Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-03-21 ENR Packet AGENDA CITY OF MAPLEWOOD ENVIRONMENTAL AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION Monday, March 21, 2022 7:00 p.m. Held Remotely Via Conference Call Dial 1-888-788-0099 Meeting ID: 876 8110 9457 Passcode: 409985 1. Call to Order 2. Roll Call 3. Approval of Agenda 4. Approval of Minutes: a. February 22, 2022 5. New Business a. Tennis Sanitation Recycling Collection Annual Review 1) 2021 Recycling Collection Year End Report 2) 2022 Recycling Collection Work Plan b. Republic Services Trash and Yard Waste Collection Annual Review 1) 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year End Report 2) 2022 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work Plan 6. Unfinished Business 7. Visitor Presentations 8. Commissioner Presentations 9. Staff Presentations (oral reports) a. ENR Commission Meeting Format – In Person Beginning April b. Arbor Day Event – May 14 c. Spring Clean Up – May 21 d. Harvest Park Native Seed Garden Pollinator Planting - May 24 e. Waterfest – June 4 10. Adjourn Agenda Item 4.a. MINUTES CITY OF MAPLEWOOD ENVIRONMENTAL AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION TUESDAY,FEBRUARY 22, 2022 7:00 P.M. (THIS MEETING WAS HELD REMOTELY VIA ZOOM AND CONFERENCE CALL) 1.CALL TO ORDER Chairperson Dosser called a meeting of the Environmental and Natural Resources Commission to order at 7:03p.m. 2.ROLL CALL Emma Broadnax, CommissionerAbsent Rebecca Bryan, Vice ChairpersonPresent Kayla Dosser, ChairpersonPresent Benjamin Guell, CommissionerPresent Mollie Miller, CommissionerPresent Ann Palzer, ChairpersonPresent Ted Redmond, CommissionerPresent(at 7:08 p.m.) Staff Present Shann Finwall, Environmental Planner 3.APPROVAL OF AGENDA Commissioner Bryan moved to approve the agenda. Seconded by Commissioner GuellAyes Bryan, Guell, Dosser, Miller, Palzer The motion passed. 4.APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Palzer moved to approve the January 25, 2022, ENR Commission meeting minutes. Seconded by Commissioner MillerAyes Bryan, Guell, Dosser, Miller, Palzer The motion passed. 5.UNFINISHED BUSINESS a.2022 Work Plan and Environmental Priorities Implementation Strategies The Commission discussed the following: 1 The 2022 environmental priorities will include Climate Action Planning, Nature Center Task Force Recommendations, and Community Garden/Urban Agriculture. Questions and comments regarding the environmental priorities: o How can the Commission support implementation of strategies outlined in the Nature Center Task Force recommendations? (Volunteer and assistance at Nature Center special events and programs.) o Will naturalists be hired to conduct the programs being put on by Community Education at the Nature Center? (Yes, the naturalists will be paid by Community Education.) o University of Minnesota Garden in a Box Program: Contact them for supplies of seeds for community gardens. Advertise the program for Maplewood residents. 6. NEW BUSINESS a. 2021 ENR Commission Annual Report The Commission reviewed the new format and approved the ENR Commission Annual Report with no changes. Environmental Planner Finwall stated the sustainability and solid waste portions of the report will be presented to the ENR Commission in March. 7. VISITOR PRESENTATIONS None. 8. COMMISSIONER PRESENTATIONS None. 9. STAFF PRESENTATIONS Environmental Planner Finwall updated the Commission on the following events and indicated there are opportunities to volunteer at the Arbor Day and Spring Clean Up events: a. Maplewood Tree Sale March 7 (registration begins), May 21/23 (tree pick up) b. Arbor Day Event May 14 (10 a.m. to noon at the Maplewood Nature Center) c. Spring Clean Up May 21 (8 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Aldrich Arena) 10. ADJOURNMENT Commissioner Miller made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Seconded by Vice-Chair Bryan. Ayes All The motion passed. Chairperson Dosser adjourned the meeting at 7:53 p.m. 2 Agenda Item 5.a. ENVIRONMENTAL & NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSIONSTAFF REPORT Meeting Date March 21, 2022 REPORT TO: Environmental and Natural Resources Commission REPORT FROM: Shann Finwall, AICP, Environmental Planner PRESENTER: Shann Finwall, AICP, Environmental Planner AGENDA ITEM: Tennis Sanitation Recycling Collection Annual Review 1)2021 Recycling Collection Year End Report 2)2022 Recycling Collection Work Plan Action Requested: MotionDiscussion Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution OrdinanceContract/Agreement Proclamation Policy Issue: The contract with Tennis Sanitation requires that the City hold an annual review of the residential recycling collection services and adopt an annual work plan. Recommended Action: Motion to approve the 2021 Recycling Collection Year-End Report and 2022 Recycling Collection Work Plan. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No Yes, the true or estimated cost is $.00 Financing source(s): Adopted Budget Budget Modification New Revenue Source Use of Reserves Other: N/A Strategic Plan Relevance: Community InclusivenessFinancial & Asset MgmtEnvironmental Stewardship Integrated Communication Operational EffectivenessTargeted Redevelopment The City’s residential recycling collection program creates operational effectiveness by protecting public health and safety and promoting city cleanliness and livability. It is also an important component of the City’s environmental stewardship and green assets by using best management practices to reduce waste and protect air quality, water quality, and natural resources. Background: 2020-2025 Recycling Collection Contract The recycling collection contract with Tennis Sanitation began on January 1, 2020, and ends June 30, 2025. Recycling Collection Annual Review The contract requires that the City schedule an annual meeting with Tennis Sanitation to: Review contractor’s annual report, including trends in Maplewood’s recycling recovery rates and participation rates. Efforts the contractor has made to expand recyclable materials markets. Review contractor’s performance based on feedback from residents to the City’s Environment and Natural Resources Commission, City Council, and City staff. Review contractor’s recommendations for improvement in the City’s recycling program, including enhanced public education and other opportunities as contained within the annual work plan for the upcoming year. Review City staff recommendations for contractor’s service improvements. Discuss other opportunities for improvement within the remaining years under the current contract. Recycling Collection Year-End Report The contract outlines requirements of the year-end reports as follows: Total quantities of recyclable materials collected, by material type (in tons). Net quantities of recyclable materials marketed, by material type (in tons). Log of all resident addresses where education tags were left because of non-targeted materials set out for recycling. Log of all complaints, including the nature of the complaints, to include the following: names, addresses, and contact numbers of the complainants; the date and time received; the contractor’s response; and the date and time of the response. Log of resident addresses that consistently do not set out recyclables. Gallons of fuel or mileage of vehicles traveled for the City’s greenhouse gas assessment. Recycling Collection Yearly Work Plan Tennis Sanitation submits an annual work plan proposal no later than November 1 for the upcoming calendar year to outline key priorities for system improvements. Public education tools shall be itemized and approximate timelines described. Other service improvements may also be included in the work plan. The City shall review and approve the work plan. The annual work plan shall be incorporated by reference as an amendment to the contract. Tennis Sanitation Annual Review Recycling Collection 2020 Year-End Report The Recycling Collection Year-End Report (Attachment 1) summarizes the City’s recycling program and outlines implementation strategies taken by Tennis Sanitation and the City to improve service: multi-family recycling education; customer service satisfaction; collection of linens and shoes; City facility recycling program; promotion of small business and church recycling; recycling composite study; 2 environmental impact analysis; market data; residual comparisons; truck weights; recycling service fee; storage of extra recycling material; and educational tags. The report also summarizes the materials collected. A comparison of a sampling of the data from 2020 to 2021 is as follows: Average pounds of recycling collected per month 2020 2021 Single family 46.13 lbs 43.74 lbs Multi-family10.39 lbs 10.14lbs Annual net tons of recycling collected Single-family3137.35 tons 2974.80 tons Multi-family 265.29 tons 259.04 tons Businesses/Churches 20.58 tons 21.39 tons 2022 Recycling Collection Draft Work Plan The 2022 Draft Recycling Collection Work Plan (Attachment 2) includes recommendations for improvements to the City’s recycling collection program including: 1) changes to yearly reports; 2) changes to yearly individual multi-family summary letters; 3) outreach to nonparticipating multi- family properties; 4) audit of City facility recycling collection; 6) educational campaign to reduce residuals; 7) recycling cart label audit; 8) roll out of recycling carts to households with no carts or personal carts; 9) assist the City with the Ramsey County 2022 SCORE Work Plan requirements. Attachments: 1.2021 Recycling Collection Year-End Report 2.2022 Recycling Collection Work 3 Attachment 1 ΑΏΑΐ - ¯«¤¶®®£ 2¤¢¸¢«¨­¦ 2¤¯®±³ Greg & Willie Tennis Tennis SanitationLLC. 1/31/2022 Prepared by: Angela Vaidich Index of Recycling Report ................... Page 2 ................... Page 3 ................... Page 4 Recycling Data (Multi-................... Page 5 Multi-................... Page 6 Inquiries, Linens, Cardboard, & Parks Summary..................... Page 7 Composite Study...................... Page 8 ................... Page 9 Glass Recycling Processor................... Page 10 Market Report - .................. Page 11 Additional Items................................................................ Page 12 Summary of Year-................. Page 13 Appendix of Recycling Report ................... Appendix A Recycling Report (Multi-.................... Appendix B ...................... Appendix C Monthly Multi-....................... Appendix D Monthly Single Family Report Dat..................... Appendix E Educational Tags and Complaints/Compliments Log Report Educational Tags............................................................... Appendix F Compliments/Complaints.................................................... Appendix G January 31, 2022 City of Maplewood Maplewood, MN 55109 1830 County Road B E RE: LETTER OF PURPOSE Dear City of Maplewood, This Year-end recycling report has been prepared for the City of Maplewood. The report contains summaries of recycling data for both single family and multi-family dwellings. Including but not limited to: inquiries, composite study information, environmental impact report, fun facts and a market report, along with a report summary. Also included is ten years of comparison data to help measure the success of the recycling program. The data in this report has been utilized over the years to assist us in understanding past, present and future progress of the recycling program as well as helping us develop future strategies to enhance the recycling programs already in place. Sincerely, Greg & Willie Tennis Greg and Willie Tennis Tennis Sanitation Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 2 RECYCLING DATA SUMMARY In this report we have compiled annual data from both single family and multi-family dwellings. This data includes: Net tonnage of all residential and multi-family dwellings combined Break-out of single family tonnage and set-out rates (orange) Break-out of multi-family tonnage (blue) (blue) Separate measurement of weights for cardboard and linens (bottom of APPENDIX A) Break-out of single family recycling materials by type and weight (orange) and Multi-family (blue) (blue) Break-out of combined tonnages (green) (green) Inquiries tracked per month (bottom of APPENDIX A) Also business volume, parks and cardboard are included The data is compiled from recyclable materials collected from our drivers on designated Maplewood routes. Loads are weighed; weights are then co period of time. Weights are broken out based on a composite ratio of the entire load. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 3 RECYCLING DATA (SINGLE FAMILY) The Single Family Data in APPENDIX A (orange)wascompiled from the single family homes after taking out the multi-family weights. From this data we are able to illustrate the weight per home (in lbs.) per month. We also -cycling out on a weekly basis. In analyzing the single family data, we are able to provide the following observations: 2021Averagelbs. per unit per month = 43.74lbs. per month 2011 = 38.91 lbs. per month2012 = 41.95 lbs. per month2013 = 43.78 lbs.per month 2014 = 53.48 lbs. per month2015 = 53.48 lbs. per month2016 = 54.59 lbs. per month 2017 =53.99 lbs. per month 2018 = 54.01 lbs.per month2019 = 53.69 lbs. per month 2020 = 46.13 lbs. per month 2021Annual Net total tons collected for single-family was 2,974.80tons 2011 =2,146.06tons2012 =2,313.61tons2013 =2,414.62tons 2014=2,949.92tons 2015 =2,949.94 tons2016 =3,011.02 tons 2017 = 2,978.13 tons2018 =2,979.18 tons2019 = 2,961.30 tons 2020 = 3,137.35 tons Total Participation Percentage YEAR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC AVRG 202196% 95% 97% 96% 97% 99% 97% 97% 97% 97% 96% 96% 97% 2013 Avg. 84%2014 Avg. 91%2015 Avg. 92% 2016 Avg. 92%2017 Avg. 93% 2018 Avg. 93% 2019 Avg. 95% 2020 Avg. 96% Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 4 RECYCLING DATA (MULTI-FAMILY) The Data in APPENDIX A (Blue) is the actual data compiled from net total weight family homes after factoring (Blue out the multi-family weights. From this data we are able to illustrate the weight per unit (in lbs.) per month. To assist us in providing accurate data, we compile weights on a quarterly basis. This weight is then used to provide us with a fair average of weight generated by each multi-family unit. Our drivers then documented the number of carts dumped at each location on a weekly basis (see APPENDIX D). These weights are then added at the end of each month to provide us with a net total. From the report we are able to calculate the weight per unit per month. In analyzing the multi-family data, we are able to provide the following observations: 2021 Average lbs. per unit per month was 10.14 lbs. per month 2011 was 12.96 lbs. per month 2012 was 11.47 lbs. per month 2013 was 13.24 lbs. per month 2014 was 12.95 lbs. per month 2015 was 13.04 lbs. per month 2016 was 13.08 lbs. per month 2017 was 11.03 lbs. per month 2018 was 12.95 lbs. per month 2019 was 9.92 lbs. per month 2020 was 10.39 lbs. per month 2021 Annual Net total tons collected for multi-family was 259.04 tons 2011 was 312.73 tons 2012 was 276.88 tons 2013 was 319.56 tons 2014 was 312.64 tons 2015 was 314.66 tons 2016 was 315.79 tons 2017 was 268.69 tons 2018 was 305.32 tons 2019 was 239.36 tons 2020 was 265.29 tons How are the weights determined for the multi-family data? On a quarterly basis we use one truck to collect all multi-family dwellings. The total weight is then divided by the number of carts emptied to get an average weight per cart. This data is then entered into a multi-family spreadsheet. See APPENDIX D for an example of this report. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 5 MULTI-FAMILY INDIVIDUAL SUMMARY LETTER From the data compiled over the twelve months we are able to provide each multi-family property with an accurate summary report of their recycling volumes (APPENDIX B). We also provide them with some information on how their efforts help with the environment along with additional information to assist them in enhancing their recycling efforts. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 6 INQUIRIES SUMMARY Below are twelve months of data documenting the number of residents that called into our office. This year the most common calls were comprised of what additional items they could recycle, and questions about the holiday schedule. We are confident that our Customer Service Representatives resolved all inquiries to 2021 Total Inquiries JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC TOTAL 40 39 49 25 32 45 27 36 45 29 17 14 398 2011 = 344 2012 = 260 2013 = 233 2014 = 1,552 2015 = 422 2016 = 662 2017 = 255 2018 = 165 2019 = 334 2020 = 370 LINENS AND SHOES SUMMARY We started a new partnership with Simple Recycling for our linen recycling as of March 2017. The 2020 year brought us many challenges, and linen recycling was one of them. Simple Recycling was shut down for multiple months due to the pandemic and not able to pick up linens from our location during that time. When Simple Recycling opened back up they had new regulations that they were able to the collect the bagged material but not able to collect it divided by City. 2019 = 9,882 lbs. 2018 = 8,989 lbs. 2017 = 35,687 lbs. 2016 = 1,577 lbs. 2015 = 5,917 lbs. 2014 = 6,270 lbs. 2013 = 8,641 lbs. 2012 = 3,692 lbs. 2011 = 6,217 lbs. CARDBOARD SUMMARY Cardboard collected for 2021 from city facilities and buildings totaled 85,830 lbs. 2020 = 74,490 lbs. 2019 = 89,120 lbs. 2018 = 102,356 lbs. 2017 = 88,337 lbs. 2016 = 104,498 lbs. 2015 = 125,020 lbs. 2014 = 131,346 lbs. 2013 = 140,650 lbs. 2012 = 92,850 lbs. 2011 = 105,615 lbs. BUSINESS and PARKS WEIGHTS 2021 BUSINESSES: 42,773 lbs. CITY PARKS: 840 lbs. 2020 BUSINESSES: 41,161 lbs. CITY PARKS: 3,220 lbs. 2019 BUSINESSES: 49,386 lbs. CITY PARKS: 5,650 lbs 2018 BUSINESSES: 71,529 lbs. CITY PARKS: 6,650 lbs. 2017 BUSINESSES: 62,460 lbs. CITY PARKS: 8,080 lbs. 2016 BUSINESSES: 60,771 lbs. CITY PARKS: 7,920 lbs. 2015 BUSINESSES: 45,885 lbs. CITY PARKS: 8,350 lbs. 2014 BUSINESSES: 30,157 lbs. CITY PARKS: 11,180 lbs. 2013 BUSINESSES: 2,855 lbs. CITY PARKS: 9,140 lbs. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 7 RECYCLING COMPOSITE STUDY Over the years of the contract we have done extensive recycling composite studies. We did this by keeping all loads froman entire weekfrom the City of Maplewood and process it though our MRF (Material Recovery Facility). Once the material is unloaded from the trucks it is sorted into each category, as listed below. Each of the categories were then weighed and documented. The results of the composite study were then entered back into the monthly reports in which you receive monthly. As of 2018, we have taken a look at all of the past data that we have collected and have tested a single load of material from the City of Maplewood. The single load of material has consistent ratios which are comparable al previously processed. Why do a composite study? Having a good understanding of the recycling composition provides us with data that may assist us in adjusting the recycling program to fit the needs of the Residents. With ongoing changes in the economy, cultural and even changes in the home, we can develop more available markets, increase processing technologies to handle more items and enhance educational materials to instruct residents on proper recycling procedures. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 8 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ANALYSIS Using the detailed recycling data from this report, we are able to provide the City of Maplewood with some unique ways that the residents recycling efforts have made a difference. Over the years, recycling markets have been able to recycle more and more items out of the waste stream. They have also been able to determine what resources are saved by recycling various materials. In this report we were able to convert the types of recycling materials into resources saved. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 9 MARKET REPORT The 2021 markets have seen their ups and downs but mostly up this past year. We continue seeing changes of our recyclable materials in the United States, mostly in the Midwest. There is definitely a change in the materials that are getting recycled, less paper, more cardboard, with schools always on the ready for distance learning, more offices working from home and a whole lot more home deliveries. The metal markets have slowly been working their way back to where pricing was back in 2018. The paper and cardboard markets are back in a comfortable place but always room to grow. Plastic markets hit their rock bottom last year but, with the cost of crude oil is increasing, we are hopeful that the plastic market will follow suit. Lastly, the glass market, with only one processor in the area, the commodity has been at a plateau again this year. With the Ni-Hot machine, we installed a few years back; we can capture more glass than in previous years which helps get more material to the processor. The processor can reclaim at least 90% of the broken glass to be made into new food and beverage containers. The outlook for 2022 Markets are stabilizing but will continue with the strict regulations on contaminates and clean material. With co-mingle curb side recycling it makes it easier to recycle but it is important to clean out your food containers, and make sure you are only placing items listed in your recycling brochure loosely into the recycling cart. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 10 ADDITIONAL ITEMS RESIDUALS: Residuals consisted of items such as Styrofoam, foam, shoes, diapers and general garbage. 2021: Residuals are down to 114.83 tons from last year 2020: Residuals are up to 131.71 tons from last year 2019: Residuals are down to 60.49 tons from last year 2018: Residuals are up to 62.54 tons from last year 2017: Residuals are up to 61.69 tons from last year 2016: Residuals are up to 38.59 tons from last year 2015: Residuals are down to 29.38 tons from last year 2014: Residuals are down to 29.36 tons from last year 2013: Residuals are down to 49.30 tons from last year 2012: Residuals are down to 55.55 tons from last year 2011: Residuals are 26.88 tons TRUCK WEIGHTS: During the 2021 Calendar year, none of our vehicles exceeded the maximum loaded weight of 40,000 pounds when hauling the recyclables collected from the residents of Maplewood. Weight tickets are available upon request. RECYCLING SERVICE FEE: The recycling service fee is $4.50 per unit per month which is based upon the contracted price. STORAGE OF EXTRA RECYCLABLE MATERIALS: During the 2021 calendar year our recycling facility had sorted all recyclable materials within 45 days of processing to recycling markets with the exception of milk cartons are baled and stored until there is enough volume to meet the vendor's minimum shipping requirements and "rare type" plastics are stored until a larger enough quantity is available to make a mill size bale. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 11 SUMMARY OF YEAR-END RECYCLING REPORT The 2021 Maplewood Year-end Recycling Report provides up-to- recycling activities over the past year. Each section of this report reflects the various ways data was collected, entered and calculated to contribute in meeting our combined goals. In the report we have illustrated the composition of recyclables and itemized volumes of recyclables from both single family and multi-family dwellings as they relate to each break-out of each separate commodity. We also provide information on how the City's recycling efforts will impact our environment. 6% participation rate. Both single family tonnages as well as multi-family recycling volumes have remained steady and consistent with other Municipalities. In 2022, we will maintain the comprehensive recycling program we offer with the additional types of plastics, metals and linens. Together with the support of The City of Maplewood we will maintain these high standards of recycling for the single family and multi-family dwellings. Maplewood recycling year-end report 2021 page 12 APPENDIX A -2021RECYCLING DATA SUMMARY APPENDIX B - Yearly Recycling Report Mulit-Family APPENDIX C -MONTHLY RECYCLING REPORT LETTER APPENDIX D - MONTHLY MULTI-FAMILY REPORT APPENDIX E-MONTHLY SINGLE FAMILY REPORT DATA APPENDIX FEducational Tags JANUARY 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 2378 Teakwood Friday Frozen 1/1/2021 2513 Knoll Monday Styrofoam 1/4/2021 2922 McKnight Wednesday Trash 1/6/2021 2976 Frederick Wednesday 3 Garbage Bags 1/6/2021 1772 Agate Thursday Styrofoam 1/7/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday 6 Carts Trash/Clothing 1/11/2021 Trails Edge TH Monday 1700 Microwave 1/11/2021 2390 Co Rd D Wednesday Styrofoam 1/13/2021 2079 Lydia Wednesday Florescent Lights 1/13/2021 1587 Grandview Wednesday Tagged For Space 1/13/2021 1989 Mesabi TH Wednesday Tagged Bigger Cart 1/13/2021 Blocked Furniture & Gold Star Apts Thursday Trash 1/14/2021 2468 Hillwood Friday Styrofoam 1/15/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 1/15/2021 1456 Sandhurst Monday Trash 1/18/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday Trash/Clothing Etc 1/18/2021 1257 Frisbie Monday Styrofoam 1/18/2021 888 Bartelmy Tuesday Tagged Space Carts 1/19/2021 TH Sterling Tuesday Styrofoam 1/19/2021 2490 Maryland Tuesday Wood/Stryo 1/19/2021 Wyngate Apts Wednesday N/O 1/20/2021 3004 Lake Wednesday Styrofoam 1/20/2021 Sibley Cove Apts Wednesday Door Broken 1/20/2021 1351,1349 Co Rd C Wednesday Foam Pad 1/20/2021 722 Roselawn Thursday Box Styrofoam 1/21/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 1/22/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday Trash 1/25/2021 1927 Cope Monday Recycle Frozen 1/25/2021 2231 Ide Monday Styrofoam 1/25/2021 1533 Lark Monday Wood 1/25/2021 1666 Rosewood Monday Mirror 1/25/2021 1247 Lealand Monday At Garage 1/25/2021 1272 Farrell Tuesday Box Styrofoam 1/26/2021 3006 Edward Wednesday Trash 1/27/2021 699 Eldridge Thursday TV Box Styrofoam 1/28/2021 145 Larpenteur Thursday Tagged Space Carts 1/28/2021 FEBRUARY 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 1934 Flandrau Monday Styrofoam 2/1/2021 1247 Lealand Monday At Garage 2/1/2021 1254 Ripley Monday Styrofoam 2/1/2021 2514 Rose Tuesday Styrofoam 2/2/2021 2541 Bittersweet Wednesday Light Bulbs 2/3/2021 2676 English Wednesday Food In Bags 2/3/2021 2409 BarclayWednesdayWood & Drywall2/3/2021 2116 Greenbrier Thursday Left Boxes Trash 2/4/2021 2180 or 2190 Arcade Thursday Styrofoam 2/4/2021 1912 McMenemy Thursday Styrofoam 2/4/2021 379 Ripley 265 Wood 2/4/2021 Couldn't Get Pup 2714 Brookview Friday Monday 2/5/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 2/5/2021 1765 & 2128 Southwind Monday Styrofoam 2/8/2021 1450 Sandhurst Monday Rug 2/8/2021 1247 Lealand Monday At Garage 2/8/2021 Silver Ridge Apts Tuesday 1 Trash 2/9/2021 2276 Hoyt Tuesday Box Styrofoam 2/9/2021 1309 Kohlman Wednesday Styrofoam 2/10/2021 2168 Kenwood Thursday Tied Shut 2/11/2021 1714 Edgemont Thursday Styrofoam 2/11/2021 Set Next To Mailbox 177 Larpentuer Thursday Multilple Bags 2/11/2021 2412 King Friday Trash & Food 2/12/2021 334 Oday Friday Styrofoam 2/12/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 2/12/2021 1120 Lealand Monday Styrofoam 2/15/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday trash/Blankets pillows 2/15/2021 2306 Kingston Monday Vases & Black Bags 2/15/2021 2615 Stillwater Tuesday Styrofoam 2/16/2021 750 Meyer Tuesday Box Styrofoam 2/16/2021 3080 Hazelwood Wednesday Stryo & Wood 2/17/2021 2423 Beam Wednesday Wood Cabinet 2/17/2021 Mapletree TH Wednesday Carts By Garage 2 Carts 2/17/2021 To Close To Mailbox 177 Larpentuer Thursday Tagged 2/18/2021 2371 Linwood Friday Box Styrofoam 2/19/2021 2409 Oakridge Friday Stryo 2/19/2021 545 Sterling Friday Box Trash 2/19/2021 569 Sterling Friday Box Styrofoam 2/19/2021 2330 Mailand Friday Styrofoam 2/19/2021 2714 Brookview Friday Couch In Way 2/19/2021 338 Oday Friday Trash 2/19/2021 1764,1709 Maple Woods TH Monday Styrofoam 2/22/2021 1963 Barclay Monday Styrofoam 2/22/2021 1120 Lealand Monday Box Styrofoam 2/22/2021 2340 TH Tuesday Box Styrofoam 2/23/2021 1320 Birch View Tuesday Box Styrofoam 2/23/2021 Cobblestone Apts Tuesday Box Styrofoam 2/23/2021 Tagged Recycle On Summer Hills Mplwd Tuesday Ground 2/23/2021 800 McKnight Tuesday Styrofoam 2/23/2021 2938 Howard Wednesday Styrofoam 2/24/2021 3080 Hazelwood Wednesday Styrofoam 2/24/2021 2006 Edgerton Thursday Food & Trash 2/25/2021 382 SummerThursdayStyrofoam2/25/2021 1714 Edgemont Thursday Styrofoam 2/25/2021 Tagged Next To 177 Larpentuer Thursday Mailbox 2/25/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday 3 Carts Frozen In Ice 2/26/2021 Carts In Garage Door 342 Parkview Friday Open 2/26/2021 MARCH 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE Emma's Place 2163 Van Dyke Monday Trash 3/1/2021 2255 Hazelwood Monday Styrofoam 3/1/2021 1501 Laurie Monday Trash 3/1/2021 Sherwood Apts Co Rd B Monday Wood/Styrofoam 3/1/2021 1313 Burke Monday Boxes Styrofoam 3/1/2021 1247 Lealand Monday By Garage 8:46am 3/1/2021 1914 Dieter Monday Styrofoam 3/1/2021 1915 Hazelwood Monday Styrofoam 3/1/2021 Cobblestone Apts Tuesday 1 Cart Styrofoam 3/2/2021 2514 Rose Tuesday Styrofoam 3/2/2021 2975 Carey Heights Wednesday Styrofoam 3/3/2021 Treadmill With Wood 908 Connor Wednesday Base 3/3/2021 1 Cart At Garage Not Mapletree TH Wednesday Walk up 3/3/2021 Tagged No Space X 1681 Co Rd C Wednesday Times 3/3/2021 1706 Abell Thursday Trash 3/4/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday 3 Trash 3/5/2021 2211 Van Dyke TH Monday Cars Blocking Carts 3/8/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O 6:05 Am 3/9/2021 2694 Ryan Dr Tuesday Trash In Cart 3/9/2021 Sibley Cove Apts Wednesday 3 Carts Trash/Food 3/10/2021 2780 Keller Wednesday Boxes Styrofoam 3/10/2021 Mpaple Tree TH 2811 & 2813 Wednesday At Garage Left 3/10/2021 521 Roselawn Thursday Cart N/O 3/11/2021 383 Belmont Thursday Yard Waste 3/11/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday 5 Trash/Food 3/15/2021 1916 Kingston Monday Trash 3/15/2021 1200 Belmont Monday Styrofoam 3/15/2021 1841 Kennard Monday Tagged For Space 3/15/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday Not Ou 6:00 3/16/2021 Sibley Cove Apts Wednesday Food/Trash 3/17/2021 Mapletree TH #2811 Wednesday By Garage 3/17/2021 2607-2621 Knollwood Wednesday Styrofoam 3/17/2021 2116 Greenbrier Thursday Yard Waste 3/18/2021 314 Bellwood Thursday Styrofoam 3/18/2021 185 Roselawn Thursday Leaves 3/18/2021 1735 Abel Thursday Drywall 3/18/2021 22 OdayFridayStyrofoam3/19/2021 2291 Hillwood Friday Styrofoam 3/19/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 3/19/2021 1959 White Bear Monday Styrofoam 3/22/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday Food/Trash 3/22/2021 1026 Mary Tuesday Styrofoam 3/23/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O 6:05AM 3/23/2021 Beaver Creek Condos Tuesday 1 Cart Trash 3/23/2021 Sibley Cove Apts Wednesday Trash & Food 3/24/2021 1763 County Rd C Wednesday Wood Post 3/24/2021 2000 Edgemont Thursday Trash/Styrofoam 3/25/2021 367 Belmont Thursday Yard Waste 3/25/2021 2468 Hillwood Friday Trash 3/26/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 3/26/2021 935 Currie Friday Styrofoam 3/26/2021 1575 Sandhurst Monday Styrofoam 3/29/2021 1387 Cope Monday Trash 3/29/2021 1958 Kennard Monday Wood Shelf 3/29/2021 1889 Co Rd B Monday Cart In Ditch 3/29/2021 1217 Frisbie Monday Styrofoam, Wood Trash 3/29/2021 2276 Arlington Tuesday Wood 3/30/2021 Cart Knocked Over In 2402 Larpenteur Tuesday Ditch 3/30/2021 Sibley Cove Apts Wednesday Trash 3/31/2021 APRIL 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 2116 Greenbrier Thursday Yard Waste 4/1/2021 2086 Burr Thursday Tras/Food 4/1/2021 367 Belmont Thursday Wood/Yard Waste 4/1/2021 2508 James Friday Styrofoam 4/2/2021 766 New Century Friday Food 4/2/2021 Garbage Bags of 389 High Point Curve Friday Recycle 4/2/2021 Mplwd Apts Friday Trash 4/2/2021 Century Trail Monday N/O 6:45 4/5/2021 1775 Barclay Monday Wood 4/5/2021 Trash On Ground 2565 Geranium Tuesday 9:15am 4/6/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O At 6:00am 4/6/2021 1695 Co Rd D Wednesday Styrofoam 4/7/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Trash & Food 4/7/2021 1846 Radatz Wednesday Compost 4/7/2021 2525 Flandrau Wednesday Plants,Wood Styro 4/7/2021 1366 Kohlman Wednesday Drywall 4/7/2021 367 Belmont Thursday Trash 4/8/2021 347 Laurie Thursday Light Bulbs Tagged 4/8/2021 37 Kingston Thursday Styrofoam 4/8/2021 2518 James Friday Styrofoam 4/9/2021 28 Oday Friday Styrofoam 4/9/2021 2473 BrookviewFridayStyrofoam 4/9/2021 2703 Snowdrift Friday Trash 4/9/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 4/9/2021 965 MCClelland Friday Styrofoam 4/9/2021 2553 Haller Friday Cart Spacing Tagged 4/9/2021 1130 Century Friday Styrofoam 4/9/2021 1138 Century Friday Styrofoam 4/9/2021 1407 Co Rd B Monday Bike Tires 4/12/2021 1468 Eldridge Monday Carpet 4/12/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday 2 Carts Trash 4/12/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O At 6:00am 4/13/2021 Beaver Creek Condos Tuesday 1 Cart Trash 4/13/2021 2129 Bradley Thursday 2 Boxes Styrofoam 4/15/2021 704 Viking Thursday Trash On Ground 4/15/2021 766 New Century Friday Trash 4/16/2021 2541 Beth Friday Luggage,Trash & Misc 4/16/2021 2431 King Friday Left Black Garbage Bags 4/16/2021 2338 Overlook Friday Tagged 4/16/2021 1239 Dorland Friday Styrofoam 4/16/2021 1211 Century Friday Compost 4/16/2021 2141 Prosperity Monday Above Ground Pool 4/19/2021 1384 Ripley Monday Styrofoam 4/19/2021 1778 Prosperity Monday Styrofoam 4/19/2021 1172 Rose Or Sterling Tuesday Tagged Space 4/20/2021 Beaver Creek Condos Tuesday 1 Cart Trash 4/20/2021 Beaver Creek Village Tuesday Styrofoam 4/20/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday Not Out 6AM 4/20/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Food & Trash 4/21/2021 2363 Gall Wednesday Light Fixtures 4/21/2021 2951 Mary Wednesday 1/2 Way Up Yard 4/21/2021 2512 Cypress Wednesday Yard Waste 4/21/2021 Damaged Vehicle 2581 Knollwood Wednesday Bumper Not Us 4/21/2021 3036 Cottage