HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997 Annual ReportCITY OF MAPLEWOOD�
HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION
1997 AN N UAL RE PO RT
MEMORANDUM
DATE: March 10, 1998
TO: Mayor George Rossbach
City Council
City Manager
FROM: Katie Thein Kimlinger, Chairperson
Human Relations Commission
RE: 1997 ANNUAL REPORT
In the past year, the Maplewood Human Relations Commission has worked
consistenty to increase oommunity awareness of diversity and discrimination issues
through education, sponsorship, and participation in community events. The
activities and acxomplishments of the Commission are outlined in this report, as well
as its goals and objections for 1998.
The seven volunteers that compose the Commission are looking forward to 1998,
and working within our community to improve the human relations climate of the
community for those who are residents, work here, or just pass through. We hope
our work will help to make Maplewood a better place for all.
The Maplewood Human Relations Commission respectfully submits its 1997 Annual
Report pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 2-75 of the City Ordinance.
CITY OF
1830 E. COLJNTY ROAD B MAPLEWOOD, MINNE,SOTA 55109
March 10, 1998
To The Citizens of Maplewood:
On behalf of the Maplewood Human Relations Commission, i present the
enclosed 1997 Maplewood Human Relations Commission's Annual Report.
It is my pleasure to be one of the volunteers on the Commission who has been
working in Maplewood to increase awareness of diversity and discrimination in our
community. Through education and dialog among ourselves and our community,
the Commission strives to emphasize the strengths and richness which diversity
brings, and to eliminate the discrimination and bias which unfortunately still exists
in our community and in society as a whole. We also help citizens who feel they
have experienced discrimination in Maplewood.
A continuing goal of the Commission is to increase our visibility, so that people in
Maplewood can tum to the Commission as a resource, or come to us with their
ideas and concems. Toward this end, we have held a poster contest in
Maplewood schools; offered a diversity award for community business, group or
school; participated in Maplewood's National Neighborhood Night Out; and
sponsored an event at the Community Center.
We invite you to read this Annual Report so that you can leam what the
Commission accomplished in 1997, and what our plans are for 1998. We
welcome you to attend one of our monthly meetings, and see what we do in
person. We look forward to meeting you, and hearing your ideas about how we
can work to make our community a better place to be.
Since ely,
Katie Thein �mlinger, Chairperson
Maplewood Human Relation Commission
Equal OpporCunity Employer
LISTING OF RESOURCES FOR VICTIMS OF
ACTS OF BIAS OR HATE CRIMES
ST PAUL RAMSEY MEDICAL CENTER
Psychiatric Social Worker (Crisis Situations)
640 JacksoNEmergency Room
NEIGHBORHOOD JUSTICE CENTER
500 Laurel Avenue
St. Paul
NEIGHBORHOOD JUSTICE CENTER (Spanish speaking) 227-8497
426 South Wabasha
St. Paul
RAMSEY COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER
(Legal Assistance) �
MAPLEWOOD HUMAN RELATIQNS COMMISSION
MAPLEWOOD POLICE DEPARTMENT
(Emergency)
(Non-Emergency)
(Supervisor of investigations)
MAPLEWOOD CITY HALL
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
(Interpreters available for
languages other then Engiish)
FIRST CALL FOR HELP
(Information 8� RefeRal)
MINNESOTA RELAY SERVICE"
221-8922
222-4703
215-Q600
770-4524
911
777-8191
770-4537
770-4500 (Voice)
779-4995 (TTY)
296-5663 (Voice)
296-1283 (lTY)
224-1133
297-5353
If you are hearing or speech impaired or need to conta�t someone who is: Dia1297-
5353 (Twin Cities}, or 1-800-627-3529 (greater Minnesota). Give the communications
assistant (CA) your area code and number and the area code and telephone number
of the person you are calling. The CA will stay on the line to typeNoice
communication.
** procedural response to acts of bias and prejudice to follow.
MAPLEWOOD HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION
PROCEDURAL RESPONSE TO
ACTS OF BIAS AND PREJUDICE
/�ction Steps:
A Coordinator, appointed from within the Commission on a yearly
basis, will handle any contact of reported acts of bias and prejudice
from the Commission membership or the general public.
