Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-07-09 City Council Workshop Packet PLEASENOTESTARTTIME PLEASENOTESTARTTIME AGENDA MAPLEWOOD CITY COUNCIL MANAGER WORKSHOP 5:30P.M. Monday,July 09, 2018 City Hall, Council Chambers A.CALL TO ORDER B.ROLL CALL C.APPROVAL OF AGENDA D.UNFINISHED BUSINESS None E.NEW BUSINESS 1.Street Conditions and Asset Management Discussion 2.Capital Improvement Plan 2019-2023 Overview F.ADJOURNMENT RULES OF CIVILITY FOR THE CITY COUNCIL, BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND OUR COMMUNITY Following are rules of civility the City of Maplewood expects of everyone appearing at Council Meetings - elected officials, staff and citizens. It is hoped that by following these simple rules, everyone’s opinions can be heard and understood in a reasonable manner. We appreciate the fact that when appearing at Council meetings, it is understood that everyone will follow these principles: Speak only for yourself, not for other council members or citizens -unless specifically tasked by your colleagues to speak for the group or for citizens in the form of a petition. Show respect during comments and/or discussions, listen actively and do not interrupt or talk amongst each other. Be respectful of the process, keeping order and decorum. Do not be critical of council members, staff or others in public. Be respectful of each other’s time keeping remarks brief, to the point and non-repetitive. THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK E1 CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT Meeting Date July 9, 2018 REPORT TO:Melinda Coleman, City Manager REPORT FROM: Steven Love, Public Works Director / City Engineer PRESENTER: Steven Love Street Conditions and Asset Management Discussion AGENDA ITEM: Action Requested: Motion Discussion Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution Ordinance Contract/Agreement Proclamation Policy Issue: At tonight’s workshop, staff will be presenting on the current conditions of City streets and providing an overview of the City’s asset management program. Recommended Action: No formal action is required or requested. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No Yes, the true or estimated cost is $0.00 Financing source(s): Adopted Budget Budget Modification New Revenue Source Use of Reserves Other: N/A Strategic Plan Relevance: Financial Sustainability Integrated Communication Targeted Redevelopment Operational Effectiveness Community Inclusiveness Infrastructure & Asset Mgmt. City streets are one of the most important assets that Public Works Department manages and the conditions of the streets have a direct effect on the quality of life for Maplewood residents. Background The City of Maplewood has approximately 135 miles of roads. Tonight staff will be giving a presentation on the current conditions of City streets, which streets are rated in the worst conditions, what areas are included in the draft Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) plan, a review of the work that has been done since 2000, and how we are managing our assets in Cartegraph. Attached to this report is a map showing the current CIP projects being constructed this year and the location of proposed CIP projects that are included in the 1- year draft CIP, a copy of the one page information sheet on franchise fees, and a one page information sheet on street conditions in the City of Maplewood. Workshop Packet Page Number 1 of 69 E1 Staff previously gave presentations on the proposed franchise fee rate increases to the City Council at the April 9, 2018 and May 14, 2018 City Council Workshops. A public hearing was held at the July 25, 2018 council meeting to gather resident input on the proposed changes to gas and electrical franchise fees. The proposed changes to the rates will be brought back to council for their consideration at a future council meeting. Attachments 1. Draft 10 Year CIP Map 2. Franchise Fee Fact Sheet 3. Maplewood’s Street Repair Plan Fact Sheet Workshop Packet Page Number 2 of 69 E1, Attachment 1 Workshop Packet Page Number 3 of 69 E1, Attachment 2 Workshop Packet Page Number 4 of 69 E1, Attachment Workshop Packet Page Number 5 of 69 E1, Attachment Maplewood’s Street Repair Plan Did you know? Current Street Conditions: Maplewood of Maplewood streets are in good or excellent condition. 60% of streets are in fair condition. has 135 miles 14% of roads to maintain? of streets need immediate repair or are nearing life expectancy. 26% Repairs based on 5-year Capital Improvement Plan (CIP): •Ensures best budgeting and construction planning •New projects are added annually To see a the entire list of Captial Improvement Plan projects. visit - maplewoodmn.gov/CIP How the City schedules projects: Physically survey Evaluate citizen Project Cost and Project’s placement 1/3 of city streets complaintsfunding sourcesin the 5-year plan annually ++= Partnership Capital Improvement Pavement condition Gathered online, at Opportunities Plan index rating assigned meetings & in person Funding Repairs: Comparison of Existing and Proposed Financing Plans: 6% 18% 17% 18% 27% CurrentNew 16% PlanPlan 34%34% 15%15% Special AssessmentsLong-Term Debt Utility FundsFranchise Fee Intergovermental Revenue More Emphasis on pay-as-you-go: •Cuts long-term borrowing from about 27% to 16% of project; lessens demand on property taxes. •Boosts up front funding from 6% to 17%; minimal gas/electric franchise increase They’re not all Maplewood Roads: Some roads running through Maplewood, like White Bear Avenue or Century and Larpenteur Avenues, are owned by the State or County, who have jurisdiction over their repair. To see a map of who maintains the roadways in Maplewood, head to - maplewoodmn.gov/roadways Workshop Packet Page Number 6 of 69 E2 CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP STAFF REPORT Meeting Date July 9, 2018 REPORT TO:Melinda Coleman REPORT FROM: Ellen Paulseth, Finance Director PRESENTER: Ellen Paulseth, Finance Director Capital Improvement Plan 2019-2023 Workshop AGENDA ITEM: Action Requested: Motion Discussion Public Hearing Form of Action: Resolution Ordinance Contract/Agreement Proclamation Policy Issue: The Capital Improvement Plan is prepared annually. It coordinates the planning, financing and timing of major equipment purchases and construction projects. The City Council will consider the adoption of the CIP along with the 2019 budget in December. This timeframe aligns the CIP process with the annual budget process and allows for changes throughout the process. Adopting the CIP does not commit the council to the proposed projects. Recommended Action: No action required at this time. This item is for discussion only. Council members should consider how they wish to prioritize projects contained in the plan and which projects will be appropriated for the 2019 budget year. Projects proposed for 2019 are highlighted in an attachment. Fiscal Impact: Is There a Fiscal Impact? No Yes, the true or estimated cost is $64,059,471 Financing source(s): Adopted Budget Budget Modification New Revenue Source Use of Reserves Other: n/a Strategic Plan Relevance: Financial Sustainability Integrated Communication Targeted Redevelopment Operational Effectiveness Community Inclusiveness Infrastructure & Asset Mgmt. An analysis of projected debt is included in the attachment, indicating the City’s ability to accomplish the recommended projects within the framework of the City’s existing debt policy. Background The plan will be reviewed by the Planning Commission and a public hearing on the CIP will be held th at the Planning Commission meeting on July 17 at 7:00 PM. The final CIP document will be completed throughout the 2019 budget process. The CIP will be available on the City’s webpage. Workshop Packet Page Number 7 of 69 E2 Attachments 1. List of Projects by Category 2019-2023 2. List of Projects by Funding Source 2019-2023 3. List of Capital Improvement Projects Scheduled for 2019 4. Project Detail for 2019 Projects 5. PowerPoint Workshop Packet Page Number 8 of 69 E2, Attachment 1 City of Maplewood, Minnesota Capital Improvement Plan 20192023 thru PROJECTS BY CATEGORY CategoryProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total Buildings Rehabilitation of Fire Station #3 Hazelwood2FD19.056,700,000 6,700,000 Municipal Facility Upgrades3MT16.01100,000100,000 1902 Building Mechanical Updates3MT17.05269,000 269,000 1902 Building Roof3MT17.06410,000410,000 City Hall/Police Department Emergency Generator3MT18.0169,000 69,000 1902 A/C Replacement3MT18.0265,00065,000 Maplewood Nature Center Improvements3PM18.01200,000 200,000 469,0007,110,000134,000100,0007,813,000 Buildings Total Equipment Fire Fighting Turn Out Gear1FD19.0192,000 92,000 Replacement of EMS Cardiac Monitors1FD19.010210,000210,000 Ambulance Replacement1FD19.011255,000272,000 527,000 Replacement of Fire Truck2FD19.02665,000665,000 Replacement of Ladder TruckFD19.032945,000 945,000 Replacement of Police & Fire 800 MHZ RadiosFD19.07179,90081,50083,20084,90084,900414,400 999,90081,50083,2001,301,900386,9002,853,400 Equipment Total Equipment: Computers Eden System replacement2IT15.020250,000250,000 Server Storage2IT16.01060,000 60,000 310,000 250,00060,000 Equipment: Computers Total Equipment: PW Equip Water Tanker2PW15.02110,000 110,000 Street Sweeper3PW16.02210,000210,000 ToolCat Work Machine3PW16.0358,000 58,000 Three Tilt-Deck Trailers3PW16.0530,00030,000 Tractor/Utility Machine3PW17.0175,000 75,000 16' Park Mower3PW17.0290,00090,000 Asphalt Paver2PW17.0556,000 56,000 629,000 163,000210,000256,000 