Ln Wednesday N/O 4/21/2021 Maple Ridge Apts Wednesday Styrofoam 4/21/2021 760 Eldridge Thursday Wood 4/22/2021 384 Lark Thursday Styrofoam 4/22/2021 1024 Crestview Friday Drywall 4/23/2021 1068 Dennis Friday Trash 4/23/2021 2303 Dahl Friday Wood 4/23/2021 1209 Lark Monday Leaves 4/26/2021 1247 Lealand Monday At Garage 8:21AM 4/26/2021 Maplewood Apts Monday 3 Carts Trash 4/26/2021 Food,Trash & 1693 Ruth Monday Styrofoam 4/26/2021 2174 Stanich Monday Vinyl & Wood Blinds 4/26/2021 1209 Frisbie Monday Styrofoam 4/26/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday Not Out 6AM 4/27/2021 Beaver Creek Condos Tuesday 1 Cart Trash 4/27/2021 3080 HazelwoodWednesday1 Cart Styrofoam4/28/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Food & Trash 4/28/2021 2439 Gall Wednesday Styrofoam 4/28/2021 2976 Frederick Wednesday Trash 4/28/2021 1763 Co Rd C Wednesday Wood 4/28/2021 1848 Desoto Thursday Yard Waste 4/29/2021 2114 McMenemy Thursday Wood Trim 4/29/2021 2090 Arcade Thursday Carpet 4/29/2021 191 Larpentuer #F Thursday Styrofoam 4/29/2021 42 Roselawn Thursday Cart Tied Shut 4/29/2021 Maplewood Gardens Friday Trash 4/30/2021 84 Dennis Friday Wood 4/30/2021 MAY 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 1468 Eldridge Monday Wood 5/3/2021 1445 Belmont Monday Bath Tub 5/3/2021 1625 Frost Monday Trash 5/3/2021 1247 Lealand Monday 8:33AM At Garage 5/3/2021 Maplewood Apts Monday 6 Trash 5/3/2021 Dirt,Yard Waste & 2204 Hazel Monday Trash 5/3/2021 1793 Duluth Monday Tagged Space 5/3/2021 1113 Ferndale Tuesday Styrofoam 5/4/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O 6:00AM 5/4/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Food/Trash 5/5/2021 1741 Co Rd C Wednesday Styrofoam 5/5/2021 Markham Wednesday 1 Trash 5/5/2021 Bellwood Apts Thursday 1 Trash 5/6/2021 1745 Edgerton Thursday Tagged Space 5/6/2021 2086 Burr Thursday Carpet 5/6/2021 Mplwd Gardens Apts Friday Trash 5/7/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday Trash 5/10/2021 Granite Apts Monday Trash 5/10/2021 1273 Frisbe Monday Trash 5/10/2021 1040 Ferndale Tuesday Rugs 5/11/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O 6:00AM 5/11/2021 1215 Ferndale Tuesday 1 Cart Trash 5/11/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Trash & Food 5/12/2021 2468 Brenner Wednesday Boxes With Trim 5/12/2021 2685 Barclay Wednesday Flo Bulbs Tagged 5/12/2021 1703 Jessie Thursday Cart Knocked Over 5/13/2021 2086 Burr Thursday Plastic Bags With Trash 5/13/2021 Mississippi Apts Thursday Microwave 5/13/2021 342 Parkview Friday Bags Foam Padding 5/14/2021 359 Parkview Friday Yard Waste 5/14/2021 Mplwd Gardens Apts Friday Trash 5/14/2021 1438 Co Rd B Monday Mirror 5/17/2021 1203 Lark Monday Styrofoam 5/17/2021 1822 Sterling Monday Trash 5/17/2021 1125 Beaver CreekTuesdayStyrofoam5/18/2021 Beaver Condos Tuesday Trash 5/18/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Trash 5/19/2021 2086 Burr Thursday Trash 5/20/2021 371 Eldridge Thursday Wood Panel 5/20/2021 41 Mayhill Friday Styrofoam 5/21/2021 Crestview Foerst Club House Friday Trash 5/21/2021 Maplewood Garden Friday Trash 5/21/2021 2270 Highwood Friday Styrofoam 5/21/2021 1500 Lark Monday Trash 5/24/2021 1406 Belmont Monday Trash 5/24/2021 1247 Lealand Monday At Garage 814am 5/24/2021 Maplewood Apts Monday Trash & Food 5/24/2021 2100 White Bear Monday Trash 5/24/2021 1708 Duluth Monday Sent Pic To Angela 5/24/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday 6:00am Not Out 5/25/2021 Beaver Condos Tuesday 1 Trash 5/25/2021 2329 Montana Tuesday Trash 5/25/2021 1695 Co Rd D Wednesday 1 Cart Wood 5/26/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Trash 5/26/2021 2292 Co Rd D Wednesday Trash 5/26/2021 2191 Beam Wednesday Wood Styrofoam Box 5/26/2021 474 Roselawn Thursday Metal Bin With Trash 5/27/2021 1775 Edgerton Thursday Yard Waste 5/27/2021 2086 Burr Thursday Trash 5/27/2021 2563 Schaller Friday Left Lawn Mower Oil 5/28/2021 341 Oday Friday Styrofoam 5/28/2021 Mplwd Gardens Apts Friday Trash 5/28/2021 Sherwood Glen Monday Trash 5/31/2021 Glass Table Deer Stand 2012 Dieter Monday Brake Down 5/31/2021 1247 Lealand Monday At Garage 8:28AM 5/31/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday Trash 5/31/2021 1748 Flandrau Monday Sticks 5/31/2021 JUNE 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 500 Ferndale Tuesday Styrofoam 6/1/2021 7760 Mary Tuesday Cart Spaced 6/1/2021 949 Evar Tuesday Styrofoam 6/1/2021 1237 Farrell Tuesday Trash 6/1/2021 2980 Carey Wednesday Styrofoam 6/2/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Trash 6/2/2021 1973 Desota Thursday Left Open Linen Bags 6/3/2021 2086 Burr Thursday Trash 6/3/2021 2103 Bradley Thursday Styrofoam 6/3/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 6/4/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday 4 Trash 6/7/2021 Van Dyke TH Monday Cars Blocking 6/7/2021 1805 White Bear Monday Trash 6/7/2021 1593 SterlingTuesdayTrash6/8/2021 3067 Edward Wednesday Left Plant 6/9/2021 3029 Mary Wednesday Styrofoam 6/9/2021 70 McClelland Friday Wooden Charger 6/11/2021 2598 Mayer Friday Tyard Waste 6/11/2021 2654 Promontory Friday Wood Pallet 6/11/2021 357 Parkview Friday Wood 6/11/2021 Left 6 Trash Bags 389 High Point Curv Friday Recycle 6/11/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 6/11/2021 1468 Eldridge Monday Paint 6/14/2021 1974 Manton Monday Carpet 6/14/2021 1732 Burke Monday Styrofoam 6/14/2021 1513 1501 Brooks Wednesday Styrofoam 6/16/2021 2116 Greenbrier Thursday Trash 6/17/2021 181 Unit E Larpentuer Thursday Trash & Carpet 6/17/2021 477 Crestview Friday Styrofoam 6/18/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 6/18/2021 1024 Crestview Friday Styrofoam 6/18/2021 1037 Marine Friday Styrofoam 6/18/2021 1024 Marine Friday Styrofoam 6/18/2021 2308 Dahl Friday Hard Wood Flooring 6/18/2021 765 Dorland Friday Styrofoam 6/18/2021 1805 White Bear Monday Trash 6/21/2021 Battle Creek Properties Tuesday N/O 6AM 6/22/2021 Tagged Vehicles 1280 Dennis Tuesday Blocked Cart 6/22/2021 1562 Lakewood Tuesday Box Styrofoam 6/22/2021 Sibley Cove Wednesday Trash 6/23/2021 Hollween Express Wednesday Sketchy Homeless Guy 6/23/2021 2525 Flandrau Wednesday Trash 6/23/2021 2170 Burr Thursday Wood 6/24/2021 1755 Agate Thursday Trash &Food 6/24/2021 83 Dennis Friday Brush 6/25/2021 2654 Promontory Friday Styrofoam 6/25/2021 1844 Flandrau Monday Styrofoam 6/28/2021 1805 White Bear Monday Trash/Leaves 6/28/2021 1808,1812,1816 Kennard Monday Cans Knocked Down 6/28/2021 2477 Brenner Wednesday Boxes Styrofoam 6/30/2021 JULY 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE Western Hill Thursday Food 2 Carts 7/1/2021 1790 Jackson Thursday Yard Waste 7/1/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 7/2/2021 1960 Clarence Monday Insulation 7/5/2021 1193 Lark Monday Fireworks 7/5/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday 11 Carts Trash 7/5/2021 1953 Cope Monday Left Plastic Bags 7/5/2021 English Manor Apts Monday 1 Cart Flor Bulbs 7/5/2021 TH SterlingsTuesdayStyrofoam7/6/2021 2308 Stillwater Tuesday Styrofoam 7/6/2021 1292 Kohlman Wednesday Tagged For Space 7/7/2021 2586 Flandrau Wednesday Styrofoam 7/7/2021 1962 Payne Thursday Yard Waste 7/8/2021 163 Larpentuer Thursday Styrofoam 7/8/2021 1239 Dorland Friday Yard Waste 7/9/2021 1713 Lark Monday TV 7/12/2021 1666 Lark Monday Styrofoam 7/12/2021 1292 Lark Monday Styrofoam 7/12/2021 English Manor Apts Monday Flor Bulbs 7/12/2021 631-639 Farrell Tuesday Flor Bulbs 7/13/2021 2480 Larpentuer Tuesday Trash 7/13/2021 3101 McKnight Wednesday Trash 7/14/2021 3065 Standridge Wednesday Trash 7/14/2021 2205 Mapleview Wednesday Trash Bags 7/14/2021 314 Bellwood Thursday Tagged For Space 7/15/2021 83 Dennis Friday Brush 7/16/2021 1239 Dorland Friday Leaves 7/16/2021 1733 Lark Monday Carpet 7/19/2021 1809 English Monday Flor Bulbs 7/19/2021 1773 Kennard Monday Wood Chair 7/19/2021 Not Reachable With 977 Century Tuesday Arm 7/20/2021 1399 Currie Tuesday Food & Trash 7/20/2021 2512 Cypress Wednesday Carpet 7/21/2021 Sherwood Glen Apts Wednesday Styrofoam 7/21/2021 1681 Co Rd C Wednesday Space Tagged 7/21/2021 Arlington Hills Church Thursday Carts Missing 7/22/2021 Western Hill Thursday Tagged Trash 7/22/2021 1239 Dorland Friday Trash 7/23/2021 204 Oday Friday Food 7/30/2021 864 New Century Friday Trash 7/30/2021 893 New Century Friday Placement 7/30/2021 915 Sterling Friday Cat Litter 7/30/2021 1065 Dennis Friday Wood 7/30/2021 AUGUST 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE Sherwood Glen Apts Monday Trash & TV's 8/2/2021 2242 Duluth Monday Light Bulbs 8/2/2021 2100 White Bear Monday 1 Cart 8/2/2021 English Manor Monday Flo Bulbs/ styrofoam 8/2/2021 1811 Kennard Monday Styrofoam & Wood 8/2/2021 1638 Frost Monday Flo Bulbs 8/2/2021 2277 Tilsen Tuesday Wood Trim 8/3/2021 1399 Currie Tuesday Food & Trash 8/3/2021 2299 Gall Wednesday Yard Waste 8/4/2021 Sherwood Glen Apts Wednesday Trash All Over Ground 8/4/2021 Gold Star Thursaday Bee Hive Under Lid 8/5/2021 2301 HillwoodFridayTrash8/6/2021 389 High Point Friday Left Plastic Bags 8/6/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 8/6/2021 2181 McAfee Monday Styrofoam 8/9/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday Trash 8/9/2021 1728 Duluth Monday Compost & Trash 8/9/2021 1805 White Bear Monday Trash 8/9/2021 1399 Currie Tuesday Trash 8/10/2021 Foam Padding & Wood 2703 Ryan Dr Tuesday Trim 8/10/2021 Cardinal Pointe Apts Wednesday No Pup's Black Topped 8/11/2021 2116 Greenbrier Thursaday Trash 8/12/2021 384 Lark Thursaday Tagged Placement 8/12/2021 Gold Star Thursaday Bee Hive Under Lid 8/12/2021 2654 Promontory Friday Plastic Bubble Wrap 8/13/2021 Crestview@ Club House Friday Trash 8/13/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 8/13/2021 2534 Haller Friday Styrofoam 8/13/2021 2012 Dieter Monday Trash 8/16/2021 1962 Hazelwood Monday Styrofoam 8/16/2021 English Manor Monday Bulbs & Styrofoam 8/16/2021 1793 Duluth Monday Close To Mailbox 8/16/2021 Trash cart Infront 1791 Atlantic Monday Tagged 8/16/2021 1399 Currie Tuesday Trash 8/17/2021 2141 Arcade Thursday Trash 8/19/2021 2116 Greenbrier Thursday Trash 8/19/2021 367 Belmont Thursday Yard Waste 8/19/2021 Gold Star Thursday Active Wasp Hives 8/19/2021 489 Crestview Dr Friday No Linen Bags Out 8/20/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 8/20/2021 1760 Burke Monday Pulled 2 Bags Trash Out 8/23/2021 1809 English Monday Bulbs & Styrofoam 8/23/2021 Tagged Multiple Cart 760 Bartelmy Tuesday Space 8/24/2021 1478 Gervais Wednesday Styrofoam 8/25/2021 Againist Truck Tagged 1587 Grandview Wednesday Mult Times 8/25/2021 2116 Greenbrier Thursday Trash 8/26/2021 #379 Townhomes Thursday Tagged Placement 8/26/2021 Gold Star Thursday Wasp Hives 8/26/2021 1726 Abell Thursday Tagged Placement 8/26/2021 766 New Century Friday Pillows 8/27/2021 2553 Dahl Friday Styrofoam 8/27/2021 Mplwd Apts Friday Trash 8/27/2021 2213 McAfee Monday Trash 8/30/2021 2049 Prosperity Monday Styrofoam 8/30/2021 2019 Kennard Monday Styrofoam 8/30/2021 1809 English Monday Flo Bulbs 8/30/2021 1728 Duluth Monday Compost 8/30/2021 1539 RipleyMondayCompost8/30/2021 760 Bartelmy Tuesday Tagged Space 8/31/2021 SEPTEMBER 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 1240 Terrace Wednesday Styrofoam 9/1/2021 1996 Co Rd D Wednesday Key Fab Wouldn't Work 9/1/2021 2956 Howard Wednesday Trash Only 9/1/2021 2137 Beam Wednesday Carts In Garage 9/1/2021 2109 Beam Wednesday Trash Only 9/1/2021 Markham