops, microbreweries, family- oriented restaurants, fast-casual patios. Sites O-S (White Bear Avenue-Highway 36 Node) The White Bear Avenue-Highway 36 Node consists of five properties, totaling 56 acres with individual parcel sizes ranging from 2.18 acres to 33 acres. Not all of this acreage would be subject to redevelopment, and Site S has recently been developed with Caretta Senior Living. Site P is comprised of Maplewood City Hall and related buildings, but there is excess land owned by the City that could be targeted for infill development. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 98 Workshop Packet Page Number 240 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Properties that could potentially be redevelopment/infill sites include: Site O | 2055 White Bear Ave | 8.88 acres | multitenant office building Site P | 1830 County Rd B East | 33 acres | excess land near City Hall Site Q | 1745/1751 Cope Ave | 2.18 acres | commercial buildings Site R | 2425 White Bear Ave | 9.19 acres | Redeeming Love church Existing land uses in the area are generally commercial along Highway 36 and White Bear Avenue with a mix of single-family and multifamily residential neighborhoods surrounding the commercial corridors. Some of the key destinations near the node include Maplewood City Hall, Maplewood YMCA and community center, Goodrich Golf Course, Aldrich Ice Arena, The Home Depot, Target, and Hy-Vee. Sites O, R, and S are large properties that could accommodate a mix of uses if redeveloped, including residential, retail, and office. Given the location, visibility, and surrounding land uses, Site Q is best suited for retail or office. Commercial redevelopment in the node should target professional office users along with community- and neighborhood-oriented businesses. While multitenant office development is very limited across the Twin Cities Metro Area currently, office vacancy rates in the Northeast Submarket and in Maplewood are low relative to the Metro Area. Sites O and P could potentially support small office/business parks comprised of either multitenant or single-tenant buildings. Examples of potential retail include drive-thru coffee and quick-service restaurants, pet supply stores, discount and apparel stores, specialty food, fitness centers. Demand for office space could be generated by financial and insurance offices, real estate firms, medical and dental clinics, law firms, financial advisors, and technology companies. The node could also potentially accommodate development of a hotel. Sites T-V (Beam Avenue Node) The Beam Avenue Node consists of Maplewood Mall, Myth Nightclub, the former Sears property (Site T), Birch Run Station (Site U), along with the M Health Fairview Hospital properties (Site V). Combined, the three sites total 114 acres, although not all this acreage is subject to redevelopment. Fairview and are not targets for redevelopment. Surrounding land uses are predominantly commercial between Highway 61 and the White Bear Avenue corridor, north of Beam Avenue. There is some multifamily residential in the node, and the area surrounding the node (west of Highway 61, south of Beam Avenue, east of White Bear Avenue) is comprised primarily of residential neighborhoods. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 99 Workshop Packet Page Number 241 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Sites T and U are developed with shopping centers surrounded by surface parking lots. These parking lots are likely underutilized, creating inefficient land use. We recommend that infill opportunities (i.e. outlots, pad sites) be explored in areas of excess parking on both Sites. Because this area , we anticipate that there is market support for hotel rooms in this node. Our demand estimates reveal growing room night demand in the area, and this node represents the top location for new hotel rooms in Maplewood. Examples of other types of uses that could be targeted for infill pad sites include multifamily residential, quick service and fast-casual restaurants, specialty grocers, auto service and parts, specialty retail. Professional office businesses could include healthcare, financial institutions, law firms, real estate companies, and coworking spaces. Additionally, commercial recreation and experiential retailers would likely be drawn to infill opportunities in the area. Examples include bowling, indoor