Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-09-28 City Council Workshop Packet AGENDA MAPLEWOOD CITY COUNCIL MANAGER WORKSHOP 6:30 P.M. Monday, September 28, 2026 City Hall, Council Chambers Pursuant to Minn. Stat. 13D.02, one or more council members may be participating remotely A. CALL TO ORDER B. ROLL CALL C. APPROVAL OF AGENDA D. UNFINISHED BUSINESS None E. NEW BUSINESS 1. Public Works Facility Study Report from Kraus-Anderson F. ADJOURNMENT RULES OF CIVILITY FOR THE CITY COUNCIL, BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND OUR COMMUNITY Following are rules of civility the City of Maplewood expects of everyone appearing at council meetings - elected officials, staff and citizens. It is hoped that by following these simple rules, everyone’s opinions can be heard and understood in a reasonable manner. We appreciate the fact that when appearing at council meetings, it is understood that everyone will follow these principles: Speak only for yourself, not for other council members or citizens - unless specifically tasked by your colleagues to speak for the group or for citizens in the form of a petition. Show respect during comments and/or discussions, listen actively and do not interrupt or talk amongst each other. Be respectful of the process, keeping order and decorum. Do not be critical of council members, staff or others in public. Be respectful of each other’s time keeping remarks brief, to the point and non-repetitive. THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK E1 CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP STAFF REPORT Meeting Date September 28, 2026 REPORT TO: Michael Sable, City Manager REPORT FROM: Mike Darrow, Assistant City Manager / Human Resource Director PRESENTER: Mike Darrow, Assistant City Manager/Human Resource Directo r AGENDA ITEM: Public Works Facility Study Report from Kraus-Anderson Action Requested: Motion Discussion Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution Ordinance Contract/Agreement Proclamation Summary: Kraus-Anderson Advisory Services (KA) was engaged, following a competitive interview process in which KA was selected over several firms based on its experience with comparably sized public works facility projects, to complete a Facility Condition Assessment (FCA) and concept-level planning study of the cityÓs public works (1902 County Road B East), park maintenance (1810 County Road B East), and nature center (2659 7th Street East) facilities. The study evaluated existing building conditions, operational needs, long-term space and fleet requirements based on extensive input from public works, streets & utilities, nature center, and park maintenance staff. Recommended Action: No formal action is requested. Staff recommend council discuss the preliminary FCA findings and concept scenarios and provide direction on the scenario(s) staff and KA should further develop into refined ÐGood, Better, BestÑ options for a future council meeting. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No Yes, the true or estimated cost is Ranges based upon concepts. Financing source(s): Adopted Budget Budget Modification New Revenue Source Use of Reserves Other: n/a Strategic Plan Relevance: Safety Focus Area: Maintain and enhance infrastructure and environmental systems Sustainability Focus Area: Maintain strong financial health and stability Development Focus Area: Invest in people and placemaking This study supports the cityÓs priorities by establishing a data-driven framework for evaluating the long-term condition, capacity, and configuration of the cityÓs public works, park maintenance, and nature center facilities. Workshop Packet Page Number 1 of 61 E1 Background: Facility Condition Assessment (FCA) All three facilities were rated ÐFairÑ on the Facility Condition Index (FCI) and have generally been well maintained. However, KA identified approximately $8.9M in deferred maintenance and capital needs over the next 10 years, driven primarily by aging electrical systems (24%), roofing (15%), and sitework/earthwork (11%). Several safety and critical maintenance items were also identified, including missing fire alarm panels, original 1970sÎ1990s electrical switchgear, and an aging and ÐunprotectedÑ fuel island at the public works facility. Stakeholder Engagement and Project Goals KA conducted interviews with public works, engineering, streets & utilities, nature center, and park maintenance staff to identify operational needs, including right-sized office and