Apts Wednesday Wood & Plants 9/1/2021 Mplwd TH Wednesday Trash 9/1/2021 1703 Jessie Thursday All Trash 9/2/2021 727 Laurie Thursday Styrofoam 9/2/2021 Gold Star Thursday Bee Hives 9/2/2021 129 Summer Thursday Wood Sticks & Carpet 9/2/2021 New Century Friday Styrofoam 9/3/2021 1621 Sandhurst Monday Styrofoam 9/7/2021 2186 Hazelwood Monday Left Pile Not Sure 9/7/2021 2240 Ide Ct Monday Styrofoam 9/7/2021 1512 Sandhurst Monday Styrofoam 9/7/2021 2125 White Bear Ave Monday Trash 9/7/2021 2722 TH Monday Trash 9/7/2021 2219 Larpentuer Monday Mostly Branches 9/7/2021 Tagged To Close To 1728 Duluth Monday Truck 9/7/2021 Touching Mailbox 1717 Clarence Monday Tagged 9/7/2021 Cobblestone Apts Tuesday 2 Trash 9/8/2021 2366 Chippewa Wednesday Brush 9/9/2021 Carpet & Stuffed 739 Skillman Thursday Animals 9/10/2021 1703 Jessie Thursday Trash 9/10/2021 2700 Brookview Friday Fish Tank 9/11/2021 2262 Dahl Friday That Was Trash Driver 9/11/2021 376 Sterling Friday Left Box Foam 9/11/2021 Had To Leave 2 Black McKnight TH Friday top 9/11/2021 2228 McAfee Monday Electroncs 9/13/2021 1970 Maryknoll Monday Styrofoam 9/13/2021 1252 Lealand Monday Trash 9/13/2021 1735 VanDyke 1st Choice Monday Car Blocking Lot 9/13/2021 Cobblestone Apts Tuesday Trash Mixed 9/14/2021 2330 Stillwater Tuesday Left Site Tarring 9/14/2021 2405 Brenner Wednesday Left 2 Bins Trash 9/15/2021 Construction Couldn't 2720 Mplwd John K Office Wednesday Get 9/15/2021 Gold Star Thursday Bee Hives 9/16/2021 455 High Point Curv Friday Branches 9/17/2021 1420-1480 Sterling Friday 1 Cart Tied Shut 9/17/2021 1775 Lark Monday Light Bulbs 9/20/2021 1212 LealandMondayStyrofoam9/20/2021 1760 Birmingham Monday Wood 9/20/2021 Cobblestone Apts Tuesday Recycling On Ground 9/21/2021 750 Meyer Tuesday Styrofoam 9/21/2021 2101 Bradley Thursday Trash 9/23/2021 Gold Star Thursday Bee Hives 9/23/2021 196 Oday Friday Food & Trash 9/24/2021 766 New Century Friday Styrofoam 9/24/2021 908 Ferndale Friday Foam 9/24/2021 866 Sterling Friday Grass 9/24/2021 826 Sterling Friday Yard waste 9/24/2021 2544 Nemitz Friday Trash 9/24/2021 1452 Burke Monday Bike Tires 9/27/2021 1936 Manton Monday Trash 9/27/2021 2125 White Bear Ave Monday Styrofoam 9/27/2021 1200 Lark Monday Styrofoam 9/27/2021 Parkview Court Apts Monday 1 Cart Wood 9/27/2021 1984 Awkwright Thursday All Foam 9/30/2021 OCTOBER 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 43 Oday Friday Carpet & Pad 10/1/2021 2213 Mcafee Monday Styrofoam 10/4/2021 2125 White Bear Ave Monday Trash & Electronics 10/4/2021 1940 Flandrau Monday Styrofoam 10/4/2021 Parkview Apts Monday Trash 10/4/2021 1808 Prosperity Monday Tire 10/4/2021 2073-2067 Lydia Wednesday Only 1 Cart Out 10/6/2021 2837-2835 Fredrick Wednesday Only 1 Cart Out 10/6/2021 Sherwwod Glen Apts Wednesday Trash Every Where 10/6/2021 2181 Sunrise Dr Thursday Tagged For Space 10/7/2021 Gold Star Apts Thursday Bee Hives 10/7/2021 2721 Upper Afton Friday Leaves 10/8/2021 2701 Red Splender Friday Trash 10/8/2021 766 New Century Friday Styrofoam 10/8/2021 915 Sterling Friday Styrofoam 10/8/2021 2532 Dahl Friday Wood & Sawdust 10/8/2021 Mpled Gardens Friday Trash 10/8/2021 2205 Ide St Monday Styrofoam 10/11/2021 1396 Laurie Monday 1 Bag Trash 10/11/2021 1475 Burke Monday Styrofoam 10/11/2021 2701 Red Splender Friday Trash In Recy Cart 10/15/2021 1764 Co Rd B Monday Yard Waste 10/18/2021 1557 Co Rd B Monday Styrofoam 10/18/2021 1706 Rosewood Monday Styrofoam 10/18/2021 1956 Ripley Monday Yard Waste 10/18/2021 957 Evar Tuesday Gas In Mower 10/19/2021 2591 Stillwater Tuesday Flo Bulbs 10/19/2021 Equipment Blocking Maple Ridge Apts Wednesday Carts 10/20/2021 Woodlyn Wednesday 1 Cart Trash 10/20/2021 2123 Beam Wednesday Engine Oil In Cart 10/20/2021 191 Larpentuer#AThursdayBy Garage10/21/2021 2675 Brookview Friday Light Bulbs 10/22/2021 2706 Brookview Friday Light Bulbs 10/22/2021 2701 Red Splender Friday Trash Tagged 10/22/2021 2441 Linwood Friday Styrofoam 10/22/2021 2412 King Friday Yard Waste 10/22/2021 Mpled Gardens Friday Trash 10/22/2021 1764 Lark 819 Dorlan Window,Glass & Wood 10/25/2021 2245 Ide Monday Toilet 10/25/2021 2111 Prosperity Monday Huge Mess Mixed 10/25/2021 1216 Junction Monday Leaves 10/25/2021 1756 ripley Monday Yard Waste 10/25/2021 Cobblestone Apts Tuesday Throw Recy On Ground 10/26/2021 Nitti Picked Up Recy Sterling Cr Tuesday Not Trash 10/26/2021 Lake View Tuesday Trash 10/26/2021 1695 Co Rd D Wednesday Blocking Roofers 10/27/2021 1838 Desota Thursday Yard Waste 10/28/2021 819 Dorland Friday Trash 10/29/2021 2366 Oakridge Friday Trash & Food 10/29/2021 2412 King Friday Yard Waste 10/29/2021 376 Sterling Friday Tagged Blocked Carts 10/29/2021 NOVEMBER 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE 1631 Co Rd B E Monday Styrofoam 11/1/2021 Mplwd Apt Monday 5 Carts Trash 11/1/2021 1996 Stanich Monday Microwave 11/1/2021 373 Skillman Thursday Tagged Blocked Cart 11/4/2021 2721 Upper Afton Friday Potted Plants 11/5/2021 2528 Schaller Friday Styrofoam 11/5/2021 692 Ferndale Friday Pumpkins 11/5/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 11/5/2021 1560 Sandhurst Monday Styrofoam 11/8/2021 1970 Prosperity Monday Trash 11/8/2021 2160 Day Monday N/O Mpwld Bins 11/8/2021 2946 McKnight Wednesday Box Trash & Food 11/10/2021 Bellwood Apts Thursday 1 Cart Trash 11/11/2021 428 Eldridge Thursday Tagged Blocked Cart 11/11/2021 Upper Afton Rd Friday All Empty 11/12/2021 425 Crestview Friday Yard Waste 11/12/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 11/12/2021 1362 Cope Monday Styrofoam 11/15/2021 2215 Ide Monday Styrofoam 11/15/2021 1247 Lealand Monday at Garage 10:17 11/15/2021 Mplwd Apts Monday 3 Carts Trash 11/15/2021 1923 Castle Monday Wood Panels 11/15/2021 2689 Midvale Tuesday Trash/Box 11/16/2021 2050 BeamWednesdayTrash/Food11/17/2021 1993 Arkwright Thursday Ytrash 11/18/2021 2412 King Friday Yard Waste 11/19/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 11/19/2021 1468 Burke Monday Styrofoam 11/22/2021 1948 Manton Monday Leaves 11/22/2021 1971 Stanich Monday Yard Waste 11/22/2021 2573 Harvester Tuesday Mower Gas In 11/23/2021 765 Meyer Tuesday Yard Waste 11/23/2021 2941 Howard Wednesday Styrofoam 11/24/2021 373 Skillman Thursday Trash 11/26/2021 1631 Co Rd B E Monday Styrofoam 11/29/2021 1384 Cope Monday Plants 11/29/2021 2225 Ide Monday Styrofoam 11/29/2021 1451 Sandhurst Monday Wood Panels 11/29/2021 1462 Sandhurst Monday Pillows 11/29/2021 1625 Frost Monday Styrofoam 11/29/2021 1996 Kingston Monday Yard Waste 11/29/2021 739 Meyer Tuesday Food & Trash 11/30/2021 DECEMBER 2021 ADDRESS ROUTE DAY REASON DATE Rt1 Marcus Wednesday Trash Left Oil On Roads 12/1/2021 2392 Standridge Wednesday Yard Waste 12/1/2021 1745 Edgerton Thursday Blocked 12/2/2021 2466 Brookview Friday Styrofoam 12/3/2021 389 High Point Friday Recy In Trash Bags 12/3/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 12/3/2021 1665 Laurie Monday Styrofoam 12/6/2021 1764 Co Rd B E Monday Trash 12/6/2021 Cart Placement Clise To 2251 Ide Monday BB Hoop 12/6/2021 1232 Lark Monday Styrofoam 12/6/2021 1160 Co Rd B E Monday Wood 12/6/2021 2472 Cypress Wednesday Styrofoam 12/8/2021 2978 Mary Wednesday Yard Waste 12/8/2021 2343 Beam Wednesday Carpet & Rugs 12/8/2021 362 Summer Thursday At Garage 12/9/2021 2675 Brookview Friday Styrofoam 12/10/2021 2605 Brookview Friday Leaves 12/10/2021 1570 Sandhurst Monday Styrofoam 12/13/2021 Sherwood Glen Monday Not Able Due To Snow 12/13/2021 1224 Lark Monday Bed Pads & Hoses 12/13/2021 Parkview Monday Left Oven & Microwave 12/13/2021 1652 Lakewood Tuesday Box & Bag Trash 12/14/2021 Mailbox Knocked Down 1077 Co Rd C Wednesday Not Marcus 12/15/2021 3060 Lake Wednesday Left Trash Bags Recycle 12/15/2021 800 Dorland Friday Trash 12/17/2021 2359 Dahl Friday Wood 12/17/2021 389 High PointFridayRecycle In Trash Bags12/17/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 12/17/2021 2181 Birmingham Monday Styrofoam 12/20/2021 Cobblestone Tuesday 2 Carts Trash 12/21/2021 1226 Summit Wednesday Carpet 12/22/2021 373 Skillman Thursday Cart Blocked 12/23/2021 177 Larpentuer Thursday Cart Next To Mailbox 12/23/2021 Mplwd Gardens Friday Trash 12/24/2021 1764 Co Rd B E Monday Trash 12/27/2021 2213 Mcafee Monday Wood 12/27/2021 1672 Rosewood Monday Trash 12/27/2021 Cobblestone Tuesday Trash & Oil 12/28/2021 2093 Bradley Thursday Trash 12/30/2021 Appendix G Complaints and Compliments City of Maplewood Complaints/Compliment s 2021 Caller Addres Date City Notes Name s My recycle was only half emptied and I was able to stop him and he was so cheerful and 1770 9/13/21 Al's wife Maplewood nice about it. Did not complain Edward St to have to empty it again for me. Thank you for coming back for me. Attachment 2 Draft 3-17-22 2022 Recycling Collection Work Plan Tennis Sanitation submits an annual workplan outliningkey priorities for residential recycling system improvements, includingimprovementsoutlined in the City’s Ramsey County SCORE recycling work plan(attached). Thework planis incorporated into therecycling contractby reference once it isapproved by the CityCouncil. 1.Yearly Reports: Update yearly reports to include the followingitems: a.Log of resident addresses that consistently do not set out recyclables. b.Summary of how the nonparticipating household percentage is determined. c.Number and size of curbside recycling carts in use. d.Net quantities of recyclable materials marketed, by materialtype (in tons). e.Gallons of fuel or mileage of vehicles traveled per route for the City’s greenhouse gas assessment. f.Relative change in type of materials found in the yearly composition study compared to the previous year’s study. g.Recycling weights fromeach City facility. h.Summary of how the previous year’s work plan items were addressed. 2.Individual Summary Letter to Multi-Family Properties and City Facilities: Update yearly summary letters to include the following: a.Do not send individual summary letters for each City facility. Instead, add City facility recycling weights to the annual report. b.Send acopy of all letters to the City in pdf format. c.Add Ramsey County BizRecycling details. d.Add information on the opportunity for multi-family properties to convert their recycling collection to the recycling dumpsters. e.Add the City of Maplewood contact and websiteinformation. 3.Nonparticipating Multi-Family Properties: The most recent household audit reflects there are three multi-family properties that do not have recycling. Tennis Sanitation will work with the City and Ramsey County’s BizRecycling program to ensure these properties offer recycling and have recycling resources available for their tenants. 4.City Facilities: Tennis Sanitation collects recycling at City facilities at no costas part of the residential recycling contract. Tennis and the City will identify the number and size of existing recycling containers at City facilities. This list will be used to right-size the number and size of containers to ensure adequate collection of recycling at City facilities. Draft 3-17-22 Residuals: Work with the City on an educational campaign to decrease residuals in the m, shoes, diapers, and general garbage. recycling stream including Styrofoam, foa Recycling Cart Label Audit: Conduct an audit of all recycling carts in use in Maplewood to ensure recycling labels are in good condition and have the correct information. No Cart or Personal Cart: The 2021 cart audit discovered there are several households without a recycling cart or are using their own personal carts. Work with the City to ensure Tennis Sanitation carts are rolled out to all of these households. 