Equipment: PW Equip Total Park Improvements Park Upgrades to Existing Parks3PM07.010100,000100,000110,000110,000120,000 540,000 Open Space Improvements3PM08.060150,00025,00025,000250,00025,000475,000 Goodrich Park3PM11.020500,000 500,000 Harvest Park3PM14.020300,000300,000 EAB Ash Removal and Planting1PM15.020100,000150,000150,000150,000150,000 700,000 Park Maintenance and Re-Investment3PM16.0011,000,0001,000,000 Maplewood Nature Center Land AcquisitionPM16.0043300,000 300,000 Workshop Packet Page Number 9 of 69 E2, Attachment 1 CategoryProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total Fish Creek Open Space3PM16.005250,000250,000 Picnic Shelters in Maplewood Area Neighborhoods3PM18.03250,000250,000 Hazelwood Park2PM19.0150,000500,000 550,000 Wakefield Park Playground2PM19.02250,000 250,000 650,0001,275,000535,0001,810,000845,0005,115,000 Park Improvements Total Redevelopment Housing Replacement Program2CD02.01100,000300,000 400,000 Gladstone Area Redevelopment1CD15.012,000,0001,000,0001,000,0004,000,000 2,100,000300,0001,000,0001,000,0004,400,000 Redevelopment Total Street Construction Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1PW09.10100,0005,930,0006,030,000 Sterling Street Bridge Replacement1PW12.02100,0001,300,000 1,400,000 White Bear Ave / I694 Interchange ProjectPW15.082500,000500,000 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street ImprovementsPW15.1113,320,000 3,320,000 Rice StreetPW16.062200,000200,000 Mailand/Crestview Forest Area PavementPW16.1011,280,000 1,280,000 Schaller Area PavementPW16.11160,0001,490,0001,550,000 Southcrest/Ferndale Area PavementPW17.06160,0001,600,000 1,660,000 East Shore Drive Area Street ImprovementsPW17.081100,0004,880,0004,980,000 Cope/McMenemy Street ImprovementsPW18.011100,0007,050,000 7,150,000 Gervais Area PavementPW18.02160,0001,500,0001,560,000 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street ImprovementsPW18.0313,300,000 3,300,000 Montana/Nebraska Area PavementPW18.111100,00060,0001,670,0001,830,000 Roselawn & Edgerton Intersection ImprovementsPW18.121955,000955,000 NSP Lake BoulevardPW18.39n/a175,000 175,000 Prosperity Road Street ImprovementsPW19.091100,0003,670,000 3,770,000 McKnight Traffic Signal ReplacementPW19.101129,500129,500 39,789,500 9,419,5009,180,0006,700,00010,820,0003,670,000 Street Construction Total Utilities Lift Station Upgrade Program2PW03.2120,00020,00020,00020,00020,000 100,000 Pond Clean Out/Dredging Projects3PW14.01100,000100,000100,000300,000 120,00020,000120,00020,000120,000400,000 Utilities Total Vehicles Replacement of Grass Truck2FD19.0665,00065,000 Squad Replacement1PD18.010185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000 940,000 Single-Axle Plow Truck2PW13.03222,571 222,571 Single-Axle Plow Truck2PW15.01220,000220,000 1 1/2-Ton Utility Truck3PW17.0390,000 90,000 Single-Axle Plow TruckPW17.042230,000230,000 One 3/4 Ton TruckPW18.13245,00045,000 One 1/2 Ton TruckPW18.14226,00026,000 One Single Axle Plow TruckPW18.152240,000 240,000 One 1-Ton Utility Sign TruckPW18.16260,00060,000 One 3/4 Ton VanPW18.17225,00025,000 One 1 1/2 Ton TruckPW18.18290,000 90,000 One 10,000lb Capacity TrailerPW18.19219,00019,000 Two Asphalt RollersPW18.20270,000 70,000 One Tandem Axle Plow TruckPW19.012245,000245,000 One 1 1/2 Ton Dump TruckPW19.02280,000 80,000 Workshop Packet Page Number 10 of 69 E2, Attachment 1 CategoryProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total One 1/2 Ton Truck2PW19.0327,00027,000 One T650 Skid Steer2PW19.0455,00055,000 717,571405,000280,000582,000765,0002,749,571 Vehicles Total 14,888,97118,641,5009,108,20014,533,9006,886,90064,059,471 GRAND TOTAL Workshop Packet Page Number 11 of 69 E2, Attachment 2 City of Maplewood, Minnesota Capital Improvement Plan 20192023 thru PROJECTS BY FUNDING SOURCE SourceProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total Ambulance Fund Replacement of EMS Cardiac Monitors1210,000 FD19.010210,000 Ambulance Replacement1FD19.011255,000272,000527,000 737,000 255,000272,000210,000 Ambulance Fund Total Bonds GO CIP Rehabilitation of Fire Station #3 Hazelwood2FD19.052,700,0002,700,000 2,700,000 2,700,000 Bonds GO CIP Total Bonds GO Improvement Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1100,0002,157,500 PW09.102,257,500 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street Improvements11,629,310 PW15.111,629,310 East Shore Drive Area Street Improvements1100,0001,977,200 PW17.082,077,200 Cope/McMenemy Street Improvements1100,0003,246,860 PW18.013,346,860 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street ImprovementsPW18.031659,600659,600 Prosperity Road Street ImprovementsPW19.091100,0001,146,0001,246,000 11,216,470 2,388,9102,257,5002,077,2003,346,8601,146,000 Bonds GO Improvement Total Bonds GO Special Assessment Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1PW09.101,010,5001,010,500 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street Improvements1524,790 PW15.11524,790 Mailand/Crestview Forest Area Pavement1607,890 PW16.10607,890 Schaller Area Pavement1793,500 PW16.11793,500 Southcrest/Ferndale Area Pavement1724,500 PW17.06724,500 East Shore Drive Area Street Improvements1693,400 PW17.08693,400 Cope/McMenemy Street Improvements11,145,540 PW18.011,145,540 Gervais Area PavementPW18.0211,111,4521,111,452 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street ImprovementsPW18.031218,400218,400 Montana/Nebraska Area PavementPW18.111896,828896,828 Prosperity Road Street ImprovementsPW19.091432,000432,000 8,158,800 1,351,0801,804,0001,417,9003,153,820432,000 Bonds GO Special Assessment Total Bonds MSA Sterling Street Bridge Replacement1PW12.02100,000115,000215,000 100,000115,000215,000 Bonds MSA Total Bonds Tax Abatement Park Maintenance and Re-Investment3PM16.0011,000,0001,000,000 Workshop Packet Page Number 12 of 69 E2, Attachment 2 SourceProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total 1,000,0001,000,000 Bonds Tax Abatement Total Bonds Tax Increment Gladstone Area Redevelopment12,000,0001,000,0001,000,000 CD15.014,000,000 2,000,0001,000,0001,000,0004,000,000 Bonds Tax Increment Total Building Replacement Fund Municipal Facility Upgrades3MT16.01100,000100,000 100,000 100,000 Building Replacement Fund Total CIP Fund Replacement of Police & Fire 800 MHZ Radios179,90081,50083,20084,90084,900 FD19.07414,400 City Hall/Police Department Emergency Generator369,000 MT18.0169,000 1902 A/C Replacement365,000 MT18.0265,000 Park Upgrades to Existing Parks3100,000100,000110,000110,000120,000 PM07.010540,000 EAB Ash Removal and PlantingPM15.0201100,000150,000150,000150,000150,000700,000 1,788,400 279,900331,500477,200344,900354,900 CIP Fund Total City of St. Paul Water Dept Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1PW09.10742,000742,000 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street Improvements1PW15.1196,90096,900 East Shore Drive Area Street Improvements1PW17.08306,400306,400 Cope/McMenemy Street ImprovementsPW18.011783,600783,600 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street Improvements1333,000 PW18.03333,000 Prosperity Road Street Improvements1431,000 PW19.09431,000 429,900742,000306,400783,600431,0002,692,900 City of St. Paul Water Dept Total Environmental Utility Fund Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1PW09.101,355,0001,355,000 Pond Clean Out/Dredging Projects3PW14.01100,000100,000100,000300,000 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street Improvements1PW15.11710,600710,600 Mailand/Crestview Forest Area Pavement1PW16.1067,00067,000 Schaller Area Pavement1PW16.1177,50077,500 Southcrest/Ferndale Area Pavement1PW17.0683,00083,000 East Shore Drive Area Street Improvements1PW17.081,144,0001,144,000 Cope/McMenemy Street Improvements1982,000 PW18.01982,000 Gervais Area Pavement178,000 PW18.0278,000 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street Improvements1606,000 PW18.03606,000 Montana/Nebraska Area Pavement1100,000186,500 PW18.11286,500 Prosperity Road Street Improvements1788,000 PW19.09788,000 1,483,6001,532,5001,327,0001,246,500888,0006,477,600 Environmental Utility Fund Total Federal Grants Roselawn & Edgerton Intersection Improvements1PW18.12679,500679,500 679,500 679,500 Federal Grants Total Workshop Packet Page Number 13 of 69 E2, Attachment 2 SourceProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total Fire Equipment Fund Fire Fighting Turn Out Gear1FD19.0192,00092,000 Replacement of Fire TruckFD19.022665,000665,000 Replacement of Ladder TruckFD19.032945,000945,000 Rehabilitation of Fire Station #3 HazelwoodFD19.0521,000,0001,000,000 Replacement of Grass Truck265,000 FD19.0665,000 730,0001,000,000945,00092,0002,767,000 Fire Equipment Fund Total Fleet Management Fund Single-Axle Plow Truck2222,571 PW13.03222,571 Single-Axle Plow Truck2PW15.01220,000220,000 Water TankerPW15.022110,000110,000 Street SweeperPW16.023210,000210,000 ToolCat Work MachinePW16.03358,00058,000 Three Tilt-Deck TrailersPW16.05330,00030,000 Tractor/Utility MachinePW17.01375,00075,000 16' Park MowerPW17.02390,00090,000 1 1/2-Ton Utility Truck390,000 PW17.0390,000 Single-Axle Plow Truck2230,000 PW17.04230,000 Asphalt Paver256,000 PW17.0556,000 One 3/4 Ton Truck245,000 PW18.1345,000 One 1/2 Ton Truck226,000 PW18.1426,000 One Single Axle Plow Truck2240,000 PW18.15240,000 One 1-Ton Utility Sign TruckPW18.16260,00060,000 One 3/4 Ton VanPW18.17225,00025,000 One 1 1/2 Ton TruckPW18.18290,00090,000 One 10,000lb Capacity TrailerPW18.19219,00019,000 Two Asphalt RollersPW18.20270,00070,000 One Tandem Axle Plow TruckPW19.012245,000245,000 One 1 1/2 Ton Dump