collaboration space, improved circulation and accessibility, expanded vehicle and equipment storage, and flexibility for future growth. Based on this input, the project team finalized five project goals at a July 7, 2026 stakeholder meeting: (1) Safety, (2) Innovation/Flexibility/Adaptability, (3) Durability/Sustainability/Maintainability, (4) People Space and Operational Efficiency, and (5) Vehicle/Fleet Accommodation. These goals align with the cityÓs safety, sustainability, and development strategic priorities and were used to filter and evaluate the concept scenarios below. Concept Scenarios Scenario 1 Î Minimal Investment ($4MÎ$5M): Addresses only high-priority FCA safety and critical maintenance items at all three facilities; does not address space, staffing, or fleet needs. Scenario 2 Î In-Place Renovation ($9MÎ$10M): Adds medium- and high-priority FCA improvements plus targeted interior renovations at 1902 and 1810; no consolidation of work groups. Scenario 3a Î Nature Center + 1902 Consolidate & Expand ($15MÎ$17M): Relocates Nature Center offices into 1902; expands and reconfigures vehicle storage and maintenance space. Scenario 3b Î Nature Center, 1810 & 1902 Consolidate & Expand ($21MÎ$22M): Consolidates all three facilities into the 1902 campus, providing the greatest operational integration on the existing site. Scenario 4 Î New Building ($36MÎ$48M): A new 90,000Î100,000 SF facility on a new site, offering the greatest flexibility and room for future growth, but requires identifying a suitable site. Discussion Requested This item is for council discussion only; no formal action or motion is being requested tonight. KA will walk through the FCA findings and each concept scenario, along with how each scenario aligns with the cityÓs safety, sustainability, and development priorities. Staff are seeking council feedback and direction on which scenario(s) merit further development. Attachments: 1. Presentation Workshop Packet Page Number 2 of 61 City Council Presentation Workshop E1, Attachment 1 Packet Page Number 3 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 4 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Project Scope Overview Kraus-Anderson Advisory Services will assist the City of Maplewood in evaluating its existing Parks & Public Works facilities and developing concept-level planning strategies to support future operational, staffing, fleet, and infrastructure needs. This effort includes Facility Condition Assessment (FCA), operational and program analysis, concept planning, and preliminary cost modeling intended to provide the City with a clear framework for future facility and capital planning decisions. Facilities th ¤bğƷǒƩĻ /ĻƓƷĻƩ ΑЋЏЎВ АStreet East ŷĻ ƭĭƚƦĻ ƚŅ ǞƚƩƉ źƓĭƌǒķĻƭ ğƭƭĻƭƭƒĻƓƷ ƚŅ ƷŷĻ /źƷǤ͸ƭ ĻǣźƭƷźƓŭ ¤tǒĬƌźĭ ‘ƚƩƉƭ ΑЊВЉЋ /ƚǒƓƷǤ wƚğķ . 9ğƭƷ Workshop Parks & Public Works facilities, associated site operations, long- ¤tğƩƉ ağźƓƷĻƓğƓĭĻ ΑЊБЊЉ /ƚǒƓƷǤ wƚğķ . 9ğƭƷ term growth considerations, and evaluation of potential facility E1, Attachment 1 improvement strategies. Packet Page Number 5 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 6 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 ¤YƩğǒƭΏ!ƓķĻƩƭƚƓ !ƭƭĻƭƭĻķ ΛЌΜ ŅğĭźƌźƷźĻƭ ƚƓ ƷŷĻ /źƷǤ ƚŅ ağƦƌĻǞƚƚķ͸ƭ ĬĻŷğƌŅʹ ¤Public Works Facility ~ 58,750 SF ¤Parks Maintenance Facility ~ 10,800 SF ¤Nature Center Facility ~ 2,984 SF ¤!ƌƌ ΛЌΜ ƷŷƩĻĻ ŅğĭźƌźƷźĻƭ ğƩĻ ƩğƷĻķ ğƭ ͷCğźƩͼ ƚƓ ƷŷĻ CğĭźƌźƷǤ /ƚƓķźƷźƚƓ LƓķĻǣ ¤Overall, the facilities have been well maintained over the years. ¤There is approximately $9M in Deferred Maintenance and Capital Expenditures expected over the next 10-years. Year of Pres. Day Repl. Building Repl. Building NameAddressFacility SF10-Year DM CostsFCI Constr.CostsCost Nature Center2659 7th Street East2,9841993/2017$ 525 $ 1,566,600 $ 229,752 0.1202 Workshop Park Maintenance1810 County Road B East10,8001984/1991$ 375 $ 4,050,000 $ 1,471,081 0.2977 Public Works1902 County Road B East58,7501977/2005$ 430 $ 25,262,500 $ 7,222,761 E1, Attachment 1 0.2344 Packet 72,534 $ - $ 8,923,593 Page Number 7 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 8 of 61 Year of Pres. Day Repl. Building Repl. Building NameAddressFacility SF Constr.CostsCost10-Year DM CostsFCI Public Works1902 County Road B East58,7501977/2005$ 430 $ 25,262,500 $ 7,222,761 0.2344 E1, Attachment 1 Pres. Day Repl. Building Repl. Building NameAddressFacility SFYear of Constr.10-Year DM CostsFCI CostsCost Park Maintenance1810 County Road B East 10,8001984/1991$ 375 $ 4,050,000 $ 1,471,081 0.2977 Workshop E1, Attachment 1 Packet Page Number 9 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 10 Year of Pres. Day Repl. Facility of DepartmentBuilding NameAddressBuilding Repl. Cost10-Year DM CostsFCI 61 Constr.Costs SF Nature Center2659 7th Street East$ 525 $ 1,566,600 $ 229,752 Public Works2,9841993/2017 0.1202 E1, Attachment 1 Percentage Breakdown of Costs per Discipline ЊА Α9ƌĻĭƷƩƚƓźĭ {ğŅĻƷǤ ğƓķ {ĻĭǒƩźƷǤͲ υЊЊЍͲЊЉЉͲ Њі ЉЋ Α{źƷĻǞƚƩƉΉ.