Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
2023 04-18 CDRB Meeting Packet
Meeting is also available on Comcast Ch. 16 and streaming vod.maplewoodmn.gov AGENDA CITY OF MAPLEWOOD COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW BOARD 6:00 P.M. Tuesday, April 18, 2023 City Hall, Council Chambers 1830 County Road B East A. CALL TO ORDER B. ROLL CALL C. APPROVAL OF AGENDA D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. February 21, 2023 Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes E. NEW BUSINESS 1. Design Review, Townhome Development, Vacant Land on 11th Avenue 2. Design Review, Multifamily Residential Project, 1310 Frost Avenue East 3. Zoning Code – Sign Code Regulations Discussion F. UNFINISHED BUSINESS None G. BOARD PRESENTATIONS H. STAFF PRESENTATIONS None I. VISITOR PRESENTATIONS – 3 minute time limit per person J. ADJOURNMENT THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK February 21, 2023 Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 1 MINUTES MAPLEWOOD COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW BOARD 6:00 P.M. Tuesday, February 21, 2023 City Hall, Council Chambers 1830 County Road B East A.CALL TO ORDER A meeting of the Board was held and called to order at 6:01 p.m. by Chairperson Kempe B.ROLL CALL Bill Kempe, Chairperson Present Jason Lamers, Boardmember Present Amanda Reinert, Boardmember Present Ananth Shankar, Boardmember Absent Tom Oszman, Boardmember Present Staff Present: Michael Martin, Assistant Community Development Director C.APPROVAL OF AGENDA Boardmember Lamers moved to approve the agenda as presented. Seconded by Boardmember Oszman Ayes – All The motion passed. D.APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.November 15, 2022, Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes Boardmember Lamers moved to approve the November 15, 2022, Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes as submitted. Seconded by Boardmember Reinert Ayes – All The motion passed. E.NEW BUSINESS 1.Design Review, Assisted Living and Memory Care Project, 1910 County Road C East Michael Martin, Assistant Community Development Director, presented the Design Review, Assisted Living and Memory Care Project, 1910 County Road C East, and answered questions from the Board. Lucas Larson, Galahad Development, addressed the board and answered questions. Ben Lindau, Doran Companies, addressed the board and answered questions. Kevin Bohl, BKBM Engineers, addressed the board and answered questions. D1 CDRB Packet Page Number 1 of 92 February 21, 2023 Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 2 Boardmember Lamers moved to approve a resolution for design review for a two-story assisted living and memory care facility to be constructed on the vacant land at 1910 County Road C East, as proposed by staff with friendly amendments underlined and in bold, below: 1. Obtain a conditional use permit from the city council for this project. 2. Repeat this review in two years if the city has not issued a building permit for this project. 3. All requirements of the fire marshal and building official must be met. 4. Satisfy the requirements set forth in the engineering review authored by Jon Jarosch, dated January 11, 2023. 5. Satisfy the requirements set forth in the environmental review authored by Shann Finwall and Carole Gernes dated January 11, 2023. 6. The applicant shall obtain all required permits from the Ramsey-Washington Metro W atershed District. 7. Rooftop vents and equipment shall be located out of view from the single-family homes to the north and northwest of the sides of the property. 8. Any identification or monument signs for the project must meet the requirements of the city’s sign ordinance. Identification or monument signs shall be designed to be consistent with the project’s building materials and colors. 9. Before the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit for staff approval the following items: a. The applicant shall provide the city with a cash escrow or an irrevocable letter of credit for all required exterior improvements. The amount shall be 150 percent of the cost of the work. b. For the new parking lot to connect to the existing parking lots located on the properties at 2603 and 2607 White Bear Avenue, the applicant shall provide copies of cross-access and parking agreements with all affected, adjacent parcels. If agreements are not in place, the applicant must maintain a five-foot setback between the new parking lot and the shared property lines to the east. c. The applicant must submit a plan to city staff showing how the potential queuing of cars onto County Road C East due to the shared drive used by the proposed senior housing use and the adjacent car wash will be mitigated. d. The applicant shall submit photos of building materials to city staff and members of the CDRB for review. e. The applicant shall provide adequate screening so the kitchen venting is screened visually from other businesses. 10. The applicant shall complete the following before occupying the building: a. Replace any property irons removed because of this construction. b. Provide continuous concrete curb and gutter around the parking lot and driveways. D1 CDRB Packet Page Number 2 of 92 February 21, 2023 Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 3 c. Install all required landscaping and an in-ground lawn irrigation system for all landscaped areas. d. Install all required outdoor lighting. e. Install all required sidewalks and trails. 11. If any required work is not done, the city may allow temporary occupancy if: a. The city determines that the work is not essential to public health, safety or welfare. b. The above-required letter of credit or cash escrow is held by the City of Maplewood for all required exterior improvements. The owner or contractor shall complete any unfinished exterior improvements by June 1 of the following year if occupancy of the building is in the fall or winter or within six weeks of occupancy of the building if occupancy is in the spring or summer. 12. All work shall follow the approved plans. The director of community development may approve minor changes. Seconded by Boardmember Kempe Ayes – All The motion passed. This item will go before Council on March 13, 2023. 2. 2022 Community Design Review Board Annual Report Michael Martin, Assistant Community Development Director, presented the 2022 Community Design Review Board Annual Report and answered questions from the Board. Boardmember Lamers moved to approve the CDRB’s 2022 Annual Report. Seconded by Boardmember Ayes – All The motion passed. 3. Election of Officers Boardmember Lamers moved to nominate Bill Kempe as the Chairperson and Tom Oszman as the Vice-Chairperson of the Community Design Review Board. Seconded by Chairperson Kemp Ayes – All The motion passed. F. UNFINISHED BUSINESS None G. BOARD PRESENTATIONS None H. STAFF PRESENTATIONS None D1 CDRB Packet Page Number 3 of 92 February 21, 2023 Community Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 4 I. VISITOR PRESENTATIONS None J. ADJOURNMENT Boardmember Lamers moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:48 p.m. Seconded by Boardmember Oszman Ayes – All The motion passed. D1 CDRB Packet Page Number 4 of 92 COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW BOARD STAFF REPORT Meeting Date April 18, 2023 REPORT TO: Melinda Coleman, City Manager REPORT FROM: Elizabeth Hammond, Planner PRESENTER: Elizabeth Hammond, Planner AGENDA ITEM: Design Review, Townhome Development, Vacant Land on 11th Avenue Action Requested: Motion ☐Discussion ☐ Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution ☐ Ordinance ☐ Contract/Agreement ☐ Proclamation Policy Issue: Kennedy Property Development proposes constructing 16 residential townhome units on the subject property. On November 28, 2022, the city council approved the applicant’s request to rezone the property from limited business commercial to high-density residential and amend the city’s comprehensive plan to change the land use designation from commercial to residential. To move forward with the project, the applicant has submitted design plans for consideration by the board. Recommended Action: Motion to approve a resolution for design review, approving a 16-unit townhome development to be constructed on the vacant land on 11th Avenue (PID 112922240029), subject to conditions of approval. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No ☐ Yes, the true or estimated cost is $0 Financing source(s): ☐ Adopted Budget ☐ Budget Modification ☐ New Revenue Source ☐Use of Reserves Other: N/A Strategic Plan Relevance: ☐Community Inclusiveness ☐Financial & Asset Mgmt ☐Environmental Stewardship ☐Integrated Communication Operational Effectiveness Targeted Redevelopment The city deemed the applicant’s application complete on March 30, 2023. The initial 60-day review deadline for a decision is May 29, 2023. As stated in Minnesota State Statute 15.99, the city can take an additional 60 days, if necessary, to complete the review. Background: Kennedy Property Development proposes constructing 16 residential townhome units on the subject property. The townhomes would be divided into four buildings with four units in each. The buildings would be three stories in height, including a ground-level enclosed garage for each unit. The applicant submitted design plans for consideration, and a video tour of a similar project they E1 CDRB Packet Page Number 5 of 92 completed is available to view on the project page: http://www.maplewoodmn.gov/Townhomes. Design Review The property is located in the R3 Multiple Dwelling Residential Zoning District and is required to meet site design standards as outlined in Sections 44-291 through 44-303 and Subdivision IV. - R- 3C Townhouses, Section 44-381 through 44-390. Site Plan The site will be accessed from the south off 11th Avenue East. A two-way drive aisle 24 feet in width is provided between the townhome buildings. The proposed traffic flow illustrates vehicles entering and exiting the site from 11th Avenue and provides a turnaround located on the north end of the property. The townhomes are divided into four separate buildings, with four townhome units in each structure. The buildings must be setback 20 feet from the north, east, and west property lines and 30 feet from the south property line. The proposed location of the buildings achieves the required setbacks. The density permitted on the site is guided by the land use classification in the city's adopted comprehensive plan. The property is guided for high-density residential, which allows between 10.1 – 25 units per acre. The site is 1.11 acres in size, allowing up to 27.7 units. The applicant is proposing a total of 16 units. Elevations Each building is three stories and 35 feet in height, achieving height requirements. The proposed building materials include vinyl siding, trim, soffit, and fascia. The applicant proposes using cedar- shake-looking vinyl siding on a portion of the building. Each unit will have a second-floor balcony and an entrance on the townhome’s front and rear sides. Floor Area and Indoor Storage The minimum habitable floor area for each R-3C multiple dwelling must be 860 square feet per three-bedroom unit. Each unit has 1,709 square feet in total. A minimum of 120 cubic feet of storage space, in addition to normal closet space, is required to be provided for each unit. The storage space must be in the same building as the dwelling unit or garage. If located in the garage, it cannot be part of the parking area. The floorplan document illustrating the first floor provides 140 cubic feet of enclosed storage space within the garage, separate from the parking area. Parking City code requires two spaces for each unit, and one must be enclosed. The plan provides two enclosed parking stalls within the garage of each unit achieving the parking requirement. Each garage has a driveway pad between the garage and the drive aisle, which is 19.5 feet in width and 16.3 feet in length. The site has four guest parking stalls 9.5 feet in width and 18 feet in length, achieving dimensional standards for low turnover, 90-degree off-street parking stalls. Open parking stalls are required to be a minimum distance of 15 feet from a dwelling-unit window. The areas where guest parking is provided achieve this requirement. Landscaping, Screening, Lighting The applicant submitted a landscape plan and tree preservation plan. The applicant must update both plans as outlined in the environmental plan review letter attached to this report. A landscaped area 20 feet in width is required where a site with multiple dwellings abuts a property zoned for single or double dwellings. The adjacent property to the north is zoned farm single dwelling residential. The plan shows a landscaped area 20 feet in width from the property line to the E1 CDRB Packet Page Number 6 of 92 area shown as a turnaround on the plan, with the building being setback further, achieving this requirement. The applicant will work with the environmental planner to achieve landscape and tree preservation ordinance requirements and provide additional landscaped screening along the site’s north end within the 20-foot landscaped setback. The landscaped screening should include evergreen trees. The updated plans are required to be approved by city staff before the issuance of a grading permit. All garbage containers serving multiple dwellings are required to be placed at the rear of the premises. The trash enclosure is located on the north end of the property and rear of the site and is six feet in height. The trash enclosure plan details indicate that the materials and colors will match the buildings on the site. However, one portion of the north elevation is open without fencing. The applicant must provide an updated plan before issuing a building permit that ensures the enclosure will be enclosed on all four sides and is 100 percent opaque. The applicant submitted a photometric plan that appears to achieve code requirements but needs additional clarifying information to be submitted with the building permit. The plan details the type and location of the luminaires proposed and illustrates the light spread and foot-candle levels. The foot-candle levels shown are under the maximum light intensity requirements of 0.4 foot-candles within the property boundaries. However, a detailed description of the proposed luminaires, including the manufacturer’s catalog cuts and drawings, including sections, will be required to obtain a building permit. City code requires screening where light from automobile headlights and other sources would be directed into residential windows. This would be possible on the east side of the property. However, the guest parking stalls located in the site’s interior will be screened by a 6-foot tall vinyl fence achieving this requirement. Department Comments Engineering – Jon Jarosch, Assistant City Engineer Please see the attached engineering review dated April 7, 2023 Environmental – Shann Finwall, Environmental Planner Please see the attached environmental review dated April 10, 2023 Building – Randy Johnson, Building Official The proposed buildings are required to meet the minimum requirements of the Minnesota State Building Code. The proposed buildings are required to be provided with the following: An automatic sprinkler system in accordance with IBC Section 903.2.8 and Minnesota Rule 1305.0903 Subpart 1b and Accessible, Type A and/or Type B units in accordance with the Minnesota Accessibility Code Section 1107.6. Board and Commission Review/Previous Council Action Planning Commission November 15, 2022: The planning commission held a public hearing and reviewed this request. The planning commission voted unanimously to recommend approval of the comprehensive plan amendment resolution and the zoning map amendment ordinance. E1 CDRB Packet Page Number 7 of 92 City Council On November 28, 2022, the city council approved the applicant’s request to rezone the property from limited business commercial to high-density residential and amend the city’s comprehensive plan to change the land use designation from commercial to residential. Community Design Review Board April 18, 2023: The community design review board will review the proposed plans. Citizen Comments Staff sent notice to the surrounding property owners within 350 feet of the proposed development. Staff did not receive any comments on the proposed design plans. Reference Information Site Description Existing Land Use: Vacant Land Surrounding Land Uses North: Single Dwellings East: Maplewood Townhomes South: Cub Foods West: Dentist Office Planning Existing Land Use: High-Density Residential Existing Zoning: R3, Multiple Dwelling Residential Attachments: 1.Design Review Resolution 2.Overview Map 3.2040 Future Land Use Map 4.Zoning Map 5.Applicant’s Narrative 6.Site Plan 7.Landscape Plan 8.Elevations and Rendering 9. Engineering Plan Review, Dated April 7, 2023 10.Environmental Plan Review, Dated April 11, 2023 11.Applicant’s Design Plans (Separate Attachment) E1 CDRB Packet Page Number 8 of 92 DESIGN REVIEW RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Maplewood, Minnesota, as follows: Section 1. Background. 1.01 Kennedy Property Development has requested design review approval for a 16-unit townhome development. 1.01 The property is located on 11th Avenue and is legally described as: PID 112922240029 Section 11, Township 29, Range 22 except the North 278.94 feet: except the West 96.50 feet and except the East 403.00 feet of Northeast 1/4 of Southeast 1/4 of Northwest 1 in Section 11, Township 29, Range 22,(subject to road) Ramsey County, Minnesota, according to the recorded plat thereof. Section 2. Site and Building Plan Findings. 2.01 City ordinance Section 2-290(b) requires that the community design review board make the following findings to approve plans: 1.That the design and location of the proposed development and its relationship to neighboring, existing or proposed developments and traffic is such that it will not impair the desirability of investment or occupation in the neighborhood; that it will not unreasonably interfere with the use and enjoyment of neighboring, existing or proposed developments; and that it will not create traffic hazards or congestion. 2.That the design and location of the proposed development are in keeping with the character of the surrounding neighborhood and are not detrimental to the harmonious, orderly and attractive development contemplated by this article and the city's comprehensive municipal plan. 3.That the design and location of the proposed development would provide a desirable environment for its occupants, as well as for its neighbors, and that it is aesthetically of good composition, materials, textures and colors. Section 3. Community Design Review Board Action. 3.01 The above-described site and design plans are hereby approved based on the findings outlined in Section 2 of this resolution. Subject to staff approval, the site must be developed and maintained in substantial conformance with the design plans date-stamped March 30, 2023. Approval is subject to the applicant doing the following: 1.Repeat this review in two years if the city has not issued a building permit for this project. 2.All requirements of the fire marshal and the building official must be met. E1, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 9 of 92 3.Satisfy the requirements outlined in the engineering review authored by Jon Jarosch, dated April 7, 2023. 4.Satisfy the requirements outlined in the environmental review authored by Shann Finwall, dated April 10, 2023. The applicant shall work with staff to replace some landscaping details on the landscape plan, per the environmental staff’s recommendations. The applicant will provide additional landscaped screening along the north side of the property between the turnaround and the north lot line. The applicant will work with the environmental planner to determine the type of landscape plantings. The applicant will submit an updated plan for review before issuing a grading permit. This plan may be reviewed and approved by staff. 