2. The Chief of Police will mail a cover letter from the Police
Department and also enclose a letter from the Commission with a
brochure outlining the victim's rights and resources that they might
want to contact for further assistance. �
3. If a victim of a bias crime calls us, the Coordinator can offer to
make a visit with another Commission member to discuss, in detail,
any further options they may want to pursue. This visit, if
requested, should be arranged as soon as possible.
4.
5.
Subsequent information regarding the incident will be shared with
the Commission and the media if relevant and appropriate.
Follow up to the victim(s) in writing or contact will be made if
deemed necessary.
6. Relevant names, titles, and phone numbers of those persons who
may have to be involved include:
CHIEF OF POLICE HRC STAFF LIAISON
Michael Ryan . Colleen Dirkswager
770-4532 770-4579
CITY MANAGER
Michael McGuire
770-4524
1998 BIAS RESPONSE COORDINATOR
Regina Laroche-Theune
773-0673
HRC CHAIR
Katie Thein Kimlinger
483-2852
as�
TABLE OF CONTENTS
POLiCY AND ORGANIZATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
COMMISSION ROSTER/ATTENDANCE RECORD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
1997 CALENDAR OF ACTIVITIES AND ACCOMPLISHMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1998 GOALS AND OBJECTIVES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
APPENDICES
CALENDAR OF MULTI-CULTURAL EVENTS AND CIVIC HOlIDAYS ........ A
ALPHABET OF THINGS THAT THE AMERICAS GAVE TO THE WORLD .... B
STRATEGIES FOR RESPONDING TO SLURS AND ETHNIC JOKES ........ C
GUIDELINES FOR ACHIEVING COMMUNICATION
FREE OF RACIAL AND ETHNIC B�AS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D
VALUING DIVERSITY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E
A CLOSER LOOK AT CULTURE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F
CHARACTERISTICS O� A CULTURALLY SENSITIVE PERSON . . . . . . . . . . . G
DEFINITIONS .................................................. H
POLICY AND ORGANIZATION
The MAPLEWOOD HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION was created by City
Ordinance No. 239 on April 18, 1968.
It is the policy of the Commission to fu�ll its charge as a partner with the State
Department of Human Rights, in securing for all citizens equal opportunity in
housing, employment, public accommodations, public services and education; and
to work consistently to improve the human relations climate of the community.
There are seven members on the Commission appointed for three-year terms by
the City Council upon recommendation of the Commission. Meetings are held
monthly (except July and August) at 7:00 p.m. normally on the first Tuesday of the
month at Maplewood City Hall. All meetings are open to the public.
It shall be the duty of the Commission to implement its policies. Such
implementation may be accomplished by making reports and/or recommendations
to the City Manager and/or the City Council, and by engaging in public relations
and educational programs as it deems necessary to accomplish established
policy.
Additional copies of this report are available at the Maplewood City Hall upon
request. Contact the Commission Chairperson through the City Manager's Office
(770-4524) conceming any matters relating to the Commission.
Jim Bartingale
HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION
ROSTER AND ATTENDANCE
Original
Appointment
Date
3-97
Lynne Croes, Secretary 1-95
Carol Cude, Chair 11-93
Gordon Heininger 1-91
Cheryl Johnson 3-97
Katie Thein Kimlinger 1-97
Regina Laroche-Theune, Vice Chair 3-95
Colleen J. Dirkswager (ex officio)
Community Oriented Services Coordinator
Michael McGuire (ex officio)
City Manager
�
End of No. Meetings
Term Attended
12-99 7/10
12-97 9/10
12-00
12-98
12-00
12-99
12-98
7/10
10/10
6/10
9/10
9/10
1997 CALENDAR OF ACTIVITIES AND ACCOMPLISHMENTS
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
* Discussed joint venture integration project - ISD 622.
* Announce 1997 Diversity Award and Poster Contest
* Report on complaint of discrimination
* Prepared cover lette� and annual report for distribution.
* Preserrtation from ISD 622 on Joint Integration Project.
* Presentation by NE Residence on Proposaf for program.
* PreseM Annual Report to City Council
' Joirrt meeting with Paric and Recreation to discuss diversity issues
effecting c�ty parks
APWL * Select winners for 1997 Diversity and Poster Contest
* Presentation on Diversity and Poster CoMest to White Bear
Avenue Association Members.
* Commission Members recognition event.
MAY * Presented Diversity and Poster Contest Awards
* In-Service training "A Worid of Difference - Dynamics of
Prejudice"
* Reviewed issues in neighborhood assoaated with Meho Funeral
Home
* Report on complaint of discrimination - habitat for humanity
JUNE *
.