2022 SCORE Agreement Work Plan: Assist the City in addressing items listed on the 2022 SCORE Agreemen 2 Addendum to 2022 Recycling Work Plan Maplewood 2022 Recycling Performance Work Plan Minimum Requirements 1.Complete all 2022 SCORE requirements, including reporting on time and submitting a mid-year status report. 2.Provide outreach to all residents about the municipality’s recycling program and submit copies of materials to Ramsey County. 3.Use Ramsey County materials and information when and where appropriate to promote increased recycling, reuse and repair (e.g., Fix-it Clinics), medicine collection, household hazardous waste, organic waste and yard waste participation. a.Send materials to Ramsey County for review prior to distribution. b.Include county contact information on materials: i.24/7 Recycling & Disposal Hotline: 651-633-EASY (3279) ii.RamseyRecycles.com c.Provide links to the Ramsey County web pages on municipality website. 4.Use hauler data to identify those not recycling and target educational materials. 5.Ensure all multi-unit properties are meeting State law requirements to recycle and are receiving free Ramsey County resources. 6.Increase opportunities for recycling in public spaces. a.All recycling bins must be paired with a trash bin and in good condition. b.Labels must be readable. c.Promote Ramsey County’s event container lending program and green event planning tips. 7.Implement a “Green” purchasing procurement policy for city functions and facilities to use reusable, recyclable or compostable packaging. 8.Ensure the collection of textiles for recycling is available to residents through curbside collection and to multi- unit dwellings through special collection or drop-off. 9.Enforce recycling contracts, including the assessment of penalties for non-compliance. a.Audit reporting by obtaining hauler weight tickets. b.Have labels replaced if not readable. 10.Attend County Recycling Coordinator meetings and attend a yearly composition study. Additional Incentive Activities Approved: 1.Promote BizRecycling. Actively work with and promote BizRecycling to businesses and institutions in collaboration with Ramsey/Washington Recycling & Energy for organics recycling and food waste reduction programs. 2.Promote Multi-unit Recycling Improvements. Actively work with and promote free resources and grants to multi-unit building in collaboration with Ramsey/Washington Recycling & Energy to improve and/or start recycling at multi-unit dwellings. Agenda Item 5.b. ENVIRONMENTAL & NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSIONSTAFF REPORT Meeting Date March 21, 2022 REPORT TO: Environmental and Natural Resources Commission REPORT FROM: Shann Finwall, AICP, Environmental Planner PRESENTER: Shann Finwall, AICP, Environmental Planner AGENDA ITEM: Republic Services Trash and Yard Waste Collection Annual Review 1) 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year End Report 2) 2022 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work Plan Action Requested: Motion Discussion Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution Ordinance Contract/Agreement Proclamation Policy Issue: The contract with Republic Services requires that the City hold an annual review of the residential trash and yard waste collection services and adopt an annual work plan. Recommended Action: Motion to approve the 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year-End Report and 2022 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work Plan. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No Yes, the true or estimated cost is $.00 Financing source(s): Adopted Budget Budget Modification New Revenue Source Use of Reserves Other: N/A Strategic Plan Relevance: Community Inclusiveness Financial & Asset Mgmt Environmental Stewardship Integrated Communication Operational Effectiveness Targeted Redevelopment The City’s residential trash and yard waste collection program creates operational effectiveness by protecting public health and safety and promoting city cleanliness and livability. It is also an important component of the City’s environmental stewardship and green assets by using best management practices to reduce waste and protect air quality, water quality, and natural resources. Background: 2020-2025 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Contract The trash and yard waste collection contract with Republic Services began on January 1, 2020, and ends June 30, 2025. Trash and Yard Waste Collection Annual Review The contract requires that the City schedule an annual meeting with Republic Services to: Review contractor’s annual report. Review contractor’s performance based on feedback from residents to the City’s Environmental and Natural Resources Commission, City Council, and City staff. Review contractor’s recommendations for improvement in the City’s trash and yard waste collection program, including enhanced public education and other opportunities as contained within the annual work plan for the upcoming year. Review City staff recommendations for contractor’s service improvements. Discuss the Pay as You Throw (PAYT) pricing schedule, including a careful review of the actual number of trash carts by size from the previous Agreement year, trash cart switches by trash cart size, and agree upon the details of PAYT price increments for the next Agreement year. (Note: The City and the contractor meet annually in August to create a PAYT price schedule for approval by the City Council yearly.) Discuss other opportunities for improvement with the remaining years under the current Agreement. ear Implementation Plan Trash and Yard Waste Collection Five-Y The contract outlines details for the City and Republic Services to develop an overall implementation plan that identifies all tasks and assignments not yet specified in the Agreement. The implementation plan shall include all future major activities, including (but not limited to): Means to maintain adequate trash cart inventory records, including addressing the potential use of the RFID tag cart identification system. Possible organic waste collections. Details of the PAYT schedule for each future Agreement year. Improvements in routing. Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year-End Report The contract outlines requirements of the year-end reports as follows: Trash cart size / collection service level, including weekly and every other week (EOW). Total quantities of trash collected (in tons). Total quantities of yard waste collected (in tons). Total quantities of bulky items collected (in tons or item counts) separated into regular bulky item collection and Fall Clean-Up Campaign collection of bulky items. Revisions to any counts of eligible households served. Number of trash cart switches, repairs, replacements, and trash cart purchases needed. Service log of all resident addresses where education tags were left because of prohibited materials set out for trash collection or other forms of non-compliance. 2 Log of all complaints, including the nature of the complaints, to include the following: names, addresses, and contact numbers of the complainants; the date and time received; the Contractor’s response; and the date and time of the response. National call center details including number of calls, speed to answer, call abandonment, average call handle time. Safety and accident reports. Residents with walk-up service. Total number of households served by: o single-family dwellings. o dwellings within homeowners’ associations (e.g., townhomes, manufactured homes, or other planned unit developments). o route by day. Customer service improvements based on the net promoter scores. Gallons of fuel or mileage of vehicles traveled for the City’s greenhouse gas assessment. Trash and Yard Waste Yearly Work Plan Republic Services submits an annual work plan proposal no later than November 1 for the upcoming calendar year to outline key priorities for system improvements. Items to be included in the annual work plan are any proposed amendments to the “five–year” implementation schedule as outlined above, customer service improvements based on the net promoter scores, household audits (as needed), discussions regarding the feasibility of on-call walk-up service, and proposed improvements to the Spring Clean Up and Fall Clean-Up Campaign. Public education tools shall be itemized and approximate timelines described. Other service improvements may also be included in the annual work plan. The City shall review and approve the work plan during the Annual Performance Review outlined below. The annual work plan shall be incorporated by reference as an amendment to the contract. Republic Services Annual Review 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year-End Report The Trash and Yard Waste Year-End Report (Attachment 1) summarizes implementation strategies taken by Republic Services and the City in 2021 to improve service. These strategies included: Trash cart warranties. Yard waste collection outreach. Spring Clean Up Fall Clean Up Campaign City facilities trash and organic collection Billing Townhome and manufactured home opt in New promoter score and improvements 3 The report also summarizes the 2021 data of materials collected, household counts, cart sizes, etc. A comparison of a sampling of the data from 2020 to 2021 follows: 2021 ____2020 Trash collected 8,871.61 tons 8,972.03 tons Bulky items 1,891.00 tons 1,343.00 units (new measurement) Yard waste collected 648.30 tons 528.84 tons Single-family accounts 8,924 accounts 8,924 accounts Townhome/manufactured home accounts 209 accounts 99 accounts Permanent exemptions 162 exemptions 145 exemptions Walk-up service 66 walk ups 77 walk ups Yard waste accounts 1,333 accounts 1,386 accounts 2022 Draft Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work Plan The 2021 Draft Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work Plan (Attachment 2) includes recommendations for improvements to the City’s trash and yard waste collection program including: 1) preparations for the County’s curbside organics collection program; 2) trash hauling audits for households, opt outs, opt ins, and walk ups; 3) townhome and manufactured home outreach; 4) improvements to yearly reports; 5) city facility trash and organic collection assessment; 6) billing changes; 7) net promoter score and customer service improvements. Attachments: 1. 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year-End Report 2. 