5.The applicant shall obtain all required permits from the Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District. 6.Rooftop vents and mechanical equipment shall be screened and located out of view from all sides of the property. Screening shall be compatible with the materials and design of the building. Rooftop equipment visible from any public street or adjoining property shall be painted to match the building. 7.The applicant shall supply additional photometric plan information. A detailed description of the proposed luminaires, including the manufacturer’s catalog cuts, drawings, and sections, must be submitted before a building permit is issued. 8.Refuse container storage for the individual townhome units shall be housed inside the buildings. The trash receptacle for the site shall be 100 percent opaque on all four sides, be of a design, material, and color compatible with the buildings, and be kept in good repair. A gate that provides 100 percent opaqueness shall be provided. The applicant must provide an updated trash enclosure plan that provides screening on all four sides and is 100 percent opaque. This plan shall be provided before the issuance of a building permit and may be reviewed and approved by staff. 9.Any identification or monument signs for the project must meet the city’s sign ordinance requirements. Identification or monument signs shall be landscaped around the sign’s base and designed to be consistent with the project’s building materials and colors. The applicant shall obtain a sign permit before installing any signage. 10.Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit for staff approval the following items: a.The applicant shall provide the city with a cash escrow or an irrevocable letter of credit for all required exterior improvements. The amount shall be 150 percent of the cost of the work. 11.The applicant shall complete the following before occupying the building: a.Replace any property irons removed because of this construction. b.Provide continuous concrete curb and gutter around the parking lot and driveways. E1, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 10 of 92 c. Install all required landscaping and an in-ground lawn irrigation system for all landscaped areas. d. Install all required outdoor lighting. e. Install all required sidewalks and trails. f. Install stop signs, handicap signs, and building address signs as required by the city. One stop sign shall be installed at the intersection of the drive aisle exit from the site onto 11th Avenue. The applicant will coordinate the location and installation of the stop sign with the Public Works Department. 12. If any required work is not done, the city may allow temporary occupancy if: a. The city determines that the work is not essential to the public, health, safety or welfare. b. The above-required letter of credit or cash escrow is held by the City of Maplewood for all required exterior improvements. The owner or contractor shall complete any unfinished exterior improvements by June 1 of the following year if the occupancy of the building is in the fall or winter or within six weeks of occupancy of the building if occupancy is in the spring or summer. 13. All work shall follow the approved plans. The director of community development may approve minor changes. __________ by the Community Design Review Board of the City of Maplewood, Minnesota, on April 18, 2023. E1, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 11 of 92 Subject Property E1 Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 12 of 92 Subject Parcel E1 Attachment 3 CDRB Packet Page Number 13 of 92 SSSubject Parcel E1 Attachment 4 CDRB Packet Page Number 14 of 92 Kennedy Property Development is proposing to develop 4, 4 unit, residential row style townhomes at the vacant lot at 11th Ave in Maplewood, PID #112922240029, which was successfully rezoned for high density residential use back in the end of 2022 by way of our Comprehensive Plan Amendment & Rezone proposal. In this design review plan, Kennedy Property Development will be building 16 total three-bedroom, three-bathroom single family units with attached 2 car garages. The townhomes we propose to develop will be called Kennedy Square, as the buildings themselves will create a square shape on the lot with two 4 unit buildings facing west and two 4 unit buildings facing east. (Building Plans included in Design Review). Our proposal for Kennedy Square Townhomes will create housing opportunities in alignment with the goals of the City of Maplewood Comprehensive Plan. The current site is vacant and has remained vacant for quite some time. By successfully rezoning the land and including great transitional elements between the neighboring lots in the building design, it is our desire to advance this opportunity to collaborate with the City and begin developing Kennedy Square Townhomes in 2023. The timing proposed for the development, Phase 1 (Units 1 - 8) of Kennedy Square is Spring 2023, where Unites 1 - 8 will be available for homebuyers Spring 2024. We are estimating a 10-11 month construction timeline (See pg 12 & 13 of attached for detailed timeline.) There will be a total of 32 parking stalls in front of each unit’s garage and 8 visitor parking stalls in the development, within city requirements. Kennedy Property Development will be creating a Homeowner’s Association for the development that offices at the developer’s headquarters located at 842 Rice Street in Saint Paul. The building exterior will be D4 lap vinyl siding and vinyl shake, which will provide long term durability with minimal required maintenance. Landscaping will be done in accordance with the City of Maplewood Standards using a combination of trees, shrubs, and grasses planted around the perimeter of the building and throughout the overall site. The design of the building is intended to create a transitional feel and modern craftsmanship between the neighboring buildings, as one neighboring building is commercial, while the other is residential. Developer | Rashad Kennedy, Kennedy Property Development Realtor | Paige Severson, Signature Group (KW Integrity Lakes) Kennedy Property Development Rashad Kennedy | Owner, Builder, Developer (651) 372-2360 2136 Ford Parkway #8004 Saint Paul, MN 55116 E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 15 of 92 1ETPI[SSH9RMX 8S[RLSQI(IZIPSTQIRX (IZIPSTIV`6EWLEH/IRRIH]/IRRIH]4VSTIVX](IZIPSTQIRX 6IEPXSV`4EMKI7IZIVWSR7MKREXYVI+VSYT /;-RXIKVMX]0EOIW Ɣ 4LEWI3RI 9RMXW &YMPHMRKW% &%ZEMPEFPI7TVMRK Ɣ 4LEWI8[S 9RMXW &YMPHMRK' (%ZEMPEFPI7TVMRK E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 16 of 92 2EXMSREP&YMPHIV8VIRHW0SGEP4IVJSVQERGI -RHMGEXSVW 2I['SRWXVYGXMSR6S[7X]PI8S[RLSQI (IZIPSTQIRXW Ɣ 1-,SQIW8LSQTWSR7UYEVI;IWX7EMRX 4EYP 4VMGI8&( Ɣ 1-,SQIW7SYXL+VSZI-RZIV+VSZI,IMKLXW 7XEVXMRKEX ` QS Ɣ 1-+EXI[E]EX1G/RMKLX2SVXL7EMRX4EYP %ZIVEKI7EPIW4VMGI E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 17 of 92 1ETPI[SSH7YTTP](IQERH)GSRSQMGW 1ETPI[SSH'SQTVILIRWMZI4PER7XEXMWXMGW ƈ;LMPIXLIVI[EWERMRGVIEWIMRXLITIVGIRXEKISJEXXEGLIHWMRKPIJEQMP]YRMXWPMOIVS[LSYWIWERH XS[RLSQIWJVSQ MRXS MRWMRKPIJEQMP]HIXEGLIHLSQIWVIQEMRXLI TVIHSQMRERXLSYWMRKX]TIEX Ɖ ƈ8LI'MX]EPWSWE[XLIRYQFIVSJTISTPITIVLSYWMRKYRMXWVIQEMRWXIEH]FIX[IIRERHEX Ɖ TEKISJXLI'SQTVILIRWMZI4PER 8LIFIHFEXLYRMXXS[RLSQIWEGGSQQSHEXIXLIGMX]ƅWTISTPITIVLSYWMRKYRMXWRSXIHMRXLITPER %HHMXMSREPP]SYVYRMXW[MPPGSRXVMFYXI SJXLISZIVEPPYRMXKSEPJSVXLIGMX]ƅW'SQTVILIRWMZI4PERJSV MRGVIEWMRKLMKLHIRWMX]VIWMHIRXMEPPERHYWI ! E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 18 of 92 )GSRSQMG(EXEJVSQ1ETPI[SSH'SQTVILIRWMZI4PERMR 6IPEXMSRXS&Y]IV(IQERH E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 19 of 92 1ETPI[SSH,SYWILSPH-RGSQI4VSƻPIJVSQ(%8%97% E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 20 of 92 2%6'LMIJ)GSRSQMWX0E[VIRGI =YRWEMHPEWX[IIO ƈ8LI]IEVQSVXKEKIVEXI HVSTTMRKYRHIV MWRS[E HMWXMRGXTSWWMFMPMX]8LIKEXIMW FIKMRRMRKXSSTIRJSV LSQIFY]IVW[LSKSXWLYXSYXMR 3GXSFIV 2SZIQFIV[LIRXLI VEXIW[IVIEFSZI ,S[IZIV XLIVIMWWXMPPELSYWMRKWLSVXEKI ERHRSXIRSYKLPMWXMRKWƉ E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 21 of 92 Ɣ 8LI2SZIQFIV(IGIQFIV MRXIVIWXVEXIWSJ MRXIVIWXVEXILEH FY]IVWTE]MRKEFSYXQSVI TIV]IEVXSXLIMVQSVXKEKI Ɣ 2S[[MXLVEXIWGPSWIVXS MRXIVIWX VEXIWS[RMRKELSQIFIGSQIW EJJSVHEFPIXSEFSYX}QMPPMSRVIRXIVW ERHQMPPMSRLSQIS[RIVW E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 22 of 92 *MVWX,SQI,SQI&Y]MRK%WWMWXERGI4VSKVEQXLEXIPMKMFPIFY]IVWGSYPHYXMPM^IXS TYVGLEWIE/IRRIH]7UYEVI8S[RLSQI E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 23 of 92 1EVOIXMRK7XVEXIK] 'YWXSQ;IFWMXI Ɣ %FSYXXLI&YMPHIV (IZIPSTQIRX'SQQYRMX] Ɣ 0IEH'ETXYVIHMVIGX%KIRXJSPPS[YT RYVXYVI Ɣ &YMPHIV8VIRH-RXIKVEXMSR Ɣ 0MZI3TTSVXYRMX]%ZEMPEFMPMX]9THEXIW Ɣ 4LSXS:MHIS8SYVW 107 Ɣ ƈ9RHIV'SRWXVYGXMSRƉ7XEXYW Ɣ ƈ'SQTPIXIH2I['SRWXVYGXMSRƉ7XEXYW 7TVMRK4EVEHI3J,SQIW E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 24 of 92 1MPIWXSRIW %R3ZIVZMI[SJXLI4VSGIWW 5` 6XEPLW'HVLJQ5HYLHZ &ORVHRQWKH/DQG4 5` 0DUNHWLQJ6WUDWHJ\ZHEVLWHDQDO\WLFV .HQQHG\ 3URSHUW\'HYHORSPHQW 6LJQDWXUH*URXS %UHDNLQJ*URXQG $SULO 5` /LVWLQJ2SSRUWXQLW\LQ0/6 ³8QGHU&RQVWUXFWLRQ´OHYHUDJLQJ (DJDQ7RZQKRPHYLGHR SKRWRJUDSK\FRXSOHGZLWKUHYLVHG SODQV %XLOGHU7UHQGV4 4 &RQVWUXFWLRQ0LOHVWRQHVDFFHVVLEOH LQWHUQDOO\IRURXULQYHVWRUSDUWQHUVDQGLQWHUHVWHGFRQVXPHUV 5` 43DUDGHRI+RPHV0DJD]LQH$G6XEPLVVLRQ ³0RGHO´2SHQ+RXVH$JHQW6FKHGXOHV 0DUNHWLQJ&DPSDLJQDQG6SULQJ0DUNHW3UHS 5`5` &RPSOHWHG1HZ&RQVWUXFWLRQ /LVWLQJ6WDWXVIRUDOOXQLWVQRW DOUHDG\XQGHUFRQWUDFW -DQ )HE 0DU $SU 0D\ -XQ -XO $XJ 6HSW 2FW 1RY 'HF E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 25 of 92 1SRXL 'SRWXVYGXMSR 7XVEXIKMGEPP]8EVKIXMRK7TVMRK1EVOIX 8MQIPMRI &VIEOHS[R 7XEKKIVMRK'SRWXVYGXMSR Ɣ &YMPHMRKW% &[MPPFIFYMPXEW4LEWI3RISJXLI (IZIPSTQIRX 9RMXW 1SZI-R%ZEMPEFPI7TVMRK Ɣ &YMPHMRKW' ([MPPFIFYMPXEW4LEWI8[S 9RMXW 1SZI-R%ZEMPEFPI7TVMRK 'SRWYQIVW[MPPFIEFPIXSVIWIVZISVƈLSPHƉJYXYVI4LEWI 8[SYRMXW[MXLEHITSWMX FVSOIVXVYWXEGGSYRX LEZIXLISTXMSRXSHMWGYWWMRXIVMSVWIPIGXMSRW[MXL/4( HIWMKRIV 4LEWI3RISTTSVXYRMXMIW[MPPFIEZEMPEFPIXSFY]IVWMRXLI 107EWƈ9RHIV'SRWXVYGXMSRƉSTTSVXYRMXMIWWSXLEX[IQE] KSYRHIVGSRXVEGXTVMSVXSGSQTPIXMSR E1 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 26 of 92 E1 Attachment 6 CDRB Packet Page Number 27 of 92 W>Ed^, h> ϭ /hKh^dZ ^YdzKDDKEED KdE/>ED KEd^tKϲ^tDWt,/d K<Yh Zh^/K>KZϮ͘ϱΗ/ͬ͘ /hKh^dZ ^YdzKDDKEED KdE/>ED KEd^Dϴ^/>s ZDW> Z^,Z/EhDϮ͘ϱΗ/ͬ͘ϯKE/& ZKh^dZ ^YdzKDDKEED KdE/>ED KEdt^ϲt,/d ^WZh W/ '>hϲ&d͘d>>ϰKE/& ZKh^dZ ^YdzKDDKEED KdE/>ED KEdEtϲ EKZd, ZEt,/d Zd,/:K/ Ed>/^ϲ&d͘d>>ϱ^,ZhYdzKDDKEED KdE/>ED KEd'^ϯϬ'K>&>D ^W/Z ^W/Z h>DhΗ'K>&>D ΗϭϮΗWKdϲ^,ZhYdzKDDKEED KdE/>ED KEd&'Ϯϲ W/E<Z >KKD/E't /'>&>KZ/KK<Z^KW/EϭϮΗWKddKd>ϴϮE1 Attachment 7 CDRB Packet Page Number 28 of 92 E1 Attachment 8 CDRB Packet Page Number 29 of 92 E1 Attachment 8 CDRB Packet Page Number 30 of 92 E1 Attachment 8 CDRB Packet Page Number 31 of 92 Engineering Plan Review PROJECT: 11th Avenue Townhomes PROJECT NO: 22-31 COMMENTS BY: Jon Jarosch, P.E. – Assistant City Engineer DATE: 4-7-2023 PLAN SET: Civil plans dated March 23, 2023 REPORTS: None The applicant is seeking a design review to construct a 16-unit townhome development on a vacant lot on 11th Avenue. This review does not constitute a final review of the plans, as the applicant will need to submit construction documents and calculations for final review. The following are engineering review comments on the design and act as conditions prior to issuing permits. Drainage and Stormwater Management 1)The amount of disturbance on this site is greater than ½ acre. As such, the project is required to meet the City’s stormwater quality, rate control, and other stormwater management requirements. 2)A stormwater management plan shall be submitted, including hydraulic calculations, to depict how the project is meeting the City and Watershed District’s stormwater management standards. 3)The project shall be submitted to the Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District (RWMWD) for review. All conditions of RWMWD shall be met. 4)A joint storm water maintenance agreement shall be prepared and signed by the owner for stormwater best management practices utilized to meet the stormwater management standards. The Owner shall submit a signed copy of the joint storm-water maintenance agreement with the RWMWD to the City. 5)The 100-Year High-Water Level (HWL) for the proposed infiltration trench shall be shown on the plans. The finished floor elevation of the townhomes shall be at a minimum 2-feet higher than the 100-year HWL within the infiltration trench system and a minimum of 1-foot higher than the emergency overflow elevation. 6)An emergency overflow for the infiltration trench shall be depicted on the plans. E1 Attachment 9 CDRB Packet Page Number 32 of 92 7)Geotechnical (soil boring) information shall be provided to support infiltration rates utilized in hydraulic calculations. Grading and Erosion Control 8)A grading and erosion control plan shall be submitted for review. 9)A copy of the project SWPPP and NDPES Permit shall be submitted prior to the issuance of a grading permit. Sanitary Sewer and Water Service 10)The applicant shall work with the City and Saint Paul regional Water Services on connecting to the water system while minimizing impacts to the newly reconstructed 11th Avenue. All requirements of SPRWS shall be met. 11)The applicant shall be responsible for paying any SAC, WAC, or PAC charges related to the improvements proposed with this project. A SAC determination is required. Other 12) 11 th Avenue was reconstructed in 2022. The applicant shall design the site entrance to minimize impacts to the newly reconstructed street. If intrusions into the street pavement are necessary for the entrance or site utilities, the right-of-way area shall be restored per the City’s right-of-way ordinance. It should be noted that restoration of the street may be significant due to it being recently reconstructed. 13)The Civil plans and stormwater management plan shall be signed by a Civil Engineer licensed in the State of Minnesota. Public Works Permits The following permits are required by the Maplewood Public Works Department for this project should the project move forward. The applicant should verify the need for other City permits with the Building Department. 14)Right-of-way permit 15)Grading and erosion control permit 16)Storm Sewer Permit 17)Sanitary Sewer Permit -END COMMENTS - E1 Attachment 9 CDRB Packet Page Number 33 of 92 Environmental Review Project: Kennedy Square Townhomes Date of Revised Plans: March 23, 2023 Date of Review: April 10, 2023 Location: XXXX 11th Avenue East Property ID 112922240029 Reviewer: Shann Finwall, Environmental Planner 651-249-2304, shann.finwall@maplewoodmn.gov Carole Gernes, Natural Resources Coordinator 651-249-2416, carole.gernes@maplewoodmn.gov Project Background: The applicant proposes constructing 16 townhome units divided into four separate buildings on a 1.11-acre vacant lot located east of 1975 11th Avenue East and west of 2451 Aerial Street North. The applicant must comply with the City’s tree preservation ordinance and landscape policies. Tree Ordinance 1.Tree Preservation Ordinance: a.Significant Trees: Maplewood’s tree preservation ordinance describes a significant tree as a healthy tree of the following size: hardwood tree with a minimum of 6 inches in diameter, an evergreen tree with a minimum of 8 inches in diameter, and a softwood tree with a minimum of 12 inches in diameter. b.Specimen Trees: A specimen tree is defined as a healthy tree of any species that is 28 inches in diameter or greater. c.Tree Replacement: If greater than 20 percent of significant trees are removed, tree replacement is based on a calculation of significant trees located on the site and significant trees removed. Credits are given for all specimen trees that are preserved. If less than 20 percent of significant trees are removed, tree replacement is based on a calculation of one 2-caliper inch replacement tree per significant tree removed. d.Tree Replacement: The tree standards require that as many replacement trees be planted on the site as possible. An applicant can pay into the City’s tree fund at a rate of $60 per caliper inch for trees that cannot be planted on site. The City uses the tree fund to manage trees in parks and within the right-of-way. 2.Tree Impacts: There are 81 significant trees on site for a total of 634 caliper inches. The applicants propose to remove 58 trees for a total of 456 caliper inches. That represents 72 percent tree removal. 3.City Code Requirements: City code requires 355 caliper inches of replacement trees on the site (which equals 177 – 2 caliper inches of replacement trees). E1 Attachment 10 CDRB Packet Page Number 34 of 92 4.Proposed Tree Replacement: The landscape plan shows 26 new trees ranging in size from 2 to 2.5 caliper inches, totaling 59 caliper inches of replacement trees. This is 296 caliper inches less than city code requirement (355 caliper inches of required replacement trees – 59 caliper inches of proposed replacement trees = 296 caliper inches less than city code requirement). 5.Tree Recommendations: a.Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant must submit the following: 1)Revised Tree Preservation Plan: The number and size of trees on the site and removed is indicated on the tree preservation plan. However, the final tree calculation based on the City of Maplewood’s Tree Preservation Ordinance was not included. Please detail the following: a)Total caliper inches of significant trees on the site. b)Total caliper inches of significant trees removed. c)Tree replacement calculation based on the City of Maplewood Tree Preservation Ordinance. 2)Revised Landscape Plan: a)Additional Trees: The revised landscape plan must identify 296 caliper inches of additional trees on the site. Alternatively, the applicant can pay into the City’s tree fund (see below). b)Maple Trees: Maplewood’s tree canopy consists of over 20 percent maples. To prevent future diseases from wiping out the same species or genera of trees, Maplewood discourages planting of maples and stands of identical species in a concentrated area or rows. Replace all of the maples with a mix of other climate resilient trees such as 1. Ironwood, Ostrya virginiana 2.Hackberry, Celtis occidentalis 3.Dutch-Elm Disease resistant selection of American elm, Ulmus Americana, such as St. Croix, Prairie Expedition, or New Harmony 4.American basswood (Linden), Tilia americana c)Spruce Trees: Spruce trees contribute to over 20 percent of Maplewood’s tree canopy. Replace or reduce the spruce trees with a mix of the deciduous trees mentioned above. d)Unless needed for screening, staff recommends relocating the conifers on the north side of the property for energy conservation, rather than the east and west. This will allow sunlight to reach the buildings in the winter. 3)Tree Planting and Maintenance: E1 Attachment 10 CDRB Packet Page Number 35 of 92 a)Planting trees to the root flare is too deep and will result in strangling/ encircling roots. Trees should be planted using recommendations found in the MN DNR Pocket Guide to Tree Planting to prevent growth of strangling encircling roots and ensure long term tree survival. Remove excess soil from the top of the tree container or root ball until the top of the first major root is exposed. Plant to a depth where the top of the first large lateral root is visible. No more than three inches of mulch is recommended, and it should not touch the tree trunk. Root-bound containerized trees and shrubs should be box-cut before planting. b)Tree stakes should be made from a flexible material, such as reinforced fiberglass to build tree trunk strength. 4)Escrow: The applicant must submit a tree escrow in the amount of $60 per caliper inch of trees to be replaced on the site. The escrow will be released once the trees are planted with a one-year warranty. 