JULY *
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
in-Service on Hmong Culture and Mediation
Development tour of Mapiewood
No scheduled meeting
* No scheduled meeting
* Participated in Maplewood's Open House
- table display, distributed information on HRC and discrimination,
hosted Multi-cultural performing arts, sponsored raffle.
* Member attended Minnesota League of Human Rights
Commission Annual Conference.
* Discussed internal business.
t Pianning.1998 calendar of activities.
* Preliminary announcement on Diversity Award and Poster Contest
for 1998.
" Reviewed diversily sensidve materials.
t Reviewed 622 Multi-Cultural Committee meeting minutes.
DECEMBER • Elected new officers for 1998
* Pressr�tation on display possibilities
' Discussion regarding region wide campaign addressing
discrimination faced by low income and minority children
3
1998 GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Establish a partnership with local businesses, educational, religious and/or
fratemal organizations regarding human rights.
Sponsor and promote activities for the residents of Maplewood which will:
increase sensitivity in, and awareness of, an area(s) of
human rights; and/or
provide an opportunity for interaction between diverse
members of the community.
" Offer no-fault grievance mediation services to residents of Maplewood.
* Invite and encourage local schools to participate in the annual Diversity
Awareness Award and the Diversity Awareness Poster Contest sponsored
by the MHRC.
* Develop a working relationship with one or more of the Human Relations
Commissions in the Twin Cities area.
* Attend various workshops and educational/informational activities related
to diversity and human rights. �
" Collaborate with the Department of Human Rights on projects of mutual
concem.
* Advise the Mayor, City Council and the City of Maplewood on human
relation issues.
* Collaborate with the Maplewood Police Department when acts of bias,
discrimination, and prejudice are reported.
* Promote and support awareness of the Americans with Disabilities Act
throughout the Maplewood private and public sectors.
4
CALENDAR OF MULTI-CULTURAL EVENTS
AND CIVIC HOLIDAYS
JANUARY 1 New Ysar's Day
1 Emancipation Da�commemorates the signing of the
Emancipation Proclamation in 1863 by President Lincoln.
15 Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s Birthday�acknowledged
nationa! leader of the civil rights movement in the 1960's.
Dr. King was assassinated on April 4, 1968. (Celebrated
on the third Monday.)
FEBRUARY B/ack History Month
16 Presiderrts's Day-commemorates the birthdays of
George Washington (Feb. 22) and Abraham Lincoln (Feb.
12). Celebrated on the third Monday.
MARCH Women's History Month
8. lnternationa/ Worrcfng Women's Day-commemorates a
demonstration by femate textile workers in New York in
1857. Established by the Intemational Conference of
Women in 1910 as an opportunity to acknowledge the
contributions made by women.
APRIL 22 Earth Da�first observed in 1970 to call attention to the
nesd to reclaim purity in our air, water, and living
environment.
MAY Amerfcan lndian Mo►rth
AsfaNPacKic Heritage Month
5 Cinco de Mayo-Mexican national holiday that celebrates
the victory over the French invaders in 1862. It is a time
when Mexican-Americans celebrate their heritage.
25 Memoria/ Dey (traditional)-a time to remember our
heroes and loved ones who have died. Observed on the
fourth Monday.
JUNE 14 Flag Day�the anniversary of the adoption of the U.S. flag
in 1777.
19 Juneteenth-June 19th, 1865 is the day that the Union
Army brought the news of the Emancipation to the slaves
in Texas. The slave owners had refused to tell them two
years earlier.
27 Stonewall Rebel/fon-commemorates the anniversary of
the protest by gays and lesbians against police
harassment in New York City in the 196Q's.
JULY 4 Independence Day�The day that the original 13 colonies
signed the Declaration of Independence from England
and announced the fomnation of the United States of
America.
A
(cont.)
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
26 Women's Equalfiy Da�-set aside in 1974 to honor the
rati�cation of the 19th Amendment to the Constitution in
1920, granting voting rights to women.
7
16
17
Labor Day�set aside to honor working people and the
contribution of labor in America. Celebrated on the first
Monday.
Hispanic Heritage Mortth beings (celebrated from Sept.
15 to Oct. 15)
Mexico's /ndependence Day-marics the beginning of the
Mexican revolt in 1810 against 350 years of Spanish rule.