TruckPW19.02280,00080,000 One 1/2 Ton TruckPW19.03227,00027,000 One T650 Skid Steer255,000 PW19.0455,000 630,571430,000346,000392,000575,0002,373,571 Fleet Management Fund Total Gas Franchise Fee Mailand/Crestview Forest Area Pavement1524,710 PW16.10524,710 Schaller Area Pavement160,000526,000 PW16.11586,000 Southcrest/Ferndale Area Pavement160,000692,900 PW17.06752,900 Gervais Area Pavement160,000216,948 PW18.02276,948 Montana/Nebraska Area Pavement1PW18.1160,000482,872542,872 Prosperity Road Street Improvements1PW19.09375,000375,000 3,058,430 584,710586,000812,900699,820375,000 Gas Franchise Fee Total IT Fund Eden System replacement2IT15.020250,000250,000 Server Storage260,000 IT16.01060,000 250,00060,000310,000 IT Fund Total Local Government Aid Workshop Packet Page Number 14 of 69 E2, Attachment 2 SourceProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total Housing Replacement Program2CD02.01100,000300,000400,000 1902 Building Mechanical Updates3269,000 MT17.05269,000 1902 Building Roof3410,000 MT17.06410,000 Roselawn & Edgerton Intersection Improvements1137,750 PW18.12137,750 NSP Lake Boulevardn/a175,000 PW18.39175,000 681,750710,0001,391,750 Local Government Aid Total Municipal State Aid White Bear Ave / I694 Interchange ProjectPW15.082500,000500,000 Rice StreetPW16.062200,000200,000 700,000 200,000500,000 Municipal State Aid Total Park Improvement Fund Open Space Improvements3150,00025,00025,000250,00025,000 PM08.060475,000 Goodrich Park3500,000 PM11.020500,000 Harvest Park3300,000 PM14.020300,000 Maplewood Nature Center Land Acquisition3300,000 PM16.004300,000 Fish Creek Open SpacePM16.0053125,000125,000 Maplewood Nature Center ImprovementsPM18.013200,000200,000 Picnic Shelters in Maplewood Area NeighborhoodsPM18.033250,000250,000 Hazelwood ParkPM19.01250,000450,000500,000 Wakefield Park PlaygroundPM19.022250,000250,000 2,900,000 650,000975,000150,000550,000575,000 Park Improvement Fund Total Police Equipment Fund Squad Replacement1185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000 PD18.010940,000 185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000940,000 Police Equipment Fund Total Proceeds from Sale Property Rehabilitation of Fire Station #3 Hazelwood2FD19.053,000,0003,000,000 3,000,000 3,000,000 Proceeds from Sale Property Total Ramsey County Fish Creek Open Space3PM16.005125,000125,000 Roselawn & Edgerton Intersection Improvements1137,750 PW18.12137,750 137,750125,000262,750 Ramsey County Total Sanitary Sewer Fund Lift Station Upgrade Program2PW03.2120,00020,00020,00020,00020,000100,000 Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1PW09.10414,000414,000 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street ImprovementsPW15.111261,500261,500 Mailand/Crestview Forest Area PavementPW16.10140,20040,200 Schaller Area PavementPW16.11146,50046,500 Southcrest/Ferndale Area PavementPW17.06149,80049,800 East Shore Drive Area Street ImprovementsPW17.081484,000484,000 Cope/McMenemy Street ImprovementsPW18.011563,000563,000 Workshop Packet Page Number 15 of 69 E2, Attachment 2 SourceProject #Priority20192020202120222023Total Gervais Area Pavement1PW18.0246,80046,800 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street Improvements1298,000 PW18.03298,000 Montana/Nebraska Area Pavement151,900 PW18.1151,900 Prosperity Road Street Improvements1353,000 PW19.09353,000 619,700480,500553,800681,700373,0002,708,700 Sanitary Sewer Fund Total State Grants Sterling Street Bridge Replacement1PW12.021,185,0001,185,000 1,185,000 1,185,000 State Grants Total Street Light Fund McKnight Traffic Signal Replacement1PW19.10129,500129,500 129,500129,500 Street Light Fund Total Water - WAC Fund Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements1PW09.10251,000251,000 Ferndale/Ivy Area Street ImprovementsPW15.11196,90096,900 Mailand/Crestview Forest Area PavementPW16.10140,20040,200 Schaller Area PavementPW16.11146,50046,500 Southcrest/Ferndale Area PavementPW17.06149,80049,800 East Shore Drive Area Street ImprovementsPW17.081275,000275,000 Cope/McMenemy Street ImprovementsPW18.011329,000329,000 Gervais Area Pavement146,800 PW18.0246,800 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street Improvements1117,000 PW18.03117,000 Montana/Nebraska Area Pavement151,900 PW18.1151,900 Prosperity Road Street Improvements1145,000 PW19.09145,000 254,100297,500324,800427,700145,0001,449,100 Water - WAC Fund Total Watershed District Hazelwood Park2PM19.0150,00050,000 Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street Improvements1PW18.031,068,0001,068,000 1,068,00050,0001,118,000 Watershed District Total 64,059,471 14,888,97118,641,5009,108,20014,533,9006,886,900 GRAND TOTAL Workshop Packet Page Number 16 of 69 E2, Attachment 3 Capital Improvement Projects Scheduled for 2019 PAGEDEPARTMENTPROJECTPROJECT TITLECOST 1AmbulanceFD19.011Ambulance Replacement255,000 2Buildin g MaintenanceMT17.051902 Building Mechanical Updates269,000 3Community DevelopmentCD02.01Housing Replacement Program100,000 4Communit y DevelopmentCD15.01Gladstone Area Redevelopment2,000,000 5Fire DepartmentFD19.02Fire Truck Replacement665,000 6Fire DepartmentFD19.06Grass Truck Replacement65,000 7Fire DepartmentFD19.07Police & Fire 800 MHz Radios Replacement79,900 8Information TechIT15.020Eden System Replacement250,000 9ParksPM07.010Park Upgrades to Existing Parks100,000 10ParksPM08.060Open Space Improvements150,000 11ParksPM15.020EAB Ash Removal & Planting100,000 12ParksPM18.01Maplewood Nature Center Improvements200,000 13ParksPM19.01Hazelwood Park Improvements50,000 14ParksPM19.02Wakefield Park Playground250,000 15PolicePM18.010Squad Replacaements185,000 16Public WorksPW03.21Lift Station Upgrades20,000 17Public WorksPW13.03Single Axle Plow Truck Replacement222,571 18Public WorksPW14.01Pond Clean Out/Dredging100,000 19Public WorksPW16.03Tool Cat Work Machine Replacement58,000 20Public WorksPW16.05Three Tilt Deck Trailers Replacement30,000 21Public WorksPW17.01Tractor/Utility Machine Replacaement75,000 22Public WorksPW19.01Tandem Axle Plow Truck Replacement245,000 23Street ImprovementsPW09.10Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements100,000 24Street ImprovementsPW12.02Sterling Street Bridge Replacement100,000 25Street ImprovementsPW15.11Ferndale/Ivy Street Improvements3,320,000 26Street ImprovementsPW16.10Mailand/Crestview Forest Area Pavement1,280,000 27Street ImprovementsPW16.11Schaller Area Pavement60,000 28Street ImprovementsPW18.03Gladstone Area Phase 3 Improvements3,300,000 29Street ImprovementsPW18.12Roselawn & Edgerton Intersection Improvements955,000 30Street ImprovementsPW18.39NSP Lake Boulevard Joint Project175,000 31Street ImprovementsPW19.10McKnight Traffic Signal Replacement129,500 Total CIP Projects Year 201914,888,971 Workshop Packet Page Number 17 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood, Minnesota Project # FD19.011 Project Name Ambulance Replacement Ambulance Department Equipment Type 5 yearsEMS Chief Useful LifeContact Equipment Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$1,372,000 Description 2019- To replace the 2000 ambulance with projected mileage in excess of 125,000 2022 - Tol replace the 2014 ambulance with projected mileage in excess of 125,000. 2024 - To replace the 2017 ambulance with projected mileage in excess of 125,000. 2025 - To replace the 2017 ambulance with projected mileage in excess of 125,000 Justification The purchase of this new ambulance will ensure that our fleet technology is consistent and meets the current healthcare needs of the community while providing enhanced safety for staff. These purchases will eliminate ambulances that are over 8 years old from our fleet and will ensure that our replacement schedule follows a cycle that does not extend ambulances beyond their useful life. We will continue to utilize three primary ambulances and one spare, primary ambulances average 20-30 thousand miles per year. Having a 5-year replacement schedule will place ambulances into reserve status once they are at least 5-years old and have an excess of 100,000 miles. This plan will ensure that the age and condition of our ambulances does not create excessive out-of-service time and maintenance costs. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 845,000 Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 255,000272,000527,000 255,000272,000527,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 845,000 Ambulance Fund 255,000272,000527,000 255,000272,000527,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other Having an ambulance replacement cycle of 5 years will help keep maintenance and operating costs level over the operating period. The cost of maintenance and operating starts to clim significantly each year after 5 years. 1 Workshop Packet Page Number 18 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # MT17.05 Project Name 1902 Building Mechanical Updates Building Maintenance Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Buildings Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$269,000 Description 1902 Building HVAC upgrades. Justification The roof mounted AHU system is recommended for renewal. The AHU system includes heating coils, cooling coils, and a VAV distribution system. The system ensures proper air flow and reliability to the work environment. The AHU unit has been recommended for renewal per the Asset Management study for 2020. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Construction/Maintenance 269,000269,000 269,000269,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Local Government Aid 269,000269,000 269,000269,000 Total Budget Impact/Other We anticipate increased efficiencies with the new mechanical system, resulting in a positive impact on the operating budget. 