5)Tree Fund: The applicants can pay into the City’s tree fund at a rate of $60 per caliper inch of replacement tree that cannot be planted on site. If no additional trees are planted, the applicant would owe the City’s tree fund $23,880 (355 caliper inches of required replacement trees – 59 caliper inches of proposed replacement trees = 296 caliper inches of trees not planted on the site x $60 = $17,760). Landscape Policies Review of the overall landscape plan to ensure nonnative and invasive species are avoided, seed mix is appropriate for use in areas proposed, and plantings are climate resilient. Landscaping Recommendations: 1.Prior to issuance of a grading permit, submit a revised landscape plan with the following changes: a)Identify that all plants are systemic-insecticide free plants in order to protect pollinators and other wildlife. b)Replace Goldflame spirea. This plant is a cultivar of Japanese spirea, which is invasive. Replace with a diversity of native pollinator-supporting shrubs such as New Jersey tea, Ceanothus americanus; native bush honeysuckle, Diervilla lonicera; a blueberry cultivar, Vaccinium ssp; or monarch supporting perennial such as Butterfly-weed, Asclepias tuberosa. Planting a mix of these species rather than 30 of the same species will also help prevent the spread of plant pests and diseases. c)Reduce the number and/or replace Weigela. This plant is not invasive, but fewer should be planted to increase diversity and prevent the spread of pests and diseases. E1 Attachment 10 CDRB Packet Page Number 36 of 92 COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW BOARD STAFF REPORT Meeting Date April 18, 2023 REPORT TO: Melinda Coleman, City Manager REPORT FROM: Michael Martin, AICP, Assistant Community Development Director PRESENTER: Michael Martin, AICP, Assistant Community Development Director AGENDA ITEM: Design Review Resolution, Multifamily Residential Project, 1310 Frost Avenue East Action Requested: Motion ☐Discussion ☐ Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution ☐ Ordinance ☐Contract/Agreement ☐ Proclamation Policy Issue: JB Vang proposes to develop Gladstone Village, a 65-unit affordable multifamily apartment project located on an approximately 1.59-acre site at the corner of Frost Avenue and English Street – 1310 Frost Avenue East. To proceed with this project, the applicant requests city council approval for a conditional use permit and design review. Recommended Action: Motion to approve a resolution for design review approving a four-story, 65-unit multifamily apartment project to be constructed at 1310 Frost Avenue East. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No ☐ Yes, the true or estimated cost is $0 Financing source(s): ☐ Adopted Budget ☐ Budget Modification ☐ New Revenue Source ☐Use of Reserves Other: N/A Strategic Plan Relevance: ☐Community Inclusiveness ☐Financial & Asset Mgmt ☐Environmental Stewardship ☐Integrated Communication Operational Effectiveness ☐Targeted Redevelopment The city deemed the applicant’s application complete on March 31, 2023. The initial 60-day review deadline for a decision is May 30, 2023. As stated in Minnesota State Statute 15.99, the city is allowed to take an additional 60 days, if necessary, to complete the review. Background: JB Vang’s proposed 65-unit affordable multifamily apartment’s amenities would include a community and co-working room, outdoor grilling and patio area, fitness, and flex spaces located on English Street facing south to take advantage of solar access, as well as convenient access to on- site surface parking and Gladstone Savanna Park located on the west side of English Street. The courtyard shaped by the building facing south is utilized as a patio and playground, giving the residents an expansive resident-only outdoor space. E2 CDRB Packet Page Number 37 of 92 Gladstone Village’s unit mix will encourage family-friendly design by including 18 three- and nine four-bedroom units. The building will have indoor and outdoor gathering areas, including community and recreation spaces for residents. The building would also provide affordable housing to those making 30 percent to 60 percent of the Area Median Income (AMI) calculated annually by HUD, and unit sizes range from approximately 700 to 1,590 square feet. A small percentage of units are set aside for people with disabilities under the Section 811 housing program and people/families experiencing homelessness. Some units will receive designated housing services, and others will receive oversight by the Minnesota Department of Human Services. The applicant hosted a community open house on March 15, 2023, from 6:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. at the Wakefield Park Community Building. Invites were sent to all property owners within 500 feet of the project’s site. The night of the open house, the applicant brought poster boards with preliminary renderings and printed out a few large plan pages for folks to see and comment on if desired. The open house was lightly attended by 4 adults and 1 child. Gladstone Neighborhood Redevelopment Plan The Gladstone Neighborhood Redevelopment Plan outlines nine guiding principles to redevelopment in the area as follows: 1. Design the future of Gladstone as a village. 2. Transform regional trails into celebrated village corridors. 3. Make Gladstone a compelling quality of life choice. 4. Weave natural systems and ecological function into the built and recreational environment. 5. Allow Gladstone’s future to whisper the story of its past. 6. Make walkability the standard. 7. Think of Gladstone as a neighborhood for all stages of life. 8. Make the Gladstone redevelopment plan a model for others to follow. 9. Make multi-modal links between Gladstone and areas beyond. Conditional Use Permit Four-Story Building The MU – mixed-use zoning district requires a conditional use permit for any residential buildings over three stories or 35 feet tall. The applicant’s proposed building will be four stories and typically approximately 48 feet from ground level to the top of the parapet. In comparison, the multi-family buildings west of this project site approved as part of the Frost-English Village redevelopment project are 51 feet tall. Design Review Site Plan The project site would be accessed from a single drive coming off English Street on the west side of the site. The proposed building would be on the site’s north side, with surface parking to the south. The city’s mixed-use district requires surface parking to be to the rear of the building. The mixed- use district also requires a front yard setback for multiple dwelling buildings to be no more than 20 feet, with a minimum of zero feet – this applies to both the English Street and Frost Avenue frontages. There are no side or rear building setback requirements. Parking lots are required to be setback five feet from side and rear property lines. All setback requirements are being met. E2 CDRB Packet Page Number 38 of 92 Building Elevations Exterior building walls adjacent to or visible from a public right-of-way or public open space may not exceed 40 feet in width. New buildings of more than 40 feet in width are allowed if the building wall is divided into smaller increments, between 20 and 40 feet in width, through the articulation of the façade. Exterior-building materials shall be classified as primary, secondary, or accent material. Primary materials shall cover at least 60 percent of all façades of a building. Secondary materials may cover no more than 30 percent of all façades of a building. Accent materials may include door and window frames, lintels, cornices, and other minor elements and may cover no more than ten percent of all façades of a building. The community design review board may consider exceptions to the above-mentioned design standards if they uphold the integrity of the guidelines and result in an attractive, cohesive development design as intended by ordinance. The primary materials for the proposed 65-unit multi-family building are brick and glass – with brick being utilized in two different tones of color – and will comprise 62 percent of the elevations. Secondary materials include stucco and masonry, making up 30 percent of the elevations. Accent materials will include charcoal metal panels. The building will be articulated in 20-40 foot segments. Unit Sizes Ordinance requires minimum unit sizes of 580 square feet per efficiency or one-bedroom units, 740 square feet for two-bedroom units, 860 square feet for three-bedroom units and 1,040 square feet for four-bedroom units. All units in this project meet these requirements. Parking Waiver The city code states that multi-family buildings must provide two parking spaces for each unit – with one of the parking spaces being covered. This project requires a total of 130 spaces. The applicant is proposing to include 64 underground parking spaces and 39 surface parking spaces, for a total of 103 parking spaces. The applicant is seeking a waiver of 27 spaces. The applicant believes the ratio of 1.58 stalls per dwelling unit will be sufficient for the targeted resident population and building’s location. Parking spaces in the mixed use district are required be nine feet wide – the applicant’s site plans meets this requirement. For parking lots consisting of 20 or more spaces, interior landscape islands are required. Interior landscape islands shall be at a rate of one landscape island for every ten parking spaces. Landscape islands shall be a minimum of 144 square feet in area and shall be a minimum of eight feet in width, as measured from back of curb to back of curb. The applicant is requesting the community design review board consider an exception to this requirement as it would eliminate at least four additional surface parking spaces. Staff is comfortable with the parking waiver and providing an exception to the interior landscape island requirement. Landscaping and Screening All areas of land not occupied by buildings, parking, driveways, sidewalks or other hard surface are required to be sodded or mulched and landscaped with approved ground cover, flowers, shrubbery and trees. Hard-surfaced areas, including sidewalks and patios, must include amenities such as benches, planters and bike racks. Perimeter landscape or pedestrian walls are required for all parking lots and shall be established along the road and edges of the parking lot. The landscape treatment or pedestrian wall shall run E2 CDRB Packet Page Number 39 of 92 the full length of the parking lot and be located between the property line and the edge of the parking lot. There are six significant trees on site equaling 73 caliper inches. The applicants propose to remove three trees equaling 46 caliper inches. This represents 59 percent tree removal. City code requires 16 caliper inches of replacement trees on the site (which equals 8 – 2 caliper inches of replacement trees). The landscape plan shows 32 new trees ranging in size from 2 to 2.5 caliper inches, totaling 71.6 caliper inches of replacement trees, which meets, and exceeds, the tree replacement requirements. In addition to the proposed trees, the applicant’s landscape plan includes many shrubs, grasses and perennials. City code also requires additional landscaping or screening when light from automobile headlights and other sources would be directed into residential windows. With the manufactured home park to the south there is a need to provide additional screening along the south property line as there is a row of parking spaces facing south. Lighting The applicant submitted a photometric plan as part of its application. It appears the plan is meeting the code requirements but is not showing the light intensity measurement at all property lines. Before any permits are issued, the applicant must submit a revised photometric plan showing all code requirements being met. Trash Enclosure All trash and recycling will be maintained within the building. Trash and recycling chute access will be available on each building floor leading to a trash room in the garage. On pick-up days, site management will pull bins outside to a staging area on the southeast corner of the site for the trash company for pick up. The bins will be rolled back inside the garage trash room on the same day. Department Comments Engineering Please see Jon Jarosch’s engineering report, dated April 10, 2023, attached to this report. Environmental Please see Shann Finwall’s environmental report, dated April 11, 2023, attached to this report. Building Official – Randy Johnson The proposed building is required to meet the minimum requirements of the Minnesota State Building Code. Board and Commission Review Community Design Review Board April 18, 2023: The community design review board will review this project. Planning Commission April 18, 2023: The planning commission will review this project and hold a public hearing. E2 CDRB Packet Page Number 40 of 92 Citizen Comments Staff surveyed the 28 surrounding property owners within 500 feet of the proposed site for their opinion about this proposal. Staff did not receive any comments. Reference Information Site Description Project Area: 1.59 acres Existing Land Use: Funeral Home Surrounding Land Uses North: Frost Avenue, multi-tenant commercial building and a vacant building East: Bruce Vento Trail and commercial buildings South: Manufactured home park West: English Street and Gladstone Savanna Planning Existing Land Use: Mixed-Use - Neighborhood HD Existing Zoning: Mixed-Use Attachments: 1.Conditional Use Permit Resolution 2.Design Review Resolution 3.Overview Map 4.2040 Future Land Use Map 5.Zoning Map 6.Applicant’s Narrative 7.Site Plan 8.Landscape Plan 9.Tree Preservation Plan 10.Photometric Plan 11.Building Elevations 12.Engineering Report, dated April 10, 2023 13.Environmental Report, dated April 11, 2023 14.Applicant’s Plans (separate attachment) E2 CDRB Packet Page Number 41 of 92 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Maplewood, Minnesota, as follows: Section 1. Background. 1.01 Ashley Bisner, of JB Vang, has requested approval of a conditional use permit to permit a four-story multifamily building. 1.02 The property is located at 1310 Frost Avenue East and is legally described as: PIN: 152922320076. Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, except the South 7 feet of said Lot 7, Block 3, Gladstone, according to the recorded plat thereof, together with the vacated Ridge Street adjacent, Ramsey County, Minnesota. Abstract Property Section 2. Standards. 2.01 City Ordinance Section 44-359 requires a Conditional Use Permit for multiple dwelling buildings that exceed a height of 35 feet. 2.02 General Conditional Use Permit Standards. City Ordinance Section 44-1097(a) states that the City Council must base approval of a Conditional Use Permit on the following nine standards for approval. 1.The use would be located, designed, maintained, constructed and operated to be in conformity with the City’s Comprehensive Plan and Code of Ordinances. 2.The use would not change the existing or planned character of the surrounding area. 3.The use would not depreciate property values. 4.The use would not involve any activity, process, materials, equipment or methods of operation that would be dangerous, hazardous, detrimental, disturbing or cause a nuisance to any person or property, because of excessive noise, glare, smoke, dust, odor, fumes, water or air pollution, drainage, water run-off, vibration, general unsightliness, electrical interference or other nuisances. 5.The use would not exceed the design standards of any affected street. 6.The use would be served by adequate public facilities and services, including streets, police and fire protection, drainage structures, water and sewer systems, schools and parks. 7.The use would not create excessive additional costs for public facilities or services. 8.The use would maximize the preservation of and incorporate the site’s natural and scenic features into the development design. 9.The use would cause minimal adverse environmental effects. E2, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 42 of 92 Section 3. Findings. 3.01 The proposal meets the specific conditional use permit standards. Section 4. City Review Process 4.01 The City conducted the following review when considering this conditional use permit request. 1. On April 18, 2023, the planning commission held a public hearing. The city staff published a hearing notice in the Pioneer Press and sent notices to the surrounding property owners. The planning commission gave everyone at the hearing a chance to speak and present written statements. 2. On May 8, 2023, the city council discussed this resolution. They considered reports and recommendations from the planning commission and city staff. Section 5. City Council 5.01 The city council hereby _______ the resolution. Approval is based on the findings outlined in section 3 of this resolution. Approval is subject to the following conditions: (additions are underlined and deletions are crossed out): 1.All construction shall follow the approved plans, date-stamped March 31, 2023. The director of community development may approve minor changes. 2.The proposed construction must be substantially started within one year of council approval or the permit shall become null and void. 3.The city council shall review this permit in one year. 4.A parking waiver of 27 parking spaces is approved. If a parking shortage develops, the city council may require additional parking spaces to be constructed. __________ by the City Council of the City of Maplewood, Minnesota, on May 8, 2023. E2, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 43 of 92 DESIGN REVIEW RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Maplewood, Minnesota, as follows: Section 1. Background. 1.01 Ashley Bisner, of JB Vang, has requested approval of design review to permit a four- story multifamily building. 1.02 The property is located at 1310 Frost Avenue East and is legally described as: 1.03 PIN: 152922320076. Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, except the South 7 feet of said Lot 7, Block 3, Gladstone, according to the recorded plat thereof, together with the vacated Ridge Street adjacent, Ramsey County, Minnesota. Abstract Property Section 2. Site and Building Plan Standards and Findings. 2.01 City ordinance Section 2-290(b) requires that the community design review board make the following findings to approve plans: 1.That the design and location of the proposed development and its relationship to neighboring, existing or proposed developments and traffic is such that it will not impair the desirability of investment or occupation in the neighborhood; that it will not unreasonably interfere with the use and enjoyment of neighboring, existing or proposed developments; and that it will not create traffic hazards or congestion. 2.That the design and location of the proposed development are in keeping with the character of the surrounding neighborhood and are not detrimental to the harmonious, orderly and attractive development contemplated by this article and the city's comprehensive municipal plan. 3.That the design and location of the proposed development would provide a desirable environment for its occupants, as well as for its neighbors, and that it is aesthetically of good composition, materials, textures and colors. Section 3. City Council Action. 3.01 The above-described site and design plans are hereby approved based on the findings outlined in Section 3 of this resolution. Subject to staff approval, the site must be developed and maintained in substantial conformance with the design plans date-stamped March 31, 2023. Approval is subject to the applicant doing the following: 1.Obtain a conditional use permit from the city council for this project. 2.Repeat this review in two years if the city has not issued a building permit for this project. 3.All requirements of the fire marshal and building official must be met. E2, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 44 of 92 4.Satisfy the requirements set forth in the engineering review authored by Jon Jarosch, dated April 10, 2023. 5.Satisfy the requirements set forth in the environmental review authored by Shann Finwall, dated April 11, 2023. 6.The applicant shall obtain all required permits from the Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District. 7.Rooftop vents and equipment shall be located out of view from all sides of the property. 