ǒźƌķźƓŭ 9ğƩƷŷǞƚƩƉͲ υЊͲЉЊБͲЊЊЌͲ ЊЊі ЊЎ Α9ƌĻĭƷƩźĭğƌͲ υЋͲЉВВͲВББͲ ЋЍі ЉЎ Α9ǣƷĻƩźƚƩ 9ƓĭƌƚƭǒƩĻͲ υАЏЍͲЍБЉͲ Ві ЉЏ ΑwƚƚŅͲ υЊͲЌЌЋͲЋББͲ ЊЎі ЊЌ ΑI!/Ͳ υБАЏͲЊЏБͲ ЊЉі Workshop ЊЊ ΑCźƩĻ tƩƚƷĻĭƷźƚƓͲ υЊАЌͲЎВЏͲ Ћі ЉА ΑLƓƷĻƩźƚƩ /ƚƓƭƷƩǒĭƷźƚƓƭͲ υВЋЏͲБЏВͲ ЊЉі ЊЉ Α/ƚƓǝĻǤźƓŭ {ǤƭƷĻƒƭͲ υЋБАͲЎЉЉ Ќі Packet E1, Attachment 1 ЉБ Α9ƨǒźƦƒĻƓƷ CǒƩƓźƷǒƩĻͲ υЋЌЉͲББЉͲ Ќі ЉВ Α{ƦĻĭźğƌ /ƚƓƭƷƩǒĭƷźƚƓͲ υЊͲЉЎАͲЉЉЉͲ ЊЋі Page Number 11 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 12 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Developing Project Goals and Objectives: Department Interviews DEPARTMENTINTERVIEWSWHAT WE HEARDGOALS & OBJECTIVES ¤Ў¤ ¤¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Workshop ¤ Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 13 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Project Goals and Objectives: The bases for which project decisions were filtered Number 14 GOAL 1: SAFETY of 61 ¤Enhance User Safety, Compliance, and Risk Management GOAL 2: INNOVATION, FLEXIBILITY, ADAPTABILITY ¤Support Future Growth, Technology, and Organizational Integration GOAL 3: DURABLE, MAINTAINABLE, SUSTAINABLE ¤Develop Durable, Sustainable, and Maintainable Infrastructure GOAL 4a: PEOPLE SPACE AND OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY ¤Create a Functional, User-Friendly Public Works Facility Supporting long-term financial and GOAL 4b: VEHICLE/FLEET ACCOMMODATION operational sustainability ¤Optimize Fleet, Equipment, and Operational Support Areas Finalized at 7/7/26 Stakeholder Meeting E1, Attachment 1 Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 15 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Scenario 1: Minimal Investment Number FCA Safety & Critical Maintenance Improvements (High Category): 16 of ¤Nature Center: $91,000 61 ¤CźƩĻ !ƌğƩƒ tğƓĻƌ Αğķķ ¤Condensing Units and Furnace replacements Scope of Work ¤Electrical Panel replacement ¤Square Footage Allocations remain the same at ¤1810 Building: $650,000 each facility. ¤Concrete repairs/replacement ¤No consolidation of work groups ¤CźƩĻ !ƌğƩƒ tğƓĻƌ Αğķķ ¤FCA work only, focused on safety and critical ¤Switchgear, Electrical Panel, Transformer replacements maintenance. ¤CO/NO Sensor replacement ¤HVAC replacements (RTU, EF) Conceptual Project Cost Estimate: $4M -$5M ¤1902 Building: $4M ¤Switchgear, Electrical Panel replacements ¤HVAC replacements (MUA, RTU, AHU, Boilers, VAVs, EF, etc) ¤Fuel Island/Fuel UST ¤Drainage issues at west elevation E1, Attachment 1 *Addresses high critical facility needs and extends useful life but does not fully address FCI or space programming needs. Scenario 2: In-Place Renovation Scope of Work ¤No consolidation of work groups ¤1902 Interior Renovation of Upper Level to support reconfiguration of existing program. Upper level approximately 7,000 SF +/-SF (does not include existing iNetleased space). ¤Explore renovation of 1810 building to support larger meeting space and workspace for staff. Convert ~ 500 SF of existing vehicle storage to expand Breakroom/Meeting Room. Square Scope AreaCost Footage FCA Improvements (Medium + High)*$7,000,000 1902 Upper-Level Interior Office Renovations7,000 SF$2,275,000 1810 Convert Vehicle Storage to expanded 500 SF$200,000 breakroom/meeting room Workshop Conceptual Estimate Total$9M -$10M Packet E1, Attachment 1 *FCA Improvements on next slide Page Number 17 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Scenario 2: In-Place Renovation Number 18 FCA Improvements (Medium + High Category) ~ $7M of 61 ¤Nature Center: $140,000 ¤1902 Building: $5.5M ¤CźƩĻ !ƌğƩƒ tğƓĻƌ Α ğķķ¤Switchgear, Electrical Panel replacements ¤Condensing Units and Furnace replacements¤HVAC replacements (MUA, RTU, AHU, Boilers, VAVs, EF, ¤Electrical Panel replacementetc) ¤ADA openers for both entryways ¤Fuel Island/Fuel UST ¤Seal/Caulk Windows¤Drainage issues at west elevation ¤Seal/Caulk Windows ¤Door Replacements ¤1810 Building: $1.3M ¤Door Opener replacements ¤Concrete repairs/replacement ¤Ballasted roof section replacement ¤CźƩĻ !