trampoline parks, family entertainment (e.g. arcade, laser tag, mini golf), party venues, fitness centers, indoor sports training facilities, interactive dining (e.g. axe throwing, golf simulators). Sites W-Y (Highway 61 Node) The Highway 61 Node consists of three properties, totaling 27 acres. Site W is currently being developed with a 32-unit senior housing facility and is not a subject for redevelopment. Site X is 11.8 acres and is occupied by the Town & Country Manufactured Home Park. Site Y consists of two parcels (6.0 acres combined), one occupied by the Northernaire Motel and the other is a vacant parcel adjacent to the hotel. Site X consists of 120 manufactured home sites with several vacant pads. Surrounding land uses are predominantly residential to the west and north, with some commercial and institutional uses to the south along Maplewood Drive. There is also a park and ride facility along Maplewood Drive. While the Site has good visibility from Highway 61, access to/from the Site is somewhat limited with a stop-sign controlled intersection at Alvarado Drive and Highway 61. Alternatively, there is a stoplight-controlled intersection at County Road C and Highway 61 which is accessible via Maplewood Drive. Manufactured home parks often provide affordable housing options for residents, and the City could explore opportunities to maximize its land area through reconfiguration or reuse while minimizing displacement of residents. Excess land/lots within the park could be repurposed for concepts like At 11.8 acres, a full redevelopment of the Site could support a mix of uses including residential and highway oriented commercial uses that attract destination or low-turnover businesses. Examples include professional office space (e.g. medical, dental, real estate, insurance, law firms), fitness center, childcare facility, auto dealership, and showrooms. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 100 Workshop Packet Page Number 242 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS SITE EVALUATION Site Y has similar constraints as Site X, with good visibility to Highway 61 but inconvenient access. Consisting of two parcels, site assembly would be beneficial as a redevelopment opportunity for one large property rather than two smaller properties. Suitable land uses would be similar to Site Y, including professional office space, auto dealership, showrooms, and industrial services (auto repair, contractors, warehousing, light manufacturing). Additionally, certain commercial recreation uses could be drawn to the Site, including indoor sports facilities (pickleball, volleyball, rock-climbing), indoor shooting range, and entertainment activities (go- kart racing, laser tag). MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 101 Workshop Packet Page Number 243 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Introduction The previous sections examined demographic, economic, and market trends that drive demand for commercial real estate in Maplewood. Based on the analysis, demand estimates for hotel rooms, retail space, and office space to 2050 are provided. Additionally, the report provides an evaluation of multiple sites in Maplewood that could be targeted for infill or redevelopment, and recommendations are provided on the types of real estate product types that would be most suitable on those sites. Summary Overall, we find that Maplewood is positioned for continued commercial demand, supported by household growth, strengthening consumer expenditures, a large employment base, low reported vacancy among available retail and office listings, and long-term demand for new commercial development. Hotel Demand Retail Demand Office Demand Rooms needed to maintain 281,086 square feet of 780,408 square feet market equilibrium new space (neighborhood- needed by 2050 community-oriented) by ~138 rooms by 2030 2050 ~60 acres of land ~1,087 rooms by 2050 ~32 acres of land Demographic and Economic Demand Drivers -term household growth, aging population, and rising incomes create sustained demand for neighborhood-serving retail, restaurants, personal services, convenience- oriented commercial uses, health care, and professional services. By 2050, the City is projected to add 1,682 households and median household incomes are expected to experienced solid growth. market has stabilized, major employers anchor daytime demand, and daily commuter inflows support restaurants, retail, convenience services, office uses, and lodging. Development activity and market indicators point to continued reinvestment and limited available space. From 2016 through May 2026, Maplewood issued 98 nonresidential permits totaling approximately $445 million, while current listings show very low retail and office vacancy within the City. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 102 Workshop Packet Page Number 244 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Hospitality Demand Outlook The lodging market has strengthened significantly since 2021, with room demand up 30%, occupancy rising to 63.3%, RevPAR up 49%, and total hotel revenue increasing to $46.2 million in 2025. Demand estimates indicate support for additional lodging supply. To maintain market equilibrium of 65%, 138 additional rooms will be needed by 2030, 566 rooms will be needed by 2040, and 1,087 rooms will be needed by 2050. There will be demand for properties that capture both the leisure and business segments. Retail Demand Outlook Retail conditions are favorable, with approximately 4.2 million square feet of inventory, only 49,772 square feet listed for lease, and a 1.2% listed vacancy rate. Retail sales increased 41% from 2020 to 2024, outpacing Metro Area growth. We estimate that there will be demand for 281,086 square feet of new retail space in Maplewood by 2050, requiring approximately 32 acres of land. The strongest opportunities are neighborhood- and community-serving uses such as restaurants, services, convenience retail, fitness, and specialty retail. Office Demand Outlook space, with very limited listed vacancy. Future demand is expected to be strongest for smaller suites, flexible layouts, medical office space, and service-oriented professional offices. The analysis estimates demand for 780,408 square feet of new office space by 2050, requiring listed vacancy and health care-oriented business growth support targeted office development. Land Supply and Development Implications Available commercial land provides some development capacity, but long-term retail and office demand could absorb substantial land by 2050. Strategic redevelopment, adaptive reuse, and infill development will be important to accommodate demand efficiently. Overall Conclusions Maplewood is positioned for additional commercial development, supported by household growth, rising incomes, major employers, low listed vacancy, strengthening lodging performance, and demand for retail, office, and hospitality uses through 2050. The best near- term opportunities are service-oriented retail, food and beverage, convenience uses, medical office, small professional office suites, and lodging. Projects should prioritize strong access, visibility, proximity to employment, and the ability to serve both residents and daytime workers. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 103 Workshop Packet Page Number 245 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Redevelopment Node Opportunities The following summarizes the recommended business types targeted for the various redevelopment sites/nodes. Primary Opportunities Hotels | Strongest fit in the Beam Avenue Node, especially near Maplewood Mall and Saint Also, potentially feasible in the White Bear AvenueHighway 36 Node. Professional Office and Medical Office | Recommended across several nodes, especially White Bear AvenueHighway 36, Beam Avenue, and Highway 61. Suggested users include medical/dental clinics, financial advisors, insurance offices, real estate firms, law firms, and technology companies. Neighborhood-Oriented Retail and Services | Strong fit for the Frost-English Node and White Bear AvenueHighway 36 Node. Examples include coffee shops, cafés, bakeries, specialty food shops, pharmacies, salons/barbershops, pet services, fitness studios, family-oriented restaurants, bike rental/repair. Restaurants and Food/Beverage Businesses | Recommended in multiple nodes, especially where there is neighborhood traffic or regional destination activity. Examples include quick- service restaurants, fast-casual restaurants, pizzerias, patios, ice cream shops, cafés, and microbreweries. Secondary Opportunities Commercial Recreation and Experiential Businesses | Best suited for the Beam Avenue Node and potentially the Highway 61 Node. Examples include bowling, trampoline