Citizenship Day-honors the thousands of people who
become U.S. citizens each year. tt is also the anniversary
of the signing of the Constitution in 1787.
Nationa/ Disability Employment Awareness Month
24 Uniteal Nations Da�commemorates the birth of the
United Nations organization.
11
26
10
Veteran's Day-formerly called 'Armistice Day' as a
remembrance of the armistice between the Allies and the
Central Powers that ended W1Nt. Now it honors all those
who have served in the armed forces in all the country's
wars.
Thanksgiving Day�honors the first harvest of the
Plymouth Colony, and originated with three days of prayer
and feasting in 1621. In 1863, President Lincoln declared
the fourth Thursday in November as a national day of
Thanksgiving.
Hmong New Year-usually observed after the fall harvest;
is commonly celebrated on the Friday and Saturday
following Thanksgiving.
Worlds A/DS Day�designated as a day to increase the
awareness and education about AIDS.
Rosa Parks Day�commemorates the anniversary of the
arrest of Rosa Parks in 1955, for refusing to give up her
seat on the bus for a white passenger. The incident led
to a boycott of the city's buses and the end of
segregation.
Human Rights Day�-established in 1948 by the United
Nations in commemoration of the adoption of the
Intemational Declaration of Human Rights.
�
�
�
ALPHABET OF THINGS THAT THE AMERICAS
GAVE TO THE WORLD
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z
avocado, amaranth, asphalt
buffalo, beaver pelts, Brazilian dye
canoe, com, caucus, chocolate, cocoa, cassava, chicle,
cotton, cashews, chayotes, catfish, chilis, cayenne
democracy, dyes, dog sleds
ecology
fertilizer, food preservation
gum, guano deposits, grits
hammock, hominy, hickory nut �
impeachment, ipecac
jerky, Jerusalem a�tichoke
kidney beans, kayaks
libraries, long pants, Ilamas
milpa, moccasins, manioc, medicines
nuts, names (half the state names of USA)
Oklahoma
potatoes, parrots, pumpkins, peanuts, popcom,
pineapple, passenger, pigeon, pear ca�tus, pa�lcas,
peppers, pomegranate, passion fruit, papaya, pecan,
paprika
quinine, quinoa
rubber
squash, silver, sisal, sunflowers, sweet potatoes,
succotash
turkey, tapioca pudding, tomatoes, tortillas, tobacco, tar
USA Constitution (influenced by Iroquois)
vanilla
wild rice, witch hazel, words (several thousand words in
English and Spanish), white potatoes
xylophone (the marimba of both African and American
origin)
yams
zero, zucchini
B
Source: Jack W�tF�ertord,
fn�an Givers,
Crown, New York 1988
STRATEGIES FOR RESPONDING T4
SLURS AND ETHNIC JOKES
Prejudiced remarks, offensive ethnic jokes and racial slurs can occur in any
setting. Left u�checked, such comments can often get out of hand and poison a
woric, school or social situation. Not responding to these remarks conditions us to
accept them; and if we accept these it may be easier to be accepting of bigotry,
discrimination, scape-goating or even violence.
While there are no cookbook strategies for confronting such nemarks, the
following are some effective strategies:
In a private conversation—
• Don't laugh at the joke or slur
If you know the person, voice your anger to them calmly but pointedly.
State how you feel rather than making an abstract statement.
Paraphrase the remarks to make sure you perceived the comment as
the person meant it.
If the speaker dismisses the obje�tion, continue the dialogue, hear the
other person's concems and point out your own.
In a group setting or meeting—
• If the remark or action is particularly outrageous, regardless of the
speaker or the setting, it may be necessary to register your
disagreement.
Usually in a group setting it is preferable not to publicly embarrass the
person making an offensive comment.
An excellent altemative is to take the offender aside afterward - then
use the strategies as in a private conversation discussed above.
At a large meeting or public talk, passing the speaker a note may be an
appropriate means of expressing your displeasure with an offensive
comment.
General Tips—
• Ask colleagues or friends who heard the remaric if they share your
views about it.
Try to get at the resentments that lie behind a racial/ethnic slur or joke
by asking open ended questions of the perpetrator.
Beware of formal resources that address discrimination, e.g. grievance
procedures, EEO office.