2022 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work 4 Attachment 1 City of Maplewood and Republic Services 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year End Report Prepared by: Beverly Mathiasen Samahra Hallada City of Maplewood and Republic Services 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year End Report Dear City of Maplewood, We are excited to provide theCity of Maplewood and Republic Services 2021 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Year End Report. In this report you will find materialonRepublic Servicescommitment to sustainableand environmental solutions roughout021 and beyondlong with llhe required and necessary reportsor e th2,aatfth City of Maplewoodstrash and yard waste collection.The report includestheapproved 2021 Work Plan Priorities and the progress made on each initiative.Welook forward to building relationships with the community while living up to our brand promise to provide simple solutions, service reliability, and environmental responsibility in everything we do. Thank you for yourtime andthe opportunity to service the great residents of the City of Maplewood. Warm wishes, Beverly Mathiasen Samahra Hallada Inver Grove Heights, MN 11380 Courthouse Blvd Inver Grove Heights, MN 55077 2 Review of Republic Services 2021 Environmental Solutions and Sustainability Goals Environmental Solutions As a leader in environmental services, Republic Services partners with customers to provide sustainable solutions across their operations. We are proud to make a positive impact on people and the planet. With 75 renewable energy projects across the organization, we are actively investing in our communities. In Minnesota the Pine Bend Landfill in Inver Grove Heights is approved to build a new renewable naturalgas (RNG) plant. The renewable gas to energy (RNG) plant will be the first of its kind in the state of Minnesota. Once operational, it will treat biogas collected from the landfill and send it into the Xcel Energy pipeline. Future plans include using the compressed natural gas to fuel a fleet of trucks at Pine Bend. The gas plant will capture the equivalent of more than $2 million metric tons of CO2 annually, which is the equivalent of taking about 435,000 passenger cars off the road 2030 Sustainability Goals Republic Services published their 2030 sustainability goals and have committed to work together with our communities, our customers, and our team to meet these oals. With Safety always being our top g priority and goal, we are excited to work with the Maplewood community on working towards a sustainable and environmentally conscious future. To learn more about Republic Services' 2030 goals and how we are demonstrating Sustainability in Action, visit RepublicServices.com/sustainability.The 2020 Sustainability Report is downloadable from the website. 3 Committed toServe Republic Services is committed to partnering with small businesses that strengthenthe community. Cities participated in a National Neighborhood Promise Event for the Rondo Neighborhood in St. thth Paul onJune18and 19of 2021. Together with Rebuilding Together Twin Cities we created a community garden at the Rondo Commemorative Plaza. In May of 2021, Republic Services Twin Cities employees volunteered in the Minneapolis community to build a handicap ramp for a local Veteran. Republic Services is committed to serve our communitiesacross the country, helping ensure the highest quality customer service & employee safety. We look forward to the 2022 opportunities to be involved in our Minnesota communities. Maplewood Community Republic Services participated in the Maplewood Touch-a-Truck event inSeptember 2021. Bev, Samahra,and ourdriver, Dave, spent the afternoon showcasing one of our new trash trucks to be used in Maplewood. Republic takes pride in the communities we serve. 4 2021Year-End Trash Services Report The 2021Year-End Trash Services Report attached as an addendum to this report summarizes the service levels for the City of Maplewood residential trash and yard waste collection program including: 1.Collection service levels.12.Types of educational call/tag. 2.Account information.13.Customercomplaints/compliments 3.Trash carts in use.14.Type of safety and accidents. 4.Trash cart inventory.15.Approximate lifts per route per day. 5.Trash carts to be purchased.16.Customer Service Improvement 6.Trash cart parts to be purchased.Based on Republic Services Net 7.Trash cart warranty issues.Promoter Score 8.Trash cart activity.17.Fall Clean-UpCampaign 9.Customer service phone calls.18.Approximate lifts per route per day 10.Disposal information in tons.19.Gasoline Used Per Vehicle 11.Delinquent accounts. 2021Year-End TrashRoll Up Item201920202021 Trash Collected (tons)8,146.448,871.618,972.03 Bulky Items (tons)1,069.001,891.001,343.00 Yard Waste Collected 785.27648.30528.84 (tons) Single-family Accounts8,9248,9248,924 Townhome/Manufactured 14420999 Home Accounts Permanent Exemptions264162145 Walk-up Service596677 Yard WasteAccounts1,2971,3331,386 5 Summary of 2021 Work Plan Priorities 1.Trash cart warranty report Number of carts submitted for warrantyand reviewed: 222carts bƚƷĻʹ ŷĻƩĻ Ǟğƭ ğƓƚƷŷĻƩ ǞğƩƩğƓƷǤƭǒĬƒźƷƷĻķ ƚƓ ЊΉЍΉЋЋ ŅƚƩ ЊЎВĭğƩƷƭ͵ Carts Submitted: Type of Damage Submitted: Size# Submitted Handle4 for Warranty 3034 Body45 60103 Cart Body Back73 9085 Lid47 Axle11 Wheel17 Bottom25 Credits received for each size cart: Carts SubmittedCarts Credited RS Date 30gal60gal90galTotal 30gal60gal90galTotal MaplewoodReceivedSubmittedCredited ET-0008-2/25/202110202050 0000 2021 WT-0111-10/28/20212483651720611980 2021 22280 6 2.Yard Waste Collection SubscriptionOutreach In December of 2021, Republic Services worked with EnvironmentalPlanner, Shann Finwall, on a bill insert that included the PAYT (Pay as YouThrow) pricing and the 2021-2022 Yard Waste pricing. This insert was included on February invoices of 2022 and was emailed to auto-pay residents. In addition to the bill insert, garbage and yardwaste tags were customized for the City of Maplewood. The tags are utilized by drivers to provide education to residents should they haveanunacceptableitem in their cart or curbside, as well as information on Maplewoodssubscription yard waste program. Snapshot of the MaplewoodGarbageandYard Waste Tag: 7 3.Spring Clean-Up Republic Services participated in the Maplewood Spring Clean Up on Saturday, April 17, 2021, from 8 am to 1 pm at Aldrich Arena (1850 White Bear Avenue). It was a very successfuleventthat provided residents the opportunityto safely dispose of larger items they no longer had a use for. The followingtons of trash and total number of bulk items were collectedat this event: MSW (trash) collected (in tons) 750.82 # Bulk items collected 122 Inadditionto the SpringClean-Up, Republics Services participatedinthe: Fall Clean-Up Campaign Republic Services assisted the citywith its ninthannual Fall Clean-Up Campaign in October 2021. The Campaign offered reduced price curbside bulky item collection and an educational component focusing on reducing, reusing, and recycling. In 2021, 288 bulk items were collected during the Campaign.An additional 1,343 bulky items were picked up throughout 2021. 8 4.City Facilities As part of thetrash and yard waste collection contract, Republic Services collects trash and organics at City facilities at no cost. Below are the locations of service, type of service, container size, and frequency of pick-upRepublic provides to the Citys municipal buildings. LocationService (TR/Organics)/Cart or Frequency Container Size City Hall 1830 County Road Trash:16-yardcontainerTwice a week-Monday and B East.Thursday Organics-1-90-galcart Once a week-Friday Public Works Building 1902 Trash: 16-yardcontainerTwice a week-Monday and County Road B East.Thursday Organics-1-90-galcart Once a week-Friday Fire Station Two 1955 Trash:3-90-galcartsOnce a week-Monday Clarence Street. Fire Station Three 1530 Trash: 2-90-galcartsOnce a week-Wednesday County Road C. Fire Training Facility 1881 Trash: 190-galcartOnce a week-Tuesday Century Avenue North. Maplewood Community Trash: 3-4-yardcontainersTwice a week-Monday and Center 2100 White Bear Thursday Organics: 1-4 -yardcontainer Avenue. Once a week-Tuesday Maplewood Nature Center Trash: 1-30-galcartOnce a week-Tuesday 2659 7thStreet East. Organics:190-galcartOnce a week-Friday 9 5.Billing: RepublicServices continues to review the logisticsand costsassociatedwith - monthly trash hauling billing to begin in January, rather than February of each new year. In the best interest of the residents and to avoidany further confusion,theRepublic ServicesFinanceand IT teams are working together to create a thorough process and plan to implement this change in the summer of 2022. TheMaplewood Bill Insert that wasenclosed on the Februarybill detailed the annual increase to decrease any confusion while Republic works with Maplewood on the large-scalebilling update. 6. Townhomes and manufactured home opt-in: Townhomes and manufactured homes canopt-in to the trash and yard waste program withRepublic Services. Republic continuesto work with the City of Maplewood on outreach notifying the townhomes and manufactured homes of their eligibility toopt-in and the current pricing.Informationon the program is on the City of Maplewood websiteand included on the annual solid waste guide. HOAscurrently opted-in: o Linwood Heights: 82 accounts o Beaver Lake #3: 17 Accounts 10 7.Net promoter score report and improvements: ŷĻ /ƚƓƷƩğĭƷƚƩ ƒğƓğŭĻƭ ĭǒƭƷƚƒĻƩ ƭĻƩǝźĭĻŷğǒƌźƓŭ ĭƚƓƷƩğĭƷ ƩĻƨǒźƩĻƭ ƷŷğƷ ƷŷĻ/ƚƓƷƩğĭƷƚƩ ƭǒƦƦƌǤ ƷŷĻ /źƷǤ ǞźƷŷ ķĻƷğźƌƭ ƚƓ ƷŷĻ ƓǒƒĬĻƩ ƚŅ ĭğƌƌƭͲ ƭƦĻĻķ Ʒƚ ğƓƭǞĻƩͲ ĭğƌƌ ğĬğƓķƚƓƒĻƓƷͲ ğǝĻƩğŭĻ ĭğƌƌ ŷğƓķƌĻ ƷźƒĻͲ ğƓķ ƓĻƷ ƦƩƚƒƚƷĻƩ ƭĭƚƩĻ͵ bĻƷ ƦƩƚƒƚƷĻƩ ƭĭƚƩĻƭ ğƩĻ ƷŷĻ ƦĻƩĭĻƓƷğŭĻ ƚŅ ĭǒƭƷƚƒĻƩƭ ƩğƷźƓŭ ƷŷĻźƩ ƌźƉĻƌźŷƚƚķ Ʒƚ ƩĻĭƚƒƒĻƓķ ğ ĭƚƒƦğƓǤ Ʒƚ ğ ŅƩźĻƓķ ƚƩ ĭƚƌƌĻğŭǒĻ ğƭ В ƚƩ ЊЉ ΛƦƩƚƒƚƷĻƩƭΜ ƒźƓǒƭ ƷŷĻ ƦĻƩĭĻƓƷğŭĻ ƩğƷźƓŭ ƷŷğƷ źƭ ğƷ Џ ƚƩ ĬĻƌƚǞ ΛķĻƷƩğĭƷƚƩƭΜ ƚƓ ğ ƭĭğƌĻ ŅƩƚƒ Љ Ʒƚ ЊЉ͵ LƷ źƭ ğ ƒğƓğŭĻƒĻƓƷ Ʒƚƚƌ ǒƭĻķ ğƭ ğ ƒĻğƭǒƩĻ ƚŅ ĭǒƭƷƚƒĻƩ ƌƚǤğƌƷǤ͵ ŷĻ ЋЉЋЉ —ĻğƩΏ9Ɠķ wĻƦƚƩƷ ķĻƷğźƌƭ ğ ƚŅ ЊЊ͵ЎͲ ğƓķ ƷŷĻ ķźŅŅĻƩĻƓĭĻ ƚŅ А͵Ў͵ /ƚƓƷƩğĭƷƚƩ ƭŷğƌƌ ƭǒƦƦƌǤ ğ ƩĻƦƚƩƷ ƚƓ ĭǒƭƷƚƒĻƩ ƭĻƩǝźĭĻ źƒƦƩƚǝĻƒĻƓƷƭ ƦƩƚƦƚƭĻķ ĬğƭĻķ ƚƓ ƷŷĻ ƭĭƚƩĻ͵ About the score: Our Annual Net Promoter Scores have significantly Calls Offered41,379 increased year over year since 2010. Average Speedto 00:06:25* Those scores include: Answer 2019:8 AverageHandle00.04:49 2020:22 (1/1/2020 12/31/2020 data; Time 175% increase over 2019) 2021:35(59% increase to date over 2020) hĭƷЋЊbƚǝЋЊ5ĻĭЋЊ ʹЍЌʹЋЌʹЍЉ *Note-Average Speed toAnswerhassignificantly decreased in Q3 of 2021. Average is higher dueto a few months of high hold times fromlabor shortages. Real examples of surveysresponsesfrom Maplewood residents: Likelihood to Recommend Explanation Open-End We are both handicapped and have a very long driveway. Your drivers come all the way up the drive and dump our trash and recycling. They do an excellent job. Kudos and many thanks to the drivers and your company for providing this service. If you would like to share any additional feedback, please feel free to note it here: We have been extremely satisfied with your services and would recommend them to friends and neighbors. Thanks again for great service. 11 Improvements: Based on the Survey feedback the customer service improvements Republic Services made year over year and will continue to implement include: 1.Knowledge Management Tool Updates 2.Auditing of Call Recordings 3.Monthly Meetings 4.Residential Education 5.Communication Mechanisms At the end of 2021and into 2022, our Customer Service Center restructured to better serve the residents. They focused on hiring in Minnesota to have agents thatunderstand the unique intricaciesof the Statestrash and recyclinglaws. In additionto focusing hiring efforts, theCall Center created team structures to service specific areas. There arenow 108 agents (remote US) that are on the MidwestPod. The calls are first routed to the agents thatreceiveadditional training on municipalities and state laws and as a backup they will go into the pool of calls in Indianapolis.This will further decrease hold times,improve first call resolution, and overall, positivelyincrease the customer experience. 