8.Any identification or monument signs for the project must meet the requirements of the city’s mixed-use sign ordinance. Identification or monument signs shall be designed to be consistent with the project’s building materials and colors. 9.Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit for staff approval the following items: a.The applicant shall provide the city with a cash escrow or an irrevocable letter of credit for all required exterior improvements. The amount shall be 150 percent of the cost of the work. b.A revised landscape plan that details screening along the south property line that meets city code requirements. c.A revised photometric plan that meets city code requirements. 10.The applicant shall complete the following before occupying the building: a.Replace any property irons removed because of this construction. b.Provide continuous concrete curb and gutter around the parking lot and driveways. c.Install all required landscaping and an in-ground lawn irrigation system for all landscaped areas. d.Install all required outdoor lighting. e.Install all required sidewalks and trails. 11.If any required work is not done, the city may allow temporary occupancy if: a.The city determines that the work is not essential to public health, safety or welfare. b.The above-required letter of credit or cash escrow is held by the City of Maplewood for all required exterior improvements. The owner or contractor shall complete any unfinished exterior improvements by June 1 of the following year if occupancy of the building is in the fall or winter or within six weeks of occupancy of the building if occupancy is in the spring or summer. E2, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 45 of 92 12.All work shall follow the approved plans. The director of community development may approve minor changes. __________ by the City Council of the City of Maplewood, Minnesota, on May 8, 2023. E2, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 46 of 92 Overview Map - 1310 Frost Avenue East City of Maplewood March 30, 2023 Legend !I 0 475 FeetSource: City of Maplewood, Ramsey County Project Site E2 Attachment 3 CDRB Packet Page Number 47 of 92 1265 1843 1825 1831 1865 1310 1940 1281 1315 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1273 12891241 1955 1344 1321 1835 18891880 1880 1880 1265 1281 131712471905 1899 1840 1965 1946 1870 1830 1880 1249 1257 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1851 1350 1881 1351 13191313 1347 1957 1842 1249 1323 1321 Future Land Use Map - 1310 Frost Avenue East City of Maplewood March 30, 2023 Legend !IFuture Land Use - 2040 Low Density Residential Medium Density Residential Mixed Use - Neighborhood High Density Public/Institutional Open Space Project Site 0 240 FeetSource: City of Maplewood, Ramsey County E2 Attachment 4 CDRB Packet Page Number 48 of 92 1265 1843 1825 1831 1865 1310 1940 1281 1315 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1273 12891241 1955 1344 1321 1835 18891880 1880 1880 1265 1281 131712471905 1899 1840 1965 1946 1870 1830 1880 1249 1257 1880 1880 1880 1880 1880 1851 1350 1881 1351 13191313 1347 1957 1842 1249 1323 1321 Zoning Map - 1310 Frost Avenue East City of Maplewood March 30, 2023 Legend !IZoning Single Dwelling (r1) Multiple Dwelling (r3) Open Space/Park Mixed Use (mu) Project Site 0 240 FeetSource: City of Maplewood, Ramsey County E2 Attachment 5 CDRB Packet Page Number 49 of 92 Advisory | Management Development | Facilities JB Vang | 1335 Pierce Butler Route | St. Paul, MN 55104 M: 651.645.5500 | F: 651.645.3907 | www.jbvang.com Gladstone Village – Project Narrative Project Team JB Vang is a BIPOC Developer located in the city of St. Paul. JB Vang has developed over 1 million square feet of real estate totaling over $700MM with a wide variety of project types such as extensive commercial experience, educational facilities, retail, office, industrial and various types of housing projects. In addition to JB Vang, the Project team consists of Urbanworks architecture, Premier property management, Simpson Housing services, Flannery construction and The Landon Group. Project Summary JB Vang, along with the project team, is proposing to develop Gladstone Village, a 65-unit affordable multifamily apartment project located on an approximately 1.59-acre site at the corner of Frost Avenue and English Street in Maplewood, Minnesota. Gladstone Village (the “Project”) received a funding allocation from Minnesota Housing Finance Agency (MHFA) in the 2022 Consolidated RFP / 2023 Housing Tax Credits Round 1. The Project will be a 4-story development providing a mix of sixty-five (65) one-, two-, three-, and four-bedroom family friendly apartments, ground level resident use amenities, and one-level of resident use underground parking. JB Vang intends to begin construction late 2023 or early 2024. The Project will consist of a four-story, stick frame building with an elevator, and the building’s exterior consists primarily of brick and stucco with metal accents. It includes 64 underground parking stalls and 39 surface parking stalls, for a total of 103 parking stalls. The code minimum for parking at the Project’s location is 2 stalls per dwelling unit. Gladstone Village parking equates to 1.58 stalls per dwelling unit, which is ample for the targeted population and location provided the Project’s adjacency to bus stops and the potential future Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Purple Line. Additional information regarding anticipated traffic and parking needs for Gladstone Village is available upon request. The Project’s amenities, which include a community and co-working room, outdoor grilling and patio area, fitness, and flex spaces, are located on English Street facing south to take advantage of solar access, as well as convenient access to on-site surface parking and Gladstone Savanna Park located on the west side of English Street. The courtyard shaped by the building facing south is utilized as a patio and playground, giving the residents an expansive resident only outdoor space. A second entry point to the Project is proposed for bus transit users and those utilizing the bicycle trail at the northeast corner of the site along Frost Avenue. Gladstone Village’s unit mix will encourage family-friendly design by including eighteen (18) three- and nine (9) four-bedroom units. The family-friendly building will have indoor and outdoor gathering areas including community and recreation spaces for residents. The Project provides affordable housing to those making 30% to 60% of the Area Median Income (AMI) calculated annually by HUD, and unit sizes range from approximately 700 to 1,590 square feet. A small percentage of units are set aside for people with disabilities (PWD) under the Section 811 housing program E2 Attachment 6 CDRB Packet Page Number 50 of 92 Advisory | Management Development | Facilities JB Vang | 1335 Pierce Butler Route | St. Paul, MN 55104 M: 651.645.5500 | F: 651.645.3907 | www.jbvang.com and people/families experiencing homelessness. Some units will receive designated housing services and others will receive oversight by the Minnesota Department of Human Services. The building is following the Enterprise Green Communities green building program for affordable housing as amended by MN Housing. In addition, the building is following the B3 Sustainable Building 2030 Energy standard, which set targets for reducing energy usage. Projects under these programs are required to meet both an energy and carbon standard, and utilize renewable energy sources. Strategies include utilizing an improved envelope design with reduced air infiltration, utilizing high-efficiency HVAC equipment, and exploring new technologies for lighting, appliances, and other building features. Access to Nearby Transit and Shopping Metro Transit Route 64, a high frequency Metro Transit bus route, has a stop adjacent to the Project. Route 64 provides access to downtown Saint Paul and major employers including Traveler’s Insurance, EcoLab, Bremer Financial, St. Paul Technical College, Metropolitan State University, and the Pioneer Press. Multiple hospital systems are also accessible by transit including Regions, United, and St. Joseph’s Hospital. To the North, Route 64 provides access to Maplewood Mall, Phalen Regional Park, Maplewood Community Center and many restaurants and small regional employers. Gladstone Village residents will have access to a wide variety of shopping options nearby including Cub Foods (1.7 miles to the south), several convenience stores, restaurants, and other retailers. Contribution to City and County Future Planning The Project site is in an area of the City of Maplewood promoting redevelopment as demonstrated in multiple area plans including the Gladstone Redevelopment Area Plan and the Maplewood 2040 Comprehensive Plan. The City of Maplewood 2040 Comprehensive Plan calls for increased, new housing stock. The community has expressed concern over the lack of affordable housing. The vacancy rate in Maplewood continues to decrease; in 2010, it was 4.4%, in 2017 it was 2.4%, and it is projected to continue to decrease in the coming years. Specifically, the 2040 Plan states, “As new projects are developed, consideration should be given to the inclusion of affordable options. While there are a number of subsidized options available, it is not enough to meet current, as well as future demands” (6-111). Gladstone Village directly addresses the need for additional affordable housing in Maplewood. The addition of 65 new affordable housing units, all set at 30%, 50%, and 60% AMI, will increase the options for the residents of Maplewood, especially families in need of two-, three-, and four-bedroom units. The Metropolitan Council has projected that Maplewood will need to bring 510 new units of housing to the market between 2021 and 2040 to keep up with demand. Over half of these units (345) need to meet affordability rates at or below 50% AMI. Gladstone Village will achieve 13.6% of this goal with the addition of 47 new units at or below 50% AMI. E2 Attachment 6 CDRB Packet Page Number 51 of 92 Advisory | Management Development | Facilities JB Vang | 1335 Pierce Butler Route | St. Paul, MN 55104 M: 651.645.5500 | F: 651.645.3907 | www.jbvang.com Community Engagement JB Vang and our architect team, Urbanworks, hosted a community open house on March 15, 2023 from 6:30pm to 7:30pm at the Wakefield Park Community Building in Maplewood, MN. We sent invites to the addresses provided to us by Michael Martin on February 16, 2023, that included all property owners located within 500 feet of the Project’s site. The night of the open house, we brought posterboards with preliminary renderings and printed out a few large plan pages for folks to see and comment on if desired. While lightly attended by 4 adults and 1 child, we received positive feedback on the preliminary designs and were offered verbal support of the Project. I provided my business card to contact us with any questions related to the project, and hope to connect with them again soon! E2 Attachment 6 CDRB Packet Page Number 52 of 92 P-01P-01P-01P-01P-01P-01P-01P-02P-02P-03ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-01ED-02ED-02ED-01ED-01P-02P-02P-01FE-02FE-02PLAYGROUNDDOG RUNPATIOFE-01(bid alternate)EDGINGSYMBOLDESCRIPTIONEDGING TYPE 1 - STEEL EDGEREDGING TYPE 2 - 8X8 TIMBER EDGERFENCE & GUARDRAILSYMBOLDESCRIPTIONFENCE TYPE 1 - CHAIN LINK - 4.5'FENCE TYPE 2 - CHAIN LINK - 6'PAVINGSYMBOLDESCRIPTIONPAVING TYPE 1 - CONCRETE WALKPAVING TYPE 2 - CRUSHED STONEPAVING TYPE 3 - WOOD MULCHED-01ED-02FE-01FE-02P-01P-02P-03MATERIALS LEGEND© URBANWORKS ARCHITECTURE LLC, 2019901 NORTH THIRD STREET, SUITE 145, MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55401CONSULTANTPRELIMINARYREVISIONSDATEPROJECT #PHASEDRAWN BYCHECKED BYNOT FORCONSTRUCTIONLAND USE APPLICATION3.21.20233/20/2023 1:38:11 PMC:\!Revit Project Files\19-0012 A22 Central_JHighley@urban-works.com.rvt1310 Frost Ave EMaplewood, MN 55109-44183/21/202319-0012LAND USE APPBMSJSJB Vang - Gladstone Village310 South 4th Avenue, Suite 7050Minneapolis, MN 55415p: 612.332.7522NORTH0SCALE:3020101" = 10'HARDSCAPEPLANL110E2 Attachment 7 CDRB Packet Page Number 53 of 92 1,529 sf - SOD203 sf - SOD1,729 sf - SOD406 sf - SOD584 sf - SOD596 sf - SOD399 sf - SOD335 sf - SOD651 sf - SODPLAYGROUNDDOG RUNPATIO(bid alternate)4 - PC22 - PC26 - PD1 - AL1 - AL2 - AL3 - TI-B4 - BF1 - BF11 - SS420 - CK13 - PH-U28 - SS418 - CK16 - RI-A4 - TT210 - TT25 - TT25 - TT219 - RI-A5 - TT27 - PA-H15 - AT-S13 - AT-S7 - SP219 - SB12 - SB18 - AT-S6 - PA-H9 - TT230 - SS424 - CK22 - CK2 - CA2EXISTING10" OAKEXISTING10" OAKEXISTING7" OAK6 - AG1,358 sf - SOD312 sf - SOD288 sf - SOD5,264 sf - SOD6 - SS46 - SS46 - SS43 - SP212 - SS47 - CA1,059 sf - SOD861 sf - SOD11 - HL211 - HL225 - SS418 - SS4DECIDUOUS TREES CODE QTY BOTANICAL / COMMON NAMEAL4ACER RUBRUM `ARMSTRONG' / ARMSTRONG MAPLEBF 5BETULA PLATYPHYLLA 'FARGO' TM / DAKOTA PINNACLE WHITE BIRCHCA2 2CORNUS ALTERNIFOLIA / PAGODA DOGWOODTI-B3TILIA AMERICANA `BOULEVARD` / BOULEVARD LINDENEVERGREEN TREESCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMEPD 6PICEA GLAUCA `DENSATA` / BLACK HILLS SPRUCEPC2 6PINUS CEMBRA / SWISS STONE PINEORNAMENTAL TREES CODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMEAG 6AMELANCHIER X GRANDIFLORA `AUTUMN BRILLIANCE` / `AUTUMN BRILLIANCE` SERVICEBERRYDECIDUOUS SHRUBS CODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMECA 7CORNUS SERICEA 'ALLEMAN'S COMPACT' / DWARF RED TWIG DOGWOODHL2 22HYDRANGEA PANICULATA `LITTLE LIME` / LITTLE LIME HYDRANGEAPH-U6PHYSOCARPUS OPULIFOLIUS `UMNHARPELL` TM / FIRESIDE NINEBARKRI-A 28RIBES ALPINUM / ALPINE CURRANTSP2 10SALIX PURPUREA `NANA` / DWARF ARCTIC WILLOWSS4 122 SORBARIA SORBIFOLIA `SEM` / SEM ASH LEAF SPIREAEVERGREEN SHRUBS CODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMETT2 38TAXUS X MEDIA `TAUNTONII` / TAUTON YEWGRASSESCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMECK84CALAMAGROSTIS X ACUTIFLORA `KARL FOERSTER` / FEATHER REED GRASSPA-H13PANICUM VIRGATUM 'HEAVY METAL' / HEAVY METAL SWITCH GRASSSB31SCHIZACHYRIUM SCOPARIUM `BLUE HEAVEN` / BLUE HEAVEN LITTLE BLUESTEMPERENNIALSCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMEAT-S46ALLIUM TANGUTICUM 'SUMMER BEAUTY' / SUMMER BEAUTY GLOBE LILYGROUND COVERS CODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMESOD15,623 SFSODPLANT SCHEDULE© URBANWORKS ARCHITECTURE LLC, 2019901 NORTH THIRD STREET, SUITE 145, MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55401CONSULTANTPRELIMINARYREVISIONSDATEPROJECT #PHASEDRAWN BYCHECKED BYNOT FORCONSTRUCTIONLAND USE APPLICATION3.21.20233/20/2023 1:38:11 PMC:\!Revit Project Files\19-0012 A22 Central_JHighley@urban-works.com.rvt1310 Frost Ave EMaplewood, MN 55109-44183/21/202319-0012LAND USE APPBMSJSJB Vang - Gladstone Village310 South 4th Avenue, Suite 7050Minneapolis, MN 55415p: 612.332.7522NORTH0SCALE:3020101" = 10'LANDSCAPEPLANL140E2 Attachment 8 CDRB Packet Page Number 54 of 92 AREA TO RECIEVE 4" HARDWOOD MULCH (TO REMAIN THRUCONSTRUCTION)AREA TO RECIEVE 4" HARDWOOD MULCH (TO REMAIN THRUCONSTRUCTION)T-01T-03T-04T-05T-06T-02TREE PROTECTION FENCEEXISTING TREE TO REMAINREMOVE EXISTING TREELEGENDSYMBOLDESCRIPTIONCAL/SIZETYPEDEMO12LOCUSTDEMO19LOCUSTDEMO15LOCUSTPRESERVE 7OAKPRESERVE 10OAKPRESERVE 10OAKT-01T-02T-03T-04T-05T-06TOTAL DIAMETER INCHES TO BE REMOVED: 46 (A)TOTAL DIAMETER INCHES: 73 (B)TREE REPLACEMENT CONSTANTTOTAL DIAMETER INCHES TO BE SAVED: 27 (D)TREE REPLACEMENT FORMULA[((A/B - 0.2) X C X A] - [D/2] = E[((46/73 - 0.2) X 1.5 X 46] - [27/2] =[29.67] - [13.5] = 16 CALIPER INCHES (REPLACEMENT TREES)REFER TO SHEET L140 FOR LANDSCAPE PLAN.CONTACT:LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTDAMON FARBER ASSOCIATESJESSE SYMYNKYWICZ - PRINCIPAL310 SO. 4TH AVE, STE 7050MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55415612-332-7522H:\19\19-0012\05 - Consultants\5.0 All\230330 CAD Titleblock\19-0012A22Central_JHighley@urban-works-ScottBeckman-4805276.jpg© URBANWORKS ARCHITECTURE LLC, 2019901 NORTH THIRD STREET, SUITE 145, MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55401CONSULTANTPRELIMINARYREVISIONSDATEPROJECT #PHASEDRAWN BYCHECKED BYNOT FORCONSTRUCTIONLAND USE APPLICATION3.21.20233/20/2023 1:38:11 PMC:\!Revit Project Files\19-0012 A22 Central_JHighley@urban-works.com.rvt1310 Frost Ave EMaplewood, MN 55109-44183/21/202319-0012LAND USE APPBMSJSJB Vang - Gladstone Village310 South 4th Avenue, Suite 7050Minneapolis, MN 55415p: 612.332.7522NORTH0SCALE:3020101" = 10'TREEPRESERVATIONPLANL000E2 Attachment 9 CDRB Packet Page Number 55 of 92 6FKHGXOH6\PERO /DEHO ,PDJH 4XDQWLW\ 0DQXIDFWXUHU&DWDORJ1XPEHU'HVFULSWLRQ1XPEHU/DPSV/XPHQV3HU/DPS/LJKW/RVV)DFWRU:DWWDJH3ORW7\SH %HDFRQ3URGXFWV93//.%& /$5*(9,3(5 7\SH %HDFRQ3URGXFWV93//.%& /$5*(9,3(5 6WDWLVWLFV'HVFULSWLRQ 6\PERO $YJ 0D[ 0LQ 0D[0LQ $YJ0LQ&DOF=RQH IF IF IF 7\SH7\SH7\SH7\SHÄÄHCZ&QWINCU&TKXG0QTVJ/KPPGCRQNKU/0'OCKN UVGGP"UVGGPGPIEQOÄÄ85%$1:25.6$5&+,7(&785(//& 1257+7+,5'675((768,7(0,11($32/,601&2168/7$1735(/,0,1$5<5(9,6,216'$7(352-(&73+$6('5$:1%<&+(&.('%<127)25&216758&7,216&+(0$7,&'(6,*1 30& ?8VHUV?MDNHP?'RFXPHQWV?8:$B0(3B-DNH06WHHQUYW)URVW$YH(0DSOHZRRG01 0DUFK8:$-0-$6,7(3+2720(75,&6(-%9DQJ *ODGVWRQH9LOODJH 6,7(3+2720(75,&6E2 Attachment 10 CDRB Packet Page Number 56 of 92 85%$1:25.6$5&+,7(&785(//& 1257+7+,5'675((768,7(0,11($32/,601&2168/7$1735(/,0,1$5<5(9,6,216'$7(352-(&73+$6('5$:1%<&+(&.('%<127)25&216758&7,21&21',7,21$/86(3(50,7 &20081,7<'(6,*15(9,(:%2$5'$33/,&$7,21 30& ?5HYLW3URMHFW)LOHV? $&HQWUDOB-+LJKOH\#XUEDQZRUNVFRPUYW)URVW$YH(0DSOHZRRG01 6'-7+'3(+3(563(&7,9((/(9$7,216$-%9DQJ *ODGVWRQH9LOODJH $1257+3(563(&7,9((/(9$7,21 $:(673(563(&7,9((/(9$7,216E2 Attachment 11 CDRB Packet Page Number 57 of 92 85%$1:25.6$5&+,7(&785(//& 1257+7+,5'675((768,7(0,11($32/,601&2168/7$1735(/,0,1$5<5(9,6,216'$7(352-(&73+$6('5$:1%<&+(&.('%<127)25&216758&7,21&21',7,21$/86(3(50,7 &20081,7<'(6,*15(9,(:%2$5'$33/,&$7,21 30& ?5HYLW3URMHFW)LOHV? $&HQWUDOB-+LJKOH\#XUEDQZRUNVFRPUYW)URVW$YH(0DSOHZRRG01 6'-7+'3(+%8,/',1*$;2120(75,&9,(:6$-%9DQJ *ODGVWRQH9LOODJH$1257+($67$;2120(75,&$1257+:(67$;2120(75,&$6287+($67$;2120(75,&$6287+:(67$;2120(75,&E2 Attachment 11 CDRB Packet Page Number 58 of 92 Engineering Plan Review PROJECT: Frost Avenue Apartments 1310 Frost Avenue East PROJECT NO: 23-05 COMMENTS BY: Jon Jarosch, P.E. – Assistant City Engineer DATE: 4-10-2023 PLAN SET: Civil plans dated 3-21-2023 REPORTS: None The applicant is seeking city approval to develop a new four-story, 65-unit multi-family housing building and associated site amenities at 1310 Frost Avenue. The applicant is requesting a review of the current design. The amount of disturbance on this site is greater than ½ acre. As such, the applicant is required to meet the City’s stormwater quality, rate control, and other stormwater management requirements. The applicant is proposing to meet these requirements via the use of an underground infiltration system. This review does not constitute a final review of the plans, as the applicant will need to submit construction documents and calculations for final review. The following are engineering review comments on the design and act as conditions prior to issuing permits. Drainage and Stormwater Management 1)A stormwater management plan shall be submitted, including hydraulic calculations, to depict how the project is meeting the City and Watershed District’s stormwater management standards. 2)The project shall be submitted to the Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District (RWMWD) for review. All conditions of RWMWD shall be met. 3)A joint storm water maintenance agreement shall be prepared and signed by the owner for the proposed infiltration system and pretreatment devices. The Owner shall submit a signed copy of the joint storm-water maintenance agreement with the RWMWD to the City. 4)Geotechnical information (soil borings) shall be provided to support infiltration rates utilized in the infiltration system design. E2 Attachment 12 CDRB Packet Page Number 59 of 92 5)An emergency overflow for the underground infiltration system shall be identified on the plans. This overflow shall be properly stabilized to prevent erosion during an overflow event. 