Fram'A World of Difference"
GUIDELINES FOR ACHIEVING COMMUNICATION
FREE OF RACIAL AND ETHNIC BIAS
introduction
The reality of global communication. .. is here. More and more, countries are
becoming multi-cultural and multilingual. Groups of various heritages are
challenging the dominance of West European influence on daily life in the United
States and Canada.
Discrimination based on race, color and national origin has been with us for
centuries. It remains with us now, despite these trends and a claim to being an
enlightened society. Our language--with all its power to reinforce bias and shape
though—is still stubbomly preserving that "Old World" culture as the standard
against which all other groups are judged.
Bias is subtle. The more deeply it has been assimilated, the more difficult it is to
uncover.
Teachers are, above atl else, communicators, and as such it is important for them
to examine language, and select ways of communicating that recognize a
broadening racial and ethnic culture.
1. Be aware of words, images, and situstions that suggest that all or most
members of a racial and ethnic groups ar+e the same. Stereotypes may
lead to assumptions that are unsupportable and offensive. They cloud the
fact that all attributes may be found in all groups and individuals.
Example: The writer who describes Mexican children as 'wvetl-dressed"
may be unconsciously portraying an exception to a mental
image of a"poor' or "unkempt" Mexican.
2. Avoid qualifiers that reinforce racial and ethnic stereotypes. A qualifier
is added information that suggest an exception to the rule.
Example: 'The intelligent Black students were guests as part of an
orientation program." Under what circumstances would you
write, 'The intelligent White students..."?
3. Ider�tify by race or ethnic origin only when relevarrt. Few situations
require such identification.
Example: tf this identification is inappropriate: "Michael Dukakis, noted
White Massachusetts Govemor..." is this phrasing any different:
"Jesse Jackson, celebrated Black Democratic leader..."?
4. Be aware of language that, to some people, has questionable racial or
ethnic connotations. While a word or phrase may not be personally
offensive to you, it may be to others.
Example: "culturally deprived" or "culturally disadvantaged." These terms.
may imply superiority of one culture over another. In fact,
people so labeled are often bicultural and bilingual.
❑�
(cont.)
"Non-white" - this word implies that white is the standard. in
North American language, similar words such as "non-black" or
"non-yellow" do not exist.
"Minority" - this word is accurate in North America. However, its
use ignores the fact that people of color comprise the majority of
the world's population (any may comprise the majority of your
immediate locale).
5. Be aware of the possible negative implications of color symbolic words.
Choose language and usage that do not offend people or reinforce bias. In
some instances "black" and 'yellow" have become associated with the
undesirable or negative. �
Example: "black reputation," 'yellow coward."
6. Avoid patronizing and tokenism toward any racial or ethnic group.
Example: Once a year articles or special editions about a particular group
may be interpreted as cultural tokenism, especially when such a
group constitutes a large part of your ... community. This
approach may suggest that a racial or ethnic group is out of the
mainstream.
7. Substitute substantive information for ethnic clich�s. Do more
homework. Don't let ethnic clich�s substitute for in-depth material.
Example: A person of Spanish heritage might prefer to be asked about
family history or political experiences rather than about fiestas.
8. Review media to see if all groups are fairly represented.
Examples: Are persons portrayed in positions of authority almost invariably
white?
Does your media provide racial and ethnic role models?
From •n wor�a or oinerence•
�
VALUING DIVERSITY
The Benefits of Diversity
• A source of richness and strength
• Promotes creativity and innovation
• Better decisions based on different perspectives and viewpoints
• Can result in greater productivity
• Makes work more fun and interesting
• Personal benefits to increasing your comfort level with people who are
different
Barriers to Being Effective in a Multi-cultural Work I�ace
• Preconceptions and stereotypes about other cultures
• Language/communication barriers
• Anxiety and discomfort in dealing with differences and unfamiliar
experiences
• Organizational constraints and rules
• Lack of knowledge
�ultural Differences
• Culture consisis of all those things that people have leamed to do,
believe, value, and enjoy in their history.
• Culture is not extemal but is "within the person"
• Millions of people today live and work in a culture other than their own
• People have a hard time identifying cultural differences between
individuals without calling one or the other superior
• Language is an expression of cutture and reflects the values of a
culture
• The valuing of cultural differences is criticaf to the development of a
culturally competent woricfores
• All cross-cultural interactions/encounters with co-workers and/or clients
are potential leaming experiences
E
(cont.)