12 2021MaplewoodYearEndTrashServicesReportSubmittedbyRepublicServices CollectionServiceLevels Jan FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd 20GallonEOW129130132133129123115113110109108109 109 20GallonWeekly300300300300300300300300300300300300 300 32GallonWeekly107110851085108110761075107210651061106010651063 1063 65GallonWeekly342234153415340834123405339933953395338533903395 3395 95GallonWeekly386038483858386038503859387738723891390139083921 3921 2/32GallonWeekly444444444444 4 2/65GallonWeekly181818181818181818181818 18 2/95GallonWeekly180180180180180180180180180180180180 180 3/95GallonWeekly484848484848484848484848 48 4/95GallonWeekly404040404040404040404040 40 5/95GallonWeekly555555555555555555555555 55 AccountInformation Jan FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd Singlefamilyaccounts8,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,9248,924 8,924 Townhome/manufacturedhomeaccounts99999999999999999999999999 Permanentexemptions145145145145145145145145145145145145145 Walkupservices767777777777777777777777 77 Yardwasteaccounts132813281329137213951407139713961392139113891386 1,386 Containersinuse Jan FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd 20GallonEOW129130132133129123115113110109108109 109 20GallonWeekly300300300300300300300300300300300300 300 32GallonWeekly107110851085108110761075107210651061106010651063 1,063 65GallonWeekly342234153415340834123405339933953395338533903395 3,395 95GallonWeekly386038483858386038503859387738723891390139083921 3,921 2/32GallonWeekly444444444444 4 2/65GallonWeekly181818181818181818181818 18 2/95GallonWeekly180180180180180180180180180180180180 180 3/95GallonWeekly484848484848484848484848 48 4/95GallonWeekly404040404040404040404040 40 5/95GallonWeekly555555555555555555555555 55 Trashcartsinuse912791239135912791129107910890909102910091169133 9,133 TrashCartInventory Jan FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd 20Gallon404017517560160188187188188177146 147 32Gallon25217427527514055247223242218238215 224 65Gallon1802241841841101284578646046 1 95Gallon10494616616475465487459360340318292 296 TrashCartstobePurchased Jan FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd 30galN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A50 60galN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A353 90galN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A198 TrashCartPartstobePurchasedJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A TrashCartWarrantyIssuesJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecYearEnd 0 50000000017200222 TrashCartActivityJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecAnnualTotal Volumeswitches262855403536173523272418 364 Replacement/Repair43304350355374781061793221 744 Removal79761251091051581091381121179672 1296 Delivery656710413991194104105881088170 1216 Removeyardwaste766351171234251686 173 Addyardwaste00366734351521191831 249 TotalActivity220207369440311483331411373465244188 4042 CustomerServicePhoneCallsJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDec Numberofphonecalls3648.002005.003193.004404.003106.003994.004143.004445.002723.003125.003511.003082.00 SpeedtoAnswer3:534:247:507:015:047:4210:439:131:59:43:23:40 Callabandonment82750912101481856156117722208942429246209 Handletimeaverage4:014:374:434:454:534:495:295:595:004:474:424:10 DisposalInformationinTonsJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecAnnualTotal MSW(trash)collected640.22576.54744.72750.82740.22850.89788.60827.13789.02734.82801.62727.43 8972.03 Yardwastecollected00052.0473.0889.439.8743.8362.568.3799.750 528.84 Bulkitemscollected865813012291103114101972889261 1343 CityCleanUpBulkItemsN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A288N/AN/A288 TippingFeepertonRRTNewport$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$84.00$87.00$84$87 DelinquentAccountsJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecTotalforYear TotalAcountsPastDue 1,264N/A1,1251,9071,8992,1221,1962,1831,1561,9759652,032 N/A 30dayspastdue$1,706.72$0.00$51,458.81$59,226.28$59,212.04$66,682.57$2,841.00$72,752.77$2,617.80$67,485.40$2,716.32$66,699.98N/A 60dayspastdue$34,644.47$593.17$0.00$24,470.28$23,535.08$1,293.49$33,542.58$1,298.83$39,055.19$1,560.78$35,966.36$952.61N/A 90dayspastdue$769.11$23,847.95$208.51$0.00$151.11$22,206.01$899.03$23,593.35$740.37$23,487.20$1,226.41$25,874.02N/A 120dayspastdue$19,080.63$246.75$16,455.25$160.55$0.00$14,223.50$15,672.31$636.30$17,664.12$271.51$17,231.78$1,099.91N/A 150dayspastdue$834.31$15,258.02$246.75$13,694.99$13,656.64$0.00$12,646.77$13,527.53$514.41$13,354.40$124.80$15,582.63N/A 180dayspastdue$19,683.21$18,308.52$28,130.45$25,371.51$25,584.84$32,006.83$30,743.68$41,450.19$50,506.44$45,789.11$1,354.55$1,260.32N/A TotalPastDueDollars$76,718.45$58,254.41$96,499.77$122,923.61$122,139.71$136,412.40$96,345.37$153,258.97$111,098.33$151,948.40$58,620.22$111,469.47N/A WrittenoffAccountsN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A118 WrittenoffFundsN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A55226.98 TypeofEducationalCall/Tag Jan FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecAnnualTotal BulkItemsoutnotscheduled31212215 0 310 21 CartPlacement33011230 2 102 18 IncreaseServiceLevel212111100 000 9 UsingPersonalCan/PlasticBags01000000 0 000 1 Carttooheavy021000100000 4 OversizedItem100100000000 2 Prohibitteditemintrash200000000000 2 Yardwasteinplasticbags/cartinstruction000020044000 10 Yardwasteintrashcart00000001 0 300 4 Yardwasteoutbutnotonprogram00022220 0 100 9 Clearsnow342100000011 12 SetOutTime264582343127 47 ChristmasTreeIssue700000000000 7 GeneralEducation413002005203 20 TrashinYWCart000000000000 0 Total23201710151011141811413 166 CustomerComplaints/ComplimentsJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecAnnualTotal GeneralInquiryComplaint100023220111 13 GeneralInquiryCompliment000000000111 3 TypeofSafetyandAccidentsJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecAnnualTotal 100000000000 1 CSImprovementBasedonRepublicServicesNet PromoterScore JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDecTotalBenchmark*Difference 2020CustomerCommentTopicsreliabilityof service(problems,complaints,consistency, experience,etc). 19295485328382959381317 3111.719.3 *Benchmarkisbasedon2019 **NPSwasnotcollectedinApril2020dueto Covid CityWideCleanUpOct Tons/QTY TotalBulkCollections(Electronics/Appliance& HomeBulks) 288 Electronics24 HomesBulksserviced236 HomesAppliance28 ApproximateliftsperrouteperdayMonTueWedThuFri 50242727906821130 50410690105700 50810321041960937795 GallonsperMilesper TrashTrucks(Allyearround)weekweek 2445164380 244764151 244875197 GallonsperMilesper weekweek CompostTrucks(AprilthroughNovember) 24293378 24301440 Attachment 2 DRAFT 3-17-22 2022 Trash and Yard Waste Collection Work Plan Republic Services submits an annual work plan outlining key priorities for system improvements, including customer service improvements based on the net promoter scores, household audits (as needed), and proposed improvements to the Spring Clean-Up and Fall Clean-Up Campaigns. The work plan will be incorporated into the trash and yard waste contract by reference once it is approved by the City. 1.Curbside Organics Collection: Ramsey and Washington Counties are rolling out curbside organics (food scraps) collection in late 2022/early 2023. Food scraps will be collected from residents using durable compostable bags (food scraps bags) that will be co-collected with trash. Bags and program participation will be free to residents in single and multi-family homes in both counties. Robotic sorting technology will be used to separate the bags from the trash at the Ramsey/Washington Recycling and Energy Center. Maplewood’s trash collection will remain the same when the new program begins. However, there may be some logistical arrangements that need to made by Republic Services in preparation of the curbside organics collection. Republic Services shall work with City and County staff in 2022 to create a plan to roll out the program to Maplewood residents. 2.Trash Hauling Audit: Republic Services will conduct an audit of the following trash hauling numbers: a.Households: A household audit was complete for the City’s recycling program in 2021. The City will share the household audit with Republic Services for comparison to the trash program household count. b.Opt Outs: Review and report on the number of households that have permanently opted out of the City’s trash program. The opt outs must have been approved by the City, with verification the residents are disposing of their trash in an environmentally responsible manner per City code. This number will be compared to the City’s list of opt outs. c.Walk Ups: Review and report on the number of walk ups serviced in the City. This number will be compared to the City’s list of walk ups. d.Opt Ins: Review and report on the number of townhomes or manufactured homes that have opted into the City’s trash program. This number will be compared to the City’s list of opt ins. DRAFT 3-17-22 3.Townhome and Manufactured Home Opt Ins: Work with the City to conduct outreach to all townhomes and manufactured homes that have not opted into the City’s trash program. Outreach to include information on opting into the City’s trash program. 4.Yearly Reports:Update yearly reports to include the following items: a.Summary of how the previous years’ work plan items were addressed. b.Size of carts submitted for warranty. c.Reason for warranty submittal. d.Credits received in dollar amount for each size cart. 5.City Facilities: As part of the new trash and yard waste collection contract, Republic Services collects trash and organics at City facilities at no cost. Republic Services and the City will identify the number and size of existing trash and organics containers at City facilities. This list will be used to right-size the number and size of containers to ensure adequate collection of trash and organics at City facilities. 6.Billing: By the end of 2022, Republic Services will transition the City’s bi-monthly trash program billing cycle to begin at the first of the year. This will allow the yearly trash rate changes to be on the January/February bill, rather than both year’s rates on the December/January bill. This has historically caused customer confusion and generates calls to the City and Republic Services. 7.N et Promoter Score/Customer Service Improvements: Republic Services manages the City’s customer service for the trash program through a national call center. To ensure residents receive accurate information and good customer service, the contract requires Republic Services supply details on the number of calls, speed to answer, call abandonment, average call handle time, and net promoter score (index ranging from -100 to 100 that measures the willingness of customers to recommend a company). The 2021 Year-End Report shows Republic Services’ net promoter at 31. This is an increase over the 2020 net promotor score of 19.2, and is a difference of 19.3 from the 2019 benchmark of 11.7. While this shows customer service improvement, the Customer Service Phone Call section of the Year End Trash Service Report reflects improvements needed in hold times. Republic Services handles an average of 3,448 Maplewood trash program calls monthly. Hold times range from 23 seconds up to 10 minutes 43 seconds with call abandonments ranging from 209 to 2,208. Republic Services shall submit a report to the City showing how the customer service experience can be improved with reduced hold times. 2