ƌğƩƒ tğƓĻƌ Α ğķķ ¤Switchgear, Electrical Panel, Transformer replacements ¤CO/NO Sensor replacement ¤HVAC replacements (RTU, EF, IR) ¤Windows and Door Replacements ¤Door opener replacements E1, Attachment 1 ¤Roof replacement Scenario 3a: Nature Center + 1902 Consolidate & Expand Scope of Work FCA Improvements: ¤Nature Center offices move to 1902.¤Medium & High FCA Improvements at Nature Center and 1902. ¤Reconfigure/Interior remodel of 1902 Upper and ¤Removed $.5M for work covered in renovations. Lower Level (does not include existing iNet¤No work at 1810building leased space). ¤Expand and reconfigure existing vehicle storage and maintenance spaces. Square Scope AreaCost ¤Relocate Cold Storage on existing site Footage Interior Office Renovations7,000 SF$2,275,000 Considerations: Reconstruct Vehicle Storage16,000 SF$4,640,000 ¤Uncaptured costs to relocate operations Addition Vehicle Storage4,000 SF$1,040,000 during construction. ¤Maintenance bay relocation and expanded Addition Wash Bay3,0000 SF$1,575,000 Workshop ķĻƦƷŷ ΛƷƚ ЊЉЋ͸Μ Ǟźƌƌ źƒƦğĭƷ ǝĻŷźĭƌĻ ƭƷƚƩğŭĻ Relocate Cold Storage$1,500,000 configuration. FCA Improvements$5,000,000 Packet E1, Attachment 1 Conceptual Estimate Total$15M -$17M Page Number 19 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 20 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Scenario 3a: Nature Center + 1902 Consolidate & Expand Scenario 3b: Nature Center, 1810, & 1902 Consolidate & Expand Scope of WorkFCA Improvements: ¤Nature Center and 1810 offices and vehicle ¤1902 Building (FCA scope will be captured in renovations and equipment storage move to 1902.and additions ¤Reconfigure/Interior remodel of 1902 Upper ¤No FCA work at other facilities and Lower Level (does not include existing iNetleased space). ¤Expand and reconfigure existing vehicle storage and maintenance spaces. ¤Relocate Cold Storage on existing site. Considerations: ¤Uncaptured costs to relocate operations during construction. Workshop ¤Maintenance Bay relocation and expanded ķĻƦƷŷ ΛƷƚ ЊЉЋ͸Μ Ǟźƌƌ źƒƦğĭƷ ǝĻŷźĭƌĻ ƭƷƚƩğŭĻ configuration. Packet E1, Attachment 1 *Scenario 3b Conceptual Estimate on next slide Page Number 21 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Scenario 3b: Nature Center, 1810, & 1902 Consolidate & Expand Number 22 of 61 Scope AreaSquare FootageCost/SF Interior Office Renovations8,600 SF$2,795,000 Convert Parts, Street, Sign and Utility Shop to Offices2,900 SF$1,087,500 Renovate 3,000 SF of Maintenance Bays for Parts, Street, Sign, and 3,000 SF$675,000 Utility Shop Reconstruct Vehicle Storage8,800 SF$2,640,000 Reconstruct New Maintenance Bays7,400 SF$3,404,000 New Addition Vehicle Storage22,700 SF$5,902,000 Relocate Cold Storage$1,500,000 New Wash Bay$1,575,000 Conceptual Estimate Total$21M - $22M E1, Attachment 1 Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Scenario 3b: Nature Center, 1810, & 1902 Consolidate & Expand Number 23 of 61 Workshop Packet Page {ĭĻƓğƩźƚ Ѝʹ ВЉͲЉЉЉ Α ЊЉЉͲЉЉЉ ƭƨǒğƩĻ ŅĻĻƷ bĻǞ .ǒźƌķźƓŭ Number 24 of Estimated Total Project Cost: $36M - $48M 61 Project Area SF Breakdown 90K SFSF Breakdown 100K SF Office13,50015,000 Maintenance/Shops19,80022,000 Vehicle Storage56,70063,000 Total GSF90,000100,000 Site Area214,920214,920 Considerations: ¤Provides for future growth ¤Allows flexibility of consolidating departments within one facility ¤Represents a median-sized facility when benchmarked against comparable neighboring city facilities based on community size and service mileage. E1, Attachment 1 ¤Facility needs and space allocations will be further evaluated and refined through the design process. Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 25 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number Based on City Strategic Priorities and Project Goals: 26 Provide Direction of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Feedback & Direction on Concept Scenarios Minimal investment Summary: ¤$5 -$10M ¤Critical FCA Items ¤Minimal Interior Renovation ¤Will improve the life cycle of facilities within a 10-year lifecycle. ¤Does not address space and people efficiency, innovation, adaptability, and vehicle accommodations. Project Goals: Safety, Sustainability Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 27 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number Feedback & Direction on Concept Scenarios 28 of 61 Consolidate & Expand Summary: ¤$15 -17M ¤Reconfigure/Interior remodel ¤Consolidation of some or all uses ¤Expand and reconfigure existing vehicle storage and maintenance spaces. ¤Relocate Cold Storage on existing