parks, arcades, laser tag, mini golf, indoor sports training, golf simulators, axe throwing, pickleball, volleyball, rock climbing, and go-kart racing. Specialty Retail | Suitable particularly for Beam Avenue, White Bear AvenueHighway 36, and trail-adjacent Frost-English sites. Examples include specialty grocers, apparel/discount stores, bike rental and repair, pet supply, and specialty food. Highway-Oriented Commercial | Most relevant to the Highway 61 Node, where visibility is good, but access is less convenient. Examples include auto dealerships, showrooms, fitness centers, childcare facilities, and destination-oriented businesses. Industrial Services/Light Industrial | Appropriate only in select locations with lower visibility or redevelopment constraints, such as Site C. Examples include auto repair, contractors, warehousing, light manufacturing, and appointment-only services. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 104 Workshop Packet Page Number 246 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Job Creation Based on our demand projections, we provide job creation estimates by real estate product type. The job creation estimates are derived from standard industry metrics regarding the average number of square feet/rooms per employee. - Based on a United States Department of Energy survey, there is an average of 945 square feet per worker in retail and services buildings. - As previously noted, an industry standard benchmark in office space is 175 square feet per employee. - According to various industry resources, hotel staffing ratios vary by hotel class. For example, limited service and economy hotels generate roughly 0.25 to 0.4 jobs per room, while mid-scale and full-service facilities generate 0.5 to 1.0 jobs per room. Upscale and luxury properties have a staffing ratio of approximately 1.2 to 2.0+ jobs per room. For the purposes of this analysis, we use a blended ratio of 0.75 jobs per room. As depicted in the following table, the 281,086 square feet of retail space needed in Maplewood between 2026 and 2050 would accommodate approximately 297 jobs. The addition of 780,408 square feet of office space in the community would support an estimated 4,459 jobs. Based on a need for 1,087 hotel rooms by 2050, we estimate that new hotels would require 815 jobs. Table 34 In total, we project that Maplewood could support roughly 1.1 million square feet of new commercial space between 2026 and 2050 along with 1,087 rooms, which could accommodate roughly 5,572 new jobs. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 105 Workshop Packet Page Number 247 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATEDEMAND ANALYSISCONCLUSIONS Target Industries We suggestMaplewooddevelop a cluster-based strategy in business recruitment efforts. Cluster development is a tool for improving regional competitiveness by actively pursuing industry sectors where Maplewoodhas a distinct competitive advantage. Companies that locate in a cluster benefit from collaboration and innovation, a skilled labor force, and coordinated efforts that can reduce overhead through economics of scale. These advantages often result in greater potential for employment growth and wealth creation. Thefollowinginformationdepictsemployment forecastsby industry sectorfrom 2022to 2032, the most recent available,in the Twin Cities compared to projected growth rates in Minnesota and the United States. The data was compiled from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statisticsand the Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development. Employment Growth Projections by Industry 2022 to 2032 MNUSTwin Cities 12.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% -4.0% -6.0% Job growth in the Metro Area (4.9%) from 2022 to 2032 is projected to exceed the rate of growth in Minnesota (4.6%) and the United States (2.8%). Employment in the service-providing industry sectors is projected to expand at faster rate than the goods-producing sectors, increasing 5.4% between 2022 and 2032 compared to 3.4% growth in the goods-producing industries. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING106 Workshop Packet Page Number 248 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Job growth is projected to be strongest in the Health Care and Social Assistance sector. Other service-providing sectors projected to experience strong growth include Transportation and Warehousing, Information, and Professional and Business Services. Among the goods-producing sectors, the Construction sector is projected to add the most jobs, followed by Natural Resources and Mining. Table 35 The following table depicts the high wage industry sectors that are expected to experience strong job growth between 2022 and 2032 in the Metro Area, as projected by MN DEED. As defined by MN DEED, high growth/high pay industries are those that represent at least 0.1% of total employment in 2022, have an annual median salary which is higher than the average for 2022, and are projected to grow at a rate which is higher than the average growth rate. As presented in the table, Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services related industries represent 24% of the top high growth/high pay job growth industries in the Metro Area from 2022 to 2032. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 107 Workshop Packet Page Number 249 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS These Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services related industries, which had an average annual salary of $113,031 in 2022, are projected to experience 12.7% job growth between 2022 and 2032, adding an estimated 14,429 jobs in the Metro Area. Other high pay industries that are projected to experience above-average growth across multiple sectors include Wholesale Trade, Information, Health Care, Manufacturing, Construction, and Finance and Insurance. Based on the median annual salary in 2022, highest-paying industry sectors among these high-growth industries include Insurance Carriers ($142,064), Scientific Research and Development Services ($141,804), Data Processing and Related Services ($138,788), Computer Systems Design and Related Services ($136,448), and Management and Technical Consulting Services ($132,964). Table 36 MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 108 Workshop Packet Page Number 250 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Economic Development Initiatives Economic development initiatives support the growth and development of business through matching grants, loans and training programs. Economic development programs available Tax Increment Financing Tax increment financing (TIF) is a planning and financing tool used by local governments to fund infrastructure and redevelopment. TIF uses future gains in property tax revenues, generated when a new project increases local property values, to pay for current development costs. Ramsey County Open to Business Program Open to Business is a partnership between Ramsey County and the Metropolitan Consortium of Community Developers (MCCD) and provides direct technical assistance and other forms of support to small business owners and entrepreneurs at no cost. All current business owners and aspiring entrepreneurs intending to establish, purchase, or improve a business within the county are eligible and encouraged to participate. Emerging Entrepreneur Loan Program The Minnesota Emerging Entrepreneur Loan Program (ELP) supports the growth of businesses owned and operated by minorities, low-income persons, women, veterans, and/or persons with disabilities. DEED provides grant funds to a network of nonprofit lenders, which use them to make loans to startup and expanding businesses throughout the state. Launch Minnesota Grants Launch Minnesota is a statewide collaborative effort to accelerate the growth of startups and amplify Minnesota as a national leader in innovation. The resources will focus on innovative, scalable startups. The Innovation Grant reimburses business expenses incurred in Minnesota for research and development, direct business expenses (including employee wages), and the purchase of technical assistance and services. State Small Business Credit Initiative (SSBCI) The SSBCI consists of six programs to support small businesses in the state. These include the Automation Loan Participation Program, the Growth Loan Fund, the Minnesota Loan Guarantee Program, the Small Business Loan Participation Program, Direct Investment Venture Capital, and Multi-Fund Venture Capital. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 109 Workshop Packet Page Number 251 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Underutilized Business Program The Metropolitan Council Underutilized Business (MCUB) program is designed to engage and promote businesses vying for Met Council projects and procurements that are owned and operated by women, Black, Indigenous, Hispanic, and Asian people, veterans, and people with disabilities. Disadvantaged Business Enterprise Program The Disadvantaged Business Enterprise Program helps level the playing field for Black-, Indigenous-, Hispanic-, Asian-, and women-owned businesses, ensuring they have the opportunity to compete for federally funded contracts. Learn more about the Disadvantaged Business Enterprise Program. Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development (DEED) The Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development funds certified nonprofit partners to provide loans to businesses across Minnesota. The program promotes private investment, supports job creation for minority and low-income individuals, strengthens minority-owned businesses, and advances economic development in low-income communities. As the competition for economic development has become global, it is important to maintain a needs will better enable communities to attract business growth. Some companies are unwilling to wait for a community to develop a site and will seek site locations in communities that are shovel-ready. Shovel-ready sites are a benefit to companies and site selectors because they reduce time, expense, and some risk out of the real estate development process. Furthermore, these sites tend to reduce overall development costs for cost-conscious companies. DEED has implemented a Certified Shovel-Ready site program that markets these properties at a national- level. After reviewing sites across Minnesota that are certified, there are currently six shovel-ready certified sites in the Twin Cities Metro Area, with the nearest being three parcels in The Heights, adjacent to Maplewood in Saint Paul. These three parcels total 18.4 acres. We recommend Maplewood consider promoting future redevelopment opportunities under this program to increase market exposure. The Minnesota Investment Fund (MIF) is available through DEED to provide financing to help add new workers and retain quality jobs in Minnesota, focusing on industrial, manufacturing, and technology-related industries. Funds are rewarded to local units of government who then provide loans to assist business expansion. Maplewood could consider applying for MIF funds to enhance an economic development package for specific expansion or relocation projects. MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 110 Workshop Packet Page Number 252 of 253 E1, Attachment 2 MAPLEWOOD COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEMAND ANALYSIS CONCLUSIONS Other Potential Programs We recommend that the City of Maplewood collaborate with other economic development organizations to identify creative incentive policies to attract commercial development and investment. The following summarizes some potential other incentives and programs that Business retention visits Commercial Storefront/Façade Improvement Program MN DEED Main Street Economic Revitalization Program Revolving Loan Fund Tax Abatement Other State and Federal loan grants MAXFIELD RESEARCH AND CONSULTING 111 Workshop Packet Page Number 253 of 253 For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Director of Research Maplewood Housing and Commercial Market Outlook Prepared for:Maplewood City CouncilPresented by: Joe Hollman Maxfield Research & Consulting September 2026 For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment ResidentialCommercial/Industrial Public & Private Clients ¤¤¤ OVERVIEW 40+ Years in BusinessDiverse Client BaseFull-ServiceComprehensive Market-Driven StrategiesProven Methodologies Maxfield Research & Consulting We are a full-service real estate advisory company providing strategic value to our private and public sector clientsÓ real estate activities. For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment ?đŎŗĩŵêŲİiją϶êŏċ϶đąŗŏŗŎiją϶ƂŵđŏċŹEŎŲňŗƢŎđŏƂ϶êŏċ϶ąŗŎŎƇƂijŏĩ϶ŲêƂƂđŵŏŹcŗƇŹijŏĩ϶ЙĨŗŵЎŹêňđϽ϶ŵđŏƂêňϽ϶ŹđŏijŗŵК϶ŎêŵńđƂ϶ąŗŏċijƂijŗŏŹcŗƇŹijŏĩ϶êĨĨŗŵċêăijňijƂƢ¤đƂêijňϽ϶ŗĨĨijąđϽ϶êŏċ϶İŗƂđň϶ŎêŵńđƂ϶ąŗŏċijƂijŗŏŹcŗƇŹijŏĩ϶ċđŎêŏċ϶Ƃŗ϶ͮ ͬͱͬ?đŎêŏċ϶Ĩŗŵ϶ŵđƂêijň϶ŹŲêąđϽ϶ŗĨĨijąđ϶ŹŲêąđϽ϶êŏċ϶İŗƂđň϶ŵŗŗŎŹ϶Ƃŗ϶ͮͬͱͬ¤đċđƚđňŗŲŎđŏƂ϶êŏċ϶ijŏĨijňň϶ijŎŲňijąêƂijŗŏŹ Key Focus Areas ċ Ĩ Ĩ Ͳ † Ў ń Ƣ϶ͮͬͮ ň Ƈ ŵƂ϶?đňijƚđŵđ s Ў ͮͬͮͲ Ųŗ Ƣ϶ ê êƂđ ¤đŲŗŵƂ϶?đňijƚđŵđċ¤đxêƂđЎsƇňƢ϶ͮͬͮͲx ¡ŵŗŁđąƂ϶uijąńЎ†ĨĨ¡ŵŗŁđąƂ϶uiją~êƢ϶ͮͬͮͲ~ ϶ͮͬͮͲ đŵ ŎŎ Ƈ ¨ƇŎŎđŵ϶ͮͬͮͲ¨ êƂê϶9ŗňňđąƂijŗŏ ?êƂê϶9ŗňňđąƂijŗŏ? Project Timeline & Scope of Work For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Key Takeaways 7ŵŗêċ϶ŵêŏĩđ϶ŗĨ϶İŗƇŹijŏĩ϶ŲŵŗċƇąƂ϶ƂƢŲđŹ϶Ɯijňň϶ăđ϶ŏđđċđċЀ϶đŏƂŵƢЎňđƚđňϽ϶ŎŗƚđЎƇŲϽ϶ŗŲƂijŗŏŹ϶Ĩŗŵ϶ŹđŏijŗŵŹ\]ŵŗƜijŏĩ϶ċđŎêŏċ϶Ĩŗŵ϶ąŗŎŎđŵąijêň϶ĩŗŗċŹ϶ъ϶ŹđŵƚijąđŹЀ϶İđêňƂİ϶ąêŵđϽ϶ŏđijĩİăŗŵİŗŗċЎêŏċ϶ąŗŏƚđŏijđŏąđЎ ŗŵijđŏƂđċϽ϶ŵđŹƂêƇŵêŏƂŹ Multiple Age Groups Population Growth Projected by 2050 (+3,045) Homeownership Rate Younger adults, move-up, seniorsWorking age population +14% by 2050 0.3% average annual growth projected 0.8% annual growth 2010-2026Down from 73% in 2010 67% Metro AreaLargest growth among non-family HHs (19%) Income & Consumer Spending Growth projected +7.1% Growth Projected Across 68% Demographic Trends For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment cŗƇŹijŏĩ϶ŗŲƂijŗŏŹ϶ŏđêŵ϶đŎŲňŗƢŎđŏƂ϶ąđŏƂđŵŹ϶Ƃŗ϶İđňŲ϶êƂƂŵêąƂЌŵđƂêijŏ϶ƜŗŵńđŵʍƂŵŗŏĩđŹƂ϶ĩŵŗƜijŏĩ϶ŹđąƂŗŵŹ϶ijŏąňƇċđ϶ŲŵŗĨđŹŹijŗŏêň϶ъ϶ăƇŹijŏđŹŹ϶ŹđŵƚijąđŹϽ϶İđêňƂİ϶ąêŵđ϶êŏċ϶Źŗąijêň϶êŹŹijŹƂêŏąđ?êƢƂijŎđ϶ŲŗŲƇňêƂijŗŏ϶ŹƂŵđŏĩƂİđ ŏŹ϶ċđŎêŏċ϶Ĩŗŵ϶ąŗŏƚđŏijđŏąđ϶ŵđƂêijňϽ϶Ĩŗŗċ϶ъ϶ăđƚđŵêĩđϽ϶ŲđŵŹŗŏêň϶ŹđŵƚijąđŹ Key Takeaways 48%Office-related jobs+3,761 office-using jobs by 2050 4.2%2025 Unemployment Rate 3.8% County, 3.6% Metro 93%Jobs Filled by Inflow 12,628 workers 5.0%Labor Force Growth+1,026 workers 2015-2025+4.1% County, +8.1% Metro 25,125 Jobs in Maplewood 8% of County employment+27%Job Growth by 2050+6,775 jobs+11% County, +16% Metro Labor Force & Employment Trends For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment (32 senior, 40 MultifamilyDetached Single-FamilyAttached Single-Family 26%affordable general occupancy units)48%133 lots 26%32 units 278 Units Pending in Maplewood Residential Construction Trends by Product Type For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Sq. Ft. Pending CommercialPublic/Institutional Industrial 193,000 71%70 permits ($2.5M value/permit)23%23 permits ($10.1M value/permit)5%5 permits ($7.6M value/permit) 9.5 Non-residential permits/year Non-Residential Development Activity For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment $265K Median MF Resale Price+5.4% annually $549K median $272K median 48% above resale median3% above resale median Single-family: Multifamily: $370K Median SF Resale Price +5.8% annually New Construction Premium¤¤ 2.6 mo.Supply on Market Sales volume down from peak with modest increases past yearSales activity declined as interest rates increasedTight inventory at 2.6-month supplyStrong annual price appreciation across both ƦƩƚķǒĭƷ ƷǤƦĻƭͶ ŅƌğƷƷĻƓĻķ ƦğƭƷ ƷǞƚ ǤĻğƩƭ Resale Market Trends¤¤¤¤ 71%Resales Detached Single-Family For-Sale Market For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment 2.4%Affordable/Subsidized Vacancy $1,869 avg (31% higher $1,507 Lengthy affordable/subsidized wait lists (1-3 years)Average Market Rate Rent: Rents increased 9% past 5 yearsRent at Newer Market Rate Properties: than older properties at $1,426)358 under lease in Maplewood Tight rental market¤Rent Trends¤¤¤Housing Choice Vouchers¤ 4.0%Market Rate Vacancy Rental Housing For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment 11.9%Service-Enhanced Vacancy Independent & Assisted Living, Memory Care Flatten to 11% growth 2026-2050!ŭĻ ЎЎњ ў ЌЋі ƚŅ ağƦƌĻǞƚƚķ͸ƭ ƦƚƦǒƌğƷźƚƓ źƓ ЋЉЎЉ (14,454 people)Additional housing options will be needed 18% Growth Projected Growth in Age 75+ Population by 2030¤¤¤ 1.2%Market Rate Active Adult Vacancy Service-EnhancedAffordable/Subsidized RentalMarket Rate Active Adult Ownership Market Rate Active Adult Rental 44% 27% 20% 9% 1,794 senior housing units in Maplewood¤¤¤¤ 5.1%Affordable/Subsidized Vacancy Senior Housing For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment 59% can afford34% can afford51% can afford40% can afford Entry-Level ($325K)Move-Up ($475K)Existing 1BR ($1,301)New Construction 1BR ($1,600) ¤¤¤¤ Based on Income OwnershipRental Cost-Burdened Renter Households Cost Burden Cost-Burdened Owner Households Housing Affordability For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment +49%RevPAR Growth Since 2021+16% ADR | +51% Total Revenue ŷĻ ğƩĻğ͸ƭ ƌƚķŭźƓŭ ƒğƩƉĻƷ has recovered and shows support for additional hotel supply 63.3%Occupancy Up from 49.3% occupancy in 2021 Weekend performance indicates strong leisure demandImproving business travel demand 68%-72% Weekend Occupancy ¤65% Midweek Occupancy¤ +30%Increase in Demand Since 2021 Hospitality Market For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Tight 0.3%Listed Office Vacancy in Maplewood7.5M SF | 106 Properties corporate facilities conditions in Maplewood support Retail sales growth in Maplewood outpaced aĻƷƩƚ !ƩĻğ ЍЊі Ʒƚ ЋЏі ƦğƭƷ Ў ǤĻğƩƭͶ supply = limited opportunity for retailers 83% of office inventory in The broader office market faces headwinds, but selective, well-positioned development 1.2%Listed Retail Vacancy in Maplewood4.2M SF | 184 Properties Commercial (Retail & Office) Market For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment For-Sale Detached SF 1,665 Units by 2050 For-Sale Other 1,362 Units by 2050 Market Rate Rental 1,819 Units by 2050 Affordable Rental 728 Units by 2050 Subsidized Rental 1,090 Units by 2050 General Occupancy Housing Demand For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Excess Senior Demand 2026 2,129 Units Excess Senior Demand 2030 2,345 Units Excess Senior Demand 2040 2,396 Units Excess Senior Demand 2050 2,548 Units Senior Housing Demand For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Retail Demand 281,086 Square Feet by 2050~32 Acres Office Demand 780,409 Square Feet by 2050~60 Acres Hotel Demand 1,087 Rooms by 2050 toMaintain Equilibrium Commercial Real Estate Demand For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment First-time buyers Θ Younger households Θ źŭŷƷ ƒğƩƉĻƷ Θ tĻƓƷΏǒƦ ķĻƒğƓķ Below equilibrium supply across most product types Housing needs across the spectrum but affordability pressures are mounting ЌЋі ƚŅ ƷƚƷğƌ ķĻƒğƓķ źƭ ğŅŅƚƩķğĬƌĻΉƭǒĬƭźķźǩĻķ ƩĻƓƷğƌ Θ ЍЌі ĻǣĭĻƭƭ ƭĻƓźƚƩ ŷƚǒƭźƓŭ ķĻƒğƓķ ğŅŅƚƩķğĬƌĻΉƭǒĬƭźķźǩĻķ Housing barriers ‘źķĻƓźƓŭ ŭğƦ ĬĻƷǞĻĻƓ ŷƚǒƭźƓŭ ĭƚƭƷƭ ğƓķ źƓĭƚƒĻƭ Θ \[źƒźƷĻķ ƷǒƩƓƚǝĻƩ ƚŅ ğŅŅƚƩķğĬƌĻ ƚƦƷźƚƓƭ Aging housing stock wĻźƓǝĻƭƷƒĻƓƷΉǒƦķğƷĻƭ Θ !ķķƭ Ʒƚ ĭƚƭƷƭ Θ /ŷğƌƌĻƓŭĻ ŅƚƩ ŅźƩƭƷΏƷźƒĻ ĬǒǤĻƩƭ New construction unattainable for many hƓƌǤ ЌЍі ĭğƓ ğŅŅƚƩķ ƒƚǝĻΏǒƦ ƭźƓŭƌĻΏŅğƒźƌǤ Θ ЍЉі ĭğƓ ğŅŅƚƩķ ƓĻǞ ĭƚƓƭƷƩǒĭƷźƚƓ Њ.w ƒğƩƉĻƷ ƩğƷĻ ƩĻƓƷğƌ $ Key Findings | Housing For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment No single solution Θ Infill Θ Redevelopment Θ Explore ways to keep housing costs down 9ǝğƌǒğƷĻ ƩĻŭǒƌğƷźƚƓƭ Θ \[ĻǝĻƩğŭĻ ƦǒĬƌźĭΉƦƩźǝğƷĻ ƦğƩƷƓĻƩƭŷźƦƭ Workforce housing hǞƓĻƩƭŷźƦ ğƓķ ƩĻƓƷğƌ ƚƦƷźƚƓƭ Θ —ƚǒƓŭ ŅğƒźƌźĻƭ Θ CźƩƭƷΏƷźƒĻ ĬǒǤĻƩƭ Single-level housing for older adults and seniors{ƷźƒǒƌğƷĻ ƷǒƩƓƚǝĻƩ ƚŅ ĻǣźƭƷźƓŭ ŷƚƒĻƭ Ʒƚ ĻǣƦğƓķ ƚƦƦƚƩƷǒƓźƷźĻƭ ŅƚƩ ǞƚƩƉŅƚƩĭĻ ğƓķ ǤƚǒƓŭĻƩ ŷƚǒƭĻŷƚƌķƭ Θ !ŅŅƚƩķğĬƌĻ ƩĻƓƷğƌ ƚƦƷźƚƓƭ New development LƓĭƩĻğƭĻ ƭǒƦƦƌǤ Θ LƓĭƩĻğƭĻ ǝğƩźĻƷǤ Θ aźƭƭźƓŭ ƒźķķƌĻ Opportunity for growth ağƩƉĻƷ ķĻƒğƓķ ĻǣĭĻĻķƭ ŭƩƚǞƷŷ ŅƚƩĻĭğƭƷƭ Θ \[ğƓķ ĭƚƓƭƷƩğźƓƷƭ Meeting Demand | Housing Priorities For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment IƚǒƭĻŷƚƌķ ŭƩƚǞƷŷ Θ tƚƦǒƌğƷźƚƓ ŭƩƚǞƷŷ {ƷĻğķǤ ŭƩƚǞƷŷ Θ 5ĻƒğƓķ ŅƚƩ ĭƚƒƒĻƩĭźğƌ ŭƚƚķƭΉƭĻƩǝźĭĻƭ Θ 5ĻƒğƓķ ŅƚƩ ĭƚƒƒĻƩĭźğƌ ƩĻğƌ ĻƭƷğƷĻ Workforce population growth\[ğĬƚƩ ŅƚƩĭĻ ŭƩƚǞƷŷ Θ !ƷƷƩğĭƷ ĻƒƦƌƚǤĻƩƭ Strong employment growth forecast hŅŅźĭĻΏǒƭźƓŭ ĻƒƦƌƚǤƒĻƓƷ ƒğƆƚƩ ķƩźǝĻƩ Θ LƓĭƩĻğƭĻķ ķğǤƷźƒĻ ƦƚƦǒƌğƷźƚƓ Limited opportunities for businesses seeking space\[ƚǞ ƌźƭƷĻķ ǝğĭğƓĭǤ ƩğƷĻƭ Θ !ķķƭ Ʒƚ ĭƚƭƷƭ Θ /ŷğƌƌĻƓŭĻ ŅƚƩ ŅźƩƭƷΏƷźƒĻ ĬǒǤĻƩƭ Strengthening lodging fundamentals\[źƒźƷĻķ ƭǒƦƦƌǤ źƓ ağƦƌĻǞƚƚķ Θ DƩƚǞźƓŭ ķĻƒğƓķ Key Findings | Commercial Real Estate For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Infill Θ Corporate facility potential Θ Redevelopment Θ Disciplined approach to development Θ Upper Midscale, Upscale Θ Smaller scale Focus on daily needs, services, destination uses where appropriate Θ Θ Lodging .ǒƭźƓĻƭƭ ƷƩğǝĻƌĻƩƭ Θ IƚƭƦźƷğƌΉƒĻķźĭğƌΏƩĻƌğƷĻķ Θ \[ĻźƭǒƩĻ ƷƩźƦƭ Θ bĻğƩĬǤ ĻǝĻƓƷƭΉƩĻĭƩĻğƷźƚƓ Θ źƭźƷƚƩƭ Retail Cƚƚķ ğƓķ ĬĻǝĻƩğŭĻ Θ wĻƭƷğǒƩğƓƷƭ Θ tĻƩƭƚƓğƌ ƭĻƩǝźĭĻƭ Θ /ƚƓǝĻƓźĻƓĭĻ Θ {ƦĻĭźğƌƷǤΉĻƓƷĻƩƷğźƓƒĻƓƷ Θ bĻźŭŷĬƚƩŷƚƚķΏƚƩźĻƓƷĻķ Office aĻķźĭğƌ ǒƭĻƭ Θ tƩƚŅĻƭƭźƚƓğƌ ƭǒźƷĻƭ Θ CƌĻǣźĬƌĻ ƌğǤƚǒƷƭ Θ {ĻƩǝźĭĻΏƚƩźĻƓƷĻķ New development 9ǣĭĻƭƭ ƦğƩƉźƓŭ Θ !ķğƦƷźǝĻ ƩĻǒƭĻ Θ wĻŷğĬźƌźƷğƷźƚƓ Θ wğǩĻ Positive outlook ağƩƉĻƷ ķĻƒğƓķ ĻǣĭĻĻķƭ ŭƩƚǞƷŷ ŅƚƩĻĭğƭƷƭ Θ \[ğƓķ ĭƚƓƭƷƩğźƓƷƭ Meeting Demand | Commercial Priorities For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment Infill | Where? Redevelopment Development For the permanent record: Meeting Date: 9/14/2026 Agenda Item E1, Additional Attachment JOE HOLLMAN Director of Research Maxfield Research & Consulting612.904.7973jhollman@maxfieldresearch.com MaxfieldResearch.com Questions & Comments