2 Workshop Packet Page Number 19 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # CD02.01 Project Name Housing Replacement Program EEDD Department Improvement Type EEDD Director Useful LifeContact Redevelopment Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$1,100,000 Description The purchase of vacant or dilapidated properties to then prepare sites for new housing is proposed for 2018 and 2020. Justification The primary purpose of the Housing Replacement Program is to prevent neighborhoods from deteriorating. If a single dwelling deteriorates to the point of becoming a detriment or an eyesore, it will have an affect on the surrounding area. Other property owners may not be motivated to care for or to improve their properties if they live near or next to a rundown house. With this in mind, the city council established the Housing Replacement Program. The city council also has adopted policy guidelines that set standards for the purchase and resale of these properties. The cost estimate is based on the premise of purchasing a minimum of one property every other year until the goals of the program change. The city is currently updating its comprehensive plan which will incorporate the housing policy requirements directed from the Metropolitan Council and also the housing policy goals established by the Maplewood City Council. This CUP expenditure is reflected to match those expected policy goals. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 700,000 Construction/Maintenance 100,000300,000400,000 100,000300,000400,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 700,000 Local Government Aid 100,000300,000400,000 100,000300,000400,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other There will be no direct impact on the operating budget. However, this program is designed to improve the tax base in the City, which could potentially lower property taxes. 3 Workshop Packet Page Number 20 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # CD15.01 Project Name Gladstone Area Redevelopment EEDD Department Improvement Type EEDD Director Useful LifeContact Redevelopment Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$6,000,000 Description Specific properties in the Gladstone area will be identified and the City may facilitate the acquistion and redevelopment of the properties in accordance with the approved Gladstone Master Plan and the City's Comprehensive Plan. Justification The development of the Gladstone is underway. Phase 1 and Phase 2 street, landscape and roadway improvements have been completed. Plans are underway for Phase 3 public improvements beginning in 2023. The Shores senior housing project on Phalen Place was constructed in 2012 and 50 future units are to be completed in the near future. In addition, redevelopment occurred in 2015 on the former Maplewood Bowl site, resulting in 50 affordable and 107 market-rate senior housing. The final phase will include funding for the acquisition of property for redevelopment. Specific properties will be identified and the City may act as developer or in agreement with a private developer to acquire and demolish existing buildings and property for development in accordance with the approved Gladstone Master Plan and the City's Comprehensive Plan. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 2,000,000 Land Acquisition 2,000,0001,000,0001,000,0004,000,000 2,000,0001,000,0001,000,0004,000,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 2,000,000 Bonds Tax Increment 2,000,0001,000,0001,000,0004,000,000 2,000,0001,000,0001,000,0004,000,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other There will be no direct impact on the operating budget. However, this program is designed to improve the tax base in the City, which could potentially lower property taxes. 4 Workshop Packet Page Number 21 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # FD19.02 Project Name Replacement of Fire Truck Fire Department Department Equipment Type 12 yearsFire Chief Useful LifeContact Equipment Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$665,000 Description 1500 GPM Fire Truck Justification This truck will replace a 2000 fire truck that has significant rust issues and ongoing maintenance costs. The goal of our replacement program for fire trucks is to have all first line pumpers replaced every 20 years. The new engine will have the additional space as well as have the capabilities of doing the function of both rescue and fire suppression. It will also be foam capable. At the time of replacement, this truck will be 19 years old. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 665,000665,000 665,000665,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fire Equipment Fund 665,000665,000 665,000665,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positvie impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. The truck will be purchased with a Tax Exempt Master Lease Agreement through the Government Leasing Program with a 12-year amortization period. 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 22 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # FD19.06 Project Name Replacement of Grass Truck Fire Department Department Equipment Type 15 yearsFire Chief Useful LifeContact Vehicles Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$65,000 Description The grass truck will provide the department the capability of fighting grass fires and other types of off-road fires. The current grass truck is a 1992 Ford 1-ton 4WD pickup, with a skid load pump and water tank in the back of the truck. The truck and tank pump system, at the time of replacement will be 29 years old.. Justification Both the vehicle and the water tank are severely rusted and in need of repairs. It is not cost effectrive to make the necessary repairs due to the age of both pieces of equipment. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 65,00065,000 65,00065,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fire Equipment Fund 65,00065,000 65,00065,000 Total Budget Impact/Other We anticipate lower operating and maintenance costs. Budget Items20192020202120222023Total Maintenance -2,500-1,000-1,000-1,000-1,000-6,500 -2,500-1,000-1,000-1,000-1,000-6,500 Total 6 Workshop Packet Page Number 23 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # FD19.07 Project Name Replacement of Police & Fire 800 MHZ Radios Fire Department Department Equipment Type 10 years Useful LifeContact Equipment Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$754,000 Description 800 MHz Mobile and Portable Radios Justification In 2007, all public safety agencies within Ramsey County moved from the old UHF VHF radio system to the new 800 MHz system. This new system provided interoperability between all public safety disciplines and improved total state communications. Moving to the new system required a total replacement of all existing radio devices within Ramsey County. Through a grant process at the time, Ramsey County was able to replace all existing radios within Ramsey County used by public safety disciplines. There was no cost to the city of Maplewood for this replacement. Starting in 2015, those radios purchased back in 2007 were no longer supported by manufacturer which in turn will require us to purchase newer models. Currently within the city of Maplewood's public safety, we have 265 radios. We are trying to reduce that number, at an average cost of $3,500 per radio. Starting in 2016, we started replacing about 10 of these a year as needed. The technology has not changed, we just won't be able to get the current radios repaired as they begin to break down. We will continue to look for grant opportunities as they become available as well as work with our neighboring departments to ensure the best possible pricing. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 339,600 Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 79,90081,50083,20084,90084,900414,400 79,90081,50083,20084,90084,900414,400 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 339,600 CIP Fund 79,90081,50083,20084,90084,900414,400 79,90081,50083,20084,90084,900414,400 Total Total Budget Impact/Other There will be no additional operating costs after the initial purchase. A maintenance plan is in place. 7 Workshop Packet Page Number 24 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # IT15.020 Project Name Eden System replacement IT Department Equipment Type 20 yearsIT Director Useful LifeContact Equipment: Computers Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$250,000 Description Replacement of portions of Eden Systems software Justification Currently we are using the application Eden Systems by Tyler Technologies to manage a variety of items within various City departments. While Eden Systems is not going away any time soon, they are not actively improving the application either. In some departments we have a need to become more mobile while also bringing resources closer to our applications/customers. This item would be to replace some modules of Eden Systems with a new application that would provide us those capabilities. In 2017 we will look at more mobile based modules for employees in the field. 2019 would be upgrading any modules left with Eden Systems. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 250,000250,000 250,000250,000 Total Funding SourcesTotal 20192020202120222023 IT Fund 250,000250,000 250,000250,000 Total Budget Impact/Other The annual maintenance agreement may increase, depending on options chosen. Impact on the operating budget will most likely be less than $5,000 annually. Budget Items20192020202120222023Total Maintenance 10,00010,00010,00010,00010,00050,000 10,00010,00010,00010,00010,00050,000 Total 8 Workshop Packet Page Number 25 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PM07.010 Project Name Park Upgrades to Existing Parks Parks and Recreation Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPark Director Useful LifeContact Park Improvements Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$1,140,000 Description Community field upgrades, equipment, fences, courts at Nebraska, Sunset, and Sherwood Parks. Justification A main theme identified by our Parks System Master Plan was “Taking care of what we have” in our aging parks system. This proposal will provide the City with resources to continue updating and/or replacing basketball and tennis courts, fields, fences and playgrounds to accomplish that goal. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 600,000 Construction/Maintenance 100,000100,000110,000110,000120,000540,000 100,000100,000110,000110,000120,000540,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 600,000 CIP Fund 100,000100,000110,000110,000120,000540,000 100,000100,000110,000110,000120,000540,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other The upgrades should not impact the operating budget, except for a sustained decrease in maintenance costs. 9 Workshop Packet Page Number 26 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PM08.060 Project Name Open Space Improvements Parks and Recreation Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPark Director Useful LifeContact Park Improvements Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$625,000 Description Provide funding for open space improvements. Justification Maplewood's Neighborhood Preserve system includes 15 preserves. Seven of the sites have maintained trails and nine sites have received major restoration or active management. The Parks System Master Plan calls for adding trails where appropriate and restoring sites to native vegetation. 2017-2018 projects include restoration projects at Prairie Farm Preserve (funded by $62,000 grant), Priory Preserve enhancements (entry, boardwalk, sitting area, restoration), and buffer improvements at Jim's Prairie. Trails will be constructed at Spoon Lake Preserve (2018 design, 2019 construction), Joy Park (2021), and Prairie Farm (2025, short section). Restoration projects are planned for 2020 and 2022. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 150,000 Construction/Maintenance 150,00025,00025,000250,00025,000475,000 150,00025,00025,000250,00025,000475,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 150,000 Park Improvement Fund 150,00025,00025,000250,00025,000475,000 150,00025,00025,000250,00025,000475,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other The improvements will require maintenance. Staff time will be allocated to future budges once the improvements are completed. 10 Workshop Packet Page Number 27 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PM15.020 Project Name EAB Ash Removal and Planting Parks and Recreation Department Improvement Type 15 yearsPark Director Useful LifeContact Park Improvements Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$1,450,000 Description Remove and Replace Ash Trees to Control the Spread of EAB. Justification Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) causes widespread decline and death of ash trees and has decimated ash populations in some states. In 2017, EAB was confirmed at two sites in Maplewood. The 2011 inventory of park and boulevard trees (does not include natural areas), found 2037 ash trees (21% of the 9563 trees). To remove and replace these ash trees at $700-$900 each would require $1,425,900-$1,833,300. In June 2011, Maplewood City Council approved a plan for managing EAB in Maplewood. The plan includes removing some ash trees before they have EAB, especially those in poor health or near existing infestations. Ash removals began in winter 2017-2018, with the Public Works crew removing over 100 ash trees. Stump grinding and tree planting will be done by contractors. As more and more ash in Maplewood succumb to EAB, we will need to hire contractors to assist with the removals as well. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 750,000 Construction/Maintenance 100,000150,000150,000150,000150,000700,000 100,000150,000150,000150,000150,000700,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 750,000 CIP Fund 100,000150,000150,000150,000150,000700,000 100,000150,000150,000150,000150,000700,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other There will be no additional impact to the operating budget once this project is completed. Tree maintenance is already incorporated into the annual operating budget. 11 Workshop Packet Page Number 28 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PM18.01 Project Name Maplewood Nature Center Improvements Parks and Recreation Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPark Director Useful LifeContact Buildings Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$300,000 Description Repairs, storage, and exhibit renovation at the Maplewood Nature Center site. Justification Maplewood Nature Center Visitor Center was built in 1978, added onto in 1994, and received major repairs and maintenance in 2017. Improvements are needed to the grounds and exhibits. 1) Replace detached storage shed with a larger storage shed (2018). 2) Replace three observation decks (2018). 3) Replace 600' boardwalk (2019). The boardwalk was constructed in 2000. It's expected useful life was 20 years, but the cables and floats have begun to show more critical deterioration and should be done prior to 2020. 4) Replace indoor exhibits (2024). Exhibits were constructed in 2004 with a useful life of 20 years. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Construction/Maintenance 200,000200,000 200,000200,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Park Improvement Fund 200,000200,000 200,000200,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other There will be no additional budget impact to the operating budget once this project is completed. Maintenance of these is already incorporated into the annual operating budget. 12 Workshop Packet Page Number 29 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PM19.01 Project Name Hazelwood Park Parks and Recreation Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPark Director Useful LifeContact Park Improvements Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$550,000 Description Creation and implementation of the Hazelwood Park Master Plan. Justification Hazelwood Park is a 50 acre park located at 1663 Co. Road C. This park is reaching its effective life cycle and many of the amenities are in poor condition. In addition, one of the major recommendations in the Parks System Master Plan is to fill the need for destination or "signature" parks. Hazelwood is home to Maplewood's largest soccer complex and is the site for the City's largest community celebration on the Fourth of July. Staff will work with residents to develop a master plan for this park in 2019 with construction to begin in 2020. Key features will include a new playground, upgraded parking, natural resources restoration, field enhancements, picnic shelter/community gathering facility with restrooms. Staff will partner with the Watershed to address water quality issues within the park and surrounding areas. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Planning/Design 50,00050,000 Construction/Maintenance 500,000500,000 50,000500,000550,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Park Improvement Fund 50,000450,000500,000 Watershed District 50,00050,000 50,000500,000550,000 Total Budget Impact/Other Equipment and facilities will require maintenance and periodic upgrades. These costs will be identified and built into the operating budget upon completion. 13 Workshop Packet Page Number 30 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PM19.02 Project Name Wakefield Park Playground Parks and Recreation Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPark Director Useful LifeContact Park Improvements Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$250,000 Description Replacement of the Wakefield Park Playround. Justification Wakefield has been identified as one of the signature parks in our Parks System Master Plan. In 2018, a multi-purpose building featuring programming space, kitchen facilities, restrooms and outdoors spaces was built, along with upgraded skating facilities and trails. The Wakefield playground is one of Maplewood's most used, is in need of replacement and will only see increased usage as a result of the other Wakefield Site Improvements. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Planning/Design 250,000250,000 250,000250,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Park Improvement Fund 250,000250,000 250,000250,000 Total Budget Impact/Other Equipment and facilities will require maintenance and periodic upgrades. These costs will be identified and built into the operating budget upon completion. 