Barriers to Communication in a Multi-cultural Setting
• Differences in styles
• Lack of awareness of our own and others' non-verbal communication
• Difficulty talking about differences
• Failure to a�tively listen
• Unexamined assumptions and expectations
Valuing Diversitv
• Make every effort to increase awareness of your own preconceptions
and stereotypes of cultures you encounter.
• Try to interpret the behavior of people from another culture from their
cultural perspective.
• Be willing to test, adapt, and change your perceptions to fit new
experiences.
• Do not judge people from another culture by your own cultural values
until you have come to know them and their cultural values.
• Maintain objectivity.
• Examine your own beliefs and values.
• Establish relationships with people like yourself and others who are
different.
• Recognize the contribution of people different from yourself.
• Leam to work constructively with those who have different perspectives
and st�rles.
• Look for �esults, not reasons.
• Develop the habit of questioning your assumptions when yau are in
contact with someone different from yourself.
From Video Series, Va/uing Diversily—Communkadng Across CuRures. Griggs Production
A CLOSER LOOK AT CULTURE
by Mako Makagawa
Culture is that part of human interactions and experience that determines how one
feels, acts and thinks. it is through one's culture that one establishes standards to
judge right from wrong, beauty and truth, and to make judgments on one's self as well
as others. The things and ideas one values and cherishes, how one leams, believes,
behaves, reacts, etc., are ail immersed in, and impacted by, one's culture. It is one's
culture that prescribes the very sense of the individual's scope of reality.
Everyone has culture. To deny anyone culture is to deny human experiences. A
person's culture is not a rigid, static state, but a continuously developing part of his/her
life as interactions with others continue. A person absorbs culture from all human
resources in one's environment. It naturally follows that (unless one happens to be in
the unusual circumstance of social isolation/insulation) most people are aligned with
many cultures. Those fortunate people deeply steeped in fin►o ethnic cultures are
designated as bicultural people. However, all people are culturally multi-faceted.
Because culture is transmitted either directly or indirectly from others, it is, by
definition, a shared experience. It is important to note that, to whatever extent _
commonalties exisi within a given culture group, each member has his/her own unique
profile of that culture. Thus, members of a cultural group have much diversity within
the group -- each drawing from his/her own unique experiences. This diversity within
the groups makes it very di�cult to teach about a cultural group with accuracy and
without succumbing to over-generalizations.
The essence of one's culture does not lend itself to a display nor can it be shared on
demand. Like a fine, elaborately spun spider web, one's culture is made of many
interlocking, intricate strands. Like a snowflake, each pattem is unique. Like all
delicate things, one's cutture must be approached with sensitive care. We are not
privy to the culture of another without eaming the trust and willingness of the keeper of
the particular web to freely share of his/herself.
Culture cannot be seen, tasted, touched, smelled or heard. When an attempt is made
to introduce someone to a culture through these senses, we are limiting leaming to the
most supe�cial form. It may be analogous to a person claiming they know who you
are because of having seen a photo image of you. The food tasting and dance
exhibitions, popular multi-cultural educational activities, are only as sound as the
educational objective being promoted. These activities are neither good nor bad. But,
unless they are tied to a specific obje�tive of educational value to the student, and
appropriate to the intellectual development of the leamer, we may be wasting vatuable
educational time.
Too often we are drawn to the colorFul or exotic aspects of cultural manifestations and
inadvertently lead students to strengthening rather than neducing stereotyping. This
mode of inappropriate multi-cultural exercises is often labeled as the "travel brochure"
approach. There is usually no evidence of ill intent, but the results are often seen as
harmful in that what is leamed is not necessarily what was meant to be taught. Much
of what is currently presented as multi-cultural activities falls into the dichotomy of
what is refeRed to as the "Dance or Blesd Syndrome." The cultures of minority people
are viewed as entertainment or painful histories of victimized groups. While both
strands of this dichotomy may be based on facts, the full vitality of real people does
not emerge through this approach.
F
(cont.)
Effective multi-cultural education must be integra(ly linked with higher thinking skills.
Effective multi-cultural education must build on one's understanding of one's self and
the interrelationships with others. We must shift from the leaming of "them" to the
leaming of "us." We must expand our sense of "me" to a sense of "we." (In a future
issue of Your Public schools, we will share the concept of "cooperative pluralism"
which concems the leaming of "us" and "we.") We must further our horizons and find
creative, fresh strategies to bring to the consciousness of our students the
understanding that we each are only one person and we are all part of a total human
race of people.