6)Pre-treatment of stormwater before discharge into infiltration system is required. A minimum 3-foot deep sump or similar pre-treatment shall be installed to provide pre- treatment and sediment removal upstream of the system. 7)The plans note that the trench drain at the bottom of the parking garage entrance ramp is to be connected to the building. Likewise, it is unclear where the building perimeter drain tile is connected. The plans shall detail the proposed connection point for these systems and ensure they are not connected to the sanitary sewer system. All storm water runoff shall be directed into the storm sewer system. Grading and Erosion Control 8)All slopes shall be 3H:1V or flatter. 9)Inlet protection devices shall be installed on all existing and proposed onsite storm sewer until all exposed soils onsite are stabilized. This includes storm sewer on adjacent streets that could potentially receive construction related sediment or debris. 10)Adjacent streets and parking areas shall be swept as needed to keep the pavement clear of sediment and construction debris. 11)All pedestrian facilities shall be ADA compliant. 12)The total grading volume (cut/fill) shall be noted on the plans. 13)A copy of the project SWPPP and NDPES Permit shall be submitted prior to the issuance of a grading permit. 14)Detail shall be provided on the east side of the proposed building depicting grades on this property and those on the property to the east. This detail is needed to ensure the proposal is not negatively impacting the neighboring property. Sanitary Sewer and Water Service 15)The applicant shall be responsible for paying any SAC, WAC, or PAC charges related to the improvements proposed with this project. A SAC determination is required. 16)All modifications to the water system shall be reviewed by Saint Paul regional Water Services. All requirements of SPRWS shall be met. E2 Attachment 12 CDRB Packet Page Number 60 of 92 17)All new sanitary sewer service piping shall be schedule 40 PVC or SDR35. 18)The sanitary sewer service connection to the mainline in English Street shall include the placement of a manhole at this location. Other 19)All work within Frost Avenue or English Street right-of-way shall be restored per the City’s right-of-way ordinance. Roadway patching shall occur within 48 hours after the completion of utility connections on these roadways. It should be noted that Frost Avenue was recently reconstructed. As such, the restoration requirements for Frost Avenue will include much larger patching than shown on the plans. 20)A public sidewalk easement shall be provided for those portions of the concrete sidewalk along English Street and Frost Avenue lying outside of the public right-of-way. 21)Onsite sidewalks and pavements shall be left in place as long as possible to reduce the time soils are exposed. 22)The plans shall be signed by a civil engineer licensed in the state of Minnesota. 23)The applicant shall provide a self-renewing letter of credit or cash escrow in the amount of 125% of the proposed site improvements including earthwork, grading, erosion control, site vegetation establishment (sod, seed, etc.), aggregate base, and paving. Public Works Permits The following permits are required by the Maplewood Public Works Department for this project. The applicant should verify the need for other City permits with the Building Department. 24)Right-of-way permit 25)Grading and erosion control permit 26)Storm Sewer Permit 27)Sanitary Sewer Permit -END COMMENTS - E2 Attachment 12 CDRB Packet Page Number 61 of 92 Environmental Review Project: Gladstone Village Date of Plans: March 21, 2023 Date of Review: April 11, 2023 Location: 1310 Frost Avenue Review ers: Shann Finwall, Environmental Planner 651-249-2304, shann.finwall@maplewoodmn.gov Carole Gernes, Natural Resources Coordinator 651-249-2416, carole.gernes@maplewoodmn.gov Project Background: The applicant proposes to redevelop the funeral home at 1310 Frost Avenue East with a 65-unit affordable multi-family apartment building. The applicant must comply with the Gladstone Area Redevelopment Plan, solid waste ordinance, tree preservation ordinance, and landscape policies. Gladstone Area Redevelopment Neighborhood The Gladstone Area Redevelopment Plan details guiding principles, implementation initiatives, and key factors for shaping redevelopment of the Gladstone Neighborhood. Environmental items pertaining to the redevelopment of properties located along English Street, south of Frost Avenue include: •Incorporation of rainwater gardens, alternative pavement strategies, shared parking, and other techniques to minimize surface water runoff and provide for treatment of runoff. •Incorporation of recycled building materials, roof top gardens, solar energy systems, and other sustainable building techniques that contribute to the educational and interpretive vision of the Gladstone Savanna. •Development should orient toward the regional trails rather than back up to them. •Building heights should be greatest along English Street. Green Building Code The Green Building Code applies to Maplewood owned and financed buildings. The goal of the Green Building Code is to safeguard the environment, public health, safety and general welfare through the establishment of requirements to reduce the negative impacts and increase the positive impacts of the built environment on the natural environment and building occupants. Green Building Code Recommendation: If the Gladstone Village is approved for the use of Tax Increment Financing, the redevelopment of the site must comply with the Green Building Code and ensure sections in the Code are complete including 1) energy conservation, efficiency, and CO2 emission reductions; and 2) material resource conservation and efficiency standards. E2 Attachment 13 CDRB Packet Page Number 62 of 92 Solid Waste Ordinance All multi-family properties are included in the City’s recycling program. The City of Maplewood contracts with Tennis Sanitation for multi-family recycling. Tennis Sanitation supplies 95-gallon recycling carts or recycling dumpsters collected weekly. The City of Maplewood adds the recycling fee onto the water bill. Solid Waste Recommendation: Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant must ensure recycling service is set up through the City’s recycling program. Tree Ordinance 1.Tree Preservation Ordinance: a.Significant Trees: Maplewood’s tree preservation ordinance describes a significant tree as a healthy tree of the following size: hardwood tree with a minimum of 6 inches in diameter, an evergreen tree with a minimum of 8 inches in diameter, and a softwood tree with a minimum of 12 inches in diameter. b.Specimen Trees: A specimen tree is defined as a healthy tree of any species that is 28 inches in diameter or greater. c.Tree Replacement: If greater than 20 percent of significant trees are removed, tree replacement is based on a calculation of significant trees located on the site and significant trees removed. Credits are given for all specimen trees that are preserved. If less than 20 percent of significant trees are removed, tree replacement is based on a calculation of one 2-caliper inch replacement tree per significant tree removed. d.Tree Replacement: The tree standards require that as many replacement trees be planted on the site as possible. An applicant can pay into the City’s tree fund at a rate of $60 per caliper inch for trees that cannot be planted on site. The City uses the tree fund to manage trees in parks and within the right-of-way. 2.Tree Impacts: There are six significant trees on site equaling 73 caliper inches. The applicants propose to remove three trees equaling 46 caliper inches. This represents 59 percent tree removal. 3.City Code Requirements: City code requires 16 caliper inches of replacement trees on the site (which equals 8 – 2 caliper inches of replacement trees). 4.Proposed Tree Replacement: The landscape plan shows 32 new trees ranging in size from 2 to 2.5 caliper inches, totaling 71.6 caliper inches of replacement trees, which meets, and exceeds, the tree replacement requirements. 5.Tree Recommendations: a.Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant must submit the following: 1)Escrow: The applicant must submit a tree escrow in the amount of $60 per caliper inch of trees to be replaced on the site. The escrow will be released once the trees are planted with a one-year warranty. E2 Attachment 13 CDRB Packet Page Number 63 of 92 Landscape Policies Review of the overall landscape plan to ensure nonnative and invasive species are avoided, seed mix is appropriate for use in areas proposed, and plantings are climate resilient. Landscaping Recommendations: 1.Prior to issuance of a grading permit, submit a revised landscape plan with the following changes: a) Replace False Spirea, Sorbaria sorbifolia, which has been found to be invasive in Minnesota and nearby Wisconsin. This is particularly concerning due to the proximity of the Gladstone Neighborhood Preserve located across the street from the development. Replace with a variety of the following native pollinator- supporting shrub species: 1) Chokeberry, Aronia melanocarpa 2)New Jersey tea, Ceanothus americanus 3)Native bush honeysuckle, Diervilla lonicera 4)Blueberry cultivars, Vaccinium ssp 5)Common elderberry, Sambucus Canadensis 6)American hazelnut, Corylus Americana 7)Gray dogwood, Cornus racemose 8)Perennial American spikenard, Aralia racemose 9)Monarch-supporting perennial such as Butterfly-weed, Asclepias tuberosa. Planting a mix of these species rather than 30 of the same species will also help prevent the spread of plant pests and diseases. There are only six ninebark shrubs included in the landscape plan. You could increase numbers of that species to around 20 to make up for some of the Sorbaria. b)Replace Asian White Birch, Betula platyphylla, which has been reported as invasive in nearby states. Replace with the non-native River Birch, Betula nigra. c)Maplewood promotes the planting of pollinator–supporting native plants. There is only one species of flowering perennial in the plan. Please replace the 46 pots of Allium tanguticum with a diverse mix of native flowers, choosing from the following list: 1)Prairie onion, Allium stellatum 2)Butterfly-weed, Asclepias tuberosa 3)Meadow blazing star, Liatris ligulistylis 4) Leadplant, Amorpha canescens 5)Canada anemone, Anemone Canadensis 6)Virginia bluebells, Mertensia virginica 7)Prairie violet, Viola pedatifida 8)Plains wild indigo, Baptisia bracteata 9)Prairie smoke, Geum triflorum 10)Prairie phlox, Phlox pilosa E2 Attachment 13 CDRB Packet Page Number 64 of 92 11)Aromatic aster, Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 12)Black-eyed Susan, Rudbeckia hirta 13)Wild petunia, Ruellia humilis 14)Wild bergamot, Monarda fistulosa 15)Prairie Coreopsis, Coreopsis palmate 16)Purple prairie clover, Dalea purpurea 17)Dotted blazingstar, Liatris punctate 18)Virginia mountain mint, Pycnanthemum virginianum 19)Showy goldenrod, Solidago speciosa 20)Large beardtongue, Penstemon grandifloras 21) Narrow-leaved purple coneflower, Echinacea angustifolia 22)Spotted horsemint, Monarda punctata E2 Attachment 13 CDRB Packet Page Number 65 of 92 COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW BOARD STAFF REPORT Meeting Date April 18, 2023 REPORT TO: Melinda Coleman, City Manager REPORT FROM: Elizabeth Hammond, Planner PRESENTER: Elizabeth Hammond, Planner Rita Trapp, HKGI AGENDA ITEM: Zoning Code – Sign Code Regulations Discussion Action Requested: ☐ Motion Discussion ☐ Public Hearing Form of Action: ☐Resolution ☐ Ordinance ☐ Contract/Agreement ☐ Proclamation Policy Issue: Staff continues to work with HKGI, the City’s consultant, on development code updates. The sign code regulations have been reviewed, and draft changes have been prepared. This information is provided for review and comment. Recommended Action: No action at this time. Please review the memo attached to this report from HKGI. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No ☐ Yes, the true or estimated cost is $0.00 Financing source(s): ☐ Adopted Budget ☐ Budget Modification ☐ New Revenue Source ☐Use of Reserves Other: N/A Strategic Plan Relevance: ☐Community Inclusiveness ☐Financial & Asset Mgmt ☐Environmental Stewardship ☐Integrated Communication Operational Effectiveness ☐Targeted Redevelopment The city’s sign code regulations were updated and adopted in 2010. Due to a 2015 Supreme Court ruling, the city needs to consider some amendments. Background: Staff has worked with HKGI to review and revise areas of the sign code. Please review the cover memo and draft code updates for our discussion. Attachments: 1.HKGI Cover Memo 2.Draft City Sign Code Regulations E3 CDRB Packet Page Number 66 of 92 HKGi 800 Washington Ave N, Suite 103, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 www.hkgi.com Creating Places that Enrich People’s Lives DEVELOPMENT CODE UPDATE TO: City of Maplewood Planning Commission and Community Design Review Board FROM: Rita Trapp, Consulting Planners DATE: March 14, 2023 SUBJECT: Updates to sign regulations MEETING DATE: April 18, 2023 One part of the 2023 City Code updates is focused on the sign regulations. The sign regulations are located in Article III of Chapter 44 Zoning Code. The purpose of the sign code is to establish a system of sign regulations that balances the needs for effective visual communication, particularly for commercial speech, and the needs for a safe, well-maintained, and attractive community. The First Amendment protects signs as speech, and as a result, courts closely review attempts to regulate signs. In 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court decided a case that changed how courts review the validity of sign ordinances (Reed v. Town of Gilbert), and thus how communities can regulate signs. The primary finding of that case was that cities could not regulate signs based on the content, or message, of the sign. Instead, communities must focus on when and how long a sign can be displayed, where the signs can be located and how the signs can be constructed or designed. Maplewood’s current sign regulations were created using a content based format. This can be seen by the use of terms like garage sale sign, real estate sign, construction sign, informational sign, political campaign sign, etc. The rewrite of the sign regulations has eliminated these content based references and focused instead on the type and location of signage within the various districts. In addition to removing content based regulations, the sign regulations have been reorganized and reformatted to improve readability, remove redundancies, and improve consistency. The following provides an overview to each section of the sign regulations and highlights changes proposed. Note that in general the size, location, height, etc. of signs was not updated in this process as it is felt that the sign regulations are generally working in the community. •Purpose and Intent. This section provides an overview as to the City’s intent of the sign regulations. One statement was removed from the purpose and intent as it was more of a standard than general statement. •Definitions. Definitions were updated to remove content based definitions (e.g. garage sale sign) and terms that were defined but never used. Terms used in the regulations but not defined were added as needed (e.g. on-site sign and off-site sign). E3, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 67 of 92 Planning Report – Development Code Update – January 23, 2023 2 •Sign area and height calculations. This section describes how sign area and height are calculated. This section was only reformatted for readability. Graphics will be added to illustrate how calculations are made. •Prohibited signs. This section lists the types of signs not allowed in the city. The list of prohibited signs did not change. There were edits made for readability and to remove references to content based regulations. •General regulations and standards. This section identifies standards that apply to all signs. Edits were generally made for readability. •Exempt signs. This section lists signs that are exempt from obtaining a permit. These signs will still need to meet all of the code’s general standards. Content based regulations were revised as needed. •Temporary signs. Temporary signs generally do not require a permit as long as minimum standards are met. This section was significantly modified as there were a lot of content based temporary signs. In addition, this section was modified for ease of use. Temporary signs have now been grouped into: o Temporary signs allowed in any district o Temporary signs on properties designated Park in the Maplewood Comprehensive Plan o Temporary signs in Residential Districts o Temporary signs in Non-Residential Districts o Temporary signs in Mixed-Use District o Exemptions – this allows for some window and banner signs to exceed requirements for size, number and time display limits. Short-term (up to 3 months) can be approved by the administrator, while long-term (more than 3 months) requires a comprehensive sign plan and approval by the CDRB. •Permanent signs. Permanent signs require a sign permit and there are limits to the amount of signage allowed by property or building. This section was modified to address some content based signage. Signage was also grouped into the categories of: o Permanent signs on properties designated Park in the Maplewood Comprehensive Plan o Permanent signs in Residential Districts o Permanent signs in Non-Residential Districts o Permanent signs in Mixed-Use District E3, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 68 of 92 Planning Report – Development Code Update – January 23, 2023 3 •Dynamic display signs. This section is specific to electronic signs that have changing messages. This section has not been significantly modified from the existing code. •Murals. This is a new section since murals are not signs and the City did not have any regulations for murals. Murals will be required to have a comprehensive mural plan approved by the CDRB. •Sign permits. This section identifies the process for issuing a sign permit. This section has not been modified significantly. •Comprehensive sign or mural plan. This section describes the comprehensive sign plan process. The major change to this section is related to a comprehensive mural plan. •Nonconforming signs. This section describes how nonconforming signs are addressed. This section has not been modified. •Enforcement procedures. This section identifies how enforcement is handled. This section has not been modified significantly. A provision regarding murals has been added. In the update process there were four use specific standards identified: gas station canopies, auto dealerships, drive-through, and minor motor vehicle stations. These standards are proposed to be moved to the use specific standards section so that property owners are aware of these regulations. A reference to these additional standards has been included in the sign regulations. E3, Attachment 1 CDRB Packet Page Number 69 of 92 ARTICLE III. SIGN AND MURAL REGULATIONS Sec. 44-731. Purpose and intent. The purpose of this article is to establish a comprehensive and impartial system of sign regulations that balances the needs for effective visual communication including business identification and the needs for a safe, well- maintained, and attractive community. It is intended through the provisions contained herein to: (1)Promote signs which by their design and dimensions are integrated and harmonized with the surrounding environment and the buildings and sites they occupy. (2)Protect the public from damage or injury caused by signs that are poorly designed or maintained and from signs that cause distractions or hazards to motorists and pedestrians using the public streets, sidewalks, and public right-of-way. (3)Avoid excessive signage in order to give each business or use optimum visibility to passer-by traffic and prevent cluttering of the streetscape. (Ord. No. 896, § 1, 1-25-2010) Sec. 44-732. Definitions. (see illustrations of sign types at the end of the draft regulations) The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Abandoned sign means a sign or sign structure that is located on a building or property that has been vacant or unoccupied for a period of three months or more, or a sign which pertains to a time, event, or purpose that no longer applies. Signs applicable to a business temporarily suspended because of a change in ownership or management of such business shall not be deemed abandoned unless the property remains vacant for a period of at least six months. Administrator means the director of community development or other person charged with the administration and enforcement of this article. Alteration, major means any major alteration to a sign, but shall not include routine maintenance, painting, or change of the sign face of an existing sign. Alteration, minor means a change of sign copy, sign face, sign color, or modifications or repairs to an existing sign that are cosmetic in nature or include a replacement of parts. Expansion of an existing sign does not constitute a minor alteration. Awning means a covering attached on the façade of a building which projects typically over a door, window, or sidewalk. Awning/canopy sign means a sign affixed flat to the surface of an awning or canopy which does not extend vertically or horizontally beyond the limits of such awning or canopy. Banner sign means a temporary sign that is constructed of cloth, flexible plastic, or fabric of any kind which can be easily folded or rolled. This term does not include flags. Billboard means a freestanding, off-site sign located adjacent to a principal arterial street. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 70 of 92 Building sign means any sign affixed to a building or an appurtenance of a building including wall signs, projecting signs, window signs, and awning/canopy signs. Changeable copy message board means a sign or portion of a sign which is characterized by interchangeable letters and figures. This definition shall not include dynamic display signs. Commercial sign means any sign, display, or device designed, intended or used to encourage or promote purchase or use of goods or services. Comprehensive sign or mural plan means a coordinated plan for all signs and/or murals located on a site or within a single development. Community design review board means the body established in Section 2 of this Ordinance as a committee of the City Council which reviews site plans, building design, landscape plans, and signage. Dynamic display sign means any sign designed for outdoor use that is capable of displaying a video signal, including, but not limited to, cathode-ray tubes (CRT), light-emitting diode (LED) displays, plasma displays, liquid- crystal displays (LCD), or other technologies used in commercially available televisions or computer monitors. Flag means any device generally made of flexible materials, such as cloth, and designed to be attached to a flagpole on one edge only. Flashing sign means an illuminated sign which contains flashing lights or exhibits with noticeable changes in light intensity. Freestanding sign means a sign that is attached to, erected on, or supported by an architecturally-planned structure (such as a pole, mast, frame, or other structure) that is not itself an integral part of or attached to a building or other structure whose principal function is something other than the support of a sign. This definition includes pylon signs and monument signs. Graffiti means unauthorized markings of paint, dye, or other similar substance that have been placed on real or personal property such as buildings, fences, transportation equipment, or other structures, or the unauthorized etching or scratching of the surfaces of such real or personal property, any of which markings, scratching, or etchings are visible from the site open to the public. Ground banner sign means a sign constructed of cloth, canvas, or other similar light material which is affixed to the ground. Ground grade means the elevation of the ground closest to the sign to which reference is made. Illuminated sign means a sign that is illuminated internally by a light source inside the sign or externally by means of external light fixtures directed at the sign. Institutional or public uses means uses such as public schools, fire stations, libraries, water system facilities, religious institutions, cemeteries, private schools, and other city, county, and state-used and owned properties. Message display face means the surface of the sign where the signs image or message is displayed. Monument sign means a permanent, freestanding sign located directly at ground grade where the width dimension of the architecturally designed base is 50 percent or more of the greatest width of the sign face. Multiple tenant building means a commercial building containing two or more tenants. Mural means artwork on the exterior of a building, generally for the purpose of decoration or artistic expression, including, but not limited to, paintings, markings, and etchings. A mural is not intended or used to encourage or promote purchase or use of goods or services. Noncommercial sign means a sign which expresses an opinion, point of view, or statement such as political, religious, or ideological sentiment, or support or opposition to a candidate or proposition for public election. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 71 of 92 Nonconforming sign means a sign lawfully erected and maintained prior to the adoption of this article that does not conform to the requirements of this article. Off-site sign means a sign located outside of the parcel lines or boundaries of the property or development for which the sign is constructed. On-site sign means a sign located within the parcel lines or boundaries of the property or development for which the sign is constructed. Painted wall sign means a sign painted or applied through adhesive tape directly on the exterior wall of a building or structure. Permanent sign means a sign permanently attached to a building, structure, or the ground which is constructed of durable materials and intended for long-term use. Projecting sign means a sign, other than a wall sign, which is supported and projects from more than 18 inches at a right angle from the wall of a building. Property Identification sign means a sign identifying the street address of a building for public safety reasons. Pylon sign means a sign that is mounted on a narrow freestanding pole or other support structure so that the bottom edge of the sign face is at least six feet above the architecturally designed base. Roof line means the uppermost line of the roof of a building or, in the case of an extended façade, the uppermost height of said façade. Roof sign means a sign erected upon the roof of a building or extending above the roof line of the building to which it is attached, and which is wholly or partially supported by said building. Sign means a communication device displaying graphics, symbols, or written copy visible from the public right-of-way and designed to attract the attention of the general public. This definition does not include murals or architectural lighting, such as neon that has no sign copy. For the purpose of removal, signs shall also include all sign structures. Sign face means the surface of the sign including letters and background upon, against, or through which the message is displayed or illustrated. Sign structure means the supports, braces, and framework of a sign. Street means public or private thoroughfare for vehicular traffic which affords primary means of access to abutting property. Street frontage means the lot line of a parcel abutting a street. Street, collector means a street designated in the city’s comprehensive plan which is designed to serve as a traffic way for a neighborhood or as a feeder to an arterial street. Street, local means a street designated in the city’s comprehensive plan which serves short trips at low speeds. Street, minor arterial means a street designated in the city's comprehensive plan which connects sub-regions that are the closest routes parallel to the principal arterials and supplements and provides relief for traffic to the principal arterial. Street, principal arterial, means a street designated in the city's comprehensive plan which is designed to carry the highest volume of traffic, allows the highest speeds, and provides subregional, regional, and inter- community access. Temporary sign means any sign or advertising display constructed of cloth, canvas, light fabric, cardboard, wallboard or other materials, with or without frames, intended to be displayed for a limited period of time only. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 72 of 92 Wall sign means a flat sign which does not project more than 18 inches from the face or wall of the building upon which it is attached, running parallel for its whole length to the face or wall of the building, and which does not extend beyond the horizontal width of such building. Wall surface of the building means the total horizontal surface area of the building face to which the sign is attached, including windows and door areas, measured to the extreme outer limits of such wall surface. Window sign means a sign painted on a window or placed inside the building to be viewed through a window by the public. This does not include merchandise on display in a window, seasonal displays of holiday pictures, decals, lights, and decorations that do not contain a commercial message or signs which are legally required to be posted. (Ord. No. 896, § 3, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 908, § 1, 8-9-2010; Ord. No. 1000, § 1, 3-25-2019; Ord. No. 1023, § I, 10-11- 2021) Sec. 44-733. Sign area and height computation. The area of a sign is determined by the Administrator using actual dimensions where practical or approximate dimensions when irregularity of a sign shape warrants. (1) Sign area. Sign area shall be calculated by measuring the entire area within a continuous perimeter enclosing the extreme limits of the sign message and background. a. Where the sign is a separate panel, structure, or other material forming a single display, the area of the message display face shall constitute the area of the sign. b. Where the sign consists of any combination of individual letters, panels, numbers, figures, illustrations, or of a line or lines, to form a display or sign, the area of the sign shall be computed using the outside dimensions of the various words, figures, and illustrations composing the entire sign. c. In the case of a sign designed with more than one exterior surface, the area shall be computed as including only the maximum single display surface which is visible from any ground position at one time. d. The supports, uprights, bases, or structures on which any sign is supported shall not count towards the sign area unless the supports, uprights, bases, or structures are an integral part of the sign display. (2) Sign height. The height of a sign shall be measured by the vertical distance from the ground grade to the top of a sign and includes its support structures. (Ord. No. 896, § 4, 1-25-2010) Sec. 44-734. Prohibited signs. The following signs are prohibited: (1) Signs or sign structures attached or supported on balconies, fences, or other nonpermanent structures. (2) Signs attached or supported on a permanently parked vehicle or semi-trailers. This shall not include signs painted directly on a parked vehicle or semi-trailer used in the business or facility or on site. (3) Signs on rocks, trees, or other natural features or public utility poles. (4) Permanent or temporary signs that have blinking, flashing, or fluttering lights, or that make noise. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 73 of 92 (5) Signs or sign structures that obstruct any part of a fire escape, doorway, standpipe, or opening intended to provide ingress or egress for any building structures. (6) Signs that by reason of location, color, or intensity create a hazard to the safe, efficient movement of vehicles or pedestrian traffic. No sign on private property shall contain words which might be construed as traffic controls such as "stop," "caution," "warning," etc., unless such sign is intended to direct traffic on the site. (7) Painted wall signs. (8) Roof signs. (9) Off-site signs except for where specifically permitted in this article. (10) Signs having features or incorporating parts of any sign prohibited in this article. (Ord. No. 896, § 7, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 1000, § 3, 3-25-2019) Sec. 44-735. General regulations and standards. All signs shall be constructed in a manner and of such materials that they shall be safe and in compliance with the building ordinance. In addition, all signs containing electrical wiring shall be subject to the provisions of the current state electrical ordinance. (1) Maintenance. All signs, together with all of their supports, braces, and anchors, shall be kept in repair and in proper state of preservation. The display surfaces of all signs shall be kept neatly painted or posted at all times. Banners shall be designed in such a way as to avoid becoming torn or weathered. (2) Every sign and the immediate surrounding site shall be maintained by the owner or person in charge thereof in a clean, sanitary, and inoffensive condition, and free and clear of all obnoxious substances, rubbish, and weeds. (3) Attachment to buildings. All signs attached to a building shall not obstruct any fire escape, exit, standpipe, or any window required for light or ventilation. The signs shall be placed flat against the building and project no further than 18 inches from the building except where specifically allowed in this article. (4) Freestanding sign placement. All signs not attached to any building or structure shall maintain at least a ten-foot setback from any lot line and shall not be placed in a public right-of-way unless specifically stated otherwise in this article. No such sign shall project over a property line or a public right-of-way, except where allowed in this article, and all required clearances from overhead power and service lines must be maintained. Signs placed near the corner of two intersecting streets shall comply with clear sight triangle requirements (refer to article VII, sections 32-246 through 32-251 - sight obstructions at intersections). (5) Illumination. All illuminated signs must be in compliance with the city's outdoor lighting requirements in section 44-20. In addition, illumination for all signs shall be constant and steady. (6) Abandoned signs. Abandoned signs shall be removed by the owner of the site by removing the sign face, painting the sign face a neutral color or installing blank sign face panels. The inner components of the sign must not be exposed. If the sign face is not re-used after one year, the remaining sign structure must be removed unless the Administrator grants an extension subject to the owner submitting a statement of intent and a reasonable time line for reuse of the sign structure. (7) Licensing. All contractors installing permanent signs must first obtain a contractor's license prior to issuance of a sign permit or installation of a permanent sign as defined in the city contractor and subcontractor ordinance (article VI). E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 74 of 92 (Ord. No. 896, § 10, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 1000, § 4, 3-25-2019) Sec. 44-736. Exempt signs. Any sign listed below shall be exempt from obtaining a sign permit but shall be required to meet any general standards identified in this chapter. (1) Any public notice or warning sign required to be maintained or posted by law or governmental order, rule, or regulation. (2) Flags and emblems that are political or ideological. (3) Any sign inside a building that is not attached to an exterior window or not legible from a distance of more than ten feet from outside the building. (4) Traffic control signs as defined by state law. (5) Property identification sign. (6) One wall sign of not more than two square feet for a residence with a permitted home occupation. (7) Temporary displays of lights and decorations. (8) No trespassing signs. Signs not exceeding nine square feet, located upon private property, and directed towards the prevention of trespassing. (Ord. No. 896, § 8, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 908, § 3, 8-9-2010) Sec. 44-737. Temporary signs. Unless specifically identified below, all temporary signs do not require a sign permit or a comprehensive sign plan, and shall not count towards the building or property permanent sign maximum signage allowed: (1) Temporary Signs Allowed in Any District a. On-site temporary signs i. Temporary freestanding sign. 1. Nonilluminated temporary freestanding sign not exceeding three square feet in area and no more than three feet in height is permitted on private property. 2. No part of such sign shall be closer than five feet to the street pavement or one foot to a sidewalk or trail. Said sign shall not be located between the street and a sidewalk or trail. ii. Temporary signs and displays under 12 square feet in area. 1. One nonilluminated temporary sign or display under 12 square feet is allowed per property (except for single and double-dwelling properties) for a period not to exceed 30 days total per sign. 2. For commercial buildings with multiple occupants, each separate tenant is permitted one such sign. 3. No more than three temporary signs under 12 square feet shall be allowed at a property at any one time. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 75 of 92 iii. Properties with open building permits. 1. One temporary sign on a property with an open building permit is permitted immediately prior to or during the construction of a development. 2. Each such sign shall not exceed a ratio of one square foot of sign area for each 1,000 square feet of lot area. In no case shall the sign exceed 64 square feet in area and ten feet in height. 3. The sign shall be removed within 30 days after major construction has finished. iv. Properties that are for sale or rent. 1. One temporary freestanding sign is permitted for each street upon which the property has frontage. a. For single and double-dwelling lots, such sign shall not exceed nine square feet in area. b. For all other types of property, each sign shall not exceed a ratio of one square foot of sign area for each 1,000 square feet of lot area. In no case shall the area of any one sign exceed 64 square feet or ten feet in height. 2. All such signs shall be removed within seven calendar days of the close of the property or when 90 percent or more of the dwelling units on the property have been sold, leased, or rented. v. Noncommercial signs. 1. Any sign which meets MS § 211B.045. 2. One noncommercial sign which shall not be illuminated, exceed 16 square feet in area, and shall be no more than six feet in height. For multiple-unit developments, the sign shall be attached to the dwelling unit or placed in a location that clearly indicates ownership. b. Off-site temporary signs i. Off-site signs on private property. An off-site sign not exceeding three square feet in area may be placed on private property. Such signs require a permit, shall not be located in the public right-of-way, and the sign owner/installer must supply written permission to the city from the property owner on which property the sign is installed. Each development is limited to one such sign. ii. Off-site signs in the public right of way. An off-site sign not exceeding three square feet in area and no more than three feet in height may be placed on the public right-of- way. 1. No part of such sign shall be closer than five feet to the street pavement or one foot to a sidewalk or trail. Said sign shall not be placed between the street and a sidewalk or trail. 2. Off-site signs may be placed in the public right-of-way for 30 days maximum. iii. Signs for nonprofit or civic businesses. Off-site temporary signs for legally recognized nonprofit businesses (e.g., 501.c3 designations) as well as civic organizations (i.e. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 76 of 92 places of worship, parks, nature centers, historic sites, etc.) are allowed in the public right-of-way. 1.Said sign is limited to four square feet in area with a maximum of three signs per nonprofit or civic organization. 2.The location of off-site temporary signs must be approved by the city prior to installation. (2)Temporary Signs on Properties Designated Park in the Maplewood Comprehensive Plan Temporary signs located within a park and/or sports facility are allowed subject to the following standards: a.Banners. Banners may be displayed in parks for special events sponsored or approved by the city. No more than three banners may be displayed per park at any one time. Each banner shall not exceed 64 square feet. Banners shall be designed to be professional looking and prevented from becoming torn or weathered. b.Signs for baseball, softball, and hockey fields. Signs may be allowed with the approval of a comprehensive sign plan (also refer to section 44-732). i.Number and size of signs shall be determined by an approved comprehensive sign plan. ii.No sign shall be illuminated except by the regular sports facility lighting during hours of use. iii.Signs are allowed to be installed for a period of one year during the baseball, softball, or hockey season. iv.Signs placed at baseball and softball fields shall be located on the outfield fences or the scoreboard, or both. Such signs shall be oriented toward the field of play. v.Signs placed at hockey rinks shall be located on the interior sides of the hockey boards. c.The Maplewood Parks & Natural Resources Department will administer all temporary park and sports facility signs in accordance with the approved comprehensive sign plan. d.Sponsorships collected for such signs will be used to help fund recreational facilities within the park in which they are installed. (3)Temporary Signs in Residential Districts. In addition to the temporary signs allowed for all zoning districts, the following temporary signs shall be allowed in any residential zoning district unless specifically stated: a.Temporary banners. i.Temporary banners may be displayed without a permit for residential subdivisions and multiple-unit developments and for all legal nonresidential uses excluding home occupation businesses for a period not to exceed 60 days per year, per property. ii.No more than one banner may be displayed per property at any one time. iii.Each banner shall not exceed 32 square feet in area and must be attached to a building or other permanent structure. b.Temporary signs and displays over 12 square feet. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 77 of 92 i.One temporary sign or display over 12 square feet is permitted by sign permit for up to 30 days per year, per property. The city shall consider a sign displayed for part of a day as having been up for an entire day. ii.All signs require a sign permit unless otherwise noted. The permit fee shall not be charged for temporary signs and displays erected by civic organizations, religious organizations, or other nonprofit organizations. iii.In no case shall the area of the sign exceed 32 square feet in area or eight feet in height. c.Ground banner signs. i.In the R-3 district, one ground banner sign shall be allowed per every 150 feet of street frontage. ii.The sign shall not exceed 32 square feet in size. iii.All ground banner signs shall be removed after 60 days. (4)Temporary Signs in Non-Residential Districts. In addition to the temporary signs allowed for all zoning districts, the following temporary signs shall be allowed in any non-residential zoning district: a.Temporary banners. i.For single tenant buildings, temporary banners may be displayed without a sign permit for a period not to exceed 60 days total per year. No more than one banner may be displayed per property at any one time. ii.For multiple-tenant buildings, each separate tenant may display temporary banners without a sign permit for a period not to exceed 60 days total per year. No more than one banner may be displayed per separate tenant at any one time. iii.Each banner shall be attached to a building or other permanent structure. iv.Maximum size 1.In the LBC (limited business commercial), CO (commercial office), SC (shopping center), and NC (neighborhood commercial) zoning districts each banner shall not exceed 32 square feet in size. 2.In the BC (business commercial), BC-M (business commercial modified), M-1 (light manufacturing), and M-2 (heavy manufacturing) zoning districts, each banner shall not exceed 64 square feet in size. b.Temporary window signs. i.Temporary window signs are allowed without a permit. ii.Temporary window signs shall be neatly painted or attached to the surface of a window, but shall cover no more than 30 percent of the total area of the window. c.Temporary signs and displays over 12 square feet. i.One temporary sign or display over 12 square feet is permitted for up to 30 days per year, per business. The time period may be extended to 60 days during the first year of operation of a new business and 90 days for a temporary seasonal business. The city shall consider a sign displayed for part of a day as having been up for an entire day. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 78 of 92 ii.All signs require a sign permit unless otherwise noted. The permit fee shall not be charged for temporary signs and displays erected by civic organizations, religious organizations, or other nonprofit organizations or groups. iii.Maximum size 1.In the LBC (limited business commercial), CO (commercial office), SC (shopping center), and NC (neighborhood commercial) zoning districts each sign or display shall not exceed 32 square feet in size. 2.In the BC (business commercial), BC-M (business commercial modified), M-1 (light manufacturing), and M-2 (heavy manufacturing) zoning districts, each sign or display shall not exceed 64 square feet in size. 3.No sign or display shall exceed eight feet in height. d.Ground banner signs. i.One ground banner sign shall be allowed per every 150 feet of street frontage. ii.The sign shall not exceed 32 square feet in size. iii.All ground banner signs shall be removed after 60 days. (5)Temporary Signs in Mixed-Use Districts. In addition to the temporary signs allowed for all zoning districts, the following temporary signs shall be allowed in the Mixed-Use (M-U) and North End (NE) zoning districts: a.Temporary banners. i.For single tenant buildings, temporary banners may be displayed without a sign permit for a period not to exceed 60 days total per year. No more than one banner may be displayed per property at any one time. ii.For multiple-tenant buildings, each separate tenant may display temporary banners without a sign permit for a period not to exceed 60 days total per year. No more than one banner may be displayed per separate tenant at any one time. iii.Each banner shall be attached to a building or other permanent structure. iv.No banner shall exceed 32 square feet in area. b.Temporary window signs. i.Temporary window signs are allowed without a permit in any building or portion of a building occupied by a nonresidential use. ii.Temporary window signs shall be neatly painted or attached to the surface of a window, but shall cover no more than 30 percent of the total area of the window. c.Temporary signs and displays over 12 square feet. i.One temporary sign or display over 12 square feet is permitted by sign permit for up to 30 days per year. The time period may be extended to 60 days during the first year of operation of a new business and 90 days for a temporary seasonal business. The city shall consider a sign displayed for part of a day as having been up for an entire day. ii.All signs require a sign permit unless otherwise noted. The permit fee shall not be charged for temporary signs and displays erected by civic organizations, religious organizations, or other nonprofit organizations. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 79 of 92 iii.In no case shall the area of the sign exceed 32 square feet in area or eight feet in height. d.Ground banner signs. i.One ground banner sign shall be allowed per every 150 feet of street frontage. ii.The sign shall not exceed 32 square feet in size. iii.All ground banner signs shall be removed after 60 days. (6)Exemptions Temporary window and banner signs which exceed the size, number, or time display limits as specified in this Section may apply for an exemption as described below: a.Short-term exemption (up to three months). i.Applicant shall submit a temporary sign permit application and fee to the Administrator. ii.The Administrator shall approve the short-term exemption if the applicant shows that there are unusual circumstances with the request. iii.The Administrator may attach conditions to the approval to assure that the sign will be compatible with surrounding properties. b.Long-term exemption (longer than three months). i.Applicant shall submit a comprehensive sign plan as specified in Section XX and fee to the city. ii.The community design review board shall approve the long-term exemption if the applicant shows that there are unusual circumstances with the request. iii.The community design review board may attach conditions to the approval to assure that the sign will be compatible with surrounding properties. (Ord. No. 896, § 11, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 906, 7-12-2010; Ord. No. 908, § 4, 8-9-2010) Sec. 44-738. Permanent signs. Unless specifically identified below, all permanent signs require a sign permit and shall count towards the building or property maximum signage allowed: (1)Permanent Signs on Properties Designated Park in the Maplewood Comprehensive Plan. a.Wall signs. One wall sign up to 24 square feet per street frontage shall be allowed for each park building. The sign may be affixed to the wall of the building or an overhanging canopy or awning. b.Monument signs. One monument sign up to 32 square feet per street frontage shall be allowed to identify each park. Said sign shall be a maximum of six feet in height. The sign shall be designed to be architecturally compatible with the park structures and buildings with the base of the sign consisting of colors and materials compatible to the structures or buildings. (2)Permanent Signs in Residential Districts. a.Wall sign. One wall sign up to 24 square feet per street frontage shall be allowed for residential subdivisions, townhomes, live-work buildings, apartments, and for all legal nonresidential uses E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 80 of 92 excluding home occupation businesses. The sign may be affixed to the wall of the main building or an overhanging canopy or awning. b.Monument sign. One monument sign up to 32 square feet per street frontage shall be allowed by sign permit for residential subdivisions and multiple-unit developments and for all legal nonresidential uses excluding home occupation businesses. Said sign shall be a maximum of six feet in height. The sign shall be designed to be architecturally compatible with the building or project with the base of the sign consisting of colors and materials compatible to the building or project. c.Changeable copy message boards. Changeable copy message boards are permitted as part of a permanent freestanding monument sign or wall sign for all legal nonresidential uses excluding home occupation businesses. The message board shall not comprise more than 70 percent of the total square footage of said sign. d.On-site dynamic display signs for permitted institutional or public uses. (Refer to section 44-743 -Dynamic Display Signs). (3)Permanent Signs in Non-Residential Districts a.LBC (limited business commercial), CO (commercial office), SC (shopping center), and NC (neighborhood commercial) zoning districts: i.Wall signs. 1.For each occupant of a building, one wall sign is allowed for each street upon which the property has frontage. The total number of wall signs may be increased by one for each clearly differentiated department of a business or enterprise. 2.The total area of any one wall sign shall not cover more than 20 percent of the wall surface to which the sign is attached or 32 square feet, whichever is greater. As an alternative, a wall sign may be placed on an overhanging awning or canopy as long as the wall sign does not exceed 50 percent of the face of the awning or canopy, or 32 square feet, whichever is less. 3.For multiple tenant buildings, the wall surface for each tenant or user shall include only the surface area of the exterior façade of the site occupied by such tenant or user. ii.Freestanding signs. 1.One freestanding sign up to 64 square feet in area and ten feet in height is permitted for each street upon which the property has frontage. 2.For buildings or developments with multiple street frontages, each additional freestanding sign must be located on a different street. Each freestanding sign must be separated by more than 100 feet measured in a straight line between the signs. 3.The sign shall be designed to be architecturally compatible with the building or project with the base of the sign consisting of colors and materials compatible to the building or project. 4.The area around the base of the sign shall also be landscaped including the bottom of a pylon sign. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 81 of 92 iii.Changeable copy message boards. Changeable copy message boards are permitted as part of a permanent freestanding sign or wall sign but shall comprise no more than 70 percent of the total square footage of said sign. iv.On-site dynamic display signs for permitted institutional or public uses. (Refer to section 44-743 - dynamic display signs). b.BC (business commercial), BC-M (business commercial modified), M-1 (light manufacturing), and M-2 (heavy manufacturing) zoning districts: i.Signage requirements for specific uses, including gas station canopies, auto dealerships, and drive-throughs are listed in Section XX use-specific standards. ii.Wall signs. 1.For each occupant of a building, one wall sign is allowed for each street upon which the property has frontage. The total number of wall signs may be increased by one for each clearly differentiated department of a business or enterprise. 2.The total size of all wall signage for single-tenant buildings is determined by the gross square footage of the principal structure on the property. The total coverage area of each wall sign, including each differentiated business, shall be based on the wall surface to which the sign is attached. The following table indicates maximum signage permitted for single-tenant buildings: Principal Structure Gross Square Feet of Floor Area Maximum Size and Coverage Area of Each Sign Less than 10,000 sq. ft 80 sq. ft. or 20% of wall face, whichever is less 10,000 to 20,000 sq. ft. 100 sq. ft. or 20% of wall face, whichever is less 20,000 to 100,000 sq. ft. 150 sq. ft. or 15% of wall face, whichever is less Greater than 100,000 sq. ft. 200 sq. ft. or 10% of wall face, whichever is less 3.The total coverage area of each wall sign for multiple-tenant buildings is ten percent of the surface area of the exterior façade of the site occupied by such tenant, or 32 square feet, whichever is more. 4.A wall sign may be attached to an overhanging awning or canopy, instead of the façade of the building, as long as the wall sign does not exceed 50 percent of the face of the awning or canopy, or the maximum size specified above, whichever is less. iii.Freestanding signs. 1.One freestanding sign is permitted for each street upon which the property has frontage. For properties with multiple street frontages, each additional freestanding sign must be located on a different street and each sign must be separated by more than 100 feet measured in a straight line between signs, excluding auto dealerships. 2.The total size and maximum height of each freestanding sign is determined by the street classification (as designated in the Maplewood Comprehensive Plan) of the closest street to which each freestanding sign is located. In the case of signs located at an intersection, the higher ranking street classification should be used to determine the maximum height and size allowable for a E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 82 of 92 freestanding sign. Businesses that are located on a frontage road designed to provide safe access to minor arterials and principal arterials shall be permitted to erect a freestanding sign up to the determined maximum height and size allowable for a freestanding sign on said minor arterial or principal arterial road to which it is adjacent. 3.The following table lists the maximum size and heights permitted for freestanding signs: Classification of Street Abutting Property Maximum Sign Size (sq. ft.) Maximum Height of Pylon Sign (feet) Maximum Height of Monument Sign (feet) Principal Arterial 180 25 12 Minor Arterial 140 20 12 Collector Street 100 15 10 Local Street 80 12 10 4.The freestanding sign shall be designed to be architecturally compatible with the building or project, with the base of the sign, including pylon sign poles, consisting of materials and colors compatible to the building or project. iv.Changeable copy message boards. Changeable copy message boards are permitted as part of a permanent freestanding sign or wall sign but are limited to comprising no more than 70 percent of the total square footage of said sign. v.On-site and off-site dynamic display signs. (Refer to section 44-743 - dynamic display signs). vi.Billboards. 1.Off-site billboards shall only be permitted with a conditional use permit and may only be located adjacent to a principal arterial street in the SC (shopping center), BC (business commercial), M-1 (light manufacturing), and M-2 (heavy manufacturing) districts. 2.Spacing. No billboard shall be located within 2,300 feet of another billboard on the same side of the street, within 100 feet to a commercial, industrial, institutional building, or an on-site sign, within 250 feet of a residential district, or within 800 feet of a residence. Billboards shall maintain a setback of 50 feet from any property line, 500 feet to a local park, and 300 feet from the nearest intersecting street corner of two public roads. 3.Size. The maximum area of the sign face of a billboard shall not exceed 450 square feet, including border and trim, but excluding base, apron supports, and other structural members. The maximum size limitation shall apply to each side of a sign structure. 4.The maximum height for billboards shall be 35 feet. 5.A billboard may only display one message at a time on any sign face. 6.Signs may be placed back-to-back or in a V-type arrangement if there are no more than two sign faces, provided that the open end separation shall not exceed 15 feet. (4)Permanent Signs in Mixed-Use Districts. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 83 of 92 The following signs shall be allowed in the Mixed-Use (M-U) and North End (NE) zoning districts: a.Signage requirements for minor motor vehicle stations are listed in Section XX use-specific standards. b.Building signs. i.Building signage in the M-U and NE districts may include wall, projecting, window, or awning/canopy signage. ii.Total allowable area of all building signage for each establishment is one and one-half square feet of signage per lineal foot of building or frontage on a road, public open space or private parking area, or 32 square feet, whichever is greater. iii.Each wall shall be calculated individually and sign area may not be transferred to another side of the building. iv.Wall signs shall not cover windows or architectural trim and detail. v.No part of a building sign shall be placed higher than the sills of the second-story window of a multi-story building. vi.Additional standards for projecting signs. 1.Projecting signs may not extend more than four feet over a public right-of- way, private road, or sidewalk/trail, and must not project out further than the sign's height. 2.Projecting signs shall have a minimum clearance of eight feet above ground level, unless projecting over a vehicular right-of-way, in which case minimum clearance shall be 14 feet. Projecting signs shall be no larger than 20 square feet per sign face. vii.Window signs. A permanent window sign shall be applied directly to the window or hung inside the window but cannot be painted directly onto the window. A window sign shall not cover more than 1/3 of the window or door in which the sign is placed. viii.Awning/canopy signs. Signs on street-level awnings/canopies are permitted if the sign on each awning/canopy is either less than seven square feet in size or eight inches in height, is located on the face of the awning/canopy (valance or skirt), and is parallel to the building façade. Where there are multiple awnings on a building, all awning signs shall have a consistent size and location on the awnings. c.Monument signs. One monument sign for each establishment is allowed if the building is set back at least 20 feet from the front property line. Monument signs must meet the following requirements: i.Limited to six feet in height and 40 square feet. ii. Maintain a five-foot setback from any side or rear property line, but can be constructed up to the front property line. iii.Must consist of a base constructed of materials and design features similar to those of the front façade of the building or development. iv. Must be landscaped with flowers or shrubbery or integrated into a plaza area. d.Lighting. Any signage lighting shall only be provided by using an external light source. The external light source shall be directed onto the sign face or use halo effect/reverse illumination, which is an external light source behind individual letters that is reversed to shine on the wall. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 84 of 92 Exposed neon lighting and LED lighting that has the appearance of exposed neon lighting is allowed. Internally illuminated signs are prohibited. (Ord. No. 896, § 12, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 908, § 5, 8-9-2010; Ord. No. 1023, § III, 10-11-2021; Ord. No. 1026, § 2, 11-22-2021) Sec. 44-739. Dynamic display signs. Dynamic displays are allowed as stated in this article with significant controls to minimize their proliferation and their potential threats to public health, safety, and welfare. (1)General Standards. All dynamic display signs shall meet the following standards: a.The images and messages displayed shall be static. Unless otherwise specified, each display shall be maintained for a minimum of two minutes. b.The transition from one display to another shall be instantaneous without any special effects. Motion, animation and video images are prohibited on dynamic LED sign displays. No portion of the images may flash, scroll, twirl, change color, or in any manner imitate movement. c.Dynamic display signs must be designed and equipped to freeze the device in one position if a malfunction occurs. The displays must also be equipped with a means to immediately discontinue the display if it malfunctions, and the sign owner must stop the dynamic display within one hour of being notified by the city that it is not meeting the standards of this article. d.Every line of copy and graphics in a dynamic display shall be at least seven inches in height on a road with a speed limit of 25 to 34 miles per hour, nine inches on a road with a speed limit of 35 to 44 miles per hour, 12 inches on a road with a speed limit of 45 to 54 miles per hour, and 15 inches on a road with a speed limit of 55 miles per hour or more. e.Brightness standards. i.The following brightness standards are required for all dynamic display signs: 1.No sign shall be brighter than is necessary for clear and adequate visibility. 2.No sign shall be of such intensity or brilliance as to impair the vision of a motor vehicle driver with average eyesight or to otherwise interfere with the driver's operation of a motor vehicle. 3.No sign may be of such intensity or brilliance that it interferes with the effectiveness of an official traffic sign, device or signal. ii.The person owning or controlling the sign must adjust the sign to meet the brightness standards in accordance with the city's instructions. The adjustment must be made within one hour upon notice of noncompliance from the city. iii.All dynamic display signs installed after August of 2008 must be equipped with a mechanism that automatically adjusts the brightness in response to ambient conditions. These signs must also be equipped with a means to immediately turn off the display or lighting if the sign malfunctions, and the sign owner or operator must turn off the sign or lighting within one hour after being notified by the city that it is not meeting the standards of this section. iv.In addition to the brightness standards required above, dynamic display signs shall meet the city's outdoor lighting requirements (subsection 44-20(1)). f.Reduction of sign surfaces for off-site dynamic display signs. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 85 of 92 i.A person or sign operator may obtain a permit for a dynamic display sign on one surface of an existing off-site sign if the following requirements are met: 1.The applicant agrees in writing to reduce its off-site sign surfaces by one by permanently removing, within 15 days after issuance of the permit, one surface of an off-site sign in the city that is owned or leased by the applicant, which sign surface must satisfy the criteria of part b. of this subsection. This removal must include the complete removal of the structure and foundation supporting each removed sign surface. The applicant must agree that the city may remove the sign surface if the applicant does not do so, and the application must identify the sign surface to be removed and be accompanied by a cash deposit or letter of credit acceptable to the city attorney sufficient to pay the city's costs for that removal. The applicant must also agree that it is removing the sign surface voluntarily and that it has no right to compensation for the removed sign surface under any law. Replacement of an existing sign surface of an off-site sign with a dynamic display sign does not constitute a removal of a sign surface. 2.If the removed sign surface is one that a state permit is required by state law, the applicant must surrender its permit to the state upon removal of the sign surface. The sign that is the subject of the dynamic display sign permit cannot begin to operate until the sign owner or operator provides proof to the city that the state permit has been surrendered. ii.If the applicant meets the permit requirements noted above, the city shall issue a dynamic display sign permit for the designated off-site sign. This permit will allow a dynamic display to occupy 100 percent of the potential copy and graphic area and to change no more frequently than once every 15 seconds. The designated sign must meet all other requirements of this article. g. Licensing. No person shall operate any dynamic display sign in the city without first obtaining a yearly license as defined in the city licensing ordinance (article II). h.Public safety. If city staff determines that a dynamic display sign is not being operated pursuant to this section due to its location or display capabilities, city staff may require that the sign be moved, removed, or modified after notice to the property owner. (2)Zoning District Standards. In addition to the general standards above, dynamic display signs shall adhere to the following district-specific requirements: a.On-site dynamic display signs in conjunction with a permitted institutional or public use in the residential, LBC, CO, SC, and NC zoning districts are permitted subject to the following conditions: i.Dynamic display signs require approval of a comprehensive sign plan. ii.All properties within 350 feet of a proposed dynamic display sign shall be notified of the application for a comprehensive sign plan. iii.Dynamic display signs are only permitted on monument signs. The area around the base of the sign shall be landscaped. iv.One dynamic display sign as part of a monument sign is permitted for each property. The entire monument sign shall not exceed eight feet in height and 50 square feet in size. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 86 of 92 v.The digital display portion of the sign shall not comprise more than 50 percent of the sign area. The remainder of the sign shall not have the capability to have a dynamic display. vi.All monument signs with a digital display shall maintain at least a ten-foot setback from any lot line and shall not be placed in a public right-of-way. This setback shall be increased to 20 feet if the adjacent property is used or shown on the city's land use plan for residential use. vii.The images and messages displayed shall be complete in themselves, without continuation in content to the next image or message or to any other sign. viii.Only one, contiguous dynamic display area is allowed on a sign face. ix.Audio speakers or any audio component is prohibited. The sign shall not emit any sound. x.The dynamic display shall not be illuminated between 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. xi.Dynamic displays must have an automatic dimmer control to produce a distinct illumination change from a higher illumination level to a lower level for the time period between a ½-hour before sunset and a ½-hour after sunrise. b.On-site dynamic display signs located in the business commercial (BC) or heavy or light industrial (M-2 and M-1) zoning districts: i.Are allowed as part of a permanent freestanding sign, provided that the sign comprises no more than 50 percent of the total square footage of said sign face. ii.Must be located at least 200 feet from any property where there are structures used for residential purposes or from any park or open space land use district. iii.Must be located at least 100 feet from any side property line. iv.Displays shall be maintained for a minimum of 15 seconds. (Ord. No. 896, § 13, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 1023, § IV, 10-11-2021) Sec. 44-740. Murals. Murals shall require approval of a comprehensive mural plan following the requirements of Sec. 44-742 and shall meet the following standards: (1)Murals shall be maintained in good repair, free from peeling paint or damage to age, weather, or vandalism. Removal of a mural must be accomplished by physical removal from a wall and/or by covering the mural completely with paint. The mural must be rendered completely invisible while maintaining the structural and architectural integrity of the structure. (2)Murals shall be composed of permanent materials and applied only to permanent surfaces. Murals may not be applied to any fabric or temporary surface. (3)Murals shall be allowed only on building facades that face a side or rear property line. (4)Murals with the following features shall not be allowed: a.Moving parts, including solar-, wind-, or water-driven devices. b.Projections from the wall surface c.Words (in any language), symbols, or representations that are obscene, offensive, of a political nature, or are derogatory. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 87 of 92 d.Representations that imitate or appear to imitate any official traffic sign or device to direct the movement of traffic. e.Colors that are predominantly fluorescent, metallic, or reflective. Sec. 44-741. Sign permits. If a sign requires a permit, the property owner shall secure the sign permit prior to the construction or major alteration of such a sign. No sign permit shall be issued for an existing or proposed sign unless such sign is in compliance with the requirements of this article. (1)Application. The application to erect or alter any sign shall be in writing, using a current sign permit application, and signed by the owner or occupant of the building. The application shall specify the location, height, dimensions of the sign and, where applicable, the dimensions of the wall surface of the building to which it is to be attached and total square footage of the building. Applications shall be accompanied by the permit fee, a sketch of the sign, and any other facts the city requires for full information of the nature and safety of the proposal. An electrical permit is also required for all signs containing electrical wiring. (2)Fees. The city council shall set all sign permit fees annually. (3)Time limits. a.All permits for the erection or alteration of signs shall be issued for the useful life of the sign. Minor alterations to an existing sign, including routine maintenance, painting, or refacing the copy, do not require a new sign permit. b.A sign permit shall become null and void if the work for which the permit was issued has not been completed within one year of the issuance or renewal. (4)Appeals. When a sign permit under this article is denied, the administrator shall give notice to the applicant within 30 days of denial, together with reasons for denial. Appeals from the decisions of the administrator under the provisions of this article shall be made to the city council. Denial shall be based on noncompliance with this article. (Ord. No. 896, § 9, 1-25-2010) Sec. 44-742. Comprehensive sign or mural plan. (1)A comprehensive sign or mural plan shall be provided for the following: a.Any non-residential property with five or more tenants on the site or any multiple-story buildings with two or more tenants in the building. b.All permitted institutional or public uses. c.All developments approved as a planned unit development. d.Large campuses consisting of buildings and land of ten or more acres. e.Shared signs that serve both the parcel on which they are placed and an adjacent parcel. f.Murals. g.Dynamic display wall signs (also refer to section 44-743 - dynamic display signs). h.Long-term exemptions to temporary window and banner signs (also refer to section 44-738 - signs exempt from regulations in this section). E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 88 of 92 i.Temporary signs on park designated land in the Maplewood Comprehensive Plan (also refer to section 44-742). (2)A comprehensive sign or mural plan request shall include the location, size, height, color, lighting, and orientation of all signs and/or murals. Requests for a comprehensive mural plan shall also include a design sketch and photos of the proposed site. Exceptions to the regulations of this article may be permitted as follows: a.For sign areas, densities, and dynamic display changeover rates for the plan as a whole if the signs are in conformity with the intent of this article b.If the exception results in an improved relationship between the various parts of the plan, c.If it encourages and promotes the removal of nonconforming signs through the use of shared signs, d.If for long-term exemptions to temporary window and banner signs, the comprehensive sign plan shows that there are unusual circumstances with the request. (3)Comprehensive sign or mural plans shall be reviewed by the community design review board. The applicant, staff, and city council may appeal the community design review board's decision. An appeal shall be presented to the administrator within 15 days of the community design review board's decision to be considered by the city council. (Ord. No. 896, § 2, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 908, § 2, 8-9-2010; Ord. No. 1023, § I, 10-11-2021) Sec. 44-743. Nonconforming signs. (1)Nonconforming temporary signs. Nonconforming temporary signs existing on the effective date of this article shall be brought into compliance or removed within 60 days from the effective date of this article. (2)Nonconforming permanent signs. Nonconforming permanent signs lawfully existing on the effective date of this article shall be allowed to continue in use, but shall not be rebuilt, relocated or altered, other than minor alterations including routine maintenance, painting, or refacing the sign copy, without being brought into compliance with this article. After a nonconforming sign has been removed, it shall not be replaced by another nonconforming sign. (Ord. No. 896, § 5, 1-25-2010) Sec. 44-744. Enforcement procedures. (1)Temporary signs. The city shall send a notice to the owner of any illegal temporary sign or temporary sign in violation of this article and allow seven days for the owner to correct all ordinance violations or remove the sign. If the sign is not a safety hazard, the city shall allow 30 days for the owner to correct the violation. If the sign is a safety hazard the city shall take immediate action to end the hazard. (2)Permanent signs. The city shall send a notice to the owner of any permanent sign in violation of the provisions of this article. The notice shall require that the owner to correct all ordinance violations. If the sign is not a safety hazard, the city shall allow 30 days for the owner to correct the violation. If the sign is a safety hazard the city shall take immediate action to end the hazard. (3)Abandoned signs. The city shall send notice to the owner of the property on which exists any abandoned sign in violation of the provisions of this article. The notice shall require that the owner correct all ordinance violations. If the sign is not a safety hazard, the city shall allow 30 days for the E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 89 of 92 owner to correct the violation. If the sign is a safety hazard the city shall take immediate action to end the hazard. (4)Removal of signs. If the sign owner does not obey the city's orders, the city may remove or alter the sign at the owner's expense under the procedures of sections 18-36 through 18-38 (notice to abate). The city may remove illegal signs on a public right-of-way without notice. If the city removes a sign the city may sell or dispose of it if the owner does not reclaim the sign and pay any removal costs within 30 days of the sign's removal. (5)Murals. The city shall send a notice to the owner of any mural that is in violation with the provisions of this article. The article shall require the owner to correct all ordinance violations. The city shall allow 60 days for the owner to correct the violation. If the mural is failed to be removed and/or maintained, the city may cause the removal of the mural. The owner shall pay all expenses under the procedures of sections 18-36 through 18-38 incurred by the city for the removal. (Ord. No. 896, § 6, 1-25-2010; Ord. No. 1000, § 2, 3-25-2019) Secs. 44-745—44-1050. Reserved. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 90 of 92 Illustrations of Sign Types E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 91 of 92 Standards being relocated to the use specific standards so that they are known earlier in the process: •Gas station canopies. Gas stations are allowed one additional wall sign that may be attached to the façade of the building or the overhanging canopy above the pump island. The wall sign on the canopy shall not exceed 50 percent of the face of the canopy, or the maximum size specified above, whichever is less. •Auto dealerships. Auto dealerships may have one freestanding sign, plus one freestanding sign for each car franchise. The maximum sign area and height for the freestanding signs shall be determined by the classification of the abutting roads, as specified above. More than one freestanding sign may be allowed per street frontage provided said signs are separated by more than 150 feet measured in a straight line between the signs. •Drive-throughs. Drive-throughs may have a message board that does not exceed 64 square feet and six feet in height. A message board shall not be located as to impair the vision of the driver of a vehicle traveling into, out of, or through the drive-through isle. •Minor motor vehicle stations. Minor motor vehicle stations with canopies are allowed to place signage on the canopy and the building; the area of the sign will contribute to the overall area allowance for wall and projecting signs described in part a. above, as long as they do not exceed the requirements above. E3, Attachment 2 CDRB Packet Page Number 92 of 92