14 Workshop Packet Page Number 31 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PD18.010 Project Name Squad Replacement Police Department Department Equipment Type 4 yearsPolice Chief Useful LifeContact Vehicles Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$2,110,000 Description Each year the police department needs to replace four to six marked squad cars. The fully burdened cost of police squads is $37,000. Instead of building in an annual inflation increase, it is recognized that certain elements (e.g., light bars, push bumpers) may or may not be replaced depending on condition and servicabiltiy. The vehicles are purchased through the State Cooperative Purchasing Program. Justification In recognition that effective policing efforts require high visibility and high mobility, the department needs to maintain and invest in fleet operations. As vehicles become more efficient and as we collect and evaluate data about the best fleet resources for specific types of police work, maintaining a current and operational fleet is critical. Marked police vehicles are the primary means of responsive service delivery. At present the police department operates 26 marked squads. With the exception of two police reserve squads, a marked police car has a useful life for approximately 40 months - 100,000 to 120,000 miles.. Prior Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 185,000985,000 Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000940,000 185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000940,000 TotalTotal Total Prior Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 185,000 985,000 Police Equipment Fund 185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000940,000 185,000185,000190,000190,000190,000940,000 Total Total Total Budget Impact/Other Adhering to the appropriate replacement schedule has a positive impact on the operating budget by minimizing maintenance costs and down time. 15 Workshop Packet Page Number 32 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW03.21 Project Name Lift Station Upgrade Program Public Works Department Maintenance Type 60 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Utilities Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$200,000 Description The city has an annual program to refurbish lift stations. Justification This program involves the refurbishing of lift stations. This expenditure is a preventive maintenance expenditure to help reduce backups and failures due to emergency situations. The program includes pump rebuilds, wet well inspections and general site improvements for the nine lift stations located throughout the City. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Construction/Maintenance 20,00020,00020,00020,00020,000100,000 20,00020,00020,00020,00020,000100,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Sanitary Sewer Fund 20,00020,00020,00020,00020,000100,000 20,00020,00020,00020,00020,000100,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other The upgrade program has a positive impact on the operating budget by reducing maintenance costs. 16 Workshop Packet Page Number 33 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW13.03 Project Name Single-Axle Plow Truck Public Works Department Equipment Type 15 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Vehicles Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$222,571 Description The 2000 single-axle plow truck, Unit 538 is due for replacement in 2018. Justification The 2000 model year plow truck is due for replacement. This unit is one of eight single-axle trucks in the fleet. This truck is an intergral piece of equipment in the fleet for the street maintenance division. It is utilized year round. In summer, the truck is used for patching and paving streets. In winter, it is used every snow/ice event for treating and plowing city streets. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 222,571222,571 222,571222,571 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fleet Management Fund 222,571222,571 222,571222,571 Total Budget Impact/Other At the November 17, 2017 City Council meeting, council approved the purchase of a replacement vehicle for Unit 538. The City will accept the delivery of the new vehicle and will be invoiced in 2018. Unit 538 has an estimated trade-in value of $18,000. These funds will go back into the fleet management fund to be used towards other 2018 purchases. 17 Workshop Packet Page Number 34 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW14.01 Project Name Pond Clean Out/Dredging Projects Public Works Department Maintenance Type 50 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Utilities Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$500,000 Description Stormwater ponds, also known as wet ponds, "NURP" ponds, or retention basins, are a necessary component for land development in order to manage stormwater runoff. These basins within the city of Maplewood were typically built to control runoff rates to minimize downstream flooding and erosion. These ponds are now also viewed as a mechanism to capture and settle pollutants. Maintaining the city’s stormwater ponds requires the removal of sediment by conducting dredging projects. Justification Due to the buildup of sediment, maintenance is required to ensure these basins are providing the designed rate control and maintain their ability to improve the quality of stormwater runoff. As part of the pond maintenance program, the city has established a goal of completing at least one pond assessment every two years based on available funding and staff resources. Additionally, the city will look to capitalize on partnerships with the local watershed districts and neighboring cities that are doing similar projects. The city is required to have a pond maintenance program as part of its NPDES MS4 general permit. This program would also coordinate with our flood mitigation projects and may be used for finalizing out identified projects as a result of the July 2011 flood event if they are of a higher priority than a pond cleanout. Future Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 200,000 Construction/Maintenance 100,000100,000100,000300,000 100,000100,000100,000300,000 Total Total Future Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 200,000 Environmental Utility Fund 100,000100,000100,000300,000 100,000100,000100,000300,000 Total Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 18 Workshop Packet Page Number 35 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW16.03 Project Name ToolCat Work Machine Public Works Department Equipment Type 5 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Equipment: PW Equip Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$58,000 Description The 2011 ToolCat 5610-F, Unit 732, is due for replacement in 2019. Justification Currently, the city operates two ToolCat Work Machines. Both ToolCats are utilized year round in all three divisions of Public Works and are the primary pieces of equipment for sidewalk snow removal. The 2011 ToolCat is in need of replacement due to high engine hours and use. The machine is continuously in need of repair which makes it unreliable and no longer cost effective to operate. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 58,00058,000 58,00058,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fleet Management Fund 58,00058,000 58,00058,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 19 Workshop Packet Page Number 36 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW16.05 Project Name Three Tilt-Deck Trailers Public Works Department Equipment Type 15 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Equipment: PW Equip Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$30,000 Description Three 2001 tilt-deck trailers, Units 718, 719 and 720, are due for replacement 2019. Justification Three 2001 trailers are in need of replacement. These trailers are utilized by all maintenance divisions in Public Works. Due to structural defects caused by years of use, the trailers will no longer pass the annual D.O.T. inspections and are unsafe for use. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 30,00030,000 30,00030,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fleet Management Fund 30,00030,000 30,00030,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 20 Workshop Packet Page Number 37 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW17.01 Project Name Tractor/Utility Machine Public Works Department Equipment Type 15 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Equipment: PW Equip Category 3 Important Priority Total Project Cost:$75,000 Description The 1987 maintenance tractor, Unit 712, is due for replacement in 2019. Justification The 1987 maintenance tractor is in need of replacement due to its age and needed engine repairs that exceed the value of the tractor. This unit will be replaced with a multi-purpose machine that can be utilized by all division in Public Works to perform functions such as snow removal on trails, sidewalks, parking lots and summer maintenance including trail mowing, boulevard mowing and miscellaneous construction work throughout the city. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 75,00075,000 75,00075,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fleet Management Fund 75,00075,000 75,00075,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 21 Workshop Packet Page Number 38 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW19.01 Project Name One Tandem Axle Plow Truck Public Works Department Equipment Type 12 yearsUtilities Superintendent Useful LifeContact Vehicles Category 2 Very Important Priority Total Project Cost:$245,000 Description The 2008 tandem axle plow truck, Unit 533 is due for replacement in 2019. Justification The 2008 model year plow truck is due for replacement. This truck is one of two tandem trucks in the fleet and is an integral piece for the street maintenance division as it is utilized year round. In the winter months it is used every snow/ice event for treating and plowing city streets. In the other months, the truck is used for sweeping and patching/paving operations. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Equip/Vehicles/Furnishings 245,000245,000 245,000245,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Fleet Management Fund 245,000245,000 245,000245,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the fleet operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 22 Workshop Packet Page Number 39 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW09.10 Project Name Dennis/McClelland Area Street Improvements Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$6,130,000 Description The Dennis/McClelland Area streets are proposed to be fully reconstructed in 2020. Full street reconstruction projects generally include the replacement of the road pavement, installation of concrete curb and gutter, expansion of stormwater facilities, sanitary sewer repairs, watermain repairs and pedestrian improvements. Justification These streets have continued to deteriorate and will require a full reconstruction with the addition of concrete curb and gutter. The following streets are included in the improvements: Sterling St., James Dr., McClelland St., Ferndale St., Dennis Ln., O'Day St., Mayer Ln., Farrell St., and Mayhill Rd. Unique storm water treatment methods will be required in this area near Battle Creek along with installation of drainage infrastructure. The proposed project will also include pavement replacement, sidewalks, and trails. Project includes $30,000 for fog seal preventative maintenance treatment (area to be determined) and $100,000 for sanitary sewer main lining (location to be determined). The $100,000 in 2018 is for a regional drainage/hydraulic study to be completed prior to the feasibility study. In 2014, city crews were required to do an emergency repair to a portion of the storm sewer network that drains directly to Battle Creek. Mayer Lane sites approximately 35 feet above Battle Creek. Improving the storm sewer system in this area will be challenging due to the significant grade difference between the neighborhood and Battle Creek. Therefore, it is proposed to complete a pre-study of potential drainage mitigation that will be needed along Battle Creek. 2.04 miles of streets, Average PCI: 36/100 Prior Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Construction/Maintenance 100,0005,930,0006,030,000 100,0005,930,0006,030,000 Total Total Prior Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Bonds GO Improvement 100,0002,157,5002,257,500 Bonds GO Special 1,010,5001,010,500 Total Assessment City of St. Paul Water Dept 742,000742,000 Environmental Utility Fund 1,355,0001,355,000 Sanitary Sewer Fund 414,000414,000 Water - WAC Fund 251,000251,000 100,0005,930,0006,030,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 23 Workshop Packet Page Number 40 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW12.02 Project Name Sterling Street Bridge Replacement Street Department Department Improvement Type 50 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$1,400,000 Description The Sterling Street Bridge is an existing timber bridge that crosses Fish Creek and is proposed to be replaced in 2020. Justification The bridge on Sterling Street in south Maplewood is in need of replacement in the coming years and programmed for a 2020 replacement in accordance with the council adopted bridge program. State Bridge Funds are expected to pay for a majority of the cost of the project once it qualifies for funding as a result of its condition. Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Construction/Maintenance 100,0001,300,0001,400,000 100,0001,300,0001,400,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Bonds MSA 100,000115,000215,000 State Grants 1,185,0001,185,000 100,0001,300,0001,400,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 24 Workshop Packet Page Number 41 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW15.11 Project Name Ferndale/Ivy Area Street Improvements Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$3,520,000 Description The Ferndale/Ivy Area streets are proposed to be fully reconstructed in 2019. Full street reconstruction projects generally include the replacement of the road pavement, installation of concrete curb and gutter, expansion of stormwater facilities, sanitary sewer repairs, watermain repairs, and pedestrian improvements. Existing storm water drainage issues will fixed as part of this project. Justification The streets north of Maryland Ave. and west of Century Ave. are in poor condition and in need of repair. The streets include Dennis St., Farrell St., Ferndale St., Hawthorne Ave., Ivy Ave., and Mayhill Rd. These streets have concrete curb and gutter which for most areas will remain. However, there are know areas with poor drainage where the curb and gutter will need to be replaced. The existing pavement will be removed and replaced. The proposed project will also include sidewalks, trails, and storm water quality features. The project includes $30,000 for fog seal preventative maintenance treatment (area to be determined) and $100,000 for sanitary sewer main lining (location to be determined). In 2018, a regional drainage/hydraulic study was completed prior to the feasibility study. In response to the July 11, 2011 flood, the city identified 22 area for flood remediation projects. The city has completed 15 projects and has leveraged partnerships with Ramsey Washington Metro Watershed District and Ramsey to help fund and complete several of the projects. The proposed study will evaluate 4 of the reaming 6 areas. Identified flood remediation work from this study will then be incorporated into the street improvement project to give a comprehensive approach to improvements needed in this specific area. 1.18 miles of streets, Average PCI: 34/100 Prior Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 200,000 Construction/Maintenance 3,320,0003,320,000 3,320,0003,320,000 Total Total Prior Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 200,000 Bonds GO Improvement 1,629,3101,629,310 Bonds GO Special 524,790524,790 Total Assessment City of St. Paul Water Dept 96,90096,900 Environmental Utility Fund 710,600710,600 Sanitary Sewer Fund 261,500261,500 Water - WAC Fund 96,90096,900 3,320,0003,320,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 25 Workshop Packet Page Number 42 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW16.10 Project Name Mailand/Crestview Forest Area Pavement Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$1,340,000 Description The street pavement in the Mailand/Crestview Forest area is proposed to be rehabilitated in 2019 due to poor pavement condition. Typically, the street pavement is milled or reclaimed and new pavement is installed. This type of rehabilitation work is done in areas with concrete curb and gutter which have underground utilities in good condition. Justification The streets lying north of Hillwood Drive and east of Highpoint Curve are in poor condition and in need of repair. The streets include Mailand Road, Deer Ridge Lane, Crestview Forest Drive, O'Day Street, O'Day Circle, Pond Avenue, O'Day Lane, Mary Lane and Mary Street. These streets have existing curb and gutter which will be maintained and the existing pavement is proposed to be reclaimed and replaced. The proposed project will be partially funded by the gas franchise fee. 2.06 miles of street, Average PCI 36/100 Prior Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 60,000 Construction/Maintenance 1,280,0001,280,000 1,280,0001,280,000 Total Total Prior Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 60,000 Bonds GO Special 607,890607,890 Assessment Total Environmental Utility Fund 67,00067,000 Gas Franchise Fee 524,710524,710 Sanitary Sewer Fund 40,20040,200 Water - WAC Fund 40,20040,200 1,280,0001,280,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 26 Workshop Packet Page Number 43 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW16.11 Project Name Schaller Area Pavement Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$1,550,000 Description The street pavement in the Schaller area is proposed to be rehabilitated in 2020 due to poor pavement condition. Typically, the street pavement is milled or reclaimed and new pavement is installed. This type of rehabilitation work is done in areas with concrete curb and gutter which have underground utilities in good condition. Justification The streets lying north of Highwood Ave. and south of Linwood Ave. are in poor condition and in need of repair. The streets include Valley View Ave., Lakewood Ct., Lakewood Dr., Marnie Cir., O'Day St., Schaller Dr., Timber Ave., Crestview Dr., Currie Ct., Dahl Ave., Dorland Rd., Dahl Ct., Phylis Ct., Timber Tr., and Linwood Ct. These streets have existing concrete curb and gutter which will be maintained and the existing pavement is proposed to be reclaimed and replaced. The proposed project will be partially funded by the gas franchise fee. 2.4 miles of street, Average PCI 36/100 Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Construction/Maintenance 60,0001,490,0001,550,000 60,0001,490,0001,550,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Bonds GO Special 793,500793,500 Assessment Environmental Utility Fund 77,50077,500 