In summary:
• Culture is shared human experiences and yet each person has his/her own
unique profile of culture.
• We draw from. many cultures to form our own unique pattems. Like the
spider, if undisturbed, we can continue to further develop our "web" from
such influences as gender, ethnicity, religion, familial p�actices, hobbies,
etc.
• Culture is fluid and dynamic - not frozen and static.
• There is much diversity within any group, including a cultural group. A
homogeneous group has the communality of only that standard which
originally identified the group.
• Teaching a cultural specific activity must not inadvertenUy strengthen
stereotyping.
• The value of a multi-cultural activity must be evaluated on the precision of
the activity meeting the educational objective, and the educational objective
must be relevant to the future of the leamer.
• Multi-cultural aetivities must be linked to higher thinking skills.
• Multi-cultural education should build bridges of trust that close the distances
befinreen people.
Source: RepriMed from YOUR PUBUC SCHOOLS/November 1966
CHARACTERISTICS OF A CULTURALLY SENSITIVE PERSON
The cutturally sensiWe person is one who has moved from being culturaily unaware
to being aware and sensitive to his/her own cultural baggage.
• ethnocentrism
• other cultures seen as being equaily valuable as own
2. A cuRurally sensiUve person is aware of his/her own values and biases and how they
may affect others.
• avoids prejudice, unwarranted labeling, stereotyping
• tries to avoid preconceived limitations/notions about people from other
cuftures
3. The culturally sensitive person will have a good understanding of the sociopolfical
system's operation in the U.S. with respect to ils treatment of people from other
cultures.
• understands impact and operation of oppression (racism, classism, sebsm,
etc.)
• understands racist concepts that have permeated social institutions
• understands the role cuftural racism plays in development of identity and
world views among people of color
4. A culturally sensitive person is one who is comfoitable with differences that exist
between groups in terms of race and beliefs.
• does not see differences as deviant
• does not profess "color blindness," does not deny e�dstence of differences
arising from membership in differeM racial groups
5. The culturally sensiGve person must possess speafic knowledge and information
about the particular g�oup he/she is interacting with.
• aware of history, experiences, cuftural values, and life-styles of various
ethnic/racial groups
• the more knowledge possessed, the more effective the communication
6. The culturally sensitive person must have a clear and explicit knowledge of the
generic characteristics.
• language, culhiral values, d�ss values
• understands value assumptions inherent in his/her profession and how thase
interad with the culturally different
7. At the skills level, the culturally sensitive person must be able to generate a wide
variety of verbal and non-verbal responses.
• expands repertoire of responses
• understands appropriate time to use these responses
It is importarrt that the culturally sensitive person respects the wo�ld view of others. This
does NOT mean each has to hold these world views as his/her own. Rather, it means
each is able to see and accept, in a nonjudgmental manner, the legitimacy of alternative
ways to view the wo�ld.
Excerpt fiar► Counselir� the CuRurallv Differerrt. Theorv and Practic�
by Derald W. Sue. John Wiley and Son Publish�s, 1981.
G
DEFtNIT10NS
Ableism: Attitudes, a�tions/inactions, policies, and physical environments, which
subordinate a person or group because of his/her physical, sensory,
psychological, or leaming disabilities. Ableism operates on a number of levels:
individual, cultural, institutional, and any combination thereof.
Beliefs: Cultural agreements about what is true or false; descriptions of
assumptions about the world and or our place in it.
Classism: Individual, cultural, institutional systems which oppress people who
may not have had access to those economic, educational, social, experiential or
intellectual resources, which are defined as important by the dominant culture.
Culture: All of the leamed and shared products of a group or a society.
Culture Encapsulation: Maintaining a cocoon by evading reality through
ethnocenfism and/or through relativism ("to each their own") and depending �
entirely on one's own intemalized value assumptions about what is good for
society. Isolation is accentuated by culture-bound and time-honored values to
prevail against the tentativeness of present knowledge. The same sociological
data which can inform us can be misused to reinforce tendencies toward
stereotyped images of cultural groups; separating and encapsulating the individual
from social reality. (From A Handbook fior Deve/oping Mu/ti-cultura/ Awar�eness by
Paul Pederson.)
Cultural Groups in United States: African American, American Indian, Asian
American, European American, Hispanic American.