site ¤Existing conditions limit program flexibility and consolidation Project Goals: Safety, Adaptability, People, Vehicle Accommodations E1, Attachment 1 Feedback & Direction on Concept Scenarios New Building Summary ¤$36M -48M ¤Consolidating nature center, park functions and public works into 1 campus ¤New construction allows for complete flexibility in organization and layout of space programming ¤Building on a new site provides an opportunity for future growth that may be limited by expanding the existing campus ¤Ability to achieve City and project goals ¤Finding a new site in the right location may pose a challenge Project Goals: Workshop Project Goals: Safety, Innovation, Adaptability, Sustainability, People, Efficiency, Vehicle Accommodations Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 29 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number Next Steps for KA and City Staff 30 of 61 ¤Based on Council direction, KA will revise scenarios to establish Good, Better, Best options with estimated project costs ¤KA will review updated scenarios with Staff ¤Present Good, Better, Best Options to Council E1, Attachment 1 Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 31 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 32 of 61 Programmatic Budget E1, Attachment 1 TOTAL ALLOWABLE COST SETTING The following pages provide an overview of two high-level concept scenarios for a new public works facility to help determine programmatic budget ranges. Total gross square footage for this exercise were Concept 1 @ 90,000 GSF and Concept 2 @ 100,000 GSF. The 90,000 GSF and 100,000 GSF sizes were based on the following: ¤We compared size and road miles served to surrounding area including: ¤Oakdale PW at approx. 76,000 GSF ¤South St. Paul PW at approx. 74,000 GSF (prior studies wanted 90,000+ GSF) ¤Roseville PW South Site Only at approx. 102,000 GSF ¤While Oakdale and South St. Paul have about 30% less City road miles they also don't have as much combined operations.Roseville is a close comparison at close to 40,000 residents and over 100 City miles of road. ¤It's important to note that this is a high-level concept and the programming needs to be proven out.Current Maplewood Public Works facilities add up to 72,534 GSF across 3 buildings. ¤The budgets on the following pages represent ranges based on perceived programing.It's important to add escalation for year of anticipated start of construction. These concepts represent building a new facility which will be the highest cost. In addition to a new facility we will explore more minimal options during this study. These alternative concepts will be developed with the results of the Facility Conditions Assessment and feedback from City staff. Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 33 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 34 of 61 2026 Total Project Cost Range $35.8M - $43.7M E1, Attachment 1 Concept 1 | 2026 Total Project Cost Range $38.9M - $47.6M Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Concept 2 | Page Number 35 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 36 of 61 Program Prioritization E1, Attachment 1 Nature Center Plan Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 37 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Nature Center Key Take Aways: Number Public Functions: Key Program Components (Location Agnostic): ¤Trailhead ¤Restrooms Public Functions: 38 ¤Room for programmed events (few programmed events with other providers) ¤Trailhead of ¤Old naturalist exhibits (not relevant anymore) ¤Restrooms 61 ¤Pick up location for keys for public to access other rentable facilities ¤Reception counter for public to pick up rental facility keys ¤Indoor common room for public to use Office Functions: ¤4 FTE Office Functions: ¤1 PTE ¤4.5 FTE Workspaces ¤General office functions ¤Breakroom ¤Staff breakroom/lunch room/conference room ¤Conference Space ¤Stage items for city wide events ¤Administrative workspace ¤Outdoor storage for Park Maintenance equipment ¤Staging items for city wide events ¤Staff provides oversight of building for public use ¤Storage (indoor) ¤Storage (Outdoor) Needs: ¤ADA Access ¤Smaller conference/phone room space E1, Attachment 1 Nature Center | Existing Square Footages Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 39 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Parks Maintenance | 1810 Building Lower Level Number 40 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Parks Maintenance | 1810 Building \[ƚǞĻƩ \[ĻǝĻƌ Α9ƒƦƌƚǤĻĻ {ƦğĭĻƭ Upper Level Storage Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 41 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Park Maintenance | 1810 Building Key Take Aways: Number Public Functions: Key Program Components (Location Agnostic) ¤None Parks Maintenance Building 42 Office Functions: ¤Foreman Office of ¤6 FTE ¤5 FTE Shared workstation space (1 future FTE) 61 ¤1 FTE Future Park Maintenance Employee ¤Breakroom/Lunchroom ¤4 Seasonal Employees ¤Conference space for full team ¤aĻƓ͸ƭ ğƓķ ‘ƚƒĻƓ͸ƭ \[ƚĭƉĻƩ wƚƚƒƭ ¤Administrative workspace ¤Staff breakroom/lunch room ¤Storage (Indoor) ¤Workstation for safety training and other administrative tasks ¤Men's and Women's Locker Room ¤Wood Shop Field Operations: ¤Vehicle storage (32 vehicles and equipment to be confirmed) ¤Wood Shop ¤Trash Enclosure ¤Storage ¤Cold Storage (off Season equipment) ¤Vehicle and Equipment Storage/Staging ¤Remote Cold Storage (in water tower) for off-season equipment Needs: ¤\[ğƩŭĻƩ ĭƚƓŅĻƩĻƓĭĻ Ʃƚƚƒ ŅƚƩ ͻ!ƌƌ IğƓķƭͼ ƒĻĻƷźƓŭƭ ¤Additional workstations for safety training and other administrative tasks ¤May need expanded locker rooms E1, Attachment 1 1810 Building | Park Maintenance Existing Interior Square Footages Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 43 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Public Works Streets & Utilities | 1902 Building Lower Level Number 44 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Public Works Streets & Utilities Key Take Aways: Key Program Components (Location Agnostic) Public Functions: ¤3 Hardwall offices ¤None ¤Open office/touchdown space for timecards, etc. ¤Breakroom/Kitchen Office Functions: ¤Large Conference Room ¤18 FTE ¤Men's and Women's Locker Room ¤2 FTE Supervisors ¤Workroom/Administrative Space ¤Pre-Work briefing ¤Storage (indoor) ¤Lunch/Break ¤Sign Shop ¤All hands meetings ¤Streets Shop ¤Utilities Shop Field Operations: ¤Parts Shop ¤General vehicle and equipment storage ¤4 Maintenance Bays ¤Vehicle and equipment maintenance (from all sites) ¤Wash Bay ¤Shop Space ¤Vehicle Storage (approximately 65 vehicles and equipment) ¤Storage ¤Outdoor storage Needed: ¤Fuel Island ¤Larger Conference space for all hands meetings ¤Wash Bay ¤Larger maintenance bays ¤Salt Shed ¤Improved circulation and access throughout facility ¤Dedicated Wash Bay ¤Storage ¤Outside storage (could increase and consolidate Parks Maintenance equipment) Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 45 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Public Works & Engineering Offices | 1902 Building Upper Level Number 46 of 61 E1, Attachment 1 Public Works & Engineering Offices Key Take Aways: Public Functions: Public Works & Engineering Offices Key Program Components (Location Agnostic) ¤Reception counter for public permits/questions ¤Interviews Public: ¤Reception Counter Office Functions: ¤Entry Lobby ¤5 FTE Engineering Employees (2 offices & 3 workstations) ¤3 FTE Public Works Administrative Staff (workstations) Office (Current): ¤2 Interns (workstations) ¤6 Hardwall Offices ¤1 FTE PW Director (Office) ¤8 Workstations ¤3 City Communications Staff (Share 2 offices) ¤Breakroom ¤2 City Facilities Operations Staff (Share 1 office) ¤Large Conference Room ¤Breakroom/lunchroom ¤Collaboration Area ¤1 conference room ¤Facilities Storage ¤Engineering Collaboration Space ¤Print/Copy/Assembly Administrative Area ¤Large format plan printing ¤4 Single use restrooms ¤City wide notices assembly area Needed: ¤ADA Accessible Entry ¤Small waiting area/landing space adjacent to counter ¤Larger conference room space for large team meetings ¤Flex/Hoteling workstation ¤Breakout space/smaller conference spaces or phone rooms ¤Dedicated storage area for supplies ¤Wellness Room ¤Consolidation of Restrooms Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 47 of 61 Workshop Packet Page 1902 Building | Public Works & Engineering Existing Interior Square Footages Number 7êŹđňijŏđϫ¡ŵŗĩŵêŎEơŲêŏċđċϫ¡ŵŗĩŵêŎ Size (SF)GrowthTotal 48 Administrative - Lower Level Office524 of Open Office354 61 Administrative - Upper Level Office2,047 Open Office 1,307 Open Work Area/Copy/File671 Reception/Lobby125 Leased Office (iNet)2,084 Subtotal ϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫͳϽͭͭͮ Staff Support - Lower Level Meeting Room/Break Room 800 Conference Room284 Mens Locker Room704 Womens Locker Room227 Janitor Closet24 Storage194 Staff Support - Upper Level Storage99 Breakroom268 Restroom186 Large Conference Room353 Utility (Mechanical)416 Subtotal ϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫϫͯϽͱͱͱ E1, Attachment 1 Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 49 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 50 of Pres. Day Repl. 61 Building NameAddressFacility SF Year of Constr.CostsBuilding Repl. Cost10-Year DM CostsFCI 58,7501977/2005 Public Works1902 County Road B East$ 430 $ 25,262,500 $ 7,222,761 0.2344 E1, Attachment 1 City of Maplewood Public Works- Expected Annual Facility Maintenance Costs $6,000,000 $5,000,000 1-Low2-Medium3-HighGrand Total $ 1,292,946 $ 943,341 $ 3,305,647 Sum of 2027$ 5,541,934 $ - $ - $ 20,250 Sum of 2028$ 20,250 $4,000,000 $ - $ 21,000 $ 49,000 Sum of 2029$ 70,000 $ 8,700 $ 161,675 $ 43,500 Sum of 2030$ 213,875 $ 24,000 $ - $ - Sum of 2031$ 24,000 $ 149,102 $ - $ - Sum of 2032$ 149,102 $3,000,000 $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2033$ - $ 160,875 $ - $ 12,375 Sum of 2034$ 173,250 $ 48,025 $ 499,800 $ 447,525 Sum of 2035$ 995,350 $2,000,000 $ - $ - $ 35,000 Sum of 2036$ 35,000 $ 1,683,648 $ 1,625,816 $ 3,913,297 $ 7,222,761 $1,000,000 Workshop $- Sum of 2027Sum of 2028Sum of 2029Sum of 2030Sum of 2031Sum of 2032Sum of 2033Sum of 2034Sum of 2035Sum of 2036 Packet E1, Attachment 1 1-Low2-Medium3-High Page Number 51 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 52 Percentage Breakdown of Costs per Discipline of 02-Sitework/Building Earthwork, $788,468 , 11% 17-Electronic Safety and Security, $69,250 , 1% 61 Sum of Total (with Inf.) 05-Exterior Enclosure, $669,840 , 15-Electrical, $1,662,138 , 23% 9% 02-Sitework/Building Earthwork$ 788,468 05-Exterior Enclosure$ 679,850 06-Roof$ 789,291 07-Interior Construction$ 801,597 08-Equipment Furniture$ 228,930 09-Special Construction$ 1,057,000 14-Mechanical Controls, $- , 0% 10-Conveying Systems$ 287,500 06-Roof, $789,291 , 11% 11-Fire Protection$ 39,000 12-Plumbing$ 26,813 13-HVAC$ 792,925 14-Mechanical Controls$ - 13-HVAC, $873,250 , 12% 15-Electrical$ 1,662,138 17-Electronic Safety and Security$ 69,250 Grand Total$ 7,222,761 12-Plumbing, $26,813 , 0% 07-Interior Construction, $801,597 , 11% 11-Fire Protection, $39,000 , 1% 10-Conveying Systems, $287,500 , 4% E1, Attachment 1 09-Special Construction, $1,057,000 , 14%08-Equipment Furniture, $228,930 , 3% ¤Address safety & security considerations: ¤A main roof discharge drain is located just to the south of Garage Door 1 on the west side of the building, water damage noted along building and employees noted pooling of water at doorway, in winter icing over, causing a safety hazard ¤!ķķ ŅĻƓĭźƓŭ ğƌƚƓŭ ƷƚƦ ƚŅ ƩĻƷğźƓźƓŭ Ǟğƌƌ ƌƚĭğƷĻķ ƚƓ ǞĻƭƷ ĻƓķ ƚŅ ƷŷĻ ĬǒźƌķźƓŭͲ ĭǒƩƩĻƓƷƌǤ ƷŷĻƩĻ źƭ ğ Џ͸ΏЉͼ ķƩƚƦ ŅƩƚƒ ƷƚƦ ƚŅ ƷŷĻ retaining wall to the ground below. ¤!5! hƦĻƓĻƩ ŅƚƩ ƒğźƓ ĻƓƷƩǤǞğǤƭ Α ĭźƷǤ źƭ ğƌƩĻğķǤ źƓ ƦƩƚĭĻƭƭ ƚŅ ğķķƩĻƭƭźƓŭ ¤Switchgear and Electrical Sub-panels original 1977, recommend replacement ¤Risks: ¤Fire Hazards - risk to employees, facility and assets ¤Could lead to expensive emergency replacement ¤CǒĻƌ LƭƌğƓķ Α ΛЋΜ ЊЉͲЉЉЉ ŭğƌ ŅǒĻƌ ƷğƓƉƭ ΛЊВВЊΜ ¤Risks: ¤Although the tanks are currently being monitored, due to the age, leaking may occur due to tank corrosion. Potential for costly environmental remediation, regulatory fines and operation interruption. There currently is no EPA information found on the MN Pollution Control Agency registration website that KA could find re: the tanks original installation date. ¤Make-up Air units and Exhaust Fans for the garages/shops currently not tied into the Building Automation System (BAS). The city Workshop źƭ ĭǒƩƩĻƓƷƌǤ ƦƌğƓƓźƓŭ ƩĻƦƌğĭĻƒĻƓƷ ƚŅ ƷŷĻ .!{ źƓ ЋЉЋЏ ğƓķ źƷ źƭ ƩĻĭƚƒƒĻƓķĻķ ƷŷğƷ ƷŷĻ a ! ğƓķ 9C͸ƭ ĬĻ ƷźĻķ źƓƷƚ ƷŷĻ ƭǤƭƷĻƒ ŅƚƩ propering monitoring for safety, if not considering it currently. Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 53 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 54 of Pres. Day Repl. Building NameAddressFacility SF 61 Year of Constr.CostsBuilding Repl. Cost10-Year DM CostsFCI 10,8001984/1991 Park Maintenance1810 County Road B East$ 375 $ 4,050,000 $ 1,471,081 0.2977 E1, Attachment 1 City of Maplewood Park Maintenance Expected Annual Facility Maintenance Costs $1,600,000 $1,400,000 1-Low2-Medium3-High Grand Total $ 193,287 $ 589,537 $ 551,493 Sum of 2027$ 1,334,317 $ - $ - $ 11,813 $1,200,000 Sum of 2028$ 11,813 $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2029$ - $1,000,000 $ - $ 11,600 $ - Sum of 2030$ 11,600 $ 2,700 $ 6,750 $ 87,038 Sum of 2031$ 96,488 $ 16,864 $ - $ - $800,000 Sum of 2032$ 16,864 $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2033$ - $ - $ - $ - $600,000 Sum of 2034$ - $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2035$ - $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2036$ - $400,000 $ 212,851 $ 607,887 $ 650,343 $ 1,471,081 Workshop $200,000 Packet E1, Attachment 1 $- Sum of 2027Sum of 2028Sum of 2029Sum of 2030Sum of 2031Sum of 2032Sum of 2033Sum of 2034Sum of 2035Sum of 2036 1-Low2-Medium3-High Page Number 55 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 56 Percentage Breakdown of Costs per Discipline of 17-Electronic Safety and Security, $16,900 , 02-Sitework/Building Earthwork, $141,890 , 10% 1% 61 05-Exterior Enclosure, $46,540 , 3% Sum of Total (with Inf.) 15-Electrical, $429,850 , 29% 02-Sitework/Building Earthwork$ 141,890 05-Exterior Enclosure$ 46,540 06-Roof$ 542,997 07-Interior Construction$ 125,271 08-Equipment Furniture$ 1,950 09-Special Construction$ - 11-Fire Protection$ 115,200 12-Plumbing$ 2,990 13-HVAC$ 47,493 15-Electrical$ 429,850 17-Electronic Safety and Security$ 16,900 06-Roof, $542,997 , 37% Grand Total$ 1,471,081 13-HVAC, $47,493 , 3% 11-Fire Protection, $115,200 , 8% E1, Attachment 1 07-Interior Construction, $125,271 , 9% ¤Address safety & security considerations: ¤Parking lot asphalt is in poor condition, presenting trip hazards, full depth replacement recommended ¤/ƚƓĭƩĻƷĻ ƭƷƚƚƦ ğƷ ƭƚǒƷŷ ĻƒĻƩŭĻƓĭǤ ĻǣźƷ ķƚƚƩ ƓĻĻķƭ Ʒƚ ĬĻ ƌĻǝĻƌ ǞźƷŷ ķƚƚƩ ΑƷƩźƦ ŷğǩğƩķ ƦƩĻƭĻƓƷ ¤No fire alarm panel monitoring building. Recommended to add to ensure safety of building and assets. ¤9ƌĻĭƷƩźĭğƌ ƦğƓĻƌƭ ğƩĻ ƚƩźŭźƓğƌ ΑƩĻĭƚƒƒĻƓķ ƩĻƦƌğĭĻƒĻƓƷ ¤Risks: ¤Fire Hazards - risk to employees, facility and assets ¤Could lead to expensive emergency replacement ¤Addressimmediate facilitydeferred maintenance items ¤ĻŭĻƷğƷźƚƓ ƩĻƒƚǝğƌ ğƩƚǒƓķ ĬǒźƌķźƓŭ Ʒƚ ƦƩƚƷĻĭƷ ƷŷĻ ĬǒźƌķźƓŭ ŅƚǒƓķğƷźƚƓ ğƓķ ƩƚƚŅΑĭźƷǤ ĭǒƩƩĻƓƷƌǤ in progress of removal ¤DğƦƭ ĬĻƷǞĻĻƓ ŅƚǒƓķğƷźƚƓ ğƓķ ĭƚƓĭƩĻƷĻ ğƦƩƚƓƭ ğƌƚƓŭ ǞĻƭƷ ĻƌĻǝğƷźƚƓ ƓĻĻķ Ʒƚ ĬĻ ğķķƩĻƭƭĻķ Α expansion and contraction with freeze thaw cycles will cause long term damage to building ¤East Elevation windows appear to have leaked in the past, replacement recommended ¤Shop floor does not appear to be slopped properly, saw cuts made in floor to aid in guiding water into floor drains Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 57 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 58 of DepartmentBuilding NameAddressFacility SF Pres. Day Repl. 61 Year of Constr.CostsBuilding Repl. Cost10-Year DM CostsFCI Public Works2,9841993/2017 Nature Center2659 7th Street East$ 525 $ 1,566,600 $ 229,752 0.1202 E1, Attachment 1 City of Maplewood Nature Center Expected Annual Facility Maintenance Costs $160,000 $140,000 1-Low2-Medium3-High Grand Total $ 36,312 $ 40,040 $ 60,346 Sum of 2027$ 136,698 $120,000 $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2028$ - $ 2,800 $ - $ - Sum of 2029$ 2,800 $100,000 $ - $ - $ 14,500 Sum of 2030$ 14,500 $ 51,444 $ - $ 8,250 Sum of 2031$ 59,694 $ - $ 8,060 $ - $80,000 Sum of 2032$ 8,060 $ - $ - $ 8,000 Sum of 2033$ 8,000 $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2034$ - $60,000 $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2035$ - $ - $ - $ - Sum of 2036$ - $40,000 $ 90,556 $ 48,100 $ 91,096 $ 229,752 Workshop $20,000 $- Sum of 2027Sum of 2028Sum of 2029Sum of 2030Sum of 2031Sum of 2032Sum of 2033Sum of 2034Sum of 2035Sum of 2036 Packet E1, Attachment 1 1-Low2-Medium3-High Page Number 59 of 61 Workshop Packet Page Number 60 Percentage Breakdown of Costs per Discipline of 61 17-Electronic Safety and Security, $27,950 , 12% 15-Electrical, $8,000 , 4% Sum of Total (with Inf.) 02-Sitework/Building Earthwork, $87,756 , 38% 02-Sitework/Building Earthwork$ 87,756 05-Exterior Enclosure$ 48,100 06-Roof$ - 07-Interior Construction$ - 08-Equipment Furniture$ - 13-HVAC, $35,750 , 16% 11-Fire Protection$ 19,396 12-Plumbing$ 2,800 13-HVAC$ 35,750 15-Electrical$ 8,000 17-Electronic Safety and Security$ 27,950 12-Plumbing, $2,800 , 1% Grand Total$ 229,752 11-Fire Protection, $19,396 , 8% E1, Attachment 1 05-Exterior Enclosure, $48,100 , 21% ¤Address safety & security considerations: ¤No fire alarm panel monitoring building. Recommended to add to ensure safety of building and assets. ¤No ADA openers at entry doors, recommended to be added for compliance ¤Addressimmediate facilitydeferred maintenance items ¤Condensing unit,1993, utilizing R22 refrigerant, needs to be replaced Workshop Packet E1, Attachment 1 Page Number 61 of 61