Gas Franchise Fee 60,000526,000586,000 Sanitary Sewer Fund 46,50046,500 Water - WAC Fund 46,50046,500 60,0001,490,0001,550,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 27 Workshop Packet Page Number 44 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW18.03 Project Name Gladstone Area Phase 3 Street Improvements Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$3,400,000 Description The third phase of the Gladstone corridor includes the section of Frost Avenue lying between English Street and White Bear Avenue. Frost Avenue is a two lane road and is approximately 50 feet wide. The width is in excess of what is required for a four lane road. The majority of this section of Frost Avenue drains directly to Wakefield Lake which is an impaired water body. The City is actively working with the Ramsey Washington Watershed District in developing a joint project that would reduce the width of Frost Avenue, provide significant water quality improvements, and provide pedestrian facilities along this section of Frost Avenue. It is currently anticipated that Frost Avenue would be partially reconstructed in 2022. Partial street reconstruction projects generally include the replacement of the road pavement, expansion of storm water facilities, sanitary sewer repairs, water main repairs, and pedestrian improvements. Justification Frost Avenue has continued to deteriorate and will require a partial reconstruction. Frost Avenue is currently built to accommodate four lanes and has no pedestrian facilities. As part of the partial reconstruction, Frost Avenue will be designed to meet the requirements of the City’s Living Streets Policy and the Gladstone Master Plan. Frost Avenue improvements will also include replacement of the existing pavement and water main. Project includes $30,000 for fog seal preventative maintenance treatment (area to be determined) and $100,000 for sanitary sewer main lining (location to be determined). Wakefield Lake is an impaired water body and a top priority of Ramsey Washington Metro Watershed District. The City if actively working with the watershed district to seek out grant opportunities. The timing and funding of this project depends on available grants and partnership opportunities. 1.08 miles of streets, Average PCI: 44/100 Prior Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Construction/Maintenance 3,300,0003,300,000 3,300,0003,300,000 Total Total Prior Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Bonds GO Improvement 659,600659,600 Bonds GO Special 218,400218,400 Total Assessment City of St. Paul Water Dept 333,000333,000 Environmental Utility Fund 606,000606,000 Sanitary Sewer Fund 298,000298,000 Water - WAC Fund 117,000117,000 Watershed District 1,068,0001,068,000 3,300,0003,300,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 28 Workshop Packet Page Number 45 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW18.12 Project Name Roselawn & Edgerton Intersection Improvements Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$1,055,000 Description The intersection of Roselawn Ave. and Edgerton St. is proposed to be reconstructed from a signalized intersection of a roundabout in 2019. As part of this project the signalized intersection will be replaced with a compact roundabout and a ADA accessable connection from the intersection to Edgerton Elementary School will be installed. The City of Maplewood and Ramsey County, in partnership, applied for and was awarded a Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) grant to help fund this project. Justification The project is located at the intersection of Roselawn Avenue and Edgerton Street. Currently the intersection is controlled by a traffic signal with single lanes of traffic approaching from each direction. Existing grades and vegetation, primarily in the northwest and northeast quadrants, limit intersection sight distance to the point where right turns on red are not permitted for eastbound or southbound traffic. A compact roundabout will be constructed as part of this project along with ADA pedestrian improvements. The HISP grant covers 90% of the estimated construction costs. Prior Expenditures20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Construction/Maintenance 955,000955,000 955,000955,000 Total Total Prior Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total 100,000 Federal Grants 679,500679,500 Local Government Aid 137,750137,750 Total Ramsey County 137,750137,750 955,000955,000 Total Budget Impact/Other Project is contingent on funding. City may have to fund the initial engineering costs in 2018 either way. 29 Workshop Packet Page Number 46 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW18.39 Project Name NSP Lake Boulevard Street Department Department Unassigned Type Public Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category n/a Priority Total Project Cost:$175,000 Description As part of the City of North Saint Paul's (NSP) CIP plan, they are planning a street and utility project located west of Century Avenue and south of Joy Road. The boundary between Maplewood and NSP is approximated 600 feet south of Joy Road. The north 600 feet of Lake Boulevard lies within Maplewood's boundary. NSP will be leading the project design and construction management. The City of Maplewood owns all the property abutting this section of Lake Boulevard, therefore there will be no assessment associated with this project. This project will include the reconstruction of Joy Road, pavement replacement, concrete curb and gutter, and utility improvements. Justification The north 600 feet of Lake Boulevard lying south of Joy Road is in poor condition and needing repair. This street currently has bituminous curb and gutter which will be replaced with concrete curb and will update the street to meet City standards. By including the Maplewood portion (600 feet) of Lake Boulevard with NSP's CIP project, it allows for a holistic design and will result in cost savings for the City compared to reconstructing this road segment as a separate project. The proposed project will be funded by local government aid funds. 0.11 miles of streets ExpendituresTotal 20192020202120222023 Construction/Maintenance 175,000175,000 175,000175,000 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Local Government Aid 175,000175,000 175,000175,000 Total Budget Impact/Other There will be a positive impact on the operating budget due to lower maintenance costs. 30 Workshop Packet Page Number 47 of 69 E2, Attachment 4 Data in Year 2019 Capital Improvement Plan City of Maplewood,Minnesota Project # PW19.10 Project Name McKnight Traffic Signal Replacement Street Department Department Improvement Type 20 yearsPublic Works Director Useful LifeContact Street Construction Category 1 Critical Priority Total Project Cost:$129,500 Description The City of Saint Paul has a proposed bicycle and pedestrian improvement project scheduled for construction in 2019. Part of the project includes the construction of a trail along the west side McKnight Road from Hudson Road to Minnehaha Avenue. The project includes ADA pedestrian upgrades, an off-street trail along McKnight Road and traffic signal improvements. Justification McKnight Road is a Ramsey County road and includes several traffic signalized intersections. Several of these signals are near the end of their lifecycle and will be replaced as part of the City of Saint Paul's project. The City of Maplewood is responsible for a portion of the signal replacement costs per existing agreements. The project is anticipated to be constructed in 2019 with Maplewood paying their portion of the signal replacement towards the end of 2019. 1.12 miles of streets, Average PCI: 31/100 Expenditures20192020202120222023Total Construction/Maintenance 129,500129,500 129,500129,500 Total Funding Sources20192020202120222023Total Street Light Fund 129,500129,500 129,500129,500 Total Budget Impact/Other Costs associated with these improvements will be paid through the Street Light Utility Fund and the improvements will have a positive impact for pedestrians and bicyclists in this area. 31 Workshop Packet Page Number 48 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 49 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 50 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Plan Range Sources Funding Identified Long Strategic CIP Needs Year Plan Five Identification Capital Capital CIP Budget Annual Implementation Workshop Packet Page Number 51 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 52 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 53 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 54 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 55 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 56 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 57 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 58 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 59 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 60 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 61 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Adequate Workshop Packet Page Number 62 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Strong Workshop Packet Page Number 63 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 64 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 65 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 66 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 67 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 68 of 69 E2, Attachment 5 Workshop Packet Page Number 69 of 69