Cultural Pluralism/Cultural Diversity: The inGusion of all culturaUethnic/racial
groups.
Curriculum: Refers to that body of knowledge which is transmitted to leamers; is
not limited to foRnal instruction; includes anything that happens to a student
during a school day; is the responsibility of all school district employees,
representatives.
Discrimination: Behavioral - differential treatment of individuals because of their
perceived membership in a minority group.
Discrimination: Results from individuals or institutions having the power to act
on prejudice.
Ethnic/Cultural/Racial Groups: Refers to groups with which individuals identify;
based on such commonly shared factors such as language, heritage, geographic
origin, religion and/or race.
Ethnocentrism: Belief in the inherent superiority of one's own group and culture;
it may be acc:ompanied by feelings of contempt for those others who do not
belong; it tends to look down upon those considered as foreign; it views and
measures alien cultures and groups in terms on one's ovm cutture.
Gender Fair: Refers to equity of females and males; does not employ sexist
language or practices.
H
(cont.)
Heterosexism: Individual, institutional and culturai systems that oppress people
because of their affectionaUsexual preference.
Homophobia: Fear, anger and hatred of lesbian and gay people.
Institutional Racism: Institutional racism represents a social system in which
race is the major criterion of role assignment, role rewards, and socialization.
After colonial contact takes place, elite monopoly of political, economic, social,
cultural, and psychological resources develops, resulting in a social system which
is oppressive of all minorities.
Minority: An individual who is not part of the power struature; in the United
States, usually a female or person or color.
Mu1ti-cultural: Refers to many cultures; goes beyond a white, westem
perspective
Multi�ultural/Gender�Fair Curriculum: A curriculum which weaves information
by and about all persons into its leamer outcomes, activities and instructional
strategies; a curriculum which comes from a sa/ad bowl rather than from a me/ting
pot perspective; a curriculum in which differences are acknowledged, accepted,
affirmed, celebrated!
Norms: A culture's rules of right and wrong behavior.
Oppression: An experience in that the living of one's life is confined and shaped
by forces and barriers which are not accidental or occasional and hence
avoidable, but are systematically related to each other in such a way as to catch
one between and among them and restrict or penalize motion in any direction. It
is the experience of being caged in: all avenues, in any direction, are blocked or
booby trapped. (From: The Politics of Reality: Essays in Feminist Theory by
Marilyn Frye.)
Organizational Cutture: All of the leamed and shared values, beliefs and norms
of an organization.
Prejudice: An unfavorable opinion or feeling formed beforehand without
adequate knowledge, thought or reason.
Racism: Any attitude, action or inaction which subordinates a person or group
because of his or her color. Racism is based on the ability to exercise power;
power + prejudice = racism. Racism can be either individual, cultural or
institutional.
Sexism: Individual, cultural and institutional systems which oppress people
because of their sex.
Stereotype: A standardized picture that is held in common by members of a
group and represents an oversimplified opinion, effective attitude (influenang
feelings and emotions) or uncritical judgment.
Values: Those things that a culture regards as moraly good or bad, desirable or
undesirable.
Human Relations Commission
Reply Card
Did you fmd this repod usefW and/or informative? _ yes _ no;
and was the information provided too little _ enough _ too much
a. What are your suggestions for additions or subtractions?
2. Were you aware of the existence of d►e Human Relations Commission prior to receiving d�is report? ff so,
how? Cirek al! t6at apply.
Prior annual report Maplewood In Motion Attended communiiy event
Booth at National Night Out Other
3. Do you have any questions about the Human Relations Commission that this report does not address? If so,
please specify.
Do you have suggestions for ways in which We Commission might become more visible within the community
and/or better serve the community?
5. Would you like to continue to receive the Human Relations Commission Annual Report? _ yes _ no.
6. We welcome any additional ideas or comments you might have. Please write them in the space below.
Pkase tear out and send to:
Maplewood City Hall
c% Human Relations Commission
] 830 East Coanty Road B
Maplewood, Minnesota 55109
AN AFFIRMATIOIV
OF
HUMAN ONENESS
I am a member of the human family. My home is earth.
The achievements of inen and women throughout the
ages are my heritage.
My destiny is bound to that of all my fellow human
beings.
What we jointly create forms our bequest to future
generations.
May my life serve the good of my